36th Parliament, 2nd Session
EDITED HANSARD • NUMBER 38
CONTENTS
Monday, December 13, 1999
| PRIVATE MEMBERS' BUSINESS
|
1105
| BLOOD SAMPLES ACT
|
| Bill C-244. Second reading
|
| Mr. Chuck Strahl |
1110
1115
1120
| Mr. John Maloney |
1125
| Mr. Peter Mancini |
1130
1135
| Mr. Michel Bellehumeur |
1140
1145
| Motion
|
1155
(Division 534)
| Motion negatived
|
1200
1205
| GOVERNMENT ORDERS
|
| NISGA'A FINAL AGREEMENT ACT
|
| Bill C-9. Third reading
|
| Hon. Robert D. Nault |
1210
1215
1220
1225
| Mr. Mike Scott |
1230
1235
1240
1245
1250
1255
1300
1305
| Mr. Claude Bachand |
1310
1315
1320
1325
1330
1335
1340
1345
| Motion
|
1350
1355
| STATEMENTS BY MEMBERS
|
| MNA FOR ABITIBI-EST
|
| Mr. Guy St-Julien |
| REVENUE CANADA
|
| Mr. Lee Morrison |
1400
| COMMUNITIES IN BLOOM
|
| Mr. John Richardson |
| CANADIAN EXECUTIVE SERVICES ORGANIZATION
|
| Ms. Jean Augustine |
| DIVORCE ACT
|
| Mr. Paul Szabo |
| LOGGING
|
| Mr. Gary Lunn |
| MINISTER OF INTERGOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS
|
| Mrs. Maud Debien |
1405
| CLUB ITALIA
|
| Mr. Gary Pillitteri |
| THÉRÈSE PERRIER
|
| Mr. Mark Assad |
| CANADIAN FORCES
|
| Mr. Art Hanger |
| CHILDREN
|
| Mr. Marcel Proulx |
| BILINGUALISM
|
| Mr. Yvon Godin |
1410
| PRESIDENT OF THE TREASURY BOARD
|
| Mr. René Laurin |
| ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OF MONTREAL
|
| Mr. Denis Paradis |
| AGRICULTURE
|
| Mr. Rick Borotsik |
| BIG BEN
|
| Mr. Ian Murray |
| ORAL QUESTION PERIOD
|
| NATIONAL UNITY
|
| Mr. Grant Hill |
1415
| Hon. Herb Gray |
| Mr. Grant Hill |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| Mr. Grant Hill |
| Hon. Herb Gray |
| TAXATION
|
| Mr. Monte Solberg |
| Hon. Paul Martin |
| Mr. Monte Solberg |
| Hon. Paul Martin |
| REFERENDUMS
|
| Mr. Gilles Duceppe |
1420
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| Mr. Gilles Duceppe |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| Mr. Daniel Turp |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| Mr. Daniel Turp |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
1425
| CHILD POVERTY
|
| Ms. Alexa McDonough |
| Hon. Herb Gray |
| Ms. Alexa McDonough |
| Hon. Herb Gray |
| NATIONAL UNITY
|
| Mr. Peter MacKay |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| REFERENDUMS
|
| Mr. André Bachand |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| TRANSITIONAL JOBS FUND
|
| Mr. Chuck Strahl |
| Hon. Jane Stewart |
1430
| Mr. Chuck Strahl |
| Hon. Jane Stewart |
| REFERENDUMS
|
| Mr. Michel Gauthier |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| Mr. Michel Gauthier |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| AGRICULTURE
|
| Mr. Howard Hilstrom |
| Hon. Lyle Vanclief |
1435
| Mr. Howard Hilstrom |
| Hon. Lyle Vanclief |
| REFERENDUMS
|
| Mrs. Francine Lalonde |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| Mrs. Francine Lalonde |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| PRISONS
|
| Mr. Jim Abbott |
| Hon. Lawrence MacAulay |
| Mr. Randy White |
1440
| Hon. Lawrence MacAulay |
| REFERENDUMS
|
| Mr. Stéphane Bergeron |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| TREASURY BOARD
|
| Mr. Roger Gallaway |
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
| COAST GUARD
|
| Mr. Myron Thompson |
| Hon. Harbance Singh Dhaliwal |
| Mr. Myron Thompson |
1445
| Hon. Harbance Singh Dhaliwal |
| HEALTH
|
| Ms. Judy Wasylycia-Leis |
| Hon. Allan Rock |
| Ms. Judy Wasylycia-Leis |
| Hon. Allan Rock |
| COAST GUARD
|
| Mr. Charlie Power |
| Hon. Harbance Singh Dhaliwal |
| Mr. Charlie Power |
| Hon. Harbance Singh Dhaliwal |
1450
| CHILDREN
|
| Mr. Mac Harb |
| Hon. Allan Rock |
| RCMP
|
| Mr. Chuck Cadman |
| Hon. Lawrence MacAulay |
| REFERENDUMS
|
| Mr. Michel Bellehumeur |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| CANADA HEALTH AND SOCIAL TRANSFER
|
| Ms. Wendy Lill |
| Hon. Paul Martin |
1455
| NATURAL RESOURCES
|
| Mr. Gerald Keddy |
| Hon. Ralph E. Goodale |
| INDUSTRY
|
| Mr. Walt Lastewka |
| Hon. John Manley |
| NATIONAL UNITY
|
| Mr. John Nunziata |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| TAXATION
|
| Mr. Jay Hill |
| Hon. Paul Martin |
1500
| REFERENDUMS
|
| Mrs. Madeleine Dalphond-Guiral |
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| CRIMINAL CODE
|
| Mr. Svend J. Robinson |
| Hon. Anne McLellan |
| NATURAL RESOURCES
|
| Mr. Gerald Keddy |
| POINTS OF ORDER
|
| Tabling of Documents
|
| Mr. Michel Gauthier |
1505
| Mr. Réal Ménard |
| Mrs. Christiane Gagnon |
| Ms. Jocelyne Girard-Bujold |
| Bell ringing
|
| Mr. John Nunziata |
| Tabling of Documents
|
| Mr. René Canuel |
1510
| Mr. Yvan Loubier |
| Hon. Don Boudria |
1515
| Mr. Jean-Guy Chrétien |
| Mr. Michel Bellehumeur |
| Mr. Yves Rocheleau |
| Mr. Daniel Turp |
| Bill C-9
|
| Mr. Jay Hill |
| Tabling of Documents
|
| Mr. Ghislain Lebel |
1520
| Mr. Benoît Sauvageau |
| Mr. Ghislain Fournier |
| Mrs. Pierrette Venne |
| Mr. Antoine Dubé |
| Mr. Maurice Godin |
| Mr. Odina Desrochers |
| Mr. Stéphane Bergeron |
| Mr. René Laurin |
| Mrs. Pauline Picard |
1525
| Mr. Gérard Asselin |
| Ms. Hélène Alarie |
| Mr. Paul Crête |
| Mrs. Madeleine Dalphond-Guiral |
| Mr. Pierre de Savoye |
| Ms. Caroline St-Hilaire |
| Mr. Bernard Bigras |
| Mr. Richard Marceau |
| Mr. Serge Cardin |
| Mr. Claude Bachand |
1530
| Mrs. Maud Debien |
| Mr. Stéphan Tremblay |
| Mrs. Francine Lalonde |
| Mr. Yvan Bernier |
| ROUTINE PROCEEDINGS
|
| ORDER IN COUNCIL APPOINTMENTS
|
| Mr. Derek Lee |
| GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO PETITIONS
|
| Mr. Derek Lee |
| COMMITTEES OF THE HOUSE
|
| Natural Resources and Government Operations
|
| Mr. Joseph Volpe |
1535
| AN ACT TO GIVE EFFECT TO THE REQUIREMENT FOR CLARITY AS SET
|
| Bill C-20. Introduction and first reading
|
| Hon. Stéphane Dion |
| CRIMINAL CODE
|
| Bill C-401. Introduction and first reading
|
| Mr. Art Hanger |
| COMPETITION ACT
|
| Bill C-402. Introduction and first reading
|
| Mr. Dan McTeague |
1540
| COMMITTEES OF THE HOUSE
|
| Transport
|
1545
1550
1555
1600
| Mr. Guy St-Julien |
1605
| Mr. Yves Rocheleau |
| Mr. Daniel Turp |
1610
| Mr. Gar Knutson |
| Motion
|
1655
(Division 535)
| Motion agreed to
|
| GOVERNMENT ORDERS
|
| NISGA'A FINAL AGREEMENT ACT
|
| Bill C-9. Third reading
|
1700
| Ms. Libby Davies |
1705
1710
1715
| Mr. Mike Scott |
1720
| Mrs. Sue Barnes |
1725
| POINTS OF ORDER
|
| Appropriation Bill
|
| Mr. John Williams |
1730
1735
| The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault) |
| NISGA'A FINAL AGREEMENT ACT
|
| Bill C-9. Third reading
|
| Mr. Ted McWhinney |
| Mr. Pierre de Savoye |
| Mr. Gerald Keddy |
1740
1745
1750
1755
| Mr. Darrel Stinson |
1800
| Hon. David Anderson |
| Mr. David Iftody |
1805
| Mr. Mike Scott |
| Mr. Derrek Konrad |
1810
| Hon. David Anderson |
1815
1845
(Division 536)
| Motion agreed to
|
1850
| POINTS OF ORDER
|
| Appropriation Bill—Speaker's Ruling
|
| The Speaker |
1855
| SUPPLY
|
| Supplementary Estimates (A), 1999-2000
|
1905
(Division 537)
| Motion No. 1 agreed to
|
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Agriculture and Agri-Food
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 538)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Agriculture and Agri-Food
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 539)
| Concurrence in Vote 15a—Agriculture and Agri-Food
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 540)
| Concurrence in Vote 20a—Agriculture and Agri-Food
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 541)
| Concurrence in Vote 25a—Agriculture and Agri-Food
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 542)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Canada Customs and Revenue Agency
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 543)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 544)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 545)
| Concurrence in Vote 50a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 546)
| Concurrence in Vote 60a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 547)
| Concurrence in Vote 65a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 548)
| Concurrence in Vote 70a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 549)
| Concurrence in Vote 75a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 550)
| Concurrence in Vote 80a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 551)
| Concurrence in Vote 90a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 552)
| Concurrence in Vote 110a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 553)
| Concurrence in Vote 115a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 554)
| Concurrence in Vote 125a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 555)
| Concurrence in Vote 130a—Canadian Heritage
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 556)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Citizenship and Immigration
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 557)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Citizenship and Immigration
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 558)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Environment
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 559)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Environment
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 560)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Environment
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 561)
| Concurrence in Vote 15a—Environment
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 562)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Finance
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 563)
| Concurrence in Vote 6a—Finance
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 564)
| Concurrence in Vote No. 25a—Finance
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 565)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Fisheries and Oceans
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 566)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Fisheries and Oceans
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 567)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Fisheries and Oceans
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 568)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Foreign Affairs and International
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 569)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Foreign Affairs and International
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 570)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Foreign Affairs and International
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 571)
| Concurrence in Vote 11a—Foreign Affairs and International
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 572)
| Concurrence in Vote 20a—Foreign Affairs and International
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 573)
| Concurrence in Vote 25a—Foreign Affairs and International
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 574)
| Concurrence in Vote 30a—Foreign Affairs and International
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 575)
| Concurrence in Vote 41a—Foreign Affairs and International
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 576)
| Concurrent in Vote 45a—Foreign Affairs and International
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 577)
| Concurrence in Vote 50a—Foreign Affairs and International
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 578)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Governor General
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 579)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Health
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 580)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Health
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 581)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Health
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 582)
| Concurrence in Vote 15a—Health
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 583)
| Concurrence in Vote 20a—Health
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 584)
| Concurrence in Vote 25a—Health
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 585)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Human Resources Development
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 586)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Human Resources Development
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 587)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Human Resources Development
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 588)
| Concurrence in Vote 15a—Human Resources Development
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 589)
| Concurrence in Vote 20a—Human Resources Development
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 590)
| Concurrence in Vote 25a—Human Resources Development
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 591)
| Concurrence in Vote 35a—Human Resources Development
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 592)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Indian Affairs and Northern
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 593)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Indian Affairs and Northern
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 594)
| Concurrence in Vote 6a—Indian Affairs and Northern
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 595)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Indian Affairs and Northern
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 596)
| Concurrence in Vote 15a—Indian Affairs and Northern
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 597)
| Concurrence in Vote 35a—Indian Affairs and Northern
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 598)
| Concurrence in Vote 50a—Indian Affairs and Northern
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 599)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 600)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 601)
| Concurrence in Vote 20a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 602)
| Concurrence in Vote 25a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 603)
| Concurrence in vote 30a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 604)
| Concurrence in vote 40a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 605)
| Concurrence in vote 50a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 606)
| Concurrence in vote 55a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 607)
| Concurrence in vote 70a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 608)
| Concurrence in Vote 75a—Justice
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 609)
| Concurrence in Vote 85a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 610)
| Concurrence in Vote 90a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 611)
| Concurrence in Vote 95a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 612)
| Concurrence in Vote 100a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 613)
| Concurrence in Vote 110a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 614)
| Concurrence in Vote 115a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 615)
| Concurrence in Vote 120a—Industry
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 616)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Justice
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 617)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Justice
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 618)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Justice
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 619)
| Concurrence in Vote 15a—Justice
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 620)
| Concurrence in Vote 30a—Justice
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 621)
| Concurrence in Vote 40a—Justice
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 622)
| Concurrence in Vote 45a—Justice
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 623)
| Concurrence in Vote 50a—Justice
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 624)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—National Defence
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 625)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—National Defence
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 626)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—National Defence
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 627)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Natural Resources
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 628)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Natural Resources
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 629)
| Concurrence in Vote 15a—Natural Resources
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 630)
| Concurrence in Vote 20a—Natural Resources
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 631)
| Concurrence in Vote 22a—Natural Resources
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 632)
| Concurrence in Vote 25a—Natural Resources
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 633)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Privy Council
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 634)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Privy Council
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 635)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Privy Council
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 636)
| Concurrence in Vote 15a—Privy Council
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 637)
| Concurrence in Vote 25a—Privy Council
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 638)
| Concurrence in Vote 30a—Privy Council
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 639)
| Concurrence in Vote 55a—Privy Council
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 640)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Public Works and Government Services
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 641)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Public Works and Government Services
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 642)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Solicitor General
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 643)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Solicitor General
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 644)
| Concurrence in Vote 15a—Solicitor General
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 645)
| Concurrence in Vote 25a—Solicitor General
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 646)
| Concurrence in Vote 35a—Solicitor General
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 647)
| Concurrence in Vote 40a—Solicitor General
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 648)
| Concurrence in Vote 50a—Solicitor General
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 649)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Treasury Board
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 650)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Treasury Board
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 651)
| Concurrence in Vote 15a—Treasury Board
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 652)
| Concurrence in Vote 1a—Veterans Affairs
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 653)
| Concurrence in Vote 5a—Veterans Affairs
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 654)
| Concurrence in Vote 10a—Veterans Affairs
|
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
(Division 655)
| Hon. Lucienne Robillard |
| Motion for concurrence
|
(Division 656)
| Bill C-21. First reading
|
| Second reading
|
(Division 657)
| Motion agreed to
|
| Motion for concurrence
|
(Division 658)
| Motion agreed to
|
| Third reading
|
(Division 659)
| Motion agreed to
|
| ADJOURNMENT PROCEEDINGS
|
1910
| Fisheries
|
| Mr. Peter Stoffer |
1915
| Mr. Lawrence D. O'Brien |
(Official Version)
EDITED HANSARD • NUMBER 38
HOUSE OF COMMONS
Monday, December 13, 1999
The House met at 11 a.m.
Prayers
PRIVATE MEMBERS' BUSINESS
1105
[English]
BLOOD SAMPLES ACT
Mr. Chuck Strahl (Fraser Valley, Ref.) moved that Bill
C-244, an act to provide for the taking of samples of blood for
the benefit of persons administering and enforcing the law and
good Samaritans and to amend the criminal code, be read the
second time and referred to a committee.
He said: Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to speak today to Bill
C-244, the blood samples act, also known, for reasons I will get
into shortly, as the good Samaritan's act.
I will start by telling the ancient story of the good Samaritan.
A certain man was going down from Jerusalem to Jericho and he
fell among robbers. They stripped him and beat him and went off
leaving him half dead. And by chance a certain priest was going
down on that road, and when he saw him, he passed by on the other
side. and likewise a Levite also, when he came to the place and
saw him, passed by on the other side.
But a certain Samaritan, who was on a journey, came upon him.
When he saw him, he felt compassion, and came to him, and
bandaged up his wounds, pouring oil and wine on them, and he put
him on his own donkey, and brought him to an inn, and took care
of him.
And on the next day he took out two silver coins and gave them
to the innkeeper and said “Take care of him, and whatever more
you spend, when I return, I will repay you”.
That is the story of the good Samaritan. It is a story of
helping the less fortunate, helping society and doing what is
right even if you are the only person prepared to follow through
on your own beliefs.
A constituent of mine acted as a good Samaritan but
unfortunately paid a price for his actions. He now runs the risk
of contracting HIV.
His father contacted me to tell of the heroic actions of his
teenage son. The young man, whom I will call Tim, was working at
a retail store when another man grabbed some items and sprinted
away on foot. Rather than just shrugging his shoulders and
letting him run away, Tim chased after the thief and tackled and
held him until the police arrived.
Unfortunately for Tim, the shoplifter cut himself in the
action and a good deal of blood was spilt on Tim as he made a
citizen's arrest. It turned out that the thief was also an
intravenous drug user, well known to the authorities and a high
risk of carrying communicable diseases. Some of the virus may
have got into Tim's young body.
I am sure Tim did not wait to see whether or not this person had
a communicable disease before he did the right thing and stopped
him from stealing. I think he is just wired up that way and that
he was taught that way. He was brought up in a home where one
does the right thing because it is the right thing to do, not
because we weigh the risk to our own person.
It was a tragedy when the police had to break the news to Tim
that the thief had refused to give him a blood sample. They
told Tim that the law makes it impossible to take a sample unless
the person is willing to give it up.
Consequently, Tim was forced into a lengthy, extensive and
expensive program of preventive drug therapy just in case the
virus was present. The therapy is not 100% effective, of course,
but more importantly Tim had to go through this therapy because
he did not know one way or the other whether a communicable
disease was present.
If Tim could have known what diseases, if any, the shoplifter
had, he could have made a more informed decision about his own
health and the care that he should have sought. He could have
decided whether to continue to take the medical treatment,
because the drug therapy carries with it serious adverse effects.
Most of all, Tim would have had greater peace of mind and more
emotional strength to face the future if he had known what his
chances were of contracting a communicable disease.
Unfortunately, Tim's example is not isolated. Let me read a
story of Isobel Anderson, an Ottawa police constable who is in
the gallery today. We can read her full story in an article by
Anna Nicolle in the November 15, 1999 edition of the Ottawa
Citizen. I will read a little of that article:
Isobel Anderson's nightmarish experience began when she arrested
a man for armed robbery in October 1997. While searching for
weapons, she reached into his pocket and felt a stab of pain.
She pulled her hand out to find a bloody needle stuck in her
palm. “My first thought, was God, I have AIDS,” recalls
Constable Anderson, a mother of three.
She then went on to describe the emotional trauma she had as a
young mother on her own. As she feared, doctors told her the
needle may have infected her with HIV. She was advised that if
she started treatment with the anti-HIV medication AZT within
hours of being jabbed she might not contract the virus.
Then she learned that the robbery suspect refused to take the
HIV test and could not be compelled by law to give a blood
sample. Hours later the man agreed to be tested because he was
hungry. He said “If you give me a hamburger, I will give you a
blood sample”.
In other words, Ms. Anderson's life, which was hanging in the
balance, was only traded off for a blood sample and a hamburger.
It should not have to be that way. The law should specifically
state that Ms. Anderson had the right to know whether or not that
person had a communicable disease.
1110
Both HIV and hepatitis C can take a long time to develop or
incubate. Ms. Anderson continued taking AZT for three days until
her initial HIV test results came back negative. Then after
consulting with her doctor, she decided not to continue using the
drugs. She said that the side effects of her treatment were life
changing. The chemotherapy side effects, which involved hives,
hair loss and chronic pain, lasted for weeks, to the point where
she could not get up out of her own chair.
Today, thankfully, Isobel Anderson is both HIV and hepatitis C
negative. It is sad when, under our present legal system, those
who help others become helpless, those who sacrifice become
sacrificed and the heroes become victims.
That is why Bill C-244 is for people like Tim and Isobel. It is
also for the literally thousands of other Canadians just like
them: the paramedics, the police officers, the ambulance
workers, the doctors, the nurses, the firefighters, the dentists,
the dental hygienists, the security guards and volunteers, the
different health workers and attendants, the ski patrol, which
was at the news conference this morning, all of the emergency
workers and thousands of people like Tim who do a good deed just
to help people out. It is for those who give the most to help our
society but receive little back in return when they are the ones
needing help. That is what this bill is about.
How would this bill help Tim, Isobel and the thousands of people
I mentioned in the future? In a nutshell, Bill C-244 enables a
judge to order the taking of a blood sample from any person who
is either accidentally or deliberately contaminated a good
Samaritan, health care professional, emergency professional or
security professional while in the course of duty. The person's
blood would be tested for HIV, hepatitis B and hepatitis C. The
blood test analysis would only be shared with the individual from
whom the blood sample was taken, the contaminated person, a
qualified medical practitioner conducting the test and the police
officer responsible for executing the warrant. Only those four
people would know the results of those three tests. The blood
test analysis would be used for medical treatment only.
What would Bill C-244 mean for people like Tim and Isobel? Some
people say that it would not mean that much because people might
want to take the treatment anyway because relying on the test
results of an alleged assailant could provide false assurances.
However, I would ask the following question of everyone in the
House. What if it were one of the members who had a high risk
exposure to someone else's blood or other bodily fluids? What if
it were you, Mr. Speaker? Would you not want to know just what
it was that you had been exposed to? Would you not want to know
what your chances were of contracting a communicable disease? I
would say yes, and I am almost certain that everyone else would
say yes. Why is this? I think it is because there are three
assurances by getting a blood sample from an alleged assailant's
blood.
I will talk about the three true assurances that the blood test
results would give. First, knowing whether the source person has
HIV, hepatitis B or hepatitis C assures the victim of a better
decision regarding his or her own health. The victim has to
decide whether to take a very intrusive chemotherapy program to
prevent the advance of the disease, and it would help the victim
to make that decision wisely because it is a difficult and very
traumatic decision to make.
In Isobel's case and in many other cases, once victims or
patients discover that the assailant or injured person has tested
negative to these diseases, they terminated the treatment. It
gives them a better chance of making a good medical decision in
their own lives.
From 1996 to 1998, the Toronto hospital assessed 30 possible
sharps-related exposures to HIV. In other words, they were
mostly pin pricks from needles where there was possible
contamination. Here is one quotation from its study, after
counselling of these 30 people, “5 persons chose not to take
treatment; 8 persons started chemoprophylaxis but discontinued
when the source patient's results were negative”. They changed
their minds based on that test result. “Rapid HIV testing
helped to reduce the duration of the treatment. The remaining 17
persons planned to take one month of medication; 9 of the 17
completed the medications”, and so on.
The study stated that the side effects experienced by all
persons on these medications included nausea, vomiting,
headaches, diarrhea and insomnia. It is a very traumatic
chemotherapy prevention program.
1115
The other serious side effects involve potential harm to
reproductive capacity, hair loss, numbness, tingling in the hands
or feet, a decrease in the number of white blood cells, anemia,
malaise, coughing, abdominal pain, kidney stones and a higher
risk of contracting diabetes. All these are side effects from a
preventive chemotherapy program.
As we can see, taking these drugs to fight HIV is not like a
doctor saying take two aspirins and see me in the morning. The
side effects are serious. Taking these drugs is not entered into
lightly. I think everyone would want to know whether or not the
person who contaminated them had a serious communicable disease.
Clearly it is far better for one's health to stop the treatment
than to continue taking the medication if one knows about it. At
least that is what many people have decided in these test cases.
The second true assurance of testing perpetrators' or people's
blood is that they are also assured of treatment if carrying a
disease unknowingly. Again that would be their decision. Imagine
people who perhaps are intravenous drug users and have not
bothered to get a blood test. If this situation came upon them,
the blood test results would be shared with them. They might
want to say that one should know if one has hepatitis B and have
some treatment for it, or the side effects or consequences will
be serious. It would help such a person as well.
The third true assurance of testing is that whether negative or
positive it provides a greater peace of mind to the good
Samaritan, emergency or health professional. Therefore I would
argue there are good reasons to take this test and to proceed
with it. Testing perpetrators or injured people for communicable
diseases will not provide false assurances to the victims and
patients. It will provide true assurances and true alternatives
for them as they decide what medical treatment they should be
taking.
Some people are focused on the negative parts of the bill. They
are concerned about charter protection of rights, security of the
person and so on. Those are valid concerns that I have tried to
address in the bill by making it very difficult but not
impossible to get a blood sample from someone who is at high risk
of passing on a communicable disease. It is a fair and proper
balance between the charter rights of the sick, injured and
perpetrators of crime and the charter rights of those who are in
service to help others.
Under the present system emergency and law enforcement
professionals and good Samaritans have no right to the security
of their person. If these individuals have a high risk exposure
to a stranger's blood they have no means to determine the
likelihood of whether or not they have contracted a disease.
They must anxiously await the incubation periods for HIV,
hepatitis C and hepatitis B. In the meantime they can choose to
undergo medical treatments with severe health side effects,
treatments they probably would not take if they knew that the
blood to which they had been exposed had tested negative for HIV.
This situation produces severe mental and physical duress and I
believe violates a person's rights. People should have a right
to know what virus may have entered their bodies. Bill C-244
would correct this rights imbalance. It does not swing the
rights all the way over one way or the other. It tries to find
that balance between the rights of a perpetrator of a crime to
privacy and security of the person, but it also protects those
who are trying to do good in society.
Bill C-244 protects people's privacy in four ways. A judge is
the only individual who can order that a blood sample be taken.
