Flag of Canada
Service Canada Government of Canada
 
Français Contact Us Help Search Canada Site
Home        
   
Services for you


  

About the Index


  

How to use the Index


  

Issues Search


  

Last Fifty Cases Posted


  

Case Search


  

Judge Search


  

Claimant Search


  

Digest


  

Jurisprudence Library

 

THE INDEX OF JURISPRUDENCE
A SUPPLEMENT TO THE DIGEST OF BENEFIT ENTITLEMENT PRINCIPLES


Case Number: Claimant: Judge: Language: Decision date:
Decision A-0366.94 Jouan Alfred J.  Federal  English 1/23/95 
Decision Appealed: Appellant: Corresponding Case:
Dismissed Unanimous  No N/A  24632 

Issue:Sub-Issue1Sub-Issue2Sub-Issue3
week of unemployment minor in extent 

Summary:

Other factors can never be relevant on their own, the conclusion in a particular case depends directly and necessarily on the "time spent". In the case of a claimant who spends, on a regular basis, 50 hours per week to the affairs of his own business, there is no way that he can invoke ss. 43(2). All 6 factors of CUB 5454 mentioned. MAGEE and VEILLET referred to. It is my conviction that the most important, most relevant and only basic factor to be taken into account has to be, in all cases, the time spent. Whatever may be the status of the other factors, they can never be relevant on their own.

Issue:Sub-Issue1Sub-Issue2Sub-Issue3
week of unemployment rationale 

Summary:

Claimant's efforts to start his own business have taken him outside the purview of the UI scheme. The Act is designed to provide temporary benefits to those who are unemployed and actively seeking other work. It cannot be used to subsidize entrepreneurs who are starting their own business.

Issue:Sub-Issue1Sub-Issue2Sub-Issue3
board of referees rules of construction official wordings differ 

Summary:

The only basic factor in ss. 43(2) is the time spent. First, this is what the French version says unequivocally, the ambiguous English phrase "so minor in extent" having to be read within the confines of the unambiguous French words "il y consacre si peu de temps".

     
   
Last modified :  2005-11-24 top Important Notices