Government of Canada | Gouvernement du Canada Government of Canada
    FrançaisContact UsHelpSearchHRDC Site
  EDD'S Home PageWhat's NewHRDC FormsHRDC RegionsQuick Links

·
·
·
·
 
·
·
·
·
·
·
·
 

Appendix D: Pre-assessment Checklist


(TO BE COMPLETED BY NOMINATOR )

 
NAME OF PRACTICE   LOCATION:
SUBMITTED BY:
ORGANIZATION
DATE: PHONE:   EMAIL:
 
EAPD PROMISING PRACTICES PRE-ASSESSMENT CHECKLIST
  YES (Y)   NO (N)
 
A.   RELEVANCE TO EAPD PRIORITIES
1   Is this practice58 part of a program/service that is currently cost-shared under EAPD?
2   Does this practice help clients prepare for, obtain, or maintain employment in labour market?
B.   INNOVATIVE/UNIQUE
3   Does this practice represent an innovative or unique approach or activity?
4   Would your peers consider that the practice uses innovative ideas, approaches, processes or technology as a solution to a problem or a client need?
C.   EVIDENCE OF SUCCESS
5   Does the program/service have clearly stated objectives and goals?
6   Does this practice help to attain the program's objectives/goals?
7   In your opinion, does this practice produce superior results for clients?
8a   Has quantitative evidence been measured or collected regarding this practice?
(Please check all that apply)
formula   Number of new participants per year
formula   Number of completions per year
square   Employment status at entry
formula   Number of participants either obtaining employment or moving on to next phase of their plan
formula   Number of participants maintained in employment upon completion
formula   Rate of attrition
formula   Evaluation data
square   Participant satisfaction surveys
formula   Cost per participant
square   Cost/benefit analysis
square   Other (please specify)_____________________
8b   Has the practice demonstrated cost effectiveness?
9   Has qualitative evidence been measured or collected regarding this practice? (Please check all that apply)
square   Focus group studies
formula   Documented interview findings
square   Academic articles
square   Awards and citations
square   Newspaper or magazine articles
square   TV or radio specials
square   Letters of recommendation from the community
formula   Letters of endorsement from former participants/family members
formula   Other (please specify) year end report and statistics
9a   Is client feedback regarding the practice positive?
9b   Is this practice acknowledged as being successful by peers and key stakeholders?
10   Does the practice contribute to a higher quality of service (e.g., timely service, knowledgeable and competent staff, fair and equitable service)?
11   Based on your own experience and knowledge, does the practice make a difference in overall impact to the client and/or citizens? (i.e., Does the practice demonstrate cost-effectiveness or a positive impact on quality of life or environment for the individuals, groups or communities concerned)
D.   IMPLEMENTATION APPROACH
12   Does the practice demonstrate effective partnerships (e.g., between clients, family, educational institutions, public, private, voluntary, or civic sectors of society)?
E.   REPLICABILITY
13   Can the practice be adapted to other organizations or situations?
14   Has the practice been used successfully in a variety of situations or in other communities?
F.   DOCUMENTATION
15   Has the practice been formally evaluated (e.g., by management, an external agency)?
16   Is this practice adequately documented with accurate and verifiable information?
 
TOTAL (Yes) /19
formula Score 13 or more- - Initiative is probably a very worthy promising practice candidate. You are encouraged to obtain program consent (below) and complete and submit the promising practice template.
square Score 8 to 12- - Initiative is a relatively sound promising practice candidate but may be missing some key information for good practice documentation. Please use your best judgment in deciding whether or not to submit for promising practice consideration. If you decide to proceed, please obtain program consent (below) and submit the promising practice template.
square Score 7 or less- - Initiative likely does not meet the identification and documentation requirements that would qualify it for a promising practice at this time. However, if you believe that the practice has potential as a promising practice, and would benefit from this documentation for learning purposes, please obtain program consent and submit the template for review. Please also provide brief rationale for inclusion:
_______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________
 
PROGRAM CONSENT TO PARTICIPATE
I consent to having my organization participate in the EAPD promising practices study.
_______________________________ (Signature of program authority)
_______________________________(Date)

(To be completed by each member of the EAPD PROMISING PRACTICES PROJECT COMMITTEE)

NAME OF PRACTICE: ______________________________________

 
Please use a scale of 1 to 5, where "1" means strongly disagree and "5" means strongly agree. Circle your rating.
A. RELEVANCE TO EAPD PRIORITIES
1 This practice is consistent with the goals of EAPD (i.e., this practice help clients prepare for, obtain, or maintain employment in labour market)
 
  1 2 3   4 5
  Strongly Disagree   Strongly Agree
 
B. EVIDENCE OF SUCCESS
2 The pre-assessment information submitted is sufficiently informative to proceed with further investigation as to whether or not it is a promising practice.
 
  1 2 3   4 5
  Strongly Disagree   Strongly Agree
 
3   There is sufficient balance of anecdotal and quantitative information in the submission to assess the level of success of the practice from a client perspective.
 
  1 2 3   4 5
  Strongly Disagree   Strongly Agree
 
C.   REPLICABILITY
4   This practice likely has the potential for replication across various programs and sites.
 
  1 2 3   4 5
  Strongly Disagree   Strongly Agree
 
SCORE: /20
Date: _____________________
EAPD PPPC member signature___________________________


Footnotes

58 The term « practice » refers to the intervention(s) targeted for study. In some instances, a promising practice may be an entire program or service; in others, it may represent just one component of a broader program. [To Top]


[Previous Page][Table of Contents]