It is not a police officer and it is not a paramedic. The blood
samples can only be analysed for hepatitis C, hepatitis B and
HIV. Blood sample results are to be used only for medical
treatment purposes and for no other reason. The only people who
may have access to the results of the blood test are a peace
officer, the medical practitioner, the applicant and the person
from whom the sample of blood was taken.
In summary, the blood samples act is about fairness. Presently
people do not have the right to know what may have infected their
bodies from a third person, and Bill C-244 would correct this.
Second, the blood samples act is about balancing rights. Under
the present system only the perpetrator of a crime or the injured
or sick person has the right to the security of the person. Bill
C-244 would correct this negative situation and make it a balance
of rights between both parties.
Third, the blood samples act is about helping everyone involved
in this very difficult situation. It is about health care,
security professionals of all kinds and good Samaritans. It
would also assist the crime suspect carrying a serious virus
unknowingly.
It is about positive change to our legal system that would
provide fairness, a better balance between different rights and
assistance for those who are in the service of others.
1120
Tim, Isobel and thousands of other professionals need this bill,
this kind of protection, as they go about their work. In the
original story of the good Samaritan the only reward was that his
name was enshrined in the Bible and he has gone on to
become an example of a good Samaritan. Good Samaritan is still
in our language today as an example of people who go out of their
way to help others when they could have just passed by.
The bill recognizes that those who help the needy in society,
health care professionals, and what we commonly call good
Samaritans should have the assurance of knowing that when they go
about their good work, when they do a good deed, when they help
the needy, they will not be penalized and restricted by their
knowledge. I ask for support from all sides of the House for the
bill.
Mr. John Maloney (Parliamentary Secretary to Minister of
Justice and Attorney General of Canada, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, I
am happy to have this opportunity to speak to Bill C-244, an act
to provide for the taking of samples of blood for the benefit of
persons administering and enforcing the law and good Samaritans
and to amend the criminal code, introduced by the hon. member for
Fraser Valley.
The government and all of us in this place are fully aware that
some persons in the execution of their duties, which include
helping people and even saving human lives, are at risk of being
contaminated by the exchange of infected bodily fluids. This is
a very sensitive issue.
We appreciate the personal difficulties which these persons who
devote their lives to help others may experience. We owe it to
these fine Canadians to provide them with a means to regain peace
of mind as soon as possible after they have been involved in
circumstances that may raise the spectre of contamination.
However well meaning, and it is very well meaning, Bill C-244
does not represent the solution to this problem.
The bill is offering to us the creation of legislation that
establishes a mechanism for obtaining and executing a search
warrant on the human body. Part I of the bill provides that a
firefighter, a medical practitioner or a person whose profession
is to care for sick people may ask a justice of the peace to
issue a warrant authorizing a peace officer to require a
qualified medical practitioner or a qualified technician to take
samples of blood. These samples would be taken from a person who
was assisted by the firefighter or the medical practitioner where
there has been contact of body fluid and where the person is
suspected of being infected with some disease.
The bill would also cover the situation of an arrest without a
warrant by a person other than a peace officer or when a person
lawfully assists a police officer. I note in passing that the
bill is not clear as to whether health practitioners can be
forced to take the sample and, for that matter, whether and how
much force can be used to compel the person to submit to the
taking of bodily fluids.
The examination of these substances would determine according to
the proposed scheme whether the person carried the virus of
hepatitis B or hepatitis C or a human autoimmune deficiency
virus. In order to issue such a warrant the justice of the peace
would have to be satisfied by the person requesting the warrant
that four essential elements are present.
First, the justice has to be satisfied that there are reasonable
grounds to believe that the applicant came into contact with a
bodily substance from another person while engaged in the
performance of his or her functions in relation to that person,
or while assisting that person believing that his or her life was
in danger or that the person had suffered or was about to suffer
physical injury.
Second, the justice may issue a warrant if by reason of the
circumstances in which the applicant came into contact with the
bodily substance he or she is satisfied that there are reasonable
grounds to believe the applicant may have been infected by a
virus.
Third, the justice could issue a warrant if he or she believes
that by reason of a lengthy incubation period for diseases caused
by these viruses and the methods available for ascertaining their
presence in the human body an analysis of the applicant's blood
would not accurately determine in a timely manner whether the
applicant had been infected by such a virus that might have been
present in the bodily substances with which the applicant came
into contact.
Finally a warrant could be issued if a qualified medical
practitioner is of the opinion that the taking of samples of
blood from the person mentioned in the warrant would not endanger
the life and health of the person.
As we can see the scope of the bill which relates to persons
involved in situations where there is an exchange of bodily
fluids is remarkably wide. On its face the bill does not apply
in cases where an offence is alleged to have been committed but
rather in any case where there has been an exchange of bodily
fluids.
1125
The bill assumes that no offence has been committed for the
power to seek a search warrant. Thus a warrant to obtain a body
sample is sought without any offence being committed. Therefore
there is no nexus with criminal law.
What criminal law purpose is served by these amendments? Why
then are we seeking to amend the criminal code? The search
warrants in our law are for the purposes of advancing an
investigation of offences. This search warrant is, on the
contrary, for the sole purpose of obtaining some information
about someone who has not committed any offence. This is an
invasion of the privacy of someone, an invasion that is
remarkably intrusive, for no reason that would have anything to
do with criminal law.
The bill raises important concerns relating to privacy,
searches, seizures and human rights guaranteed by the Canadian
Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The taking of bodily substances
always raises significant constitutional issues. The taking of
bodily substances without any charges being laid or before
conviction raises issues under section 7 on life, liberty and
security of the person as well as under section 8 on reasonable
search and seizure of our charter of rights and freedoms.
Beyond the legal impediments in pursuing the legislation there
are also clear limitations as to what can be accomplished from a
scientific standpoint even if a warrant could be obtained. Thus
another reason for not supporting the bill is that even if it
were possible to adopt this kind legislation its value as an
instrument to comfort those who fear they have been affected is
certainly less than adequate.
[Translation]
The issue of blood samples was studied in depth in relation to
criminal law and in the context of sexual assault. The medical
experts are of the opinion that the only way a sexual assault
victim can be sure that he or she has not been contaminated is
to undergo a test to detect the hepatitis B or C virus, or HIV,
following the recommended procedures.
[English]
There is a variable period of time between the moment of
infection and the capacity of routinely available antibody tests
to detect the presence of the antibodies to the virus. Experts
in the field refer to that as the window period. Accordingly,
relying on the test results could provide false assurances to the
victim. For example, a person who would be the object of a
search warrant may be tested and the results negative. A peace
officer or a firefighter who relies on this information might in
fact later test positive if the person tested was in the window
period when he or she tested negative.
The issue of blood testing clearly belongs to the domain of
health. The Department of Justice is actively working with other
departments, in particular Health Canada, to ensure that more is
done to provide support and assistance to those who may be
concerned about the risk of hepatitis B, hepatitis C or HIV
infection. This is where our efforts should be concentrated. I
encourage these departments to continue these efforts on an
expedited basis.
I certainly appreciate that the sponsor of the bill means well.
I acknowledge him for his initiative in this regard. The use of
search warrants to invade privacy where nothing of a criminal
natural is even suspected should be of grave concern to the House
when, on top of that, the information that may be obtained with
such a search warrant is at best of very limited value. One
questions what can be usefully achieved by Bill C-244
notwithstanding its good intentions.
Mr. Peter Mancini (Sydney—Victoria, NDP): Mr. Speaker,
like the previous speakers I too am pleased to speak to this
private member's bill. A private member's bill is an important
avenue for those of us in the House to put forward issues we
think are important. I commend the member for Fraser Valley for
bringing forward this piece of legislation, Bill C-244.
He began his remarks by talking about and relating the story of
the good Samaritan. I suppose it would have been helpful to us
all if we had looked back at that time to see if the good
Samaritan had taken the gentleman he found in the ditch to be
tested for the plague. Then we would not have had to have this
debate today. We might have had some guidance from the Divine.
It is a well intentioned piece of legislation and I commend him
for bringing it forward. It raises some important questions
about people who partake in the kind of activity envisioned.
1130
When listening to his remarks I became a little concerned, and
the government member raised some of my concerns. There is a
difference between those who engage in criminal activity and the
important examples which he has given of those people who in the
execution of their professional duties as crime fighters or
peacekeepers have suffered or had cause to be concerned about
whether they had been infected with hepatitis B, hepatitis C or
HIV.
A great deal of his time was spent referring to the perpetrators
of crime. He is right. When someone is committing an offence,
should our police forces or security guards not have a right to
find out if they have been infected with some kind of disease if
in the execution of their duty, which is the protection of
society, they encounter some activity that might cause them
concern.
Bill C-244 is wider and goes further than that. It does not
narrow those affected to those involved in fighting crime and to
the perpetrators of crime. The legislation says that a person,
not a crime fighter or a police officer, may apply to a justice
for a warrant authorizing the taking of a sample of blood from
another person who is not necessarily the perpetrator of a crime.
There are numerous examples. We can envisage how wide ranging
the legislation would be. For example, it would apply to
firefighters who, in the execution of their duties, perhaps
saving an individual from a burning building, come into contact
with bodily fluid, blood or whatever, and may have cause to
wonder if they have been infected in the line of their duty with
some disease. The same would apply to health care workers and
paramedics. The bill is quite broad. It applies to persons who
in their professional capacity may find themselves in that
situation.
Like the government member, I wonder if the criminal code is the
best way to meet the need that is obviously a real concern for
the member and the people engaged in those activities.
I intend to support the legislation to at least get it to
committee where it can be examined. However, I wonder if we
might better look at labour legislation, because we are talking
about the health and safety of individuals engaged in the
performance of their professional duties, be they nurses,
firefighters, policemen, security guards, prison guards, teachers
or people in day care centres help children. We are talking
about a wide range of professionals and working people who are
faced in 1999 with health and safety concerns that we could not
possibly have imagined 25 years ago.
I applaud the intent of the legislation. The purpose of the
legislation is good. However, I wonder if working collectively
through the committee, members of the Conservative Party, Reform,
the Bloc, the NDP and the Liberals might find a better way to
ensure that this legislation does what the member wants it to do
without running into all kinds of hurdles. Working collectively
we may be able to achieve that.
In addition to wondering whether the criminal code is the
appropriate piece of legislation, there are certain civil
liberties that have been raised by the government speaker.
We may be able to find a way to take the thrust of this
legislation out of the criminal code and place it in labour
legislation. The government talks about working in tandem with
health. I lean toward labour legislation. If we find a way to
do that then we may avoid some of the constitutional challenges
that could follow as a result of criminal code legislation.
The hon. member in speaking to his bill referred to the
perpetrators of crime. However, I remind him, and he obviously
knows, that this legislation has a wider ranging.
I am a lawyer and a bit of a wordsmith, and we deal with words
all the time. Subclause 3(b) states that a judge can issue a
warrant, and it outlines the considerations.
Subclause 3(b) goes on to state “by reason of the circumstances
in which the applicant came into contact with the bodily
substance”. I need to explore that to see exactly what it
means. If it is a matter of a criminal code offence, then we
know that if, in the execution of his or her duties—and the
examples were given by the mover of the legislation—a police
officer gets stabbed by a needle or gets bitten, those are
compelling circumstances.
1135
However, for a nurse who works in a hospital, in a unit where a
number of people suffer from HIV or hepatitis B, are those
circumstances sufficiently compelling? No one says, as in some
of the criminal cases cited by the member, “I bit you. Now you
have HIV” or “I have a score to settle with you and I am going
to pierce you with a needle”. How compelling should the
circumstances be for the invasion of someone's civil liberties to
take a blood sample?
I need some clarification on that. By sending the bill to
committee we might very well get some of the clarification that
is required.
In summary, there is a serious point raised by the government,
and that is the arresting of someone who has not committed a
criminal offence. That is a serious matter for us to consider.
In this country one of the things we take pride in is our
freedom; freedom from arbitrary arrest, freedom from arrest
without the reading of rights and without knowing what we have
done wrong. That is where the criminal aspect of this is
different than applying it to the civil aspect, to those engaged
in health and safety occupations where no crime has been
committed.
I applaud the intent of the legislation. I think it should have
serious examination in committee. There are some real concerns
that I see with it, but I think that working together we may be
able to iron them out.
Mr. John Bryden: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.
The member for Lakeland and I would like to change positions on
the order of precedence of our Private Members' Business. He is
on for tomorrow and I am about 12 down. Members might recall
that my bill is Bill C-206, which is a bill to amend the Access
to Information Act. There are about 80 proposed amendments and
the bill has all party support from every party in the House.
All the backbenchers support it, Mr. Speaker.
But my problem, or our problem, the member for Lakeland and I,
is that his position is tomorrow and the rule of Private Members'
Business is that there should be 48 hours notice. I would ask
the House if I could get unanimous consent to waive the 48 hour
rule and replace it with 24 hours notice so that we can make the
exchange tomorrow.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): The hon. member for
Wentworth—Burlington has asked for the consent of the House to
exchange his bill with another bill in the order of precedence
for Private Members' Business. Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
[Translation]
Mr. Michel Bellehumeur (Berthier—Montcalm, BQ): Mr. Speaker, it
is rather strange. It is as if nothing had happened last
Friday, as if nothing had gone on in this House, as if there had
not been a major attack on a subject of great importance for
Canada and for Quebec: democracy. They are carrying on as if
nothing had happened.
This morning we are discussing Bill C-244, a bill that will never
get to be voted on, whereas last Friday we learned that the
government over there was preparing to use legislation to gag
Quebec completely so that it could not decide its political
future. I find that rather strange.
It is as if nothing had happened; life goes on as before. That
is not how things are in real life.
1140
We are now dealing with Bill C-244 and then we will move on to
real business. I will read the title of the bill, and hon.
members may understand why I have some hesitations. It is
entitled an act to provide for the taking of samples of blood
for the benefit of persons administering and enforcing the
law—and here is where it gets strange—and good Samaritans and to
amend the Criminal Code.
The last time I personally read the words good Samaritan, it was
in the Bible.
It is rather odd that we are talking of good Samaritans here
this morning, when the government opposite is certainly a good
example of what a good Samaritan is not.
The title is ambiguous, so I thought the contents would be
clearer. There are some definitions that I am familiar with
because they are the same as those found in the Criminal Code.
There is nothing wrong with that. However, let us look at clause 3:
Therefore, I could tell anybody that I want a blood sample taken
from them because they came too close to me and I think they
have AIDS.
An hon. member: This is an invasion of privacy.
Mr. Michel Bellehumeur: It most certainly is an invasion of
privacy. I will now resume reading the clause:
3. A person may apply to a justice for a warrant authorizing the
taking of a sample of blood from another person, in order to
determine whether that person carries a designated virus, where
the applicant believes on reasonable grounds that—
I believe that, yes, he came too close to me. Therefore, by
reason the circumstances under which that person came into
contact with a bodily substance of the other person, he or she
may have been infected by a designated virus.
This bill goes a little bit too far. We are not used to that in
a free and democratic society—or at least I think we are in a
democratic society despite the government's attack on Quebec
with its referendum legislation. This bill goes too far.
We are talking about arresting people without a warrant. We are
talking about taking a blood sample from a person. What kind of
force will be used to obtain that blood sample? Will we have to
tie the person up? Will we use the cane the Reform Party wanted
to use on young offenders? Exactly what kind of force will be
used? It is an extremely complex process.
I read the bill about ten times—and I do not think I am stupid—but
it would be rather complicated to enforce. In any case, if I am
stupid, there are many people on the other side who also are.
So the process is quite complex, and some of the bill's clauses
are extremely difficult to interpret. And, for the first time I
am aware of, a person could be required to provide a blood
sample even though that person has not been accused of anything
and has not committed any offence. This, merely because someone
thinks that person may carry the virus and got a little too
close to another person.
Just how far are Reformers prepared to go? Do they want to get
into people's bedrooms? Whether it is gay or straight people, if
someone slept with a person and is upset at that person the next
day, will he or she require that spouse or that one night
partner to undergo a blood test?
The Reform Party should clarify its views or intentions, because
I sincerely think that this would be a violation of fundamental
rights.
On the face of it, this bill utterly unacceptable to the Bloc
Quebecois. It is not a votable item, so one can say and propose
just about anything in the House—our system is rather archaic, in
this regard—and, quite often, what is proposed here is
meaningless. This proposed legislation is an example of that.
I began by saying that while we are debating this bill, some
extremely important events are taking place, and I want to
discuss them. It is unacceptable to be discussing such a
measure, when last Friday this government inflicted a terrible
blow to democracy in Canada and Quebec.
1145
It is getting ready to do it again this week with its
much-talked-about bill to prevent Quebecers from making a
democratic decision about their political future, and this is
unacceptable.
If there is one thing the Liberals have managed to do, it is to
unite Quebecers against the Prime Minister and the Minister of
Intergovernmental Affairs. The Minister of Justice is nodding
in agreement. I think she understands what I am saying, because
I think she is a democrat. She must not support the Minister of
Intergovernmental Affairs.
I am certain that, deep down, this wise woman is on the side of
justice.
I also think that the entire Liberal government opposite should
do some thinking and take a look at what all of Quebec's
commentators, journalists and politicians wrote on the weekend
and today on this subject. They would see that they are alone
on this in Quebec and that they are striking a hard blow to
democracy.
In order to give them the time to do a bit of reading and
thinking, pursuant to Standing Order 60, I move:
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): Is it the pleasure of the
House to adopt the motion?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland: All those in favour will
please say yea.
Some hon. members: Yea.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland: All those opposed will
please say nay.
Some hon. members: Nay.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland: In my opinion the nays have
it.
And more than five members having risen:
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland: Call in the members.
1155
(The House divided on the motion, which was negatived on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bellehumeur
| Bergeron
| Bigras
|
Crête
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Debien
| Desrochers
|
Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Gagnon
| Girard - Bujold
| Guimond
|
Lebel
| Loubier
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Sauvageau
|
St - Hilaire
| Turp – 18
|
NAYS
Members
Assadourian
| Bailey
| Bélair
| Boudria
|
Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Bryden
| Casey
| Catterall
|
Cullen
| Davies
| Doyle
| Graham
|
Grose
| Hanger
| Hilstrom
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Keddy
(South Shore)
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Knutson
|
Konrad
| Lee
| Leung
| Limoges
|
Longfield
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Maloney
| Mancini
|
Mark
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Muise
|
Nault
| Pankiw
| Phinney
| Power
|
Pratt
| Proud
| Proulx
| Richardson
|
Robillard
| Saada
| Sgro
| Solberg
|
St - Julien
| Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
|
Wasylycia - Leis
| Wilfert
| Williams – 51
|
PAIRED
Members
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): I declare the motion lost.
Mr. Michel Guimond: Mr. Speaker, I simply wanted to be sure that
my vote was counted with my Bloc Quebecois colleagues. I am not
sure my vote was counted, although I was present here in the
House and wanted to vote in support of my colleague's motion.
[English]
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): I have checked and
the vote has been counted.
[Translation]
Mr. Benoît Sauvageau: Mr. Speaker, if the division bells had
rung for 30 minutes, I would have been here to vote in support
of the motion by my colleague from Berthier—Montcalm. I therefore
want my vote to be recorded with the votes of the other members
of my party.
[English]
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): The vote was
counted.
[Translation]
Ms. Jocelyne Girard-Bujold: Mr. Speaker, I would like my vote to
be recorded as in favour of my colleague's motion.
[English]
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): The hon. member for
Jonquière was not in the Chamber.
[Translation]
Mr. Paul Crête: Mr. Speaker, I find it most unacceptable that it
has been decided today to make use of a technicality to prevent
members from voting.
1200
The members who were in committee—
An hon. member: The opposition has been gagged.
Mr. Paul Crête: The decision was made to do away with the usual
half hour which members need to get back to the House on this
occasion—
An hon. member: Shame on the Liberals.
Mr. Paul Crête: —and I think that the argument of the hon. member
for Jonquière in this connection is very valid.
Mr. Michel Bellehumeur: What happened is undemocratic.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): I am sorry. I would like
to respond in French but it is better that I respond in English
for greater certainty.
[English]
I have checked with the clerk. The clerk advises me that the
bells are up to 30 minutes, but anytime that the chief government
whip and the opposition whip advance to the Chair that cuts it
off. The request to adjourn debate was in order. The whips'
calling the vote was in order. Everything that has been done has
been done in order.
We are in Private Members' Business.
[Translation]
Mr. Yvan Loubier: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.
Several of my colleagues were working in various committees that
were sitting and, if committees are an extension of the House of
Commons and parliament, these members should be given enough
time to come back to the House to vote since they cannot do it
when they are at committee meetings. I think there is unanimous
consent of the House—
[English]
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): The rules of the
House were fairly applied to take the vote. The rules of the
House were finely applied to have the vote. There will be other
opportunities. At this time there are a couple of minutes left
in Private Members' Business, so let us please return to Private
Members' Business.
[Translation]
Mr. Stéphane Bergeron: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.
I have to say that the government whip and the whip of the
official opposition failed to show the most basic courtesy by
not allowing our colleagues to come back from the committee
meeting or from their office outside of this building to take
part in this important vote.
In the spirit of courtesy, I ask the unanimous consent of the
House to allow all our colleagues who were not here at the time
of the vote, who are here now and who want to have their vote
recorded, to be recorded as having voted on the motion.
[English]
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): The Chair certainly
understands what is going on here this morning. I had said
earlier that it is Private Members' Business. I will put the
unanimous consent request. But during the course of events, once
we have accomplished what was intended to be accomplished
particularly in Private Members' Business, it is appropriate to
get back to Private Members' Business. I will put the unanimous
consent request to the House.
The whip of the Bloc Quebecois has requested the unanimous
consent of the House to have the names of all members of the Bloc
who were not in the House applied to the vote. Is there
unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): There will be no further
points of order on this question. There
are two minutes left on debate on Private Members' Business.
Mr. Mac Harb: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order of
simple protocol. I have been standing for approximately 20
minutes and for whatever reason your eyes seem to focus on one
side of the House. Should I have been here when the time—
1205
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): I am sorry but the
time for Private Members' Business has expired. Orders of the
day.
[Translation]
Mr. Stéphane Bergeron: Mr. Speaker, I do not mean to belabour
the point, but I think you misunderstood my request for
unanimous consent.
I did not ask for unanimous consent to allow that all members of the
Bloc Quebecois be recorded as having voted on that motion, but
only those who are here now and who were not able to vote on the
motion.
[English]
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): I thank you very
much and I stand corrected. The whip of the Bloc Quebecois is
quite correct. I did not put the question as it was indicated. I
put the question that all members of the Bloc be recorded as
being here. The question was that those members presently in the
House be recorded.
I will put the question again. The hon. chief whip of the Bloc
Quebecois has requested the unanimous consent of the House that
all members of the Bloc present now in the House be recorded as
having voted in favour of the motion.
Is there unanimous consent of the House to adopt the motion?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): Agreed and so
ordered. We will need to record the people who were here. The
clerk will record those members standing.
GOVERNMENT ORDERS
[English]
NISGA'A FINAL AGREEMENT ACT
Hon. Robert D. Nault (Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern
Development, Lib.) moved that Bill C-9, an act to give effect
to the Nisga'a final agreement, be read the third time and
passed.
He said: Mr. Speaker, it gives me great pleasure to speak to
Bill C-9, legislation giving effect to the Nisga'a final
agreement.
We are nearing the end of a lengthy process, not only the
legislative process in the House and the B.C. legislature, but
the journey embarked on by the Nisga'a people more than 100 years
ago. I am hopeful that when debate in the House concludes,
members will see fit to pass Bill C-9 for its consideration in
the other place.
I have followed the debate and the committee proceedings with
great interest. I thank the members of the Standing Committee on
Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development for the excellent
work they have done.
It is interesting to note that throughout the debate a number of
common themes have emerged from those in favour of the Nisga'a
final agreement as well as from those opposed. The agreement
meets the tests that have been set out. It will provide
certainty. It will remove the restrictions of the Indian Act so
the Nisga'a people will have greater opportunities to prosper in
the future. It will protect the rights of Nisga'a women. It
will ensure that the rights of non-Nisga'a people living within
Nisga'a lands have been addressed. It will respect and maintain
Canada's existing legal and constitutional framework.
1210
The Nisga'a final agreement achieves all of these goals and
many, many more. It will provide certainty. By clearly setting
out all of the Nisga'a aboriginal rights, the agreement gives the
Nisga'a and their neighbours a chance to build a future together
knowing that issues of the past have been dealt with in an
honourable manner.
The Nisga'a final agreement will settle the ownership of land,
not just the land included in the treaty, but the huge expansive
territory over which the Nisga'a had originally laid claim. This
means certainty for investors which in turn means increased
economic activity and employment in British Columbia. Roslyn
Kunin, chief economist for the Laurier Institute testified before
the standing committee that current uncertainty is costing
British Columbians a minimum of $1 billion worth of investment.
One billion dollars is the minimum annual cost of not moving
ahead.
Let me quote David McLean, chairman of the board of Canadian
National, when he addressed the committee. He said: “What
appeals to me as a business leader is the certainty it creates”.
Of course for the final word on certainty, let me quote the
agreement itself: “This agreement constitutes a full and final
settlement in respect of the aboriginal rights, including
aboriginal title, in Canada of the Nisga'a nation”.
Throughout this debate there has been a great deal of criticism
of the Indian Act. Numerous provisions of the Indian Act are not
conducive to building successful communities in a modern context.
This is especially true as it pertains to land management and
economic development.
The Nisga'a final agreement offers a new approach. For all time
it will remove the Nisga'a people out from under the Indian Act.
With fee simple ownership of land, the Nisga'a will be able to
more fully develop their economy.
The achievement of self-government means the Nisga'a will no
longer have to seek permission of the federal government to
conduct their day to day affairs. The Nisga'a people have chosen
to take this step forward. They have agreed to a model of
government that provides them with greater authority and with it
greater responsibility.
[Translation]
Mr. Yvan Loubier: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I call for a
quorum count.
And the count having been taken:
[English]
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): The hon. member for
Saint-Hyacinthe—Bagot has requested a quorum call. We have a
quorum.
Hon. Robert D. Nault: They have chosen a path that makes
them answerable to themselves and to future generations for the
choices they make.
