Flag of Canada  
Government of Canada Government of Canada
 
 Français  Contact Us  Help  Search  Canada Site
Federal Labour Standards Review
Canadian Labour Code
Interim Report
Submissions
Consultations
Research
Terms of Reference
Resources
Consultation Paper
 

Submission

Submissions: Formal Briefs | Letters and Other Written Comments
Disclaimer
Author: Name withheld (individual)
Date: November 8, 2005
Type: Letters and Other Written Comments
Language: English only

Regulation of placement agencies

Hello,

I work as a Graphic Designer.
My field has been monopolized by temporary placement agencies such as Aquent and The Creative Group/Robert Half. It is extremely difficult to find work outside of these agencies, and they are very well aware of that fact. These agencies use the desperation of Designers to force them to accept lower wages, especially during off-season, such as holidays or summer.

My last assignment was billed by my agency, The Creative Group/ Robert Half at $55 per hour. Of that, I was paid $32/hour, with over 12 years of experience and a Master's Degree. That is a 45% take of my negotiated pay rate. The agency offers no benefits - no Pension, no paid vacation or sick days.

I was recently given 4 days notice that my year long contract was not going to be renewed, and offered no Severance Pay.

I should be able to expect my earnings to gradually go up, just as any other college educated professional does, in other fields of employment. These agencies bargain with a company, based on my education and skill level, and then take as much as they can from me, depending on how long they have kept me waiting for another assignment - they use my desperation against me.

I have seen my pay rate through The Creative Group/Robert Half fluctuate from $33/hour down to $27/hour in the past 15 months.

The freelance rate for a graphic designer, without going through an agency, is anywhere from $40-80/hour, dependant on one's experience. The rate of percentage an employment agency can take from a contract worker needs to be strictly regulated and enforced. There are employees with higher levels of education, or more years of experience, that are not properly compensated. They are often sent out on assignments that are paying the entry level pay scale, even though the negotiated rate is for someone of their qualifications, making it difficult for them to progess in their lives financially and to be able to properly care for themselves and their families. This is especially true in fields such as graphic design, that have become "freelance based industries" - due in most part, to agencies such as Aquent and The Creative Group.

Taking 45-50% of a contract workers' pay rate is not substantied, especially when the worker recieves no benefits or legal protection.

A standard 30% cut of a contract workers negotiated pay rate is what should be strictly enforced by the government.


Disclaimer: We would like to thank those who submitted comments and opinions to the Federal Labour Standards Review Commission. Letters, comments and formal briefs received from individuals and organizations across Canada have been posted below. Those submissions that specifically address labour standards issues have been selected. Please note that not all issues raised in the submissions necessarily fall within the mandate of the Review.

Submissions posted reflect the views and opinions of the interested party only and do not necessarily represent the views of the Government of Canada or the Commission. The Commission is not responsible for the content of the submissions and does not guarantee the accuracy or reliability of any information provided. Further submissions will be printed as they become available.

   
   
Last modified :  2/14/2006 top Important Notices