CBC MARKETPLACE: HEALTH » PESTICIDE
SAFETY
The pesticide debate: To spray or not to
spray
Broadcast: October 12, 1999
![](https://bac-lac.wayback.archive-it.org/web/20061031052529im_/http://cbc.ca/gfx/photos/pesticide_spray000516.jpg)
Canadians use hundreds and thousands of kilograms of
pesticides on their lawns |
Canadians use hundreds and thousands of kilograms of pesticides
-weed killers and insecticides- on their lawns.
Other users -parks, golf courses, sod farms- also use huge
quantities of the stuff.
The trouble is it doesn't all stay on the grass. It's getting
into our water, our rivers, even into the rain.
In the summer of 1998 in Lethbridge Alberta, the rain was
laced with the common weed killer 2,4-D. It drenched both
city and farms.
![](/web/20061031052529im_/http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/lawnchem/images/rivertest1.jpg)
The City of Toronto
tests the Humber River for lawn pesticides |
In Southern Ontario, similar chemicals have turned up in
waterways, possibly the Humber River in Toronto where the
city is testing for lawn pesticides.
"They're herbicides and insecticides, so if they were able
to get into the streams at very high concentrations they could
kill fish or affect plants themselves," says John Struger,
a scientist with the Canadian Centre for Inland Waters.
He has analyzed urban streams and detected nine kinds of
lawn pesticides in them. In one instance, a bug killer exceeded
by 140 times the provincial guideline set to protect water.
![](/web/20061031052529im_/http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/lawnchem/images/struger1.jpg)
John Struger is a scientist
with the Canadian Centre for Inland Waters |
Dr. Kelly Martin is an emergency room doctor at the Royal
Victoria Hospital in Montreal. "Children are … at increased
risk from pesticides," she says.
Martin is also an epidemiologist and a member of Health
Canada's Pest Management Review Agency. She's about to tell
a parliamentary committee of a number of studies linking pesticides
and cancer.
The studies Dr. Martin has reviewed deal with children exposed
to lawn pesticides:
"We have five or six good studies that show that if you use
lawn pesticides on your lawn or garden one to four times a
year your child has a five to six times increase of developing
leukemia."
![](/web/20061031052529im_/http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/lawnchem/images/martin3.jpg)
"Children are … at increased
risk from pesticides," says Dr. Kelly Martin |
But Wendy Rose, with the Urban Pest Management Council, cites
a different study -by Health Canada- which found no elevated
risk of cancer to agricultural workers using pesticides.
"We are the first people to want to make sure that those
products are okay for use on the market," she says.
"Our industry is the most regulated in Canada," Rose adds.
"Every product, before it goes on the market, is approved
by the Pest Management Regulatory Agency. And if at any time
the PMRA feels there are potential adverse effects for a product
they remove it."
![](/web/20061031052529im_/http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/lawnchem/images/rose2.jpg)
"Our industry is the
most regulated in Canada," says Wendy Rose |
The Turfgrass Institute at the University of Guelph is recognized
around the world for its research on pesticides and grass.
Gerry Stephenson is a professor of biology there.
"Pesticides are toxic chemicals," he says. "They are particularly
toxic to weeds and insects we want to control."
Stephenson has tested people for chemicals after they have
shuffled through turf that's been sprayed with pesticide:
"You can get detectable residues that have penetrated the
skin, and fortunately, with 2,4-D, 99 per cent of what gets
through the skin is excreted within 48 hours."
![](/web/20061031052529im_/http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/lawnchem/images/stephenson1.jpg)
"Pesticides are toxic
chemicals," says Gerry Stephenson |
Dr. Martin notes: "These are adults. These aren't children
who are playing around for an hour on the grass."
She says that 20 per cent of the people who arrive in a hospital
emergency room with toxic pesticide exposure are children
who've crawled on a lawn after it's been sprayed "safely."
The industry is confident that registered pesticides have
an adequate margin of safety. Dr. Stephenson agrees, but he
says pesticides should be used more discriminately.
![](/web/20061031052529im_/http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/lawnchem/images/stephenson3.jpg)
Dr. Stephenson says pesticides
should be used more discriminately |
"We have to educate the lawn care companies," he says. "They
don't believe that, a lot of them, that if they're not applying
the pesticide they think maybe their customer would think
they're not doing anything."
Toronto's Parks and Recreation department manages one of
the largest inventories of urban parks in Canada - 31 square
miles, from ravines and golf courses to sports fields and
play areas.
Traditionally, parks departments have been among the largest
users of pesticides. Seeking a balance between good-looking
green spaces and healthy living led Toronto to adopt a Pesticide
Reduction Program this summer.
![](/web/20061031052529im_/http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/lawnchem/images/aqua1.jpg)
'Aquacide,' is a truck-mounted
device that is a new take on an old technology |
It employed some unconventional pest-control measures like
Aquacide, a truck-mounted device that is a new take on an
old technology. It uses steam to kill weeds. No warning signs,
no toxic chemicals, no chemical residues.
Another approach is to leave the ground cover in some park
areas uncut. Weeds become wildflowers creating an urban pocket
of natural habitat where birds and small animals have returned.
But Wendy Rose is not impressed.
"I've seen some communities, as an environmental initiative,
reduce their use of pesticides. Then two, three or eight years
later have to go and use more product," she says.
![](/web/20061031052529im_/http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/lawnchem/images/rose4.jpg)
"Citizens are complaining
about municipal weeds blowing onto their property," says
Wendy Rose |
"Citizens are complaining about municipal weeds blowing onto
their property."
But many complaints have been about pesticides and there
have been concerns expressed about chemicals and the long-term
potential effects of these chemicals.
Toronto is not the first city to reduce the use of pesticides
in its parks.
Calgary and Vancouver have done it too. Waterloo, Ont. has
virtually eliminated pesticides in its public places. Nine
municipalities in Quebec have passed by-laws restricting use
of pesticides by institutions and homeowners as well.
So what's a person with a lawn to do? Some lawn care companies
are sensitive to the excessive use of pesticides.
"Pesticides are not the foundation of our program, fertility
is," says Ken Pavely with Nutri-lawn.
![](/web/20061031052529im_/http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/lawnchem/images/lawnguy3.jpg)
"Pesticides are not the
foundation of our program, fertility is," says Ken Pavely |
"We use all kinds of different fertilizers to achieve a good
thick healthy lawn," Pavely continues. "That's the best defence
against weed encroachment, and insect and disease infestation."
Rather then blanketing your lawn with a combination of fertilizer
and weed control, the pesticide is sprayed directly on the
weeds as needed using a special trigger.
"A lot of people are under the misconception that when we
spray a lawn we're going to prevent weeds from coming up with
a weed control. That's not the case," Gravely says. "So the
best defense against a weed infestation in a lawn is a thick
thick turf."
Cheryl Shour goes even further. Her company offers customers
chemical-free lawn care.
"I was shocked by what was used and there was no alternative
to using chemicals," she says.
![](/web/20061031052529im_/http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/lawnchem/images/shore1.jpg)
Cheryl Shour's company
offers customers chemical-free lawn care |
So Shour offers an organic lawn care program with four visits
for $200. But she admits that using no chemicals means there's
no quick fix.
"This time of year, which is perfect for seeding, we also
put down an organic fertilizer. Once is all you really need
in the fall," says Shour. "We also educate the homeowner
on healthy maintenance practices which includes cutting nice
and long to encourage healthy root growth."
So if you're interested in reducing pesticide use on your
lawn, check out our tips.
NEXT: Tips
for a pesticide-free lawn »
^TOP
|