In short, the Nisga'a people have achieved what most of us take
for granted. To reject this agreement would take this
achievement away. It would force the Nisga'a to remain under the
Indian Act, an act which rather ironically has been most
persistently denounced by those speaking against this
legislation.
Ending the application of the Indian Act to the Nisga'a also
represents a significant gain for Nisga'a women. As I have
stated in the House, the Indian Act is silent on the rights of
women. Its last major revision was in 1951, long before either
the bill of rights or the charter of rights and freedoms.
Ending the Indian reserve system and the Indian Act for the
Nisga'a will put Nisga'a women on an equal footing with other
women in British Columbia with respect to the division of
matrimonial property in cases of marital breakdown. The reason
for this is that all provincial laws, including the B.C. Family
Relations Act, will apply to Nisga'a lands, something that is not
currently case for Indian reserve lands.
Once again I will quote the agreement: “The Canadian Charter
of Rights and Freedoms applies to the Nisga'a government in
respect of all matters within its authority”.
Nisga'a women will enjoy the full equality guaranteed by sections
15, 28 and 35 of the charter.
1215
In addition, there are important protections for women in our
constitution. Section 35(4) of the Constitution Act, 1982 makes
it clear that treaty rights are guaranteed equally to male and
female persons. Bill C-9 states in its preamble “The
constitution is the supreme law of Canada”. This treaty will
operate within the existing Canadian constitutional framework,
something which all three parties agree to.
It is clear that not only does the Nisga'a final agreement
protect the rights of women, it offers a significant improvement
over the status quo.
The relationship between the Nisga'a and their neighbours has
probably been the subject of more myths and misinformation than
any other aspect of the agreement. Throughout the negotiations
leading up to the Nisga'a final agreement great efforts were made
to accommodate the needs of neighbouring communities and
non-Nisga'a individuals who reside on Nisga'a lands. Almost
every chapter in the agreement reflects input that was received
in nearly 500 consultation and information sessions.
The agreement does not, as some would have us believe, provide
the Nisga'a government with any taxation authority over
non-Nisga'a residents. The only taxation authority for the
Nisga'a government is found in chapter 16, section 1 of the final
agreement, and it only extends to Nisga'a citizens living on
Nisga'a lands.
Nisga'a lawmaking authority is limited to matters internal to
the Nisga'a people, such as their language and their culture. All
Nisga'a laws will be subject to the Canadian Charter of Rights
and Freedoms. The Nisga'a government will be obliged to consult
with non-Nisga'a residents on any proposed measure that
substantially affects those individuals who will also, and this
is one to remember, have full access to the court system for
redress.
Where institutions are established that affect all residents of
the Nass Valley, such as school boards or health boards,
non-Nisga'a residents will be able to seek election and vote for
the candidate of their choice.
Who better to speak to this issue than the people directly
involved? Here is what Bill Young, a businessman, Nass Valley
Residents' Association member and the largest non-Nisga'a
landowner in the Nass Valley had to say about the Nisga'a final
agreement when he testified before the standing committee:
Any fears that we have had are alleviated and clearly defined in
the treaty documents.
Nisga'a self-government will not have any jurisdiction over land
currently owned by non-Nisga'a within the Nass Valley.
I believe that the Nisga'a treaty is a fair and honourable
solution that will protect and be fair to all parties.
I ask the honourable members of parliament to ratify this
treaty.
Terrace is the city lying closest to the Nisga'a. Here is what
the mayor, Jack Talstra, had to say to the committee:
We wish the treaty signed sooner, rather than later, so we might
focus our energy and creativity on implementation, rather than
past discussion and previous arguments.
Let us move forward with this new treaty.
As hon. members can see, this government is listening to the
people most directly affected by the Nisga'a final agreement.
Those people are comfortable with the agreement. They have
received the assurances and protection they sought. They
recognize the benefits that everyone will derive from the treaty.
They want us to get on with the job.
Finally, I would like to touch on the relationship between the
Nisga'a final agreement and the Canadian legal and constitutional
framework. There are those who continue to state that the
agreement changes the constitution. As I have before, I would
refer them to the agreement itself, which states quite clearly
“This agreement does not alter the constitution of Canada”.
The committee held a great deal of testimony from constitutional
and legal scholars and experts. There was a general consensus
that the agreement does not change the constitution, and the
self-government provisions of the agreement serve to define an
already existing constitutional right.
1220
As Professor Patrick Monahan of Osgoode Hall Law School stated:
We are not creating a third order of government because on this
argument the courts have implicitly already recognized that
aboriginal peoples and rights of self-government of aboriginal
peoples have constitutional status.
Clarifying the Nisga'a right to self-government sends a positive
signal. It demonstrates that this government is serious about
the relationship we are trying to build with aboriginal people
and it shows what we can accomplish within the existing
framework.
I have just quoted the agreement to the extent that it does not
alter the constitution. It is also quite clear that the treaty
will be subject to the constitution and the charter of rights and
freedoms.
Despite the often unfortunate history of our relationship with
the Nisga'a people, I have heard Nisga'a tribal council president
Joe Gosnell speak about his pride in Canada and in being a
Canadian. The Nisga'a people never wanted an agreement that
would make them less Canadian. By framing the final agreement
within the Canadian constitution they have demonstrated in a
tangible way their desire to remain an active part of the
Canadian family.
Not only is the agreement clear on the application of the
constitution and the charter, it is clear on the application of
federal and provincial laws. The self-government provisions of
the agreement do not provide the Nisga'a government with any
exclusive lawmaking jurisdiction. The Nisga'a government's
authorities are clearly defined and the Nisga'a government will
only have authority over the matter specifically outlined in the
agreement.
The Nisga'a government will have the principal authority to make
laws, and I quote the agreement again, “in respect of Nisga'a
government, Nisga'a citizenship, Nisga'a culture, Nisga'a
language, Nisga'a lands and Nisga'a assets”.
When I appeared before the standing committee I challenged
members opposed to the agreement to demonstrate why the Nisga'a
should not have primary authority over their language and
culture. So far I have heard no response to that challenge. I
also challenged those members to demonstrate why the Nisga'a
should not have authority over land use planning that is
consistent with the authority enjoyed by neighbouring
municipalities. Once again I have heard no response.
In some other areas the Nisga'a may adopt their own laws, but
those laws will only take precedence if they meet or exceed
standards in federal or provincial law. For example, if the
Nisga'a decide that they want to include the teaching of Nisga'a
language or culture in their schools they may do so. Teacher
certification and curriculum standards must meet or exceed
provincial standards. This only makes sense.
In the great majority of lawmaking areas either federal and
provincial laws will prevail or the Nisga'a will have no
authority to make laws. The interests of the Nisga'a and all
other Canadians are met with these arrangements. The Nisga'a did
not ask for unreasonable authorities and we would not have agreed
if they had.
As we enter a new millennium it is imperative for Canada to
renew and define its relationship with aboriginal people. Every
day we can see the results of the status quo. How we define that
relationship will vary from community to community and from
province to province. First nations have different
circumstances, different needs, and different desires. The
arrangements we make with them have to reflect that.
Let me be clear, this government's policy is that the
relationship will be developed. We have a fundamental difference
of opinion with those, like members of the Reform Party, who do
not see the need to develop that relationship; those whose view
of equality is to offer people individual cash payments if they
agree to give up their constitutional rights; those who deny the
balance between individual and collective rights that has made
Canada such a unique and successful country; those who see
society as a competition where the strongest thrive and the
weakest are left to fend for themselves; and those who would
perpetuate the mistakes of the past by imposing their belief
system on cultures that thrived for thousands of years before the
arrival of European settlers.
That approach would never lead to the new relationship to which
this government is committed. The Nisga'a final agreement proves
that we can develop that relationship. It proves that first
nations, provincial governments and the Government of Canada can
reach honourable arrangements that satisfy the needs of all
parties.
1225
It is a promising first step. The adoption of the Nisga'a final
agreement will send a clear signal that we as a society are ready
to build new relationships based on mutual trust, respect and
understanding. The adoption of Bill C-9 and the Nisga'a final
agreement will bring one journey to an end, but it will also mark
the beginning of another journey, one in which Canada and the
Nisga'a enter the millennium together, united as we have never
been before in our efforts to build a better society for future
generations.
It has been an honour to have the opportunity to speak to a
treaty that will go down in history as defining a new
relationship with aboriginal peoples based on trust. I think
that speaks much to Canada's viability in the future.
Mr. Mike Scott: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.
I would seek the unanimous consent of the House, since we have
the minister here speaking at third reading on the Nisga'a
treaty, to have a 10 minute question and answer period with the
minister.
The Deputy Speaker: Is there unanimous consent to have a
10 minute question and comment period?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
An hon. member: No.
Mr. Mike Scott (Skeena, Ref.): Mr. Speaker, I listened to
the minister speak about the myths and shameful actions of other
members of the House. I cannot think of anything more shameful
than to deliberately set out to misrepresent to Canadians and
British Columbians what this treaty represents.
From being involved in this entire matter for five and a half
years, I can say that the Government of Canada, this minister and
previous ministers from that side of the House have deliberately
set out to misrepresent and mislead Canadians on what the content
of the Nisga'a agreement is and what it represents for the
future, not only for Nisga'a people but for other aboriginal
people in British Columbia and across Canada.
I want to start by talking about the process. I have spoken
about it before in the House, but it bears repeating. In 1991
the Government of Canada—
Mr. David Iftody: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of
order. The member for Skeena is using very provocative language,
with suggestions that people on this side of the House
deliberately misled Canadians. I would ask the member to
withdraw those statements.
The Deputy Speaker: I have been listening very carefully
to the hon. member for Skeena and I do not believe he has used
unparliamentary language in his speech so far. He has not
suggested that the government misled members of the House, which
would be unparliamentary. In my view, he was careful to avoid
any such suggestion.
Mr. Mike Scott: Mr. Speaker, I want to talk about the
process which led to this agreement.
In 1991 the federal government, the province of British Columbia
and the Nisga'a leadership signed an agreement to negotiate a
land claim settlement behind closed doors, out of the public eye.
I was not even aware that this agreement had been signed. Most
British Columbians were not aware that the Government of British
Columbia and the federal government were intent on doing this.
I was elected as member of parliament for Skeena, which
encompasses the Nisga'a traditional lands, as it does the
Gitksan, the Gitanyow, the Tahltan, the Tsimpsean, the Haisla,
the Haida and the Taku River Tlingit. I became aware in 1994
that this agreement had been signed and that there were
negotiations taking place behind closed doors. I became rather
concerned, because any time government wants to negotiate
agreements behind closed doors which have the potential to impact
the area that I represent, I feel that I have a duty, an
obligation and a right to know what is being discussed. I
believe the people in the area that I represent have the same
right. They have the right to know what is going on.
1230
I wrote to the minister of the day asking to be included in some
form in order to keep abreast and be aware of what was being
discussed behind closed doors so I could report back to my
constituents.
I received a very curt response telling me that there was a
secrecy agreement that the parties were bound to, and that I was
not privy to the information, as an elected representative of
Skeena encompassing the Nisga'a traditional lands, nor was I
about to be given any information with respect to the
negotiations.
I felt it was my duty at that point to inform my constituents of
what was going on. We held a series of townhall meetings
throughout Skeena and then throughout British Columbia during the
course of 1994 and 1995 trying to make British Columbians aware
of the precedent setting set of negotiations taking place. We
recognize, as do most thinking people, that this was a precedent
setting set of negotiations. It was the first land claim treaty
to be negotiated in British Columbia in modern times. It
obviously will set the floor and not the ceiling for other land
claim agreements in British Columbia, and across Canada for that
matter.
The minister and the Government of British Columbia try to tell
us that this is not a template, although Premier Clark, in his
more lucid moments, did admit that it was indeed a template.
I ask anybody watching the debate on television how anybody
could possibly believe that a native negotiator somewhere in
British Columbia negotiating a treaty would not look at what the
Nisga'a have received and say that they have at least an
extremely strong morale argument, if not a legal argument, to say
“we are entitled to the same thing”. How can the Government of
Canada deny that?
I and many of my colleagues in the Reform Party from British
Columbia attempted, to the best of our abilities, to shed some
light on what was taking place. The government steadfastly
refused to provide any information, not only to me but to any
members of the public.
In 1996, with a great deal of fanfare, the government released
jointly with the Nisga'a leadership what is known as the AIP or
agreement in principle. From that, we started to get a much
clearer picture of what was intended in terms of a final
agreement because the framework for the final agreement was
before us.
It was at that point that the provincial government put together
a parliamentary committee, the committee for aboriginal affairs
for British Columbia, and went around the province in what I call
a dog and pony show, ostensibly to hear the views of concerned
citizens in British Columbia and to take into account what the
concerns or views might be in relation to the AIP so that the
final agreement could reflect those.
I attended some of those hearings held by the committee. I can
tell the House what happened. There was a long list of people
who were put in place by the government, who were set up ahead of
time, and who showed up and lauded the treaty's benefits and all
of its supposedly wonderful clauses and so on. Anybody who
showed up and expressed concern or opposition to any of the
elements of the agreement in principle were routinely dismissed
and often dismissed with the most degrading kind of attacks on
their character and their motives because they disagreed with the
direction in which the government policy was going.
It is shameful that British Columbians and Canadians cannot go
to a meeting and express their views and opposition to the
principles incorporated in the AIP without being treated in that
manner. That is the way the government and the Government of
British Columbia treated citizens not only in my constituency but
right across the province. I was there for it. It is a matter
of record because it is in the British Columbia proceedings. All
the meetings that committee held were recorded and it is a matter
of public record. I invite anybody who has any questions
whatsoever to access it through the Internet because it is all
there.
1235
In August 1998, the federal government, the provincial
government and the Nisga'a leadership unveiled the final
agreement. We were very anxious to see it. We looked through it
and noted right away that as a result of the committee's work in
British Columbia and all the public concern, criticism and so on
of various components of the Nisga'a treaty, not one major change
was made from the AIP to the final agreement. It was essentially
the same. It was just the framework fleshed out with the same
principles, the same policy, the same direction.
The rank and file Nisga'a people, who this agreement will affect
the most, were given a few weeks to consider this agreement
before they had to vote on it in the ratification process. They
were given a few weeks to consider a final agreement that is
250-some pages long and 450 pages of appendices. They were
supposed to evaluate a new Nisga'a constitution, a taxation
agreement and other related documents. They were supposed to
review all of this and make a decision within a few weeks as to
whether or not this was the right thing for them and their
families to go.
[Translation]
Mr. Claude Bachand: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.
This is an extremely important debate and there are not many
members in the House. I call for a quorum count.
And the count having been taken:
[English]
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): I thank the hon.
member for Saint-Jean. There is quorum.
Mr. Mike Scott: Many Nisga'a people have told us that the
ratification process was not fair. This charge was made by
people such as Frank Barton. He made these charges when he came
before the federal standing committee when it was in British
Columbia and there has been no response from any of the parties
involved.
The minister talked about what he and the government
characterize as the myths in the treaty. The minister stood in
the House of Commons and, with a straight face, said that when
the federal committee held hearings several weeks ago in British
Columbia and Ottawa, there was “general consensus” that the
Constitution of Canada would not be altered as a result of this
agreement.
Nothing could be further from the truth. The minister knows
that and he sits there with a smirk on his face because he thinks
it is funny when the likes of Professor Stephen Scott from McGill
University, a recognized legal expert; Professor Tom Flanagan
from the University of Alberta; Mel Smith, former constitutional
adviser to the Government of British Columbia for several
decades; Gordon Gibson, the former leader of the Liberal Party of
British Columbia; Professor Ehor Boyanowsky from Simon Fraser
University; and Liberal leader Gordon Campbell of the current
Liberal opposition in British Columbia, all appeared before that
committee and said exactly the opposite.
How can government members and this minister sit there with
smirks on their faces and say that there is general consensus
that this agreement does not change the Constitution of Canada?
That is a load of bunk and the minister knows it.
How does it change the constitution? There are at least 14
areas in the agreement where the Nisga'a central government will
receive legislative authority that goes beyond the reach of
parliament and beyond the legislature of British Columbia and
that will be constitutionally protected under section 35 of the
Canadian constitution. It will be considered an aboriginal or
treaty right. It is right in the Nisga'a treaty itself that this
treaty exhaustively sets out section 35 rights. Chapter 11 in
this agreement, which deals with self-government, will obviously
be considered an aboriginal treaty right and it will be
constitutionally protected. It will be entrenched in
constitutional concrete, never to be changed.
1240
When I look around the House at the opposition parties that have
a solemn duty to uphold the Constitution of Canada and I see what
they have done in collusion with one another to override the
constitution and to go against the wishes of Canadians, because
Canadians said no to this very idea in 1992 in the Charlottetown
accord, I am appalled. I am sickened by what members of the
House have done or are attempting to do. That is not a myth.
Those are the plain facts.
If the government wants to entrench aboriginal self-government
as a constitutionally protected right with legislative authority
that goes beyond the reach of parliament and the provincial
legislatures, it can do it but it has to use the amending
formula. It needs seven provinces with 50% of the population to
do it. It tried to do that in 1992 with the Charlottetown
accord, the same political parties that are here now with the
same faces and the same failed ideas, and the Canadian people and
British Columbians said “no'. British Columbians had the
highest no of all the provinces. Aboriginal Canadians also said
no.
What part of no does the government and the other political
parties not understand. Why are they colluding with one another
to try and get this constitutional amendment through the back
door? Frankly, I find that sickening.
In 1950, the Supreme Court of Canada said, in the Lord Elgin
Hotel case, if the minister cares to refer to it, “The
Constitution of Canada does not belong to the legislatures. It
does not belong to the politicians. It does not belong to
governments. It belongs to the people of Canada and the people
of Canada are the only ones who can consent to these kinds of
constitutional changes”. There is an amending formula to
determine whether that consent is given or not.
But no, the government and other parties are trying to do an end
run around that. They are trying to do an end run around the
amending formula and around the constitutional process to
entrench aboriginal self-government as a constitutionally
protected right with legislative authority that for all time will
go beyond the reach of parliament and the reach of the provincial
legislatures. That is exactly what René Lévesque was talking
about when he spoke about sovereignty association. What this
will do is create a semi-sovereign state within the boundaries of
Canada.
As a precedent, because the government is pressing ahead with
other treaties, not just in British Columbia but in other parts
of Canada, what Canadians can expect over time is a large number
of semi-sovereign states within the boundaries of Canada where
people will live by different rules, different regulations and a
different status based on ethnicity. Frankly, I find that idea
repugnant.
The idea of legislated segregation has been tried around the
world. The minister, instead of sitting there flapping his gums,
should get out his history books and read what happened in the
United States and in South with legislated segregation. The
government can say that this is legislated segregation driven
with good intentions. I do not doubt that it is, but legislated
segregation driven with good intentions is not acceptable. It is
always wrong. That is what the government and the other
political parties in the House are in agreement on.
In the history of Canada, from before Canada was a country and
before Confederation, in dealing with aboriginal people, there is
a history of legislated segregation. Look where it has left
native people in the country. We do not have to go any further
than the closest reserve. Most reserves are not very desirable
places to live. Unemployment is at 70%, 80% or 90%, depending on
which reserve we are talking about. There are social pathologies
that are unheard of in other Canadian communities. There are
people living in squalor, in what amounts to third world
conditions, as we have heard so many times in the House.
Why does the government not get the message? Legislated
segregation does not work.
The people it affects the most are the people this kind of policy
is supposed to help. If I were an aboriginal Canadian I would
ask the federal government to stop helping me because all the
help it has given so far has not been very good. I would ask the
government to leave me alone, but it will not.
1245
The Liberals talk about the application of the charter of rights
and protecting the rights of Nisga'a women and other aboriginal
women in Canada. The minister sits in the House and
pontificates. I do not know why he has not bothered to listen to
people like Mizie Baker, a Squamish woman who came before our
committee because she was not allowed to appear before the
minister's committee to testify, or Wendy Lundberg who came
before our committee because she was denied the opportunity to go
before the minister's committee. He did not want to hear from
her. The Liberals did not want to hear from these people. They
do not like to hear from anyone who disagrees with them.
It is not unlike some of the more dictatorial regimes we have
seen around the world in recent history. They insulate themselves
from any kind of opposition or negative feedback from Canadians.
People such as Mizie Baker and Wendy Lundberg, as well as a
number of other aboriginal women, have told us of their concern
and their lack of rights as aboriginal women, as Canadians, not
only through this legislation but also through Bill C-49.
Wendy Lundberg wrote a letter to a Liberal member from British
Columbia expressing her concern over the fact that her rights as
an aboriginal woman were not protected. The response she
received from the Liberal member of parliament was that they were
working on that. Her letter was written in relation to Bill C-49
and in relation to the Nisga'a final agreement.
How will the charter of rights and freedoms apply? There is
wording in chapter 2 of the agreement, the general provisions,
which says that the charter of rights and freedoms applies,
bearing in mind the free and democratic nature of the Nisga'a
government. What do they mean? They sound like innocuous words.
We are not constitutional or legal experts so we took the time
to consult with the likes of Professor Tom Flanagan, Professor
Steven Scott, Mel Smith and others. We took the time to ask them
what it meant in their view. In their view the addition really
means that the Nisga'a central government will have a free rein
in denying charter rights, bearing in mind the free and
democratic nature of the Nisga'a central government.
I do not mean to imply the Nisga'a leadership that negotiated
this agreement has ulterior motives. I do not know and I am not
trying to make that allegation, but this sets the groundwork for
individual charter rights to be overridden in the future.
Under section 35 of the constitution the Nisga'a final agreement
will be considered an aboriginal or treaty right. Under section
25 of the constitution in applying the charter of rights and
freedoms, aboriginal and treaty rights take precedence over
individual rights as expressed in the charter. That is not a
myth. Any Canadian can read the charter of rights and freedoms
and section 25 of the Canadian constitution. I do not think the
minister has read it but I urge him to do so. From the way he
talks in the House, I do not think he has read the agreement or
is familiar with it.
There is no question that the individual rights of Nisga'a
people are seriously diminished as a result of this agreement.
There is no doubt about that whatsoever.
1250
Not only Nisga'a people but more and more aboriginal people in
British Columbia are coming to understand that. They are
concerned about it. They are asking how they can deal with a
government that will come along in the future, for example, and
ban trade unions like the Kamloops band recently attempted to do
in British Columbia.
What happens if a future Nisga'a central government or some
other aboriginal government that is working within the same kind
of self-government framework as in this document happens to say
that trade unions are culturally incompatible with Nisga'a
tradition? They have legislative supremacy in the area of
culture. In the self-government provisions they have the
absolute right to regulate and ban businesses, professions and
trades on Nisga'a land. That is not a myth. It is right in the
agreement.
If a Nisga'a central government takes that position, what would
be the recourse of the people who have attempted to organize the
trade unions? They could go to court if they have the money but
likely they will not have it to do that. However, if they go to
court and say that their charter rights have been violated as a
result of the law that has been passed by the Nisga'a central
government, the Supreme Court of Canada will have to look at the
section 35 rights.
The court will have to apply those rights as they relate to
section 25 of the constitution. It will have to look at the
wording bearing in mind the free and democratic nature of the
Nisga'a government. It will have to look at the provisions that
say that the Nisga'a central government has the absolute right to
regulate and ban businesses, professions and trades on Nisga'a
lands. With all those taken together it is easy to see that the
court will have a difficult time upholding the charter of rights
of Nisga'a individuals under those circumstances. That is just
one set of circumstances.
The Nisga'a will have legislative authority to determine Nisga'a
citizenship. That legislative authority goes beyond parliament
and provincial legislatures. In other words it is up to the
Nisga'a central government to determine who is a citizen and who
is not.
What happens if one is a Nisga'a living in the Nass Valley in
one of the four Nisga'a communities who happens to disagree
vociferously with the Nisga'a central government on an issue or
on a range of issues? One becomes what is known as a dissident.
This has happened in other aboriginal communities in Canada. We
have had letters from people on reserves in the prairies and so
on where leadership has determined that in some cases the easiest
way to deal with dissidents was to excommunicate them or attempt
to pull their band membership.
Right now under the Indian Act and under the current system,
which I do not mean in any way to defend, at the very least there
is the ultimate protection of the Parliament of Canada for those
people if the Parliament of Canada chooses to invoke it. However,
under the Nisga'a final agreement that is lost forever.
If in the future the Nisga'a central government determines that
people are not citizens for whatever reason, they are no longer
entitled to be considered Nisga'a or to receive or partake in the
benefits of this treaty. In fact they become exiles in their own
lands. Aboriginal people in British Columbia have told me of
their concerns about being exiles in their own lands. That is an
absolute fact.
In terms of principle, individual rights versus collective
rights is at the core of this treaty. Fundamentally that is what
is the most wrong with it. The province of British Columbia and
the Government of Canada, but primarily the Government of Canada,
see aboriginal people as collectives. They do not see them as
individuals.
1255
They do not realize or choose not to realize that the
400,000-odd aboriginal Canadians who live on reserves in Canada
today are all individuals. They do not think the same way. They
do not want the same things. They are like everyone else. They
have many different aspirations, hopes, dreams and goals.
How will they be able to reach those aspirations, dreams and
goals when collectivities with centralized decision making will
have enormous control over assets, land and wealth? Very little
of it will flow to individuals. Most of it will flow to
collective ownership. How will these people tap into that as
individuals and get ahead?
I talked about legislative segregation a few minutes ago.
Collectivities have been tried all over the world. In east bloc
countries it was known as communism or state socialism. It has
been a demonstrated failure everywhere it has been tried.
What makes these people so arrogant as to believe that they
somehow have a new formula for recreating a failed idea and
making it work? Who will suffer the most? It will be the very
people that the agreement ostensibly sets out to help.
Why cannot the government think outside the box? Why can it not
stop for a few minutes? Why cannot the minister and the
department stop and re-evaluate where they are going with
aboriginal policy, where they have gone, where they would like to
go, and do it in a manner that is intellectually honest? With
this agreement and with the policy coming from the government we
have seen a tremendous amount of intellectual dishonesty.
We have seen a government that routinely tries to downplay and
conceal the extent of accountability problems on reserves, which
exist because the government has set forth policies that allow
them to happen and create the environment for them to happen.
