CBC.ca Thunder Bay
Weighing the Balance
 
The story of two men caught up in an investigation into the sexual exploitation of children on the internet raises troubling questions about whether or not authorities should publicly release the identities of those who are charged.

by Kellie Hudson
CBC News

Police forces across the country fight a tireless battle against child pornography. In one year alone, Toronto police seized millions of images of children being sexually exploited.

While Canadian law enforcement agencies make a dent in the trade of images of children being violated, their efforts can also take a heavy toll on the people under scrutiny.

In one recent example, Toronto police held a news conference as part of Operation Snowball, a Canada-wide investigation into child pornography on the internet. At the April 16, 2003 conference, they announced the arrest of five men accused of using their credit cards to buy child porn. A warrant had been issued for the arrest of a sixth suspect.

The names and ages of all the suspects were released to the media, who turned out in droves for the announcement.

For one of the men named that day, the arrest and public naming and shaming sent him into a tailspin. Although the charges against him were eventually withdrawn, he never recovered from the stigma of being associated with such a despicable crime.

He lost his job, his friends, his reputation – and eventually his will to live.

But for another man identified at the same media event, a father of three named John, the public arrest and jail term proved to be a wake-up call. His arrest and subsequent jail sentence led him to seek help for a lifelong addiction to pornography.

The stories of these two men show the often opposing forces at work in law enforcement: on the one hand is the desire that most people have to get rid of child pornography – the makers, the abusers and the voyeurs.

And on the other is the fundamental principle of our legal system: the need and the right to be considered innocent until proven guilty.

NEXT > A brother's tragic tale

^ Top Of Page

Story Navigation


AWARD WINNING JOURNALISM

RTNDA AWARD

This series is based on the RTNDA Edward R. Murrow International award winning investigative radio documentary by Kellie Hudson.


Related Links

Child porn FAQ

Toronto police say some child porn produced in Canada

The Supreme Court and child porn

Porn free: watchwords to safe surfing

The Fifth Estate - Landslide: Child porn on the internet


External Links
External Links CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites. Links will open in new window.

Cybertip.ca (for reporting the online sexual exploitation of children)

Software tracks child porn distributor

Reveal: anti-child-porn software to protect home computers

Sexaholics Anonymous Inc.