Why cannot the Government of Canada just once look at aboriginal
people as individuals, not as collectives? Why cannot the
government resolve these claims which we all agree need to be
resolved with a generosity of spirit, a fairness of mind, and
bearing in mind the horrible position in which aboriginal people
have been placed as a result of legislated segregation in the
country? The real crime perpetrated against aboriginals in
Canada is legislated segregation.
Why cannot the government look at individuals and come up with a
policy that says in resolving these outstanding claims and in
trying to set things right it will try to the greatest extent
possible to compensate individuals with land, cash and other
assets? At the end of the process aboriginal people who freely
choose of their own accord to stay together in communities will
be provided with a municipal style government not unlike that of
the city of Toronto, the city of Brantford or the city of
Kamloops, British Columbia. What is wrong with that?
Why does the federal government and the province of British
Columbia insist on having a form of government which can only be
called a semi-sovereign state with legislative authority that
goes far beyond that of any municipality in the country? Why
cannot they see aboriginal people as individuals? Why cannot
they go in that direction?
I do not think most Canadians would object in any way to a true
municipal style of aboriginal self-government for aboriginal
people. It would give aboriginal people who choose to stay in
aboriginal communities the tools they need to run their
communities as much as it gives the people who freely choose to
live in the city of Ottawa as a group of citizens the tools they
need to have a city that functions, that provides transportation
corridors and transportation services, snow removal, and all
other things we expect from a city.
1300
At the same time it would also provide them with the absolute
protection of the Canadian constitution, most particularly the
charter of rights and freedoms. It would also break from the
notion of centralizing collective ownership and decision making
in the hands of a few people.
I am puzzled, frustrated and completely unable to understand why
the Government of Canada cannot see that. Why can it not pause
and go through an intellectual debate that is honest and willing
to look at history, even recent history, and look at the failure
in that recent history and learn from it rather than repeat it
over and over again? I am appalled that the Government of Canada
wants to continue to march down this road; damn the torpedoes,
not a care about what British Columbians think or what other
aboriginal people think.
The rudest comments are made about those who disagree with it.
Their character and motives are trashed. They are called bigots,
anti-Indian, racists. I could go on and on. That is what the
other parties in the House either imply or sometimes directly say
when they talk about anybody who expresses opposition to the
principles contained in the agreement.
Mr. Peter Stoffer: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of
order.
I respect the right of the hon. gentleman from Skeena to give
his point of view, but to indicate in any way, shape or form that
our party would call him or his party racist in a public forum
would be completely out of line. I would like him to retract
that statement, please.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): It is a matter for
debate. I was listening very carefully to the member for Skeena.
He made the comments in a reflective manner. He was not
impugning motive. He was saying what has happened. In my
opinion the words as presented were quite in order.
Mr. Mike Scott: Mr. Speaker, I have respect for the hon.
member who just rose. However, I would like to point out that
the member from Kamloops, who is not here right now, not a week
ago in public, in a widely circulated media interview, said
exactly that. I would ask the hon. member in all fairness to
look up what the hon. member from Kamloops said. I am not making
it up.
And it was not just once. It has been over and over again.
Members on this side of the House have said this about Reformers
in the House. That is a matter of public record. I am sorry if
it offends people, but it is the truth. That is what happened
and it happened with the member from Kamloops not 10 days ago in
an interview. They should be ashamed of themselves. We should be
able to engage in honest, intellectual debate without getting
into that kind of mudslinging and name calling.
I will conclude my remarks by saying that at the end of the day
in discussing this treaty the people we ought to be considering
the very most is the Nisga'a people themselves. They are going
to have to live with this for all time because it will be set in
constitutional concrete.
I say that individual Nisga'a people, and I think there are more
of them who are coming to understand it, are going to recognize
that this is not a good deal for them. It is not a good deal for
their families.
It is going to be a good deal for people who are involved in
Nisga'a central government for sure. It is going to be a good
deal for lawyers as my colleague points out. It is going to be a
good deal for all those hangers on in the Indian industry in this
country who have been sucking millions upon millions of dollars
out of the taxpayers' wallets and out of the aboriginal
communities for decades now.
It will be a good deal for them.
1305
It will be a good deal for the courts. The Marshall decision
was based on a treaty that was half a dozen pages in length.
Imagine the amount of litigation that will come out of this kind
of an agreement.
The minister even said in his remarks a few minutes ago in the
House that people have access to the courts. What kind of answer
is that for a minister of the crown to be giving? It is almost
as if the Liberals are inviting and expecting legal challenges.
They want to see it happen. Maybe all their friends in the legal
profession are rubbing their hands together waiting for this to
get passed so they can all make a buck on it.
This will not be a good deal for Nisga'a people. That will
become evident very quickly. It will not be a good deal for
other aboriginal people in Canada because the precedent has been
set in terms of the government's provisions in this treaty, in
terms of collective ownership of land and collective control over
finances. At the end of the day it is supposed to be the Nisga'a
people who benefit from this.
Let the record show that the Reform Party was the only party
that stood in the House and said that not only is this deal
unprincipled, not only is it unconstitutional, but it is wrong
for the country and for all Canadians. Let it be said and never
forgotten that the Reform Party was the only party that stood in
this parliament and said that this agreement is bad for Nisga'a
people. History will prove us right.
We know the Liberals have the majority. We know that they can
ram this through. That is the way our dysfunctional
parliamentary system is operating in Canada these days. We know
that the Liberals can get away with it. We have mounted the best
opposition that we could. We have done everything within the
powers that are granted the official opposition to highlight the
defects in this deal and to bring it to the attention of
Canadians.
Let the history books show that we did our jobs while other
members of this place sat in their seats. They would not hold
the government accountable. They were in collusion. They were
intellectually dishonest. At the end of the day they failed not
only to serve Canadians, but they failed to serve the best
interests of the Nisga'a people.
[Translation]
Mr. Claude Bachand (Saint-Jean, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I usually begin
my speeches on Indian affairs by saying that I am very pleased
to address the issue, but today it is with somewhat mixed
feelings that I do so.
I am pleased because this is a historic day—and I know that a
number of Nisga'a are in the gallery today—a day when we will
finally vote to give the Nisga'a the opportunity to shake off a
yoke called the Indian Act. The Nisga'a have been constrained
by that act for over 100 years, and today the Bloc Quebecois,
along with other parties in this House, will enable the Nisga'a
to free themselves from that act.
I have mixed feelings however because, while we are about to do
this for the Nisga'a, the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs
wants to put Quebecers under a yoke. This threat is the reason
why it is somewhat difficult for me to be totally pleased on
what should otherwise be a happy occasion.
The Nisga'a will understand that if the Bloc Quebecois
supported their quest for self-government, it must also protect
the Quebec people, another very important people in Canada but
who many in this House will not recognize. I will elaborate
toward the end of my speech.
I first want to salute Joe Gosnell and Harry Nice, who
co-ordinated the entire negotiation team which is here today.
I know this is a very important day for them, bringing to a
close a long negotiation process.
Earlier I listened to the hon. member for Skeena, who said that
negotiations first began in 1981, but in fact we must go back
much further than that.
We must go back to the end of the 19th century.
1310
Even then aboriginal leaders were trying to convince the
British crown in London of the importance of greater autonomy.
This dragged on for over 100 years. I agree with the
member that the pace has picked up in the past 20 or 25 years.
Now we are reaching a conclusion with the signature of a final
agreement and the necessary endorsement of the Parliament of
Canada.
I first heard about the Nisga'a people at the time the agreement
in principle was signed. I went to their territory and was
shown around.
These people were very happy about the signing of the agreement
in principle, but I do not think they had any idea that, even after
signing an agreement with the federal government, a whole series
of stumbling blocks would remain before the final stage of third
reading in the House of Commons, not to mention Royal Assent in
the Senate. Today, they have made it through all these hurdles
and the Bloc Quebecois has been with them all the way.
When parliament signed the final agreement last spring—the former
Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development signed it—I
again visited the Nisga'a territories and received the same
welcome. It is an amazing area, with the Nass River that I
mentioned earlier.
This far north in British Columbia, the water is the most
amazing shade of blue-green. This is the result of mineral salts
in the water. The Nisga'a attachment to the land of their
birth, to the Nass River and the entire river valley, which is
of extreme importance to them, is understandable.
Every time I have been there, I have had a chance to see what
they call the lava beds. There is a fable relating to these
waterways. I have read this fable; nearly 2,000 Nisga'a died
500 years ago because of a volcanic eruption.
According to the fable, the children had lost contact with
nature and were mistreating animals. They were extremely cruel
to the animals. The elders apparently told them “Stop your
cruelty or the Creator will get angry if we are too cruel to the
animals.”
According to the fable, the volcano then erupted and two whole
villages were engulfed by the lava, killing close to 2,000
Nisga'a villagers, who now lie under the lava beds of the
volcano.
It was all explained to me during my visit. I was told about
the importance of fishing, especially salmon fishing using the
famous salmon wheel. When the salmon swim upstream, they swim
into a sort of paddlewheel, which scoops them into a box where
they can be kept fresh for days until they are caught. I
thought this was an invention of the native people of the Yukon,
but the Nisga'a have assured me that they are the ones who
invented it. This goes to show how important fishing and this
wheel is to the Nisga'a.
My guide on my latest visit was Eric Grandison, and with the
usual warm welcome one gets from the Nisga'a, he took me to his
mother's home to see the family smokehouse, where we sampled
some excellent smoked salmon.
This was not frozen smoked salmon like Price Club salmon. This
was salmon that had been caught only a day or two before and
then fully smoked. The taste was exquisite and this was
something that one can rarely, if ever, get here.
Unfortunately, I would have had the opportunity to taste it
again here last week but the Bloc Quebecois Christmas party was
the same night as their salmon party so I could not attend.
During my two visits there, I could see that a rush on the
natural resources on the Nisga'a lands was under way. The first
time, when I visited the lands of the Chilcotin and Carrier
Sekani, hundreds of trucks were hurrying to cut down the forests
as quickly as possible before the land was handed over to the
aboriginal people.
1315
The Nisga'a will now have control over their own forests, but I
also want to speak up for the Carrier Sekani and the Chilcotin,
whose land claims are ongoing and who are unfortunately the
victims of this rush on natural resources.
The agreement in principle and the historic bill were presented.
After second reading, we travelled to British Columbia. We went
to Terrace, Prince George, Smithers, Victoria and Vancouver. I
will admit that it was a bit of a shock to Bloc Quebecois
members. The hon. member for Manicouagan was also with me.
Of course, we asked for interpretation services.
The witnesses who spoke in support of aboriginals and aboriginal
people themselves were treated shoddily at the hearings. Bloc
Quebecois members were stunned whenever they were asked to
“speak white”. This was very shameful.
I do not want to make any generalization, but I think those who
said that are best described as “rednecks”. My feeling is that
these people came out to treat the Nisga'a, the aboriginals and
French speaking people in a malevolent way. However, after
speaking with many people in Terrace, Victoria and Vancouver, I
am convinced that these rednecks were a very small minority.
I raised these incidents with Phil Fontaine, the first nations
chief, when he made his presentation on the Nisga'a.
His response was “You were told to “speak white” during one or
two days, while this is the attitude we have been confronted with
all our lives. How do you feel when you are being treated like
that?”
We did not like it, of course, but it helped us better
understand the Nisga'a issue and understand how long aboriginals
have been in that situation, and what should be done to correct that
situation, to change it and turn the page so that these people
can now decide their own future.
The Bloc Quebecois showed its compassion and understanding. I
think the Nisga'a will agree that we have always supported them.
There are Nisga'a representatives here today, but I must warn
them that they are in a turbulent zone and that the turbulence
will keep increasing.
I can promise members of the federal Liberal Party that this
will get worse, probably tomorrow, if the minister introduces
his bill. We are warning them. They need to tighten their
seatbelts because I think we are in for quite a ride. If they
have never seen what stuff Quebecers are made of, they will now.
We are as proud to defend our people as the Nisga'a were to
defend theirs. That is all I wanted to add.
As to the concept of a people, I also heard the member for
Skeena earlier cite an eminent constitutional expert by the name
of Tom Flanagan. Mr. Flanagan tabled a brief before the
Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs and Northern
Development. Throughout the trip, I brought up the concept of
peoples with those I met. Opponents of the bill have always
thrown two arguments at us: the uncertainty caused by this debate
and the agreement's lack of equality.
We often hear that everyone must be equal in Canada.
I asked Mr. Flanagan whether he believed that there were several
nations and several peoples in Canada and his answer was that,
like Pierre Elliott Trudeau, he thought that there was only one
people in Canada, the Canadian people. So there was no point in
supplementary questions on the rights of these nations, if we
were hung up on that.
I think that this is the trouble with the Reform Party. It does
not think that there are other peoples and other nations in
Canada. It is proving its point with the Nisga'a issue, as
well as its stand with the members of the Liberal Party to put
Quebec into a straitjacket. Reformers no more believe in the
concept of a Nisga'a people than they believe in a people of
Quebec. For them, everyone must be treated equally.
Quebec is as important as Prince Edward Island.
1320
We disagree completely on this and that is why we are perhaps in
a better position to understand the native peoples' move toward
autonomy because we are taking those same steps ourselves. It is
easy for us to understand them. When aboriginals approach the
Bloc Quebecois and announce that they are working for greater
self-government, it is only natural that we understand where they
are coming from.
During my tour, I tested their concept of nation by asking
people whether they believed that there were several nations and
peoples in Canada. Their answer was yes. If there is
recognition for this concept, it follows that these nations and
peoples have specific rights. This is recognized in
international law. With recognition as a people or nation comes
recognition of specific rights.
Defining specific rights requires partnership agreements. As we
see it, the final Nisga'a agreement is a partnership agreement
between two, even three peoples.
[English]
Mr. David Iftody: Mr. Speaker, I rose on a point of order
a few minutes ago with respect to the comments of the member for
Skeena who, in reference to the minister and the government, used
the words “deliberately” and “misrepresent”.
In normal situations it is regretfully normal that one may, I
believe, refer to the government or political parties, but I will
read for the Chair the Hansard blues which I obtained a few
minutes ago. The member for Skeena said: Mr. Speaker, when I
listened to the minister speak and talk about myths and shameful
actions of other members in the House, I cannot think of anything
more shameful than to deliberately set out to misrepresent to
Canadians and British Columbians what this treaty represents.
It goes on to say in the next paragraph: This minister and
previous ministers before him have deliberately set out to
misrepresent and mislead Canadians on the content of the Nisga'a
agreement.
That is the end of the quote from the Hansard blues. I
ask, based on the new information before the House, that the
member for Skeena apologize to the minister of Indian affairs and
withdraw those unparliamentary comments.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): The Deputy Speaker
was in the chair when the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister
of Indian Affairs and Northern Development rose on his point of
order and subsequently waited to have the draft blues of
Hansard to review.
Before the Deputy Speaker left and I took the chair we discussed
exactly that because it was, in his opinion, very close to the
line but it did not cross the line. It did not cross the line
because of the tone and the context. It was a question of what
had brought us to this point today.
I have discussed this at great length with the Deputy Speaker
because it is a question worthy of being discussed at great
length.
I invite the hon. member for Skeena, only if he chooses, to
clarify those remarks to ensure that I and the Deputy Speaker
have interpreted his remarks accurately. I would invite the hon.
member for Skeena to do so, if he so chooses.
Mr. Mike Scott: Mr. Speaker, first, in my remarks I was
responding to the government's position that the Reform Party was
propagating myths, and I did not ascribe my remarks to any
individual in particular. I was ascribing my remarks to a
government policy and position that I felt was going over the
line in terms of how it was trying to represent an issue to
Canadians which was not correct.
1325
Mr. John Williams: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of
order. I find it rather unfortunate that a member, in this case
the member for Skeena, has to stand to defend his remarks in the
House. As he has since pointed out, he was clearly talking about
government policy and the way that this whole treaty has been
handled. It is rather unfortunate that a parliamentary secretary
would cast aspersions on the member for Skeena. I think this
whole matter should be laid to rest. The government should
withdraw its allegations and let the member for Skeena—
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): We are not getting
into debate on this matter. The Deputy Speaker ruled at the time
that in his opinion it was not unparliamentary. I am ruling,
after reviewing exactly the same draft and after having heard the
interventions, that it was not unparliamentary. We will resume
debate with the hon. member for Saint-Jean.
[Translation]
Mr. Claude Bachand: Mr. Speaker, I have serious questions
regarding the relevance of points of order that have nothing to
do with me. I was making an important speech for my Nisga'a
friends and I was interrupted by a parliamentary secretary who
raised a point of order about something another member had said.
I hope you counted the time this exchange took and that you will
extend my time accordingly.
I was wondering about the relevance of a point of order that
does not concern me. Can you clarify that for me? I am talking
about the point of order.
Is it relevant to interrupt my speech to raise a point of order
that does not concern me? I would like you to clarify that for
me before I go on with my speech.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): The point of order was in
order.
Mr. Claude Bachand: Mr. Speaker, if I understood your signal
correctly, you will be extending my time to compensate for the
time lost during this point of order. How much time do I have
left?
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): You have 25 minutes left.
Mr. Claude Bachand: I invite my colleagues to show respect to
those members who speak in the House. If there is a point of
order that concerns me, I will be glad to hear it.
However, if a point of order is in no way related to my speech,
I would ask members to wait until the end of my speech to raise
it, if that is possible.
I was talking about the concept of peoples and nations. I was
saying that, if the Nisga'a are recognized as a nation or a
people, or if Quebecers are recognized as a nation or a people,
there are some specific rights that must be recognized and
defined in a partnership agreement.
The Nisga'a treaty is exactly the type of partnership agreement
that must exist between peoples. I was always supported in that
belief, except by Mr. Flanagan, as I was saying earlier, who
believed there was only one people in Canada, the Canadian
people. Obviously, it is impossible to go very far in this
assessment of reality.
If there is a partnership agreement, that creates some
certainty, for people are wondering “What is going on with the
aboriginal question, the land claims and the self-government
issue?” That may be what creates the uncertainty. When a
partnership agreement has been signed, people know exactly where
things stand.
As for the question raised by the Reform Party on the importance
of certainty and equality, I believed it was my duty to raise
those same concepts in order to show that, in our opinion, their
fears are unjustified.
I also raised some points that were somewhat controversial
throughout the discussions. One of these was the matter of the
Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Some people hold that
the charter does not apply.
1330
However, I brought out some interesting sections, including the
one I want to quote here, section 9 of chapter 2. In it, it is
stated in black and white that:
The answer is, therefore, fairly clear to me. Is this agreement
subject to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms? Well,
that is set out in the agreement itself. There were also some
fears expressed that it was not included in the act and that
this could mean that it only applied loosely, but I shall
explain later the link between the agreement and the act.
It seemed very important to me that an overview of the history
of the charter was necessary in order to state that, yes, it is
applicable. I have just read the exact passage where it is
written that it applies, for those who say that it is not.
Now for the protection of aboriginal women.
This is another contentious issue that kept being raised
throughout the proceedings and the bill clearly states that the
provincial legislation will apply in this regard. The British
Columbia legislation deals with all issues relating to the
breakup of a marriage, including the division of matrimonial
property. There is also similar legislation in Quebec.
There is definitely a major problem for those who are not
parties to the Nisga'a treaty. I agree—and we raised this issue
in the House before—that there is a problem for all other
aboriginals, for all other reserves in Canada that come under
the Indian Act. There is a grey area, a legal vacuum, as was
illustrated several years ago by the Derickson ruling, in which
a woman who had separated from her husband was not entitled to
anything.
The court ruled that the matrimonial property act does not apply
to reserves. The Indian affairs minister claims that he wants to
settle this issue as quickly as possible. We raised it with the
former minister and this is an urgent matter. But for the time
being, it is also not true that, under the agreement, Nisga'a
women are not protected.
Another very contentious issue is territorial overlap. As we
know, there are many land claims in British Columbia. Reform
Party members said that at the time 125% of British Columbia's
territory was the subject of land claims by aboriginals because
of this overlap.
There were aboriginal peoples that told us that the Nisga'a
land claims overlapped their own. This is what we heard in
Smithers, where the Gitksan and Gitanyow came to present their
views.
I have a number of comments. First, the Nisga'a also claimed
100% of their traditional lands but the final figure in the
agreement was 7%. They settled for 2,000 square kilometres
or 7% of what they had asked for.
The Government of British Columbia is taking a somewhat similar
view. At the time, Mike Harcourt said that the Government of
British Columbia was prepared to give up 5% of the province's
territory to accommodate all native land claims in British
Columbia.
Seven per cent is not far off. The problem with the Gitksan and
the Gitanyow is that they are still going after 100% of their
traditional lands and naturally there is a part in the northern
area of Nisga'a lands that the Gitksan say should belong to
them.
There are A and B categories of lands—and I do not want to get
into defining them—but there are lands where jurisdiction is more
shared, and some of them are also being claimed by the Gitksan
and Gitanyow.
This has been a bit complicated and very emotional because
lands are involved. There were some very good presentations and
here again I refer to the agreement.
1335
The agreement contains provisions on what is to be done in case
of overlapping claims. It must be pointed out that the Nisga'a
had repeatedly tried to come to an agreement with the Gitskan
and the Gitanyow on how to share this territory.
We have a letter signed by the eight hereditary chiefs of the
Gitksan people showing that they had reached an agreement under
which the northern border of the Nisga'a land was to be drawn
the way it is today. We have no qualms about people making
claims, but we are not always in a position to rule on
everything.
The sections I am going to read say what is to be done. I will
start with section 34.
If a superior court of a province, the Federal Court of Canada,
or the Supreme Court of Canada finally determines that any
aboriginal people, other than the Nisga'a Nation, has rights
under section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982 that are
adversely affected by a provision of this Agreement:
a. the provision will operate and have effect to the extent that
it does not adversely affect those rights; and
b. if the provision cannot operate and have effect in a way that
it does not adversely affect those rights, the Parties will make
best efforts to amend this Agreement to remedy or replace the
provision.
The section that follows, section 35, is very important:
a. Canada or British Columbia, or both, as the case may be, will
provide the Nisga'a Nation with additional or replacement rights
or other appropriate remedies;
This is very clear. Whenever there is overlapping, the Gitskan
and the Gitanyow can go to court. I just mentioned the various
courts they can appeal to. If the courts tell them “You are
right, these lands belong to you”, then what this section says
to the Nisga'as who entered into this agreement and who will be
dispossessed of these lands is that through British Columbia and
the Parliament of Canada, they will receive other lands and
compensation to make up for the loss of these lands.
In our opinion, this was enough to say that one could not
prevent the conclusion of this final Nisga'a agreement based on
possible overlapping we find it very difficult to assess. Let
the courts rule on such matters.
If the Gitksan and the Gitanyow feel they are disadvantaged and
that part of their lands have been taken from them, they may go
to court. If they make a good case and the courts decide they
are right, then the Nisga'a will be compensated for losing part
of these lands.
It was very important to be able to put this issue aside because
it was one of the major issues we were faced with.
Many people could say to me “As the member for Saint-Jean, you
are referring to the final agreement, but that is not the act”.
Some people say “We would like the provisions in the agreement
to be transferred in the act”. On that point, the bill is again
very explicit. I must point out two very important clauses
stating that this final agreement is included in the act and
even takes precedence over the act. I will read clause 4:
4. (1) The Nisga'a Final Agreement is approved, given effect and
declared valid and has the force of law.
The agreement I was referring to earlier has the force of
law. Clause 6 goes even farther:
6. In the event of an inconsistency or conflict between the
Nisga'a Final Agreement and the provisions of any federal or
provincial law, including this Act, that Agreement prevails to
the extent of the inconsistency or conflict.
This is clear. The final agreement takes precedence over the
act. It is included in the act, and in case of misinterpretation
or if there are interpretations to be made between the act and
the agreement, the latter will prevail. It is very clear
and this refutes one of the arguments of our adversaries who say
“What is included in the agreement is not necessarily included
in the act”. I have just demonstrated the opposite.
I could dwell on several provisions of the agreement, for
example the whole issue of the fishery, where we will at last
have some certainty about the fishery issue.
It is not a quota. There is no determined number of pounds of
salmon or shrimp or any other kind of fish that will be allowed,
but a percentage of the fish stock in the Nass River, I think,
is 27%.
1340
That means that protection of the resource has been taken into
consideration. The stock is protected in the sense that if, in a
given year, the stock is low, the allowable catch will still be
27% but the amount of fish caught will be lower. If in the
following year there is plenty of fish, the allowable catch
will stay at 27%, but in that case the amount of fish caught
will be higher.
The part on migratory birds is a very interesting one. The
fish sector is also interesting because under the agreement the
Nisga'a will have their say in developing the Canadian position
in international negotiations.
We believe that it is very important for a people, a nation, to
have its say in the signing of international treaties.
Considering the numerous provisions included in the agreement to
manage the situation, we believe that they will translate into
certainties when the agreement is implemented after third
reading and adoption in the Senate.
Provisions concerning Nisga'a governments and relations with
third parties are clear and precise.
There is another point I really must deal with. Some people said
that there should be no taxation without representation. It is
another myth that we have been hearing for a long time. Some
people who are not Nisga'a will live on Nisga'a lands. They will
not pay taxes to the Nisga'a government.
They will continue to pay their taxes at the federal, provincial
and municipal levels but they will pay no taxes to the Nisga'a.
Therefore those people cannot demand to be part of the Nisga'a
government if they do not pay taxes.
This was another argument that was often raised by the bill's
opponents and I had to refute it.
There are also many other areas, such as economic and political
activities defined in the accord, that ensure that there really
is a partnership between parliament and the Nisga'a nation.
We white people often tend to have a certain conception of
values. I recall that when Mr. Bouchard named me critic for
Indian affairs, I wondered what I was going to do.
I discovered that the issue of Indian affairs was an
extremely important one because it forces us to look into our
hearts and it greatly changes us.
I think it also changes our values system. For us, the measure
of one's success is often having a Mercedes, a mansion, a
cottage and a big bank account. The Nisga'a and other native
peoples do not have the same values.
I am really happy when these people give me the opportunity to
discover new values. It makes me happy when they take me fishing
salmon in their boat for part of the day. For me, that is very
important. It is a concept of values that we white people forgot
long ago.
If more of my colleagues went fishing with the natives there
would be less arguing in the House. People's values would
probably change and animosity would probably disappear.
One has to see how these people react to animosity, to all those
rednecks yelling at them to speak white or telling them to go
back to their reserves, as we heard before. Almost all of these people
went to residential schools. They have a great inner peace
because they all experienced a lot of problems. Today they are
enthusiastic and determined to conclude these agreements. They
are immune to all the snide remarks and insults hurled at them.
They are convinced that they will succeed, and having been
around them, I too am convinced that they will.
It is the Mercedes versus the small boat to go salmon fishing,
the Mercedes versus the moose hunt, the fishing camp versus the
mansion. But, as far as I am concerned, one can certainly be as
happy in a fishing camp as in a castle on the Loire because communing
with nature is easier.
These people taught me that. As for gathering berries, they have
always taken me to the places where the best berries are to be
found.
They are probably better than the ones served at banquets in the
Château Laurier here in Ottawa because they are eaten in the
wild and in a traditional way that we do not know about.
1345
I find that the values that these people help us discover
are important. Nature is important for them. It is important for
them to live happily in the wild and in perfect harmony with
nature.
I started my speech by saying that the Bloc Quebecois was
willing to take one of the keys and to open the cage in which
the Nisga'a people have been locked for several centuries now.
The Indian Act is at least 125 years old.
They have been subject to this act since the beginning. It is
important for us to accompany the Nisga'a people on the road to
self-government. In fact, we said, in the language of the
Nisga'a:
[Editor's note: The member spoke in Nisga'a]
[Translation]
That means “We walk with the Nisga'a people”.
We never stopped walking with the Nisga'a people since the
beginning, but now I also want the Nisga'a people to understand,
and they are here today, that we are going through some
turbulence, as I said this earlier, and if we are happy that
they obtained their autonomy, the greatest autonomy possible,
we, the Bloc Quebecois, are very unhappy with the turn of events
concerning our own people. People must understand each
other.
As I said earlier, the Reform Party denies the existence of
several nations in Canada.
It is quite obvious that the Reform Party wants to gag Quebec,
to lock it up, like the Liberal Party, in the cage of status
quo. We, too, want out of this cage. The Nisga'a people must
understand that Quebec wants out of this cage, that it wants to
free itself from this trap, that it wants to look to the future
from a different perspective, from the perspective that I
explained earlier, whereby a sovereign Quebec will maintain
a partnership with its Canadian friends and with the native
people with whom we have shared the same territory for a very
long time.
Consequently, we have to increase the opportunities for
partnership. It is not acceptable to say to Quebecers “We are
locking you up in a cage and throwing away the key; you will
stay there and nothing will change”. We gave up the idea of
changing things a long time ago.
We believe that we must achieve full independence now, and that
is why we have some mixed feelings today.
We are happy for the Nisga'a people. Obviously the Bloc does
not want to block this bill. We cannot do that to a people that
is moving toward self-government. However, as I mentioned
earlier, there are distortions and zones of turbulence.
That is why I move the following motion:
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): Order please. I am sorry,
but to be clear, I have to respond in English.
1350
[English]
Because the House is under special order on Bill C-9, I have to
find out whether or not the request is receivable by the Chair. I
further point out that the special order relates to closure on
Bill C-9. Obviously this motion would be receivable if the House
were not under special order on closure for the vote on Bill C-9
today. That is the ambiguity I need to address.
[Translation]
Mr. Michel Guimond: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I
would like to know when the Chair will make a ruling. We cannot
go on waiting like this all day long. I totally agree with my
colleagues from across—
[English]
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): Sometimes it takes
time to conclave the mavens. The mavens have been conclaved and
the motion is receivable.
[Translation]
Is it the pleasure of the House to adopt the motion?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): All those in favour will
please say yea.
Some hon. members: Yea.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): All those opposed will
please say nay.
Some hon. members: Nay.
Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): In my opinion the nays have
it.
And more than five members having risen:
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): Call in the members.
1355
And the bells having rung:
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): I have to explain in
English because this is a complicated problem.
[English]
As members will recall, when the motion was first presented, I
asked for time to consult. It was my opinion that because the
House was under a special order on closure on Bill C-9, a motion
to adjourn would not be receivable. I was informed that the
motion was receivable. I have been subsequently informed after
further research that under Standing Order 25 a motion to adjourn
is only receivable if given by a minister of the government.
I made a mistake earlier this morning in not presenting a motion
for unanimous consent correctly. I made another one now in
receiving a motion that was not receivable. Under the standing
orders of the House, the motion is not receivable. Therefore,
with my apologies to those who have been called to the House
early, there will not be a vote on that motion. The motion is
not receivable.
[Translation]
An hon. member: I rise on a point of order.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): There can be no point of
order on this ruling. The ruling has been made and that is
that.
Some hon. members: Oh, oh.
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): The member for Chambly on a
point of order.
Mr. Ghislain Lebel: Mr. Speaker, it is not this ruling that
worries me, but the other one you handed down this morning. At
that time, was it a minister who proposed that we adjourn or
interrupt the procedures?
You say you made—
The Acting Speaker (Mr. McClelland): I must say to the member
for Chambly that the situation which prevailed this morning was
in no way similar to the present situation.
The Speaker: It being 2 p.m., the House will now proceed to
statements by members.
STATEMENTS BY MEMBERS
[Translation]
MNA FOR ABITIBI-EST
Mr. Guy St-Julien (Abitibi—Baie-James—Nunavik, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
on November 23, in an interview with Denis Labrecque of the
Parlemenu, the daily newspaper of Abitibi's Vallée-de-l'Or, André
Pelletier, the Parti Quebecois member of the National Assembly
for Abitibi-Est made a statement in connection with a recent
survey in which 59% of respondents reported they would have
voted no in a referendum on Quebec independence. He said “The
results will be far different when the real question is asked”.
According to PQ MNA André Pelletier, the real question should be
“Do you want to disappear?”
Who is it that this MNA wants to see disappear? Once again this
PQ MNA is stirring up fear and uncertainty, wanting to see
Abitibi separate from Canada.
He will never get me to disappear, as a native of Abitibi, a
Quebecer and a Canadian.
The culture of Abitibi is going to stand up steadfastly against
the cynical threats by PQ MNA for Abitibi-Est André Pelletier.
* * *
[English]
REVENUE CANADA
Mr. Lee Morrison (Cypress Hills—Grasslands, Ref.): Mr.
Speaker, Revenue Canada's knights of the double standard are off
on a fearless crusade against non-profit community associations
in rural Saskatchewan.
Apparently having solved all the minor problems like movement of
major corporate assets offshore, they now have time to go after
the really big stuff: recreational facilities provided for
children by groups of volunteers.
Many such groups contract local individuals to maintain skating
and curling rinks.
1400
Contractors are personally responsible for remitting income tax
and payments till now have been exempt from EI and CPP
deductions. Suddenly arrangements that have worked well for
years are being questioned. Service clubs are being billed for
thousands of dollars in back payments for EI and CPP, money that
they do not have.
Thanks to Liberal policies, few Saskatchewan farmers have
taxable income. Revenue Canada is recovering a tiny fraction of
the shortfall by putting the boots to rural communities.
* * *
COMMUNITIES IN BLOOM
Mr. John Richardson (Perth—Middlesex, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, it is my pleasure to rise in the House today to speak
about people, plants and pride, the slogan of Communities in
Bloom, an organization which seeks to provide a national focus
for established provincial and community based beautification
programs across Canada.
Launched in 1995 with 29 municipalities participating, this
year's edition had the involvement of all provinces and
territories. Hundreds of municipalities were involved at the
provincial level, while 94 municipalities competed at the
national level. With competitions designed to build a spirit of
community and to increase civic pride, Communities in Bloom has
popularized environmental awareness and heritage conservation.
It gives me great pleasure to announce that the town of Mitchell
received four out of five blooms in this year's competition and
was a national finalist in the 2,000 to 5,000 population
category.
* * *
CANADIAN EXECUTIVE SERVICES ORGANIZATION
Ms. Jean Augustine (Etobicoke—Lakeshore, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, many of the constituents of Etobicoke—Lakeshore share
their skills and expertise with others around the world in the
Canadian Executive Services Organization, CESO.
Today I would like to take this opportunity to recognize and
congratulate two of my constituents, Dr. Gordon Agar and Mrs.
Regina Pearce. Dr. Agar spent one month in Lima, Peru, where he
provided training to the ministry of energy to overcome
environmental problems caused by mercury and cyanide
contamination. Mrs. Pearce shared her expertise with municipal
leaders and business persons in Russia to improve the quality of
their services.
On behalf of the people of Etobicoke—Lakeshore I am proud to
extend my hearty congratulations to both Dr. Agar and Mrs. Pearce
for a job well done.
* * *
DIVORCE ACT
Mr. Paul Szabo (Mississauga South, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
the Special Joint Committee of the Commons and Senate on Custody
and Access recommended that the Divorce Act be changed to become
more child centred and to affirm the fact that both parents have
an important role to play in the lives of their children, even
after divorce.
According to a 1996 study in the U.S., children in fatherless
homes account for the following: 63% of youth suicides, 83% of
children with behaviour disorders, 71% of high school dropouts,
85% of youths sitting in jails, and 80% of rapists.
The list goes on. It is clear that children are the real
victims of divorce. I support the recommendations of the special
joint committee, in particular the requirement for mandatory
parenting education prior to the granting of a divorce.
Children do have rights. We as legislators have a duty to
protect those rights.
* * *
LOGGING
Mr. Gary Lunn (Saanich—Gulf Islands, Ref.): Mr. Speaker,
Helen Point on Mayne Island is a postcard of British Columbia's
natural beauty. It is viewed by millions of ferry passengers
travelling through Active Pass.
Today Helen Point is being logged. This situation could have
been avoided if it were not for the complete inaction of not one,
not two, but three federal cabinet ministers.
The Minister of the Environment refuses to intervene. The
Minister of Canadian Heritage referred to the Gulf Islands as
“the jewel of Canada”. Completely out of character, she then
fell silent. The Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern
Development promised on November 18 that there would be no
logging until all requirements had been met, this two weeks after
he had already issued the permit.
The local Islands Trust stated that this situation “requires
jurisdictional leadership of the Government of Canada”. I could
not agree more. There is considerable goodwill on all sides, if
only the government would investigate alternatives. Unfortunately
the only finger the government lifted for British Columbia was
the middle—
The Speaker: The hon. member for Laval East
* * *
[Translation]
MINISTER OF INTERGOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS
Mrs. Maud Debien (Laval East, BQ): Mr. Speaker, in September of
1994, a certain political science professor stated, with regard
to the referendum process in Quebec, that the referendum
question was sufficiently clear. First about-face: today this
professor, who is now the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs,
is proclaiming the opposite, loud and clear.
He also said that Ottawa's insistence on the use of the term
separation in the question had no legal basis.
For this person, who is now threatening Quebec with an
anti-democratic bill, this is the second about-face.
1405
Finally, he stated that the terms “sovereignty”, “independence”,
“separation” and “secession” were all synonymous. In his third
about-face, this person who has since become a minister is now
claiming the contrary.
Who is right, the minister or the professor? There is a lack of
clarity here, as is obvious in the bill requiring clarity tabled
by the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, the confusion and
obscurity of which are striking.
* * *
[English]
CLUB ITALIA
Mr. Gary Pillitteri (Niagara Falls, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
on Wednesday, December 8, while the Reformers were filibustering
in the House of Commons, a group of constituent members of the
choir of Club Italia performed in the rotunda of Parliament Hill
and delighted us with their talent.
The choir is well known in the Niagara area as it often performs
in senior citizen homes and hospitals. It is a must in our
riding's Canada Day celebrations.
The members of the choir worked hard on their own time holding a
series of events to raise the funds necessary to travel to
Ottawa. They were proud and thankful of having the privilege of
performing on Parliament Hill in the very heart of the nation.
The Club Italia choir embodies what is so great about our
country. By keeping their traditions alive, fostering our
present culture and wrapping it altogether in an attractive
package, the members of the Club Italia choir showed us that
diversity is the stuff that unites us and makes Canada strong.
* * *
[Translation]
THÉRÈSE PERRIER
Mr. Mark Assad (Gatineau, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, I want to
congratulate Thérèse Perrier, a resident of Masson-Angers in my
riding of Gatineau, for her volunteer work in a medical school
located in Ishevsk, Russia.
As a professor of health sciences, Mrs. Perrier helped train the
staff in administrative and organizational methods. She visited
medical schools and hospitals to show how similar methods work
in Canada.
Mrs. Perrier made presentations to medical school students on
nursing techniques relating to pediatrics and gynecology. She
also made recommendations to improve the health care system.
Congratulations to you, Mrs. Perrier, for your dedication, and
good luck in your future endeavours.
* * *
[English]
CANADIAN FORCES
Mr. Art Hanger (Calgary Northeast, Ref.): Mr. Speaker, I
rise in the House today to congratulate the men and women of our
armed forces who are returning from a six month NATO deployment
in Kosovo. They are to be further congratulated given the fact
that our military members are often deployed with inadequate
clothing and equipment.
While the much lauded clothe the soldier program is overdue and
overbudget, military personnel are still being sent to combat
zones without proper clothing. The Coyote, the light armoured
vehicle, remains a liability if faced with heavy enemy fire.
Twelve of these vehicles broke down with steering problems last
summer.
These chronic problems are well known to rank and file members
of our Canadian forces who just get on with the job. They should
be as well known to this indifferent government that denies any
responsibility for this crisis.
During this Christmas season it is time to pay tribute to our
soldiers, sailors and airmen who are regularly sent overseas to
enforce Canadian military commitments. They often return home
with the barest of public recognition, appreciated only by their
families and friends.
Let it be otherwise—
The Speaker: The hon. member for Hull—Aylmer.
* * *
[Translation]
CHILDREN
Mr. Marcel Proulx (Hull—Aylmer, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, this morning,
UNICEF released a report on progress made over the past century
in improving the plight of children. This progress is very real
but, unfortunately, it is jeopardized by scourges such as AIDS
and military conflicts.
The report calls on governments around the world, and on our
collective and individual conscience, to find concrete solutions
to the problems experienced by children all over the world.
Canada is making great efforts to alleviate human suffering. For
example, our country is taking part in several military missions
to maintain peace in various parts of the world.
We also contributes to economic and social development projects
in poor countries.
A tremendous amount of work remains to be done to reduce human
suffering. However, we can be proud of the leadership role
played by our government in improving the quality of life of
children around the world.
* * *
BILINGUALISM
Mr. Yvon Godin (Acadie—Bathurst, NDP): Mr. Speaker, the Harris
government's decision to ignore advisor Glen Shortliffe's
recommendation that Ottawa become a bilingual city, and now its
intention to appeal the Montfort ruling, are insults to the
Francophonie of Canada and Ontario.
1410
As the nation's capital, Ottawa must reflect the bilingual
nature of our country. As well, francophones and anglophones
living in our capital must have access to services in their
mother tongue.
Since this shocking announcement, we have had a motion from the
Standing Joint Committee on Official Languages calling for
bilingual status for Ottawa. But the Prime Minister prefers to
wait until he has a chance to speak to Mr. Harris.
Our Prime Minister must show leadership and intervene
immediately with Premier Harris in order to defend the bilingual
nature of Ottawa.
There is nothing tricky about it: Canada's national capital must
be bilingual.
* * *
PRESIDENT OF THE TREASURY BOARD
Mr. René Laurin (Joliette, BQ): Mr. Speaker, we read in the
weekend newspapers that the President of the Treasury Board said
she was delighted with her government's bill to fetter the
Government of Quebec.
But, on November 27, 1991, the President of the Treasury Board,
then a member of Quebec's National Assembly, voted in favour of
a motion that the National Assembly call on the federal
government to respect the process set in motion by Bill 150 and
reaffirm the right of Quebecers to take responsibility for their
own destiny and determine their own political and constitutional
status.
Such an about-face should not surprise us.
In 1995, as the minister responsible for the UNITY operation,
she spent the $4.8 million her government gave Option Canada, in
contravention of Quebec's referendum legislation.
Clearly, when it came to choosing between the Canadian limousine
and the rights of Quebec, the member for Westmount—Ville-Marie
went for the limousine.
* * *
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OF MONTREAL
Mr. Denis Paradis (Brome—Missisquoi, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, I wish
to speak today of an excellent initiative taken by our
government to develop Montreal's international vocation.
On December 6, the member for Outremont and Secretary of State
responsible for Canada Economic Development announced that our
government was contributing $24 million to ensure the development
of the international quarter of Montreal, a strategic growing
point for the orientation Montreal has set for itself.
This $60 million plus short-term project will generate more than
$1 billion in property investment in the long term.
Through the project, Montreal will develop into a world-wide pole
of attraction for international organizations.
It represents a clear commitment by our government to the future
of Greater Montreal. I am sure that the economic benefits will
spread as far as Brome—Missisquoi and throughout Quebec.
* * *
[English]
AGRICULTURE
Mr. Rick Borotsik (Brandon—Souris, PC): Mr. Speaker, I
would like to report back to the House on last week's informative
committee hearings in western Canada on the farm income crisis.
The hearings were very revealing, to say the least.
In a committee meeting in Dauphin, Manitoba, we heard one of the
witnesses comment on the Reform Party. The farmer stated that
the Reform Party had very clearly stated that it was opposed to
subsidies, did not think government should be supporting
agriculture out of taxpayer dollars, and was not speaking on
their behalf.
Not only was the Reform Party not speaking on their behalf but
its chief agriculture critic did not show up for any of the
meetings. What was even more revealing were comments made by
Liberal members of the committee. Perhaps they should have
checked with the minister before speaking.
The Liberal committee chairman stated “AIDA has been an
absolute failure and we have got to get out of the ad hoc
programs”. The Liberal rural caucus chair also went on to say
“I am ashamed”. I too am ashamed and I hope that the
government will now place agriculture in a much higher priority
on the national agenda.
* * *
BIG BEN
Mr. Ian Murray (Lanark—Carleton, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, I
wish to pay tribute today to Big Ben, Canada's most famous show
jumping horse that died on Saturday at Millar Brooke Farm at the
age of 23.
Big Ben, ridden by Ian Millar of Perth, won two World Cup
titles, two Pan-American Games gold medals and appeared in three
Olympic Games. He was one of only two animals, Northern Dancer
being the other, to be inducted into the Canadian Sports Hall of
Fame. Big Ben retired from competition in 1994 following a
national farewell tour.
Canadian interest in show jumping was greatly enhanced through
Big Ben's international appearances, and the pride inspired by
his spirited competition will long be remembered.
ORAL QUESTION PERIOD
[English]
NATIONAL UNITY
Mr. Grant Hill (Macleod, Ref.): Mr. Speaker, we support
the bill to clarify referendum rules. There are ways to improve
that bill. There should be a clear question in the bill.
Why does the Liberal government not lay out one clear question
as a suggestion for a province that might want to secede?
1415
Hon. Herb Gray (Deputy Prime Minister, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, we appreciate the support of the Reform Party for our
measure. I would suggest that the hon. member wait for the
debate to begin on the bill. There will be an opportunity to
consider the point of view of the hon. member.
Basically our approach is that this should be something taken
through a decision by the House of Commons after due
consultation. I hope that on reflection the hon. member will
continue to support that position.
[Translation]
Mr. Grant Hill (Macleod, Ref.): Mr. Speaker, we support the
bill to clarify the referendum rules but there is room for
improvement. The required majority is not at all clear.
Why does the government continue to be so vague about such an
important issue?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.):
Mr. Speaker, the bill is not about the clarity of a referendum.
It is about this Chamber's responsibilities relating to the
possibility of negotiating secession.
According to the bill, if it is clear, the government will
negotiate, and if it is not clear, it will not. The conditions
of clarity are what would lead the government to negotiate. That
is what the bill is all about.
[English]
Mr. Grant Hill (Macleod, Ref.): Mr. Speaker, this
referendum bill has no focus on improving the federation, no
improvement to the way parliament works, no improvement to the
way our court system works and no improvement on democracy.
Why is the bill so silent on the issue of improving the
federation?
Hon. Herb Gray (Deputy Prime Minister, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, we have already been carrying out a number of important
steps to improve the federation. There is a resolution of this
House on Quebec being a distinct society. There was the bill
adopted by the House on the matter of a veto on constitutional
reform for Quebec, British Columbia and other regions. There was
the development of the social union framework.
We have been doing a number of important things to improve the
federation, and this is shown by the fact that most Canadians,
including Quebecers, continue to believe that Canada is the best
country in the world in which to live. We will continue to work
to ensure that is the case.
* * *
TAXATION
Mr. Monte Solberg (Medicine Hat, Ref.): Mr. Speaker, now
that the government is moving our way on unity, maybe it will
move our way on taxes.
Canadians are now paying record high taxes. They have never
paid taxes higher than they are today and they want immediate tax
relief. The grassroots Liberal resolutions made at their spring
convention are calling for record increases in spending, just as
the Prime Minister has said and just as we saw in the throne
speech.
Does the finance minister agree with the Prime Minister and with
grassroots Liberals that tax relief should be pushed to the
bottom of the agenda?
Hon. Paul Martin (Minister of Finance, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, the Prime Minister has made it very clear, as have the
Liberals on the finance committee and grassroots Liberals from
coast to coast, that they support the necessity of bringing down
tax cuts. They support the government and the last two budgets
have brought down tax cuts.
In terms of who is moving whose way, we brought them down. The
Reform Party policy in Fresh Start was not to bring down taxes.
Mr. Monte Solberg (Medicine Hat, Ref.): Mr. Speaker,
after all these years it should be fairly clear that nobody likes
Christmas fruitcakes.
We want some clarity now on the finance portfolio. The hon.
minister's party does not believe in tax relief. The Prime
Minister does not believe in tax relief. Apparently this
minister himself does not believe in tax relief or he would not
keep raising taxes.
With taxes going up again on January 1, why should Canadians
believe for a moment that the minister wants to cut taxes?
Hon. Paul Martin (Minister of Finance, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, speaking of Christmas fruitcakes, it is a pleasure to
respond to the Reform Party. This government brought taxes down
in the last budget and in the budget before that.
The basic issue that Canadians want to know is why the Reform
Party stands up in the House and pretends that it is in favour of
tax cuts when a clear statement in its own election platform,
Fresh Start, says that it would not cut taxes before the year
2000.
* * *
[Translation]
REFERENDUMS
Mr. Gilles Duceppe (Laurier—Sainte-Marie, BQ): Mr. Speaker, the
draft bill introduced by the government on Friday does not
include any objective test. It is up to Ottawa, Ottawa acting as
both judge and jury.
Will the Prime Minister recognize that this draft bill is unique
and that it is a paradox, since Ottawa will enjoy all the
flexibility, while Quebec will have all the constraints?
1420
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.):
Mr. Speaker, the answer is no.
The draft bill fully respects the rights of the National
Assembly, which can ask any question it wants to Quebec voters.
However, it is not just any question that can lead to
negotiations on secession.
This is what the Supreme Court of Canada said and it only makes
sense.
Mr. Gilles Duceppe (Laurier—Sainte-Marie, BQ): Mr. Speaker, the
Prime Minister says he likes consensus. There is a large
consensus against the federal legislation among all democratic
groups in Quebec, including all political parties at the
National Assembly and the overwhelming majority of Bloc
Quebecois, Progressive Conservative and NDP members who
represent Quebec in this House. Democrats are opposed to that
measure.
The Prime Minister finds himself in a provocative group, with
allies such as the Reform Party, Keith Anderson, Bill Johnson,
Howard Galdanov and Guy Bertrand. Does the Prime Minister feel
comfortable with such allies?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.):
Mr. Speaker, we are very comfortable with the vast majority of
Quebecers who believe it would be better not to have a
referendum. But if there is to be a referendum, then it should
be on separation, not on a confusing question, and that it would
be totally irresponsible to try to achieve separation with 50%
plus one.
This is the view shared by the vast majority of Quebecers and,
again, it is consistent with the supreme court opinion.
Mr. Daniel Turp (Beauharnois—Salaberry, BQ): Mr. Speaker, one
consensus is emerging in Quebec against the government bill,
while another is emerging in the rest of Canada in favour of it,
just like in 1982 with respect to patriation of the Constitution
and in 1999 with respect to adoption of the social union
framework, which saw Quebec and the rest of Canada go their
separate ways.
Does the Prime Minister realize that, whenever Quebec and Canada
differ on an important issue, he sides with the rest of Canada
against Quebec?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, this bill is pro-Quebec. This bill is pro-democracy.
This bill guarantees us Quebecers that we will never lose Canada
through trickery, that we will be able to remain part of Canada
for as long as we wish, because we built this country. It is
ours and we will not give it up.
Mr. Daniel Turp (Beauharnois—Salaberry, BQ): Mr. Speaker, by
going ahead with this bill, as he means to do, is the Prime
Minister admitting that what he is trying to do is give the
House of Commons an actual veto over decisions made by the
people of Quebec and over the authority of the National
Assembly, a veto over Quebec's democracy?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, Quebecers are fortunate to have two governments with
constitutional powers, two parliaments with constitutional
powers, and Quebec's democracy finds expression here as well.
Each member of the House has the constitutional and moral
responsibility to look out for the interests of all Canadians,
including Quebecers.
* * *
1425
[English]
CHILD POVERTY
Ms. Alexa McDonough (Halifax, NDP): Mr. Speaker, today the
National Council of Welfare and UNICEF slammed our Prime Minister
for ignoring poor children.
In Canada today 60% of young families are poor; 1.4 million
children are living in poverty. That is the legacy of the
government. That is the legacy of the Prime Minister, turning
his back on poor children.
Is that how the Prime Minister wants to be remembered?
Hon. Herb Gray (Deputy Prime Minister, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, historically there is an unwarranted and faulty premise
in the hon. member's questions. We have worked actively for poor
children. A major example is the national child benefit. We put
billions of dollars into it. We will do more. We will continue
working for poor children and we will build on the good record we
have already achieved.
Ms. Alexa McDonough (Halifax, NDP): Mr. Speaker, the
government's record is 1.4 million children living in poverty.
The government is in denial. The Prime Minister is in denial.
He does not believe that child poverty is real. I wish the Prime
Minister were half as obsessed with child poverty as he is with
his poor performance in the 1995 referendum.
Children are a nation's future. A child growing up in poverty
will never have an equal opportunity in life. I implore the
government to make the elimination of child poverty its first
priority.
What will it take to get the government to do that?
Hon. Herb Gray (Deputy Prime Minister, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, as was stated clearly in the throne speech, our priority
is the elimination of child poverty and the improvement of
conditions for all Canadians.
To show how out of touch the hon. member is, instead of standing
up and supporting our position on clarity and keeping Canada
together, she makes an unwarranted and inaccurate slur on the
fine work of the Prime Minister in making sure that the
referendum was won by people who want to keep Canada together.
Where is she when she has to stand up for Canada in the House?
Nowhere.
* * *
NATIONAL UNITY
Mr. Peter MacKay (Pictou—Antigonish—Guysborough, PC):
Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Prime Minister.
Will he advise the House whether, prior to Friday's release of
the so-called clarity bill, he not only consulted with but sought
the opinion of all provincial premiers on the bill and if he has
not, will he be convening a first ministers conference prior to
putting this matter to a vote in the House?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council
for Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.):
Mr. Speaker, we are speaking with the provincial premiers and
governments about every file, including unity issues.
* * *
[Translation]
REFERENDUMS
Mr. André Bachand (Richmond—Arthabaska, PC): Mr. Speaker, this
country was built upon common interests by and for the people
here.
We cannot allow the House of Commons to introduce a bill which,
in reality, provides a recipe for destroying this country.
Does the government realize that this draft bill is an avowal of
failure by this government as far as the future of the
federation is concerned?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.): No, Mr.
Speaker. This bill is a follow-up to the supreme court judgment
referring back to the political stakeholders the responsibility
to establish the conditions of clarity under which they would
agree to negotiate the secession of a province from Canada, and
it seems to me that one of those stakeholders is the Canadian
House of Commons.
* * *
[English]
TRANSITIONAL JOBS FUND
Mr. Chuck Strahl (Fraser Valley, Ref.): Mr. Speaker, even
after the Prime Minister found nearly $1 million in federal
grants and loans for the Grand-Mère Inn in his riding, it is out
of money again. There are lawsuits over unpaid debts, and now it
is even up for sale.
Fortunately for the Prime Minister, Mr. Duhaime was taking the
Prime Minister's money losing hotel off his hands at that time,
but unfortunately for the taxpayers, it looks like their
so-called investment is about to go down a black hole or into
cyberspace, depending on what we like to call it.
Why did the Prime Minister give Mr. Duhaime $1 million in the
first place? How much money will taxpayers lose over this
latest fiasco?
Hon. Jane Stewart (Minister of Human Resources Development,
Lib.): Mr. Speaker, while the majority of Canadians are
celebrating the lowest unemployment levels that we have had in
almost a decade, 6.9%, there are areas in the country that
are not benefiting from this.
The opposition would have those regions suffer due to a lack of
employment opportunities. That is not our approach. We have
supported the transitional jobs fund and the Canada jobs fund.
1430
Mr. Chuck Strahl (Fraser Valley, Ref.): Mr. Speaker, in
the words of Yogi Berra, it is déjà vu all over again.
This time Mr. Duhaime owes the federal government $66,000 in
back taxes; Revenue Quebec, $61,000; the town of Grand-Mère,
$46,000; the city of Shawinigan, $15,000; and a local contractor,
$80,000.
The last time Mr. Duhaime was in this much trouble his first
hotel burned to the ground and the Prime Minister came up with $1
million to get him back in business. Will the Prime Minister
assure us that the fire trucks are standing by, that there are no
more grants for Mr. Duhaime, and will he tell us how much money
this will cost the taxpayers?
Hon. Jane Stewart (Minister of Human Resources Development,
Lib.): Mr. Speaker, I remind the hon. member that the
unemployment levels in that area are very high. I also would
remind the House that this project was contracted in good faith
based on a business plan and on the advice and support of the
whole community. In support of this project, we were with the
provincial government, Caisse Populaire Le Rocher, the Fédération
des Travailleurs du Quebec's solidarity fund, the Groupe Forces,
a private sector investor and the Business Development Bank of
Canada.
* * *
[Translation]
REFERENDUMS
Mr. Michel Gauthier (Roberval, BQ): Mr. Speaker, clause 2(2) of
the draft bill by the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs on
the Quebec referendum calls for determination of the majority to
be based on the size of the majority, not specified, the
percentage of participation, again not specified, and “any other
matters or circumstances it considers to be relevant”.
Can the minister, that friend of Galganov and Guy Bertrand, tell
us what the matters and circumstances relevant to the evaluation
of the majority might be? What is this saying between the
lines?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.): It is
very difficult, Mr. Speaker, in the calm of a united country, in
the situation we find ourselves today, to predict all of the
circumstances, probably difficult and troubled ones, that would
occur after a referendum that led to a yes vote, which the
government of the province would have deemed a sufficiently
clear majority to call for negotiations on secession.
The first ones to make that assessment would be the government
of the province. One might think, for instance, that government
might be sufficiently forward looking not to want to proceed if
the figures were within the zone for a recount; that is one
example.
Mr. Michel Gauthier (Roberval, BQ): Mr. Speaker, the government
will decide if the majority is sufficient and if the question is
clear enough, taking into consideration the opinions of the
political parties in the National Assembly, the governments of
the provinces, the governments of the territories, and the
Senate, as well as any other opinion it might deem relevant.
Has the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs not made
sufficient provision for different opinions in order to be
absolutely certain that one of them at least would back him up
in not following through on the referendum?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, for secession to be achieved, a great deal of calm and
a great deal of reasonable action will be necessary. Most of
all, motives must not be judged; faith must be placed in the
intentions of others, and they must be worked with.
If an aggressive approach is taken, calling names and insulting
others, then of course secession may go off very badly.
I would invite the leader of the Bloc Quebecois and his team to
give Quebecers proof that they have sufficient statesmanship to
carry out secession properly, because that is not the case at
this time.
* * *
[English]
AGRICULTURE
Mr. Howard Hilstrom (Selkirk—Interlake, Ref.): Mr.
Speaker, the farm income crisis rages on while the government
looks for bureaucratic ways to fiddle with its wounded AIDA
program.
Let me read some quotes from the Liberal chairman of the
agriculture committee: “AIDA has been an absolute failure” and
“we have got to find a way of fixing it or at least coming up
with a sequel that will do a better job”.
Since he will not listen to farmers, why will the Prime Minister
not listen to his own caucus members and help farmers now?
Hon. Lyle Vanclief (Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food,
Lib.): Mr. Speaker, the hon. member knows that I was meeting
with the ministers of agriculture from across the country last
week. I wish we could have reached consensus at that point. We
still have more work to do. I am working with the safety nets
advisory committee to improve the situation, to find other ways,
new ways and better ways to assist Canadian farmers. We know they
need the help. We know the importance of the industry and we
will do all we can.
1435
Mr. Howard Hilstrom (Selkirk—Interlake, Ref.): Mr.
Speaker, listen to this quote: “AIDA has been a disaster all on
its own. It still has over $1 billion in the pot, yet only $500
million has been distributed so far”. Those are not my words.
Those are the words of the agriculture committee chairman in a
statement made last week. Even the member for
Hastings—Frontenac—Lennox and Addington said that he was
ashamed of AIDA.
Does the Prime Minister agree with his caucus colleagues that he
has failed farmers, or is this just another example of the
Liberals saying one thing out west and doing a different thing
here in Ottawa?
Hon. Lyle Vanclief (Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food,
Lib.): Mr. Speaker, I remind the House, farmers, and all
Canadians of the opposition party's election promise that it
would take some $600 million out of support to agriculture. In
the last 12 months we have added $1.1 billion.
* * *
[Translation]
REFERENDUMS
Mrs. Francine Lalonde (Mercier, BQ): Mr. Speaker, the supreme
court recognized the legitimacy of the Quebec sovereignist
project. However, with its bill, the federal government is
attacking that legitimacy.
By introducing its referendum legislation, is the federal
government not trying to send to the international community and
to the rest of Canada the message that if Ottawa is not the one
that sets the rules, the referendum exercise will be a fraud and
will not be valid? Is the federal government not trying to
tarnish the image of democracy in Quebec, which makes us so
proud?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, the National Assembly is free to ask any question it
wants to voters. There is absolutely nothing in the bill that
questions the National Assembly's prerogatives.
But everyone, whether in Quebec, in all of Canada or in the
world, would find it unreasonable that the government of a
country would be forced to negotiate the breakup of that country
on just any question. It will take a clear question on
separation to negotiate separation.
If the hon. member wants to travel the world to try to condemn
that, she will be told everywhere “but Madam, this is obvious”.
The Speaker: Dear colleagues, I remind you that you must always
address the Chair.
Mrs. Francine Lalonde (Mercier, BQ): Mr. Speaker, in 1995, the
Quebec referendum process was thoroughly examined by the whole
world.
Is the federal government not sending to the international
community the message that it is not acting in good faith with
Quebec, that it does not want to act in good faith, and that
regardless of what we do or say, it will find excuses to refuse
to negotiate?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, the confusing process used in 1995 was indeed
thoroughly examined. The hon. member should read the book
written by sociologist Maurice Pinard on the confusion that the
question generated among voters.
As for the international community, I think this bill will be
perceived as something very liberal and open regarding
secession, which is not at all a popular concept around the
world, so much so in fact that many very respectable democracies
have declared themselves indivisible.
* * *
[English]
PRISONS
Mr. Jim Abbott (Kootenay—Columbia, Ref.): Mr. Speaker,
an internal Correctional Service Canada survey obtained through
access to information proves that the prison drug prevention
strategy is a failure. Correctional Service Canada staff
confirmed what the Reform Party has been saying for months. Only
31% of them rated the drug strategy as successful. In other
words, almost 70% of his own staff think the program is a
failure.
When was the solicitor general planning to tell Canadians that
his drug strategy plan is an abject failure?
Hon. Lawrence MacAulay (Solicitor General of Canada,
Lib.): Mr. Speaker, as my hon. colleague is well aware, the
drug initiative program by the Correctional Service of Canada has
not been a failure. We have been working full time to make sure
all the actions taken by the Correctional Service of Canada to
address the drug problem are worked on and improved as we go on.
Mr. Randy White (Langley—Abbotsford, Ref.): Mr. Speaker,
I will tell you what the solicitor general has been working on.
It is a $2.5 million building to research drugs placed in his
riding in Prince Edward Island where there are no prisons.
Meanwhile, just a few miles down the road at the closed base CFB
Summerside, there are more than 11 buildings closed.
1440
Is it not true that the solicitor general does not give a damn
about drugs in prisons, but is preoccupied about patronage—
The Speaker: Order, please. It is probably acceptable in
most circumstances but I would ask hon. members to stay away from
very strong language today. I will let the hon. solicitor
general answer the question.
Hon. Lawrence MacAulay (Solicitor General of Canada,
Lib.): Mr. Speaker, as I have indicated a number of times in
the House, when I was appointed—
Some hon. members: Oh, oh.
Hon. Lawrence MacAulay: Mr. Speaker, they asked the
question. Why do they not listen to the answer?
This is a serious problem. Quite simply, when I was appointed
Solicitor General of Canada, 70% of the people in our federal
institutions were alcoholics or had drug problems. It would make
great sense to address the major problem in our federal
institutions. That is what this government is going to do. We
are going to address the addiction and drug problems in the
federal penitentiaries.
* * *
[Translation]
REFERENDUMS
Mr. Stéphane Bergeron (Verchères—Les-Patriotes, BQ): Mr. Speaker,
since the minister wanted to talk about the international
community, let us do that.
For at least ten years now, the federal government has insisted
internationally that existing borders be maintained in the
recognition of new sovereign states. But its draft bill on the
Quebec referendum calls Quebec's borders into question.
What is different today that the federal government has
abandoned its traditional position? Might it be because, this
time, its own turf is involved?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, borders have been known to shift during secessions.
These shifts have been carried out successfully.
The Czech Republic and Slovakia shifted their borders slightly
after negotiations. Latvia agreed to review its border with
Russia.
This sort of thing happens. It is really not desirable, but it
can happen that, in order for a separation agreement to take
place in the least unfavourable conditions possible, there must
be an agreement to shift borders.
* * *
[English]
TREASURY BOARD
Mr. Roger Gallaway (Sarnia—Lambton, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
my question is for the President of the Treasury Board.
A large number of industry and commercial groups state this
government's rules concerning cost recovery are not transparent,
are usurious, generally unfair and an additional burden on the
cost of doing business in this country.
Will the minister lend her support to a parliamentary committee
study which would examine all government departments and agencies
and how they recover costs?
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
cost recovery by the Government of Canada is implemented all the
time after large consultations with stakeholders, through
economic impact and according to a fair and transparent process.
Right now there is a review of the policies which will involve
everyone, including parliamentarians, businesses, consumers,
NGOs, federal departments and agencies that are concerned by
this.
* * *
COAST GUARD
Mr. Myron Thompson (Wild Rose, Ref.): Mr. Speaker,
according to Saturday's media reports a man lost his life off the
coast of Newfoundland while a coast guard rescue ship was
preparing for a lavish party for Correctional Service Canada
officials.
Why does the coast guard put a higher priority on parties rather
than saving lives?
Hon. Harbance Singh Dhaliwal (Minister of Fisheries and
Oceans, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, the women and men take pride in
the work they do and they do an excellent job when it comes to
search and rescue.
As I said to the House last week, search and rescue is a
priority for the coast guard and our rescue centre. There was a
young man who lost his life on the shoreline in Newfoundland. The
RCMP, the coast guard, as well as a DND helicopter responded
according to the guidelines. They made every effort to respond
to the situation.
Mr. Myron Thompson (Wild Rose, Ref.): Mr. Speaker, let
me remind the minister of his statement in Hansard last
week. He said: “Mr. Speaker, I want to make it very clear to
the members that no lives were at risk at any time”. Well, a
person drowned.
What I want to know from the minister is why are they using
coast guard ships for parties? Where are their priorities?
1445
Hon. Harbance Singh Dhaliwal (Minister of Fisheries and
Oceans, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, it is typical of the Reform Party
to use such sleazy tactics in a very—
Some hon. members: Oh, oh.
The Speaker: Order, please. I ask the hon. minister to
withdraw “sleazy”.
Hon. Harbance Singh Dhaliwal: Mr. Speaker, I withdraw
it.
As I said last week, no lives were at risk. The coast guard
ship Cape Roger attended to this as soon as it was alerted.
The RCMP, which has jurisdiction because of the action on the
shoreline, responded, and the DND helicopter from Gander also
responded. They responded exactly in accordance with the rescue
standards which we have established in this country.
* * *
HEALTH
Ms. Judy Wasylycia-Leis (Winnipeg North Centre, NDP): Mr.
Speaker, on Friday the Alberta government replied to the health
minister's questions about its move toward a privatized two-tier
health care system.
If members have had a chance to look at the reply they will see
that it does not allay Canadians' fears one bit that the Alberta
plan will erode our public universal health care system. Yet,
Alberta sees no problems and still plans to proceed.
Does the health minister find Alberta's answers to his questions
satisfactory? If not, what action will the government take to
keep Alberta from unilaterally destroying our public health care
system?
Hon. Allan Rock (Minister of Health, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
we have received the letter from Minister Jonson of Alberta and
it is under consideration. We will react to it as soon as we
have completed our examination of it.
Ms. Judy Wasylycia-Leis (Winnipeg North Centre, NDP): Mr.
Speaker, we would like a little more information. This is an
urgent situation. On the one hand the minister stands to defend
medicare and says that he will protect our universal health care
system, and on the other hand we have the Liberal dominated
finance committee whose members tell us that the government will
not be spending its surplus on much needed money for our health
care system.
What are Canadians to believe, the nice empty words of the
health minister or the contradictory financial policies of the
government that are driving us toward privatized two-tier health
care just as surely as any provincial government policy today?
Can the health minister tell us whether his government will back
up the Canada Health Act with financial resources?
Hon. Allan Rock (Minister of Health, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
a few months ago this government gave Canadians 11.5 billion
reasons to believe in our commitment to medicare.
At that time the Minister of Finance said when he tabled the
budget in the House that as our balance sheet improves we will do
more. That is a commitment that Canadians can take very
seriously.
* * *
COAST GUARD
Mr. Charlie Power (St. John's West, PC): Mr. Speaker, I
listened attentively to the answer of the Minister of Fisheries
and Oceans to the question just asked.
I ask the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans if anybody has been
disciplined for taking the search and rescue vessel J. E.
Bernier off active search and rescue duty. Nobody can tell me
that the lives of Newfoundlanders were not at risk when that
vessel went out on a cruise. Has anybody been disciplined?
Hon. Harbance Singh Dhaliwal (Minister of Fisheries and
Oceans, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, as I said last week, we have
informed our managers that what happened on the J. E.
Bernier was not acceptable. However, let me say that the
Cape Roger, which was in the vicinity, was the closest
coast guard vessel to respond to the rescue centre, along with
the RCMP and the Canadian forces' helicopter from Gander.
All the standards were fulfilled. Unfortunately the young man,
Mr. Collins, died. I think all members of the House would want
to express their condolences to Mr. Anthony Collins' family.
Mr. Charlie Power (St. John's West, PC): Mr. Speaker,
the minister is not getting the right information from his
officials in Newfoundland and Labrador. The Cape Roger did
not respond to the search and rescue. The Cape Roger was
going offshore 200 miles for conservation duty, and when this
tragedy occurred it had to come back to the waters of
Newfoundland and Labrador.
It was 4.09 p.m. when the distress call came in. The cruise
started at 5 p.m. Why was the cruise not cancelled and the J.
E. Bernier put back on search and rescue?
Hon. Harbance Singh Dhaliwal (Minister of Fisheries and
Oceans, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, as I said, the closest ship that
could have responded was the Cape Roger. It was
appropriate to make sure that we called the closest ship that
could have gone to the destination in the quickest fashion, and
that is exactly what happened.
* * *
1450
CHILDREN
Mr. Mac Harb (Ottawa Centre, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, the
Speech from the Throne made several commitments to address the
needs of children living in Canada.
I ask the Minister of Health what he is doing to address the
needs of children. What is he doing to implement the commitments
made in the Speech from the Throne?
Hon. Allan Rock (Minister of Health, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
I am working with the Minister of Human Resources Development and
with my colleagues in caucus to fulfill the ambitious agenda
which the Prime Minister set out in his speech in the House,
which is contained in the Speech from the Throne.
It is an agenda for children. By December of this year we hope
to have in place a framework agreement with our provincial
colleagues on early childhood development. In doing this we will
build on the efforts already in place: the 20,000 women every
year who are beneficiaries of the prenatal nutrition program and
the 40,000 women and their children every year in community
action programs for children. These programs make a difference
and we will continue this work.
* * *
RCMP
Mr. Chuck Cadman (Surrey North, Ref.): Mr. Speaker, two
weeks ago I asked a question of the solicitor general regarding
the city of Surrey's request to be compensated for overtime paid
to the RCMP, costs resulting directly from budget slashing by the
government. Surrey is now considering its own municipal police
force.
In dismissing my question as being trivial and for show only,
the parliamentary secretary insulted the 330,000 citizens of
Surrey. This was a question posed by them through their city
council, their mayor and their member of parliament.
My question involves the overtime bill in Surrey. Will the
solicitor general honour this request and reimburse the RCMP
overtime costs?
Hon. Lawrence MacAulay (Solicitor General of Canada,
Lib.): Mr. Speaker, I think my hon. colleague is well aware
that the resource review has taken place. It is in the hands of
the government. It will be dealt with in the next budget. If my
hon. colleague had listened to the Speech from the Throne he
would have realized that there was a commitment from the
government to provide the tools to the RCMP to do their job.
* * *
[Translation]
REFERENDUMS
Mr. Michel Bellehumeur (Berthier—Montcalm, BQ): Mr. Speaker, in
1991, the current President of the Treasury Board supported a
resolution in the Quebec National Assembly calling on the
federal government to respect the process set in motion by Bill
150, which reaffirmed the right of Quebecers to take
responsibility for their destiny and to be the only ones to
determine their political and constitutional status.
How can the President of the Treasury Board now support the
federal government's bill to lay down the conditions for
Quebec's next referendum? Would it be because she has opted for
the limousine over Quebec's interests?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, there is not a single political entity in Canada that
wishes to keep Quebecers in Canada against their will. That is
not the issue.
Accusing one of our colleagues of turning her back on this
fundamental principle whereby Canada is a country founded on
mutual respect is particularly unfair of the member.
* * *
[English]
CANADA HEALTH AND SOCIAL TRANSFER
Ms. Wendy Lill (Dartmouth, NDP): Mr. Speaker, my question
is for the Minister of Finance.
The minister knows that his surplus was created by withdrawing
important services to Canadians. His draconian transfer cuts
shredded the social fabric of Nova Scotian communities. Nova
Scotian citizens are hurting. Last month over 10,000 children
were fed from Nova Scotian food banks. Thousands in Dartmouth
live in substandard housing and the health and education systems
are in tatters.
Nova Scotians want their money back as well as their quality of
life. Will the minister today commit to a complete restoration
of social spending transfers to Nova Scotian communities?
Hon. Paul Martin (Minister of Finance, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, one of the first things which the government did as we
began to approach the elimination of the deficit was to restore
and introduce a new floor protecting the Canada health and social
transfer. In last year's budget we put $11.5 billion toward the
Canadian health and social transfer.
1455
At the same time, the government has invested close to $2
billion in the national child tax benefit. We have put money
into CAPC. We have put money into prenatal nutrition. The
government understands full well the problems that families have
in raising young children, especially low income families. The
government has stepped up to the mark.
* * *
NATURAL RESOURCES
Mr. Gerald Keddy (South Shore, PC): Mr. Speaker, the
Minister of Natural Resources stated in the House that points
raised by the Premier of Nova Scotia in his letter to the
minister were rhetorical positions only.
Nova Scotia wants an interim agreement to allow exploratory
drilling for Nova Scotia and Newfoundland in the Laurentian
sub-basin.
Is the minister accusing the Premier of Nova Scotia of
deliberately misleading Canadians?
The Speaker: The way the question was posed it is
acceptable, but I would ask the hon. member to please stay away
from the words “deliberately misleading”.
Hon. Ralph E. Goodale (Minister of Natural Resources and
Minister responsible for the Canadian Wheat Board, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, what I said was that the dispute about a boundary line
offshore in eastern Canada is a matter for the provinces, first
and foremost, to resolve.
If they are not able to resolve the matter, then there are
provisions for the Government of Canada to resolve it through
arbitration. I will receive by the end of this year a report
from the facilitator who has been working on the potential terms
of arbitration. If the provinces continue to be unable to
resolve their own problem, then the Government of Canada will
move forward with arbitration to solve it for them.
* * *
INDUSTRY
Mr. Walt Lastewka (St. Catharines, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
Canada's productivity can best be increased by assisting small
and medium size businesses to adapt to new and innovative
technologies.
We know these businesses are the engines of our economy and the
future of economic growth. What is the Minister of Industry
doing to assist SMEs to foster growth through new technologies?
Hon. John Manley (Minister of Industry, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, I do not think that any member of the House has been
more determined in support of small businesses and understanding
their needs than the member for St. Catharines.
He will know that the contribution that needs to be made to
productivity in the Canadian economy will depend very much on how
rapidly we can enable our small business sector to adapt to new
technologies, to reach out to find new discoveries and to use the
resources of connecting Canadians to make them more efficient.
That is why he has supported programs like the industrial
research assistance program of the National Research Council, TPC
and IRAP. The student connections program is helping small
businesses get connected to the Internet. That is where the
differences will be made.
* * *
NATIONAL UNITY
Mr. John Nunziata (York South—Weston, Ind.): Mr.
Speaker, it is the government's position that it will refuse to
negotiate separation unless the Government of Quebec puts forward
a clear question.
My question is for the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs.
In the event that the question is not clear, is it the intention
of the federal government to participate in the referendum
campaign, or would it be the position of the government that it
would boycott a referendum that did not include a clear question?
Would he not agree that it would be illogical not to negotiate
while participating in the referendum campaign?
The Speaker: That is a hypothetical question. However,
if the minister wants to respond, I will permit it.
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council
for Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.):
Mr. Speaker, one possibility would be to do exactly what was done
by the Prime Minister of Canada in 1980.
Prime Minister Trudeau said to Premier Lévesque:
[Translation]
“Mr. Lévesque, if you go the route of sovereignty-association,
there will be no negotiation”.
* * *
[English]
TAXATION
Mr. Jay Hill (Prince George—Peace River, Ref.): Mr.
Speaker, Mackenzie, a small, remote town in the Rocky Mountains,
is being discriminated against. Although further north, more
isolated and with far less amenities than nearby cities to the
southeast, Mackenzie residents do not qualify for the northern
residents' tax deduction.
During a visit to my riding last spring the finance minister
promised to review this blatantly unfair practice. Will he now
correct the problem so that the citizens of Mackenzie can enjoy
the same rights and benefits as other northerners?
Hon. Paul Martin (Minister of Finance, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, when the previous government established these lines,
obviously there were those who won and those who did not.
In fact, the hon. member is right. In a meeting with people in
his riding I discussed this and we did undertake to review it.
* * *
1500
[Translation]
REFERENDUMS
Mrs. Madeleine Dalphond-Guiral (Laval Centre, BQ): Mr. Speaker,
when the Prime Minister began his political career, Quebec
sovereignty was supported by 6% of voters. At the last
referendum, over 49% of people voted in favour of sovereignty.
Given these results, are we to understand that the Prime
Minister has come to a conclusion that justifies, in his mind,
the tabling of a bill which seeks to put Quebec and its National
Assembly in a straitjacket?
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, the hon. member is showing just how confusing the whole
issue is, because it is obvious—as everyone knows—that on
October 30, 1995, separatists did not account for 49% of the
Quebec population.
* * *
[English]
CRIMINAL CODE
Mr. Svend J. Robinson (Burnaby—Douglas, NDP): Mr.
Speaker, my question is for the Minister of Justice. Last month
Robbie Peterson, a young law student in Fredericton, New
Brunswick, was brutally attacked on a downtown street simply
because he is gay. Similar bashings occur across this land.
When will the minister finally bring forward her long overdue
omnibus bill on equality for gays and lesbians? Will she assure
the House that the bill will amend the criminal code to outlaw
propaganda which promotes violence and hatred based on sexual
orientation?
Hon. Anne McLellan (Minister of Justice and Attorney General
of Canada, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, as the hon. member knows, I
had the opportunity to discuss the issue of hate propagated
against gays and lesbians with my provincial and territorial
colleagues last week.
Let me say that the Attorney General of British Columbia, Ujjal
Dosanjh, has brought this issue to my attention. The provinces,
the territories and the federal government are working together.
We will be the making necessary changes to the criminal code in
the coming months.
* * *
NATURAL RESOURCES
Mr. Gerald Keddy (South Shore, PC): Mr. Speaker, my
question is again for the Minister of Natural Resources. Would
the minister kindly explain the reason for the need of a mediator
regarding the Nova Scotia—Newfoundland boundary when in 1982
under the Canada-Nova Scotia agreement on offshore oil and gas
resource management and revenue sharing such a boundary was
defined?
Is the minister saying that he has no faith in the principals of
the day who signed the agreement: the then Prime Minister Pierre
Elliott Trudeau and his minister of energy who was none other
than Jean Chrétien?
The Speaker: I always ask members not to use each other's
names in the House of Commons. That will terminate question
period for today.
* * *
[Translation]
POINTS OF ORDER
TABLING OF DOCUMENTS
Mr. Michel Gauthier (Roberval, BQ): Mr. Speaker, following the
Prime Minister's announcement to introduce a bill denying the
fundamental rights of Quebecers, I am asking for the unanimous
consent of the House to table a document that will enlighten the
House.
The document is a very thorough newspaper article published on
October 20, which shows the real intentions of the Minister of
Intergovernmental Affairs concerning Quebec's future.
The Speaker: Does the hon. member have leave of the House to
table the document?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
1505
Mr. Réal Ménard (Hochelaga—Maisonneuve, BQ): Mr. Speaker,
following the Prime Minister's announcement to introduce a bill
denying the fundamental rights of Quebecers, I am asking for the
unanimous consent of the House to table a document that will
enlighten the House.
The document is a partnership agreement between the Parti
Quebecois, the Bloc Quebecois and Action démocratique du Québec.
This agreement—
The Speaker: Does the House give unanimous consent for the hon.
member to table the document?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mrs. Christiane Gagnon (Québec, BQ): Mr. Speaker, further to the
Prime Minister's announcement that he wants to introduce a bill
denying Quebecers their fundamental rights, I ask for the
unanimous consent of the House to table a document that will
clarify matters for the House. It is an article from today's La
Presse outlining criticism of the bill by Quebec's labour
unions.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House for the
hon. member to table the document?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
The Speaker: There will be a few more points of order concerning
tabling of documents, but I think the results are similar.
Perhaps members will try once again.
The hon. member for Jonquière.
Ms. Jocelyne Girard-Bujold (Jonquière, BQ): Mr. Speaker, further
to the Prime Minister's announcement that he wants to introduce
a bill denying Quebecers their fundamental rights, I ask for the
unanimous consent of the House to table a document that will
clarify matters for the House.
It is—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House for the
hon. member to table the document?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
[English]
BELL RINGING
Mr. John Nunziata (York South—Weston, Ind.): Mr.
Speaker, at about 11.30 today the bells calling in the members
for a vote started to ring. It was indicated on the
parliamentary channel that the vote would take place 30 minutes
from the moment the bells started ringing.
Within a matter of minutes both the opposition whip and the
government whip were approaching the Chair and the vote
commenced. I would submit that breaches the parliamentary
privileges of members of parliament who were not present in the
House at the time.
The Speaker: Order, please. That particular problem was
dealt with earlier in the day. A decision was made and it rests
there.
[Translation]
TABLING OF DOCUMENTS
Mr. René Canuel (Matapédia—Matane, BQ): Mr. Speaker, further to
the Prime Minister's announcement that he wants to introduce a
bill denying Quebecers their fundamental rights, I ask for the
unanimous consent of the House to table a document that will
clarify matters for the House.
It is an article from the December 11, 1999, issue of Le Journal
de Montréal, in which Pierre—
The Speaker: Does the hon. member have the unanimous consent of
the House to table the document?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
1510
The Speaker: Order, please. The answer is pretty much the same
every time. I will accept a few more, but I do not want to use
all the time we have for debate today on these points of order.
Mr. Yvan Loubier (Saint-Hyacinthe—Bagot, BQ): Mr. Speaker, an
article from the December 11 issue of The Gazette questions the
fact that under the bill to be tabled today a no will have
more weight than a yes. Following the announcement of the
tabling of this bill, I ask the unanimous consent of the House
to table this article from The Gazette.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Michel Gauthier: Mr. Speaker, it seems to me that you are
trying to be fair in a situation that may seem delicate at first
glance, but I think it is the role of the Chair to allow members
to speak in the House, a role that you have always played
properly.
Nobody can assume what request will be made and nobody can
decide in advance whether a member may or may not ask for the
unanimous consent of the House to table a document of some kind,
given that all the documents tabled by my colleagues or
regarding which unanimous consent was requested were basically
all different.
Either you go beyond the standing orders and presume that
members of the Bloc Quebecois cannot ask for the unanimous
consent of the House or you declare that the government is so
stubborn and narrow-minded that it will never give consent for
any document.
I do not know on what basis you can sincerely assume that my
colleagues' requests are out of order or inadmissible.
Hon. Don Boudria (Leader of the Government in the House of
Commons, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, in the holiday spirit of
co-operation, it might help the House if I said right now that
the government does not intend to give consent to have any
document tabled today. This might help the Chair in his decision
later on.
Some hon. members: Oh, oh.
Mr. Michel Gauthier: Mr. Speaker, I sincerely and honestly
thought I had seen it all in this House.
Not only does the government House leader hold the all-time
record for the number of closure and time allocation motions in
this parliament, not only, contrary to the usual practice, has
he reneged on his word last week to deceive the Bloc Quebecois
and trample Quebecers' basic rights, but today we have this
unique, extraordinary situation where, for the first time in
living memory, a parliamentarian, the government House leader to
boot, is forewarning the House, saying “Today, we will not
accept any document whatsoever, whatever the topic”. That is
closure at its worst.
Some hon. members: Oh, oh.
1515
The Speaker: I remind the hon. members that the Chair will
decide as appropriate how many points of order we will have. I
believe it would be irresponsible to have much more than 10, or
20 at the most.
Let us hear a few more and see what happens.
Mr. Jean-Guy Chrétien (Frontenac—Mégantic, BQ): Mr. Speaker, this
is in the same vein as what the Parti Quebecois House leader
said. Following last week's announcement by the Prime Minister,
who tabled a draft bill, I am asking for unanimous consent to
table a report. I urge the government House leader to think
twice before saying no.
It is part of a report on Quebec's territorial integrity in the
event of sovereignty, which was tabled before the committee to
examine matters—
The Speaker: I am sorry to interrupt the member.
Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Michel Bellehumeur (Berthier—Montcalm, BQ): Mr. Speaker,
before introducing its draft bill undermining the basic human
rights of Quebecers, the government across the way obviously did
not take the time to go over the new modern and exciting
Quebec-Canada partnership proposal put forward by the Bloc
Quebecois and distributed throughout the province of Quebec.
I ask for the unanimous consent of the House to table the
document so that the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs can
read it.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Yves Rocheleau (Trois-Rivières, BQ): Mr. Speaker, for the
benefit of the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, I ask for
the unanimous consent of the House to table a document that
should enlighten the minister and all the hon. members. It is
the Quebec Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms, the basis of
democracy and equality in Quebec.
The Speaker: Does the hon. member have the unanimous consent of
the House to table this document?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Daniel Turp (Beauharnois—Salaberry, BQ): Mr. Speaker, the
Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs having stated his intent
to introduce a draft bill undermining the basic human rights of
Quebecers, I ask for the unanimous consent of the House to table
a document that should answer some of the questions the House
might have. It is a document entitled “Chantier de réflexion sur
la citoyenneté et la démocratie”.
The Speaker: Does the hon. member have the unanimous consent of
the House to table this document?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
[English]
BILL C-9
Mr. Jay Hill (Prince George—Peace River, Ref.): Mr.
Speaker, I just remind the Chair, the House and the viewing
audience today that we are dealing with a very important piece of
legislation, Bill C-9, an act to implement the Nisga'a treaty.
Time allocation has been called on this legislation. British
Columbians' voices have gone largely unheard during debate. I
have some colleagues who are waiting their turn to get their
points made on this legislation on the last day that they will
have a chance to debate the legislation.
If the Bloc Quebecois intend to go on with this all afternoon,
will it agree to sit tonight and add those hours to the debate on
Bill C-9 so that debate can go on?
The Speaker: Hon. member for Prince George—Peace River,
are you asking for unanimous consent to put this motion?
Mr. Jay Hill: Yes, Mr. Speaker.
The Speaker: Does the hon. member for Prince
George—Peace River have the unanimous consent of the House to
put the motion?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
[Translation]
TABLING OF DOCUMENTS
Mr. Ghislain Lebel (Chambly, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I am sure the
minister reacted too quickly when he turned down our request for
unanimous consent. The document I want to table with the
unanimous consent of the House will certainly be reflected in
some of the answers he will be giving us in the future. It is in
his best interest to allow me to table it.
It was written by a reporter who is on his side. The document is
entitled “The 53.1416% question”.
1520
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Benoît Sauvageau (Repentigny, BQ): Mr. Speaker, now that the
Prime Minister has announced his intention to introduce a bill
negating Quebec's fundamental rights, I would like to table a
list of auto dealers for the benefit of the President of the
Treasury Board, who will soon have to give up her limousine.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Ghislain Fournier (Manicouagan, BQ): Mr. Speaker, the Prime
Minister having announced his intention to introduce a bill
negating Quebec's fundamental rights, I ask the unanimous
consent of the House to table a very informative document.
This is a news story that appeared in the National Post of
October 20, in which the intergovernmental affairs minister
warned Quebecers against—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mrs. Pierrette Venne (Saint-Bruno—Saint-Hubert, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I
have here a story from the December 11, 1999 issue of Le Droit,
which clearly indicates how the government intends to stop
Quebecers from deciding freely their own future.
I am asking for the unanimous consent of the House to table this
document which will—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Antoine Dubé (Lévis-et-Chutes-de-la-Chaudière, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I
have here an article published in La Presse concerning the
negative reaction of Jean Charest, the leader of the Liberal
Party in Quebec, to the bill the Prime Minister has announced.
I am asking for the unanimous consent of the House to table—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Maurice Godin (Châteauguay, BQ): Mr. Speaker, further to the
Prime Minister's announcement that he wants to introduce a bill
denying Quebecers their fundamental rights, I ask for the
unanimous consent of the House to table a document that will
clarify matters for the House.
It is an article from the Journal de Montréal which explains
very well the counter-offensive—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Odina Desrochers (Lotbinière, BQ): Mr. Speaker, further to
the Prime Minister's announcement that he wants to introduce a
bill denying Quebecers their fundamental rights, I ask for the
unanimous consent of the House to table a document that will
clarify matters for the House.
It is an article—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Stéphane Bergeron (Verchères—Les-Patriotes, BQ): Mr. Speaker,
I have here an article from the December 11, 1999 issue Le
Devoir which describes the mobilization efforts made by all the
sovereignist groups in Quebec to counter the offensive project
of the Prime Minister and his Minister of Intergovernmental
Affairs.
I ask the unanimous consent of the House in order to table this
document.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. René Laurin (Joliette, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I found in my
documentation a document entitled “Quebec and its Territory”,
which explains why Quebec borders will be guaranteed after
Quebec becomes sovereign.
Since this document will surely enlighten the House, I ask its
unanimous consent to table it.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mrs. Pauline Picard (Drummond, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I have here the
text of a speech given by Joseph Facal, the Quebec minister, on
the right to democracy and sovereignty, in response to the
Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs.
I ask for the unanimous consent of the House to table this
document now.
The Speaker: Does the hon. member have unanimous consent to
table the document?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Michel Guimond
(Beauport—Montmorency—Côte-de-Beaupré—Île-d'Orléans, BQ): Mr. Speaker,
I would like the leader of the government in the House to listen
to this quote from Étienne Parent, a Beauport journalist in the
19th century.
We all know that in the 19th century, the people of Quebec were
referred to as French Canadians. He said “It is the fate of the
French Canadians not only to have kept their civil liberties,
but also to struggle—”
1525
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Gérard Asselin (Charlevoix, BQ): Mr. Speaker, further to the
announcement made by the Prime Minister of the introduction of a
bill denying the fundamental rights of the Quebec people, I
request the unanimous consent of the House to table a document
that would enlighten the House.
It is the report of Quebec's director general of elections on
the results of the 1980 referendum, to which 85.6 % of the
registered voters participated. That is democracy.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Michel Bellehumeur: On a point of order, Mr. Speaker.
The Speaker: The hon. member for Berthier—Montcalm has already
had his turn.
Some hon. members: Oh, oh.
Ms. Hélène Alarie (Louis-Hébert, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I would like
to present to the House an article from today's La Presse, which
points out that the Prime Minister found the 1980 and 1995
questions clear. I request the unanimous consent of the House to
table a document that would enlighten the House.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Paul Crête (Kamouraska—Rivière-du-Loup—Témiscouata—Les Basques,
BQ): Mr. Speaker, I ask for the unanimous consent of the House
to table a newspaper article which comments on remarks made by
the Premier of Quebec and which shows how much damage will be
done to Canada's international reputation if the—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Maurice Godin: On a point of order, Mr. Speaker.
The Speaker: The hon. member for Châteauguay has already had his
turn.
Mrs. Madeleine Dalphond-Guiral (Laval Centre, BQ): Mr. Speaker,
as a result of this bill whose purpose is to deny the Quebec
people their fundamental rights, I ask for the unanimous consent
of this House to table—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Pierre de Savoye (Portneuf, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I have here a
background document on the main events that led to the federal
government's appropriation of provincial jurisdictions since
1882. I would like to table this document. Do I have unanimous
consent to do so? .
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Ms. Caroline St-Hilaire (Longueuil, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I have here
an article from Le Devoir dated December 11, 1999, which
explains very well the attack on Quebec this bill constitutes.
Consequently, for the benefit of the leader of the government in
the House, I ask for the unanimous consent of the House to table
this document which will enlighten the minister and the House.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Bernard Bigras (Rosemont, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I have an
editorial that was published last weekend in Le Devoir and that
condemns the bill to be introduced today. I ask for the
unanimous consent of the House to table this document.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Richard Marceau (Charlesbourg, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I have here
an article by an excellent journalist who is following our
debate from the press gallery today, Graham Fraser. I ask for
the unanimous consent of the House to table this article.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Serge Cardin (Sherbrooke, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I have here an
excellent document entitled “En marche vers un pays, le Québec.”
I ask for the unanimous consent of the House to table this
document.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent of the House?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Claude Bachand (Saint-Jean, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I have
here a very important article that could in fact be used as a
guide by the Liberal Party in the next few days.
1530
It is entitled “Sleepless in Ottawa”. I ask for the unanimous
consent of the House to table this.
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
The Speaker: How many more are there?
Mrs. Maud Debien (Laval East, BQ): Mr. Speaker, following the
announcement by the Prime Minister, who wants to introduce a
bill denying the fundamental rights of Quebecers, I ask for the
unanimous consent of the House to table a document that—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Stéphan Tremblay (Lac-Saint-Jean, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I have
here the report by a great democrat, the chief electoral
officer, a great democrat just like you, on the results of the
1995 referendum where 93% of registered voters exercised their
right to vote. That is democracy, I believe.
I ask the unanimous consent of the House to—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mrs. Francine Lalonde (Mercier, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I have here a
document that is extremely interesting and important for the
House. It is the position of Quebec's three central labour
bodies on the bill the government is supposed to introduce
today. This article is entitled “A slap in the face of
democracy”.
I ask the unanimous consent—
The Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Yvan Bernier (Bonaventure—Gaspé—Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Pabok, BQ):
Mr. Speaker, I am glad you saved me for last. Do not forget that
Canada evolved from Gaspé. Therefore, I am pleased to have the
last word in this first round in the House today.
The Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs is still listening to
us and he is certainly one who likes to see what is happening in
other countries. Maybe he would find it interesting to know what
was signed in Paris on May 8, 1992 by Thomas Frank, Rosalyn
Higgins, Alain Tellet, Mrs. Malcolm—
The Speaker: This is a fine dessert, but the question has to be
asked. Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
The Speaker: Has everybody had one turn?
Some hon. members: Yes.
Some hon. members: No.
The Speaker: Maybe we will have another day like that. It is a
fine afternoon. Thank you, but enough is enough.
ROUTINE PROCEEDINGS
[English]
ORDER IN COUNCIL APPOINTMENTS
Mr. Derek Lee (Parliamentary Secretary to Leader of the
Government in the House of Commons, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, I am
pleased to table, in both official languages, a number of order
in council appointments recently made by the government.
Pursuant to the provisions of Standing Order 110 they are deemed
referred to the appropriate standing committees, a list of which
is attached.
* * *
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO PETITIONS
Mr. Derek Lee (Parliamentary Secretary to Leader of the
Government in the House of Commons, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, I
have the honour to table, in both official languages, the
government's response to four petitions.
* * *
COMMITTEES OF THE HOUSE
NATURAL RESOURCES AND GOVERNMENT OPERATIONS
Mr. Joseph Volpe (Eglinton—Lawrence, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
I have the honour to present, in both official languages, the
first report of the Standing Committee on Natural Resources and
Government Operations.
In accordance with its order of reference of November 30, 1999,
your committee has considered Bill C-10, an act to amend the
Municipal Grants Act, and has agreed to report it with amendment.
* * *
1535
[Translation]
AN ACT TO GIVE EFFECT TO THE REQUIREMENT FOR CLARITY AS SET
OUT IN THE OPINION OF THE SUPREME COURT OF CANADA IN THE QUEBEC
SECESSION REFERENCE
Hon. Stéphane Dion (President of the Queen's Privy Council for
Canada and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Lib.) moved
for leave to introduce Bill C-20, an act to give effect to the
requirement for clarity as set out in the opinion of the Supreme
Court of Canada in the Quebec Secession Reference.
(Motions deemed adopted, bill read the first time and
printed)
* * *
[English]
CRIMINAL CODE
Mr. Art Hanger (Calgary Northeast, Ref.): moved for leave
to introduce Bill C-401, an act to amend the Criminal Code (no
parole when imprisoned for life).
He said: Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to reintroduce this private
member's bill so that a life sentence will actually mean life. It
amends certain provisions of the criminal code relating to life
imprisonment. The bill is supported by many on this side of the
House in my party. It would eliminate any provision for early
parole, early release or parole eligibility for a criminal who is
sentenced to life.
The bill is about justice: justice for families of victims, for
those who have suffered an irreplaceable loss at the hands of
killers. For them, knowing that the offender will never walk the
streets again as a free person will bring a sense of relief and
an element of closure to a sad chapter in their lives.
The bill sends a clear message to murderers and other violent
habitual criminals that if they take they life of another they
will be locked away for the remainder of their lives.
(Motions deemed adopted, bill read the first time and
printed)
* * *
COMPETITION ACT
Mr. Dan McTeague (Pickering—Ajax—Uxbridge, Lib.): moved
for leave to introduce Bill C-402, an act to amend the
Competition Act (abuse of dominant position).
He said: Mr. Speaker, this bill would amend section 78 of the
Competition Act with respect to the anti-competitive act of abuse
of dominant position. Under this section the competition
tribunal may make an order prohibiting certain persons from
engaging in anti-competitive acts. The bill expands the
definition of anti-competitive act currently listed in section
78.
The bill will permit the competition tribunal to prohibit a
person holding a dominant position in the wholesale or retail
market from engaging in certain practices that will now be viewed
as being anti-competitive, as well as any other abusive
anti-competitive practice directed toward a competitor or a
supplier.
(Motions deemed adopted, bill read the first time and
printed)
* * *
1540
[Translation]
COMMITTEES OF THE HOUSE
TRANSPORT
Mr. Michel Guimond
(Beauport—Montmorency—Côte-de-Beaupré—Île-d'Orléans, BQ)
moved that the first report of the Standing Committee on
Transport, presented to the House on Tuesday, December 7, 1999,
be concurred in.
He said: Mr. Speaker,
this speech will obviously deal first with air transport but, as
you will understand, considering the bill just introduced by the
government, it will be very difficult for me not to refer to
this sad day for democracy in Quebec and in Canada.
Not to be accused of being out of order, I will have to deal
with the first report of the transport committee. At the outset,
I would like to tell the men and women who work for the Canadian
transportation industry that my colleagues from the Bloc
Quebecois and myself, as the transport critic for the Bloc, are
very concerned with the uncertainty they now experience, a few
days only before Christmas.
This has been particularly true for a number of months, more
precisely since August 13 when the Minister of Transport and the
Minister of Industry, by suspending the provisions of the
Competition Act, created total chaos in the Canadian
transportation industry. This situation recently led to the
shutdown of operations at InterCanadian, and 900 workers and
their families, could perhaps be forced in the very near future
to go on welfare.
I think that 14 days before Christmas we, as parliamentarians,
cannot remain insensitive to the gloomy situation faced by the
workers of InterCanadian, a company based in Montreal.
I could talk for a long time about the content of this report,
but I will of course be able to revisit it in the future.
Since I am running short on time, am allowed only 20 minutes to
make a speech and have already been talking for two minutes, I
would like to turn immediately to the second part of my speech
since I am afraid to run out of time.
For the benefit of the members in the House and of our viewers,
and I know that there are quite a few of them, I would like to
go back to a statement made by a person who said “No matter
what, Quebec is and will always be a distinct and free society
capable of assuming its own destiny and development”.
Some hon. members: Hear, hear.
Mr. Michel Guimond: These words were said at the Quebec National
Assembly—
The Deputy Speaker: The hon. member for
Sackville—Musquodoboit Valley—Eastern Shore, on a point of order.
[English]
Mr. Peter Stoffer: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of
order. With all due respect to my friend from the Bloc Party, as
a former airline employee for over 18 years I wish he would get
back to the subject of the airline industry so that it can know
where the Bloc stands on this very important subject.
[Translation]
The Deputy Speaker: I trust the member for
Beauport—Montmorency—Côte-de-Beaupré—Île-d'Orléans will revert to the
topic of the report very shortly.
Mr. Michel Guimond: Indeed, but I am surprised that my
colleague, who used to work for Canadian in Nova Scotia, more
precisely in Halifax, who is a member of the NDP, would use
dilatory tactics of this kind to cause a member who is doing his
best as a parliamentarian and is working on a speech with
researchers and a whole team, to lose his concentration.
This is very sad coming from a former unionized employee of
Canadian; this is very sad coming from a member of the New
Democratic Party that is supposed to be a progressive party.
I am very surprised that the NDP would do such a thing. But when
the time comes to save Canada, I would like our fellow citizens
who are listening to us in Quebec to remember that the NDP is a
federalist party just as the Liberals, the Reform and the
Conservatives are.
They all sing from the same song sheet when it comes to standing
up for this great and beautiful Canada they refer to all the
time.
1545
On June 22, 1990, someone said in the Quebec National Assembly:
“No matter what one says or does, Quebec is today and forever a
distinct society, free and able to take its own destiny and
development into its own hands.”
This person was the former Liberal Premier Robert Bourassa, a
federalist, the day after the failure of the Meech Lake Accord.
Also, a group of individuals said: “The people of Quebec may not
be deprived of the responsibility to decide their own future.”
This is what the Assemblée des évêques du Québec said on
February 22, 1995.
Somebody else said: “It is imperative that Quebec be allowed to
retain full authority over decisions regarding its future within
the framework of Quebec democratic institutions.” This statement
was made by the Conservative senator Jean-Claude Rivest, a former
political advisor to Premier Bourassa.
I would like to read one more quote. Somebody mentioned: “One
thing is certain, from now on the future of Quebec will no
longer be decided in—”
[English]
Mr. John Williams: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of
order. I have been listening attentively to the speech by the
Bloc member who seems to have lost his train of thought and is
now on to bishops and democracy and so on. We are talking about
the transport committee's report. I would hope that he would not
hijack that report, the ability to talk about the report and the
livelihoods of many people when he gets off on tangents.
Mr. Speaker, I am asking that you question the member on the
relevance of his speech regarding the transport committee.
[Translation]
The Deputy Speaker: The hon. member for St. Albert is perfectly
right. The hon. member for
Beauport—Montmorency—Côte-de-Beaupré—Île-d'Orléans moved a motion for
concurrence in the report of the Standing Committee on
Transport. I know that this is what he wishes to talk about and
that his comments will deal with the report.
Mr. Michel Guimond: Mr. Speaker, as to the point of order raised
by the Reform member for St. Albert, with whom I sat on the
Standing Committee on Public Accounts when I was chair and he
was vice-chair of the committee, I want to say that he acted as
the watchdog of democracy.
I must say I find it very sad that he is trying to distract me
while I am speaking, as I am doing the best I can. I am only a
backbencher with qualities and shortcomings, and more
shortcomings than qualities, in fact—
Mr. René Canuel: It is not true. You belittle yourself.
[English]
Mr. John Williams: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of
order. Again, I have been listening attentively to the speech of
the member from the Bloc. He talked about my defending democracy.
In my role as the chairman of the Standing Committee on Public
Accounts I have done that and I continue to do so in this House.
I wonder why he is challenging my performance here in the House
regarding defending democracy because we all have rights and
freedoms to speak in this House. But I thought we were talking
about transport. I want to hear about transport. I want to hear
about how we are going to save jobs for Canadians.
The Deputy Speaker: I think we have had the point here
but the matter is not one that the Chair can easily resolve. I
am urging the member who has the floor to deal with the issue of
the transport committee's report and to perhaps stick to that
subject since he has proposed the motion for concurrence in that
report. I know hon. members will want to hear his views on the
report and his reasons for proposing this motion.
[Translation]
Mr. Michel Guimond: Mr. Speaker, I was just about to talk about
the 10% ownership rule in Air Canada. I hope that I will not be
interrupted. That rule is essential to maintain a broad
shareholder base.
1550
I want to explain that the Bloc does not support the majority
report of the Liberals, who want to raise that percentage to
20%. That would have the effect of giving effective control to a
single shareholder or a group of shareholders. If we want to
maintain a broad shareholder base, we absolutely must keep the
10% limit.
We read in The Gazette “The Liberal hon. member for Vaudreuil
said the following. Personally, I think that the limit should
not be set at 20%, because that would give the separatist Caisse
de dépôt control over Air Canada”.
Across the way, there are people, like the member for
Vaudreuil—Soulanges, who will charter buses, just as at the time
of the last referendum in 1995, three days before the next
referendum, for crowds to come and tell us they love us. Do you
think Quebecers are gullible enough to believe such a thing once
again?
That reminds me of those members from the Reform Party who were
lucky enough to get Canadian Airlines tickets. At the time of
the last referendum, Canadian Airlines chartered 747 planes and
people came from Vancouver to Montreal, three days before the
referendum, just to participate in the love parade.
You want me to speak about air transportation? Let us do so. VIA
Rail changed its name; it is now VIA Rail Canada and its engines
bear a logo with a big maple leaf. They speak about
transportation, but they will not let me finish my speech. I am
an impulsive person. I wonder if you have realized that, Mr.
Speaker.
The Standing Committee on Transport voted upon a second rule.
Before the President of the Treasury Board leaves, I want to say
I am convinced she will agree with me that the 10% ownership
rule at Air Canada should not be modified. I am sure she is a
true Quebecer, and I am sure she will be against changing that
rule.
Unfortunately, since she left the House, I cannot say she is not
here, but I want to say there is another important element in
this report from the Standing Committee on Transport. It is the
25% foreign ownership rule, which the Liberal majority wants to
increase to 49%. This means that Americans could control up to
49% of the airline industry.
This creates a totally ironic situation whereby members from the
Bloc Quebecois agree that the foreign ownership rule should
remain as it is, and the limit be maintained at 25%.
Believe it or not, we will respect the partnership between an
independent and sovereign Quebec and the rest of Canada. We are
so respectful that we are opposing the 49% rule in order to
promote Canada's sovereignty against the Americans.
If we accept the increase to 49%, there will more situations
such as those we already witnessed, for example American
Airlines which held large blocks of shares and which transferred
the positions of machinists, repairmen, and maintenance
employees from Vancouver and Calgary to the United States.
The Liberal majority pointed out that it agreed to increase the
percentage because we apparently need foreign capital. There is
not enough solid capital to justify ownership in Canada, wealth
in Canada.
And yet one of the proudest achievements of Quebecers, the
Caisse de dépôt, is ready to invest in Air Canada, not to take
control of it. The Caisse de dépôt's role is to ensure that the
savings of Quebecers earn a return so as to provide a future for
our children and our grandchildren.
1555
That is the role of the Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec.
This is not like the derogatory comments of the hon. member for
Vaudreuil—Soulanges who says that he does not want the limit
raised to 20% because he does not want to see the separatist
Caisse de dépôt take control of Air Canada. These are
unacceptable remarks coming from a Quebecer like the hon. member
for Vaudreuil—Soulanges, who is as much a Quebecer as I am. That
does not prevent him from saying this kind of things. That is
where the inconsistency is: it is acceptable for Americans to
control Air Canada but not the Caisse de dépôt et placement du
Québec.
Mr. Yvan Loubier: This is terrible.
Mr. Michel Guimond: The Standing Committee on Transport does not
say a word either on air safety. I will finish on a darker note,
a little bit more serious—although I should not say serious,
because I have been serious since the beginning—but I have making
my points in a more casual way. What I want to say is that this
report does not say a word about the lack of safety in numerous
regional airports. Unfortunately, in the last year and a half,
many people have lost their lives in Baie-Comeau, Gaspe and
Sept-Îles because Nav Canada closed down control towers.
The transport minister, answering a letter sent to him by the
leader of the Bloc Quebecois, the member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie,
said “The ministry is prepared to accept and tolerate an
acceptable risk”. But what is an acceptable risk? Is it playing
Russian roulette? Is every Quebecer travelling in regions of
Quebec, such as the Lower St. Lawrence, Gaspe, North Shore,
Abitibi or Saguenay-Lac-Saint-Jean, entitled to safe regional air
transportation? Do we say “I hope I will not be subjected to
unacceptable risk because if that is the case, my plane could
crash on the account of there being no air traffic controller”.
This should have be mentioned in the report.
The last issue I would like to talk about is this: the Bloc
Quebecois asked that regional airlines be subject to the
Official Languages Act, as is the main airline, Air Canada. As
members know, in the regions of Quebec, 98% of the customers are
francophones. Flight attendants act as a link between the pilot
and the passengers and are in charge of safety on board. The
primary function of a flight attendant is not, as many people
think, to serve meals and drinks, but to ensure safety.
It is not enough for flight attendants to know the usual speech
and say “Exits are above the wings and lavatories are at the
back”. A first grader, the young daughter of my colleague from
Saint-Hyacinthe—Bagot, for example, if taught properly, could say
that in front of 700 or 800 people.
It is one thing to teach that to a first grader, but it is quite
another to act in an emergency situation like the one we had
recently where a Focker 28 from Canadian Regional on a flight
from Quebec to Montreal had trouble with its front landing gear
and the flight attendant had to go through the emergency landing
procedures. And she only spoke English. She knew the usual
speech.
But when the time came to tell passengers to take off their
eyeglasses, their dentures and their shoes and to assume a
foetal position, she could not do it. It takes a flight
attendant who is capable of communicating in both official
languages.
1600
I will finish with a quote that goes back to the second point I
raised in my speech. Unfortunately, you interrupted me, but we
will have the opportunity to talk about it again later this
week. I barely touched on the subject in my speech today.
Someone said that it is up to Quebecers to decide, that the
federal government is wrong to try at all costs to impose a way
through the courts. This is what Gordon Wilson, constitutional
adviser to the Premier of British Columbia, said on February 5, 1998.
I will conclude with a quote from another journalist from
Beauport from the 19th century, when Quebecers were called
French Canadians.
This journalist from Beauport by the name of Étienne Parent said
“It is the fate of the French Canadian people not only to try to
keep their fundamental freedoms, but also to fight for their
very existence as a people. If we do not govern ourselves, we
will be governed”.
Mr. Guy St-Julien (Abitibi—Baie-James—Nunavik, Lib.): Mr. Speaker,
I would like to comment on the motion which states, and I quote:
That the First Report of the Standing Committee on Transport,
presented on Tuesday, December 7, 1999, be concurred in.
I have a relevant document. I am referring to page 31 of the
report, under recommendation 29. Incidentally, I am an associate
member of the committee, and I have tabled a number of motions
in the House of Commons. My motions, including motions M-333,
M-334, M-335, M-336, and M-337, are listed in today's notice paper.
Motion M-337 is important for the large federal riding of
Abitibi—Baie-James—Nunavik. The motion reads as follows:
That, in the opinion of this House, the government should
examine the financial assistance available to airports under the
Airport Capital Assistance Program, and on what terms, and
consider the possibility of extending the Program to operating
costs in order to sustain the provision of air transportation
services at airports in the riding of Abitibi—James Bay—Nunavik,
including the regional airport—
Ms. Caroline St-Hilaire: What is the question?
Mr. Guy St-Julien: It is in that motion. It concerns the regional
airports in Val d'Or, Amos, Lebel-sur-Quévillon, Matagami, La
Grande, Akulivik, Aupaluk, Inukjuaq, Ivujivik, Kangiqsualujjuaq,
Kangirsuk, Kangiqsujuaq, Kuujjuaq, Kuujjuaraapik, Umiujaq,
Puvirnituq, Chisasibi, EastMain, Quaqtaq, Salluit, Tasiujaq,
Waskaganish and Wemindji.
Could the hon. member tell me whether these airports should have
the means to finance emergency response services and receive
government assistance for this?
Mr. Gérard Asselin: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. You
have to agree with me that the question should not be longer
than the speech. Since we are talking about air transportation
and the hon. member for
Beauport—Montmorency—Côte-de-Beaupré—Île-d'Orléans is in full flight,
will the Chair be kind enough to ask for the unanimous consent
of the House to let the hon. member complete his excellent
speech?
The Deputy Speaker: Is there unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
Mr. Michel Guimond: Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for
Abitibi—Baie-James—Nunavik for his question, which I find
interesting in various regards.
The hon. member for Abitibi—Baie-James—Nunavik and I do not see the
relationship between Quebec and the rest of Canada the same way,
but we both worry about the airports located in subnorthern
areas and especially those in my riding. He knows that I am very
sensitive to this whole issue.
On the other hand, I am a bit disappointed with the hon. member
for Abitibi—Baie-James—Nunavik because I did talk about the
constitutional aspect of the relationship between Quebec and
Canada in my speech and I would have expected the hon. member to
refer to this aspect in his question.
For instance, if the hon. member for Abitibi—Baie-James—Nunavik had
asked me if I trust the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, I
had a truly remarkable figure of speech ready for him.
1605
As the Germans say “Do not ask the cat to look after the
cream”. That is how I see the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs.
To give him another example, the Americans say “Do not put the
rabbit in charge of the lettuce”. Or “Do not ask Dracula to run
the blood bank”. Or still “Do not hand the keys to the hen house
over to Colonel Sanders”.
I could also quote from the Three Little Pigs, where the poor
wee things hire the big bad wolf as a real estate agent and tell
him “Come, we will give you a tour of our houses”.
I would have thought the hon. member for Abitibi—Baie-James—Nunavik
would have realized that we ought to ask the federal government
to prove that the status quo has more to offer than the
sovereignty project we, the sovereignists, are putting forward.
Mr. Yves Rocheleau (Trois-Rivières, BQ): Mr. Speaker, I am very
pleased to ask a question of my colleague.
The Prime Minister is using as an example the changes promised
in 1980 by Pierre Trudeau, who put his head on the chopping
block to make changes, implying that they would be favourable to
the Quebec people. In Verdun, the member for Saint-Maurice was
again speaking of change, again implying that they would be
favourable to the Quebec people. Is my colleague satisfied with
the Prime Minister's response?
He is saying “Yes, we have made some changes, we have introduced
the concept of the distinct society”. I would like to have the
opinion of my colleague from
Beauport—Montmorency—Côte-de-Beaupré—Île-d'Orléans as to whether he
finds this intellectually satisfactory?
The Deputy Speaker: The problem with the question by the hon.
member for Trois-Rivières is that it does not deal with the
report of the Standing Committee on Transport. That is what is
being debated.
Mr. Michel Guimond: Mr. Speaker, it obvious from the question by
the member for Trois-Rivières that we are going through turbulent
times.
Since I must stick to the topic of transportation, it ties in
with the Prime Minister's personality. He is bound and
determined to put Quebecers back in their place. It is
unfortunate that Ottawa should recruit Quebecers to do its dirty
jobs.
A dirty job does not necessarily reflect on those doing it. In
this case however, I believe it does, even though I am not
allowed to say so. It is really sad to see what the Prime
Minister and the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs are
doing. I cannot wait to see how Quebec members will vote on this
draft bill.
How is the member for Westmount—Ville-Marie going to vote? How
will the member for Papineau—Saint-Denis and the 20 members from
Quebec vote? I cannot wait to see how the member for
Abitibi—Baie-James—Nunavik is going to vote. How will the members
for Outremont and Beauce vote? This is going to be interesting.
In Quebec, we have a great motto. It is on our licence plate. It
reads “Je me souviens.”
Mr. Daniel Turp (Beauharnois—Salaberry, BQ): Mr. Speaker, first
I would like to congratulate my colleague from
Beauport—Montmorency—Côte-de-Beaupré—Île-d'Orléans. He is very
eloquent.
He speaks with zest and spirit, as we saw this afternoon. He
also has a number of ideas on the issue of transportation. He
must certainly have ideas on air transportation in a sovereign
Quebec. I would like to hear what he has to say about that.
Mr. Michel Guimond: Mr. Speaker, my colleague who taught
constitutional law at the university level knows full well that
international routes are given through agreements between
countries.
1610
When the level of 200,000 passengers a year to a certain
destination is reached, representatives from one country meet
representatives from the other country, and a bilateral air
transport agreement is signed.
We saw that, in the past, Air Canada suffered from the fact that
the federal government always favoured Canadian International
Airlines. Members will recall that when we reached the required
number of passengers to Hong Kong. The Minister of Transport of
the day was the late Doug Young—I say the late Doug Young since
he was defeated because of his arrogance. He is still alive, but
he is the late Doug Young in this House because he was arrogant.
There was also the late David Dingwall, who was just as
arrogant. He was defeated as well.
Ordinary people do not like people who are arrogant. They prefer
real people, with their qualities and their faults.
An hon. member: Calm down.
Mr. Michel Guimond: I will try to calm down. All I want to say
is that, when Quebec achieves sovereignty, which I hope will be
soon, Quebec as a state will be able to go meet officials from
Switzerland, Belgium, Hong Kong or Taiwan to sign bilateral air
transport agreements for those companies that will be here and
that will want to do business in other countries. I hope
everybody recognizes that, in a sovereign Quebec, people will
continue to fly. Achieving sovereignty does not mean Quebecers
will go back to oxcarts.
We will be the sixteenth industrial power in the world, and I
hope nobody thinks that we will go back to steamships or to the
kinds of ships that sailed when Marco Polo was alive. So there
will be agreements.
The Deputy Speaker: It is my duty, pursuant to Standing Order
38, to inform the House that the questions to be raised tonight
at the time of adjournment are as follows: the hon. member for
Sackville—Musquodoboit Valley—Eastern Shore, Fisheries.
[English]
Mr. Gar Knutson (Parliamentary Secretary to Prime Minister,
Lib.): Mr. Speaker, I move:
The Deputy Speaker: Is it the pleasure of the House to
adopt the motion?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
The Deputy Speaker: All those in favour of the motion
will please say yea.
Some hon. members: Yea.
The Deputy Speaker: All those opposed will please say
nay.
Some hon. members: Nay.
The Deputy Speaker: In my opinion the nays have it.
And more than five members having risen:
The Deputy Speaker: Call in the members.
1655
(The House divided on the motion, which was agreed to on the
following division):
YEAS
Members
Abbott
| Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
|
Assad
| Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
|
Bailey
| Baker
| Bakopanos
| Barnes
|
Beaumier
| Bélair
| Bélanger
| Bellemare
|
Bennett
| Benoit
| Bertrand
| Bevilacqua
|
Blaikie
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Borotsik
|
Boudria
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brison
| Brown
|
Bryden
| Bulte
| Caccia
| Cadman
|
Cannis
| Caplan
| Carroll
| Casey
|
Casson
| Catterall
| Chan
| Charbonneau
|
Chatters
| Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| Cummins
|
Davies
| DeVillers
| Dhaliwal
| Dion
|
Discepola
| Doyle
| Drouin
| Duhamel
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Epp
| Finlay
| Gagliano
| Gallaway
|
Godfrey
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Goldring
| Goodale
|
Graham
| Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Grose
|
Gruending
| Guarnieri
| Hanger
| Harb
|
Harris
| Harvard
| Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
|
Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
| Hubbard
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jaffer
| Jennings
| Johnston
|
Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
| Keddy
(South Shore)
| Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Konrad
| Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
|
Leung
| Lill
| Limoges
| Lincoln
|
Longfield
| Lunn
| MacAulay
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
|
Mahoney
| Maloney
| Mancini
| Manley
|
Mark
| Marleau
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
|
Matthews
| Mayfield
| McCormick
| McGuire
|
McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
| McWhinney
|
Meredith
| Mifflin
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
| Mills
(Red Deer)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Muise
| Murray
|
Myers
| Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
|
O'Brien
(Labrador)
| O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
|
Pankiw
| Paradis
| Patry
| Penson
|
Peterson
| Pettigrew
| Phinney
| Pillitteri
|
Power
| Pratt
| Proctor
| Proud
|
Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
| Reed
|
Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
| Saada
|
Schmidt
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Scott
(Skeena)
| Serré
|
Sgro
| Solberg
| Solomon
| Speller
|
St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Szabo
| Telegdi
|
Thibeault
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
| Torsney
|
Ur
| Vanclief
| Volpe
| Wappel
|
Wasylycia - Leis
| Whelan
| White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Wilfert
|
Williams
| Wood – 190
|
NAYS
Members
Alarie
| Asselin
| Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bellehumeur
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bigras
| Brien
|
Canuel
| Cardin
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
| Crête
|
Dalphond - Guiral
| de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
|
Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
| Fournier
|
Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
|
Guimond
| Lalonde
| Laurin
| Lebel
|
Loubier
| Marceau
| Ménard
| Picard
(Drummond)
|
Plamondon
| Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| St - Hilaire
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
– 39
|
PAIRED
Members
The Speaker: I declare the motion carried.
Mr. Randy White: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.
I would like to ask you if it is in order to acknowledge that
the Reform Party is finally winning votes in the House.
The Speaker: No comment.
GOVERNMENT ORDERS
[English]
NISGA'A FINAL AGREEMENT ACT
The House resumed consideration of the motion that Bill C-9, an
act to give effect to the Nisga'a final agreement, be read the
third time and passed.
1700
Ms. Libby Davies (Vancouver East, NDP): Madam Speaker, I
am very proud to rise in the House today to speak to Bill C-9,
the Nisga'a final agreement, at third reading. I am proud to say
that all members of the federal NDP caucus have supported Bill
C-9, and have been very supportive of the process and the debate
that has taken place. We have stood firmly in support of the
Nisga'a final agreement.
I would like to recognize the work of our aboriginal affairs
spokesperson, the member for Yukon. She has played a very
positive role at committee with her thoughtful comments, her
experience and her deep understanding of aboriginal affairs. I
would like to pay special thanks to her for her very dedicated
work and participation in the process.
Being from British Columbia, I would like to put on the record
that the work of our provincial government on the Nisga'a
agreement and on the negotiations which took place also needs to
be acknowledged. Two former premiers, Michael Harcourt and Glen
Clark, really made this a centrepiece of their agendas. They
were personally very committed to seeing a redress of the wrongs
that had been done in the past and seeking social and economic
justice for the Nisga'a people. Mike Harcourt, Glen Clark, Ian
Waddell, the MLA who chaired the B.C. legislative committee that
went around the province, as well as Dale Lovick, the current
minister of aboriginal affairs for B.C., did a very good job.
It has to be recognized that they took on this job and were
faced with a lot of political opportunism, which was seen to be
more politically expedient than achieving justice, by the B.C.
Liberal Party and the federal Reform Party.
I toyed with the idea of also thanking another former premier of
British Columbia, Mr. Vander Zalm, who actually brought the
provincial government to the negotiating table in 1991. However,
after seeing what he did in the last few years I do not think I
could thank him. He basically trashed aboriginal people and the
Nisga'a agreement. When the committee was in Vancouver he played
a role in the games that were played with his little
demonstration. Mr. Vander Zalm brought in the people who hurled
obscenities, while he sat there apparently in agreement. He has
not played a positive role. He too has sunk to the level of his
federal colleagues in the Reform Party in seeing this issue as
political opportunism.
Most of all, I would like to thank the Nisga'a people for their
patience, not just today with the entire process that has
unfolded in the House, but for their patience over the last 20
years and that of the generations before them. If we look back
and reflect on the oppression that aboriginal and Nisga'a people
suffered and the fact that they had the faith to negotiate an
agreement, we know that this is something that is very historic
and needs to be acknowledged, particularly in light of what has
been a very difficult debate. Horrific statements have been made
and thrown at them.
I particularly want to thank Joe Gosnell, the leader of the
Nisga'a people, as well as the teams of negotiators. As we were
doing our business in the House they kept faith in the process. I
am sure there were ups and downs. I am sure there were days when
they thought that maybe this would not work and people had to
compromise. The fact is that the federal, provincial and Nisga'a
negotiators arrived at the agreement which is before us today.
Earlier we heard from Reform members that they believe part of
the negotiation process which unfolded was somehow a stacked
deal, that it was all done behind closed doors. We have said
this many times on the record, and let it be said again: no
piece of legislation has had as much scrutiny, examination,
debate and public hearing as the Nisga'a agreement in principle
as well as the final agreement. We know that for the 20 years
that negotiations took place, especially the last few years,
advisory committees were involved and public hearings were held
by various organizations.
For example, the labour movement in British Columbia was involved
in the advisory committees. It held consultations with its
membership on the treaty to get feedback. We have heard the same
thing from the business community, as well as the aboriginal
community.
1705
The member for Skeena earlier today said that this was a stacked
process which was carried out behind closed doors. I cannot
think of anything further from the truth in terms of what really
took place. Committee hearings were held in B.C. and in Ottawa.
We have to ask ourselves what this agreement is about. There
are many ways to sum it up. I believe this agreement is
important and significant. It provides the opportunity for the
Nisga'a people to assert themselves as a people, to realize their
rights, to undertake their own affairs in economic terms, in
social terms, in cultural terms and in terms of equality.
The agreement allows the Nisga'a people to redress the wrongs of
the past. It allows the Nisga'a people to develop a stewardship
of the land and it allows them to develop resource based
management from which all Canadians will learn.
The Nisga'a agreement is within the Canadian constitution. It
burns me to hear Reform members spreading information again and
again that somehow the agreement is illegal.
Earlier today we again heard the member for Skeena say that the
Nisga'a final agreement is legislated segregation. In fact the
member went on to equate legislated segregation with apartheid.
This is really disgusting. I feel that it displays an astounding
arrogance.
The member is suggesting to the Nisga'a people that they have
accepted a system of apartheid. He has a lot of arrogance to say
that after 20 years of negotiation. This agreement is about
equality and social justice. This agreement is within the
Canadian constitution. I do not know the response to these
comments, but to use these terms, to use the word apartheid, to
use the term legislated segregation, is a denial of what has
really taken place.
We have to ask ourselves why there has been such a vitriolic
response. Even today I was still receiving e-mails full of
hatred, viciousness, meanness and racial overtones. I ask myself
where this information is coming from. We have to admit,
unfortunately, that some of the information comes from the media,
which has bought into certain arguments of the Reform Party and
its cohort in British Columbia, the B.C. Liberal Party. These
messages have been repeated over and over until the people have
begun to believe them.
Within the media there has also been some very reasoned,
thoughtful and reflective debate which has tried to present the
agreement as something that can be examined. Yes, there are some
criticisms and there are some issues. This is not a perfect
document. We should acknowledge that in the sea of
misinformation and a campaign full of misrepresentation and
divisiveness some members of the media have tried to ensure that
there was a balanced debate.
Today we heard the member for Skeena say that the Reform Party
was trying to shed light on the Nisga'a final agreement. What
does that mean? I came to the conclusion that Reform members
have not shed any light on the Nisga'a final agreement; they have
only shed darkness.
That is what has been very upsetting about the process which we
have gone through. Misinformation has been peddled to the media
and the message has gone out again and again that somehow women's
rights will not be upheld, that this is a constitutional
amendment through the back door, that it will be taxation without
representation, that it will be legislated separation, that it
will be apartheid, and on and on it goes. That is not shedding
light; that is conducting a campaign of fear.
1710
When are Reform members going to stop putting out information
that is incorrect, information that is designed to divide people
and exploit people's fears about change and about what is taking
place? From that point of view, it has been a process that has
in some ways brought out the best in terms of public debate and
certainly has been a model of what negotiation should be about.
However, it has also been a public process, regrettably, that has
brought out the worst in some people and the worst in some
members of the House.
I have supported this agreement from the beginning. I have to
say that the Nass Valley is many hundreds of miles from my riding
of Vancouver East. I do not have a direct physical connection
with that part of British Columbia. However, I feel that there
is a very significant link between what happens in the Nass
Valley to the Nisga'a people and what happens in my riding of
Vancouver East. My riding also contains a very large population
of urban aboriginal people. As we know, something like 60% of
aboriginal people live off reserve because they have been
oppressed by the system, by the way we have conducted affairs
through the Department of Indian Affairs and Northern
Development.
This agreement provides a way to open up a new door. It is a
way for government to sit down in equal partnership with
aboriginal people and say that it is going to change the way it
does business, that it will be on the basis of equality and that
it will be on the basis of justice.
I support the Nisga'a final agreement. To me it is a step
forward. However, it is not the end of the road. In some ways
it is only the beginning. I am not saying that the agreement is
a “one size fits all” for all of B.C. or all of Canada.
Nothing could be further from the truth.
The process is important. The process that was conducted needs
to be repeated in terms of arriving at negotiated settlements;
not conflict and litigation through the courts, such as we have
seen on our east coast.
Taking that step forward is a sign of hope. It is a sign that
federal representatives, provincial representatives and
aboriginal representatives can sit down, work out very complex
issues and arrive at something with which we can all live. I
hope that we continue along that path. I hope too that we
recognize that urban aboriginal people are also in great distress
and that their issues need to be addressed.
I ask the government to consider that. We had the royal
commission on aboriginal affairs. I do not know how much dust
the report is collecting, but it is a job that we need to get on
with. There are people in my riding who are literally dying on
the street. There are people who are suffering from addiction.
There are people who are living in substandard housing. There
are people who are living far below the poverty line and are
struggling to survive each and every day. It takes a lot of
courage and survival skills to do that.
It is important that we see this agreement as a step in a
process, a step along the road in dealing as well with those
other issues that are very important.
When the member for Skeena concluded his remarks he said that
the Nisga'a final agreement was not a good deal for the Nisga'a
people. I thought about that. I assume that the member believed
what he said, that it is not a good deal for the Nisga'a people.
We have to be very careful about the kinds of conclusions we come
to.
This is not something that was put together over a few days.
This is not something that was prepared by the federal
government, the department or the provincial government, which
then said “Take it or leave it”. This was a process in which
an agreement was negotiated. It was the Nisga'a people
themselves, their leadership and the members of that community,
who finally at the end of the day decided that this was a good
deal.
Maybe it is not all they had hoped for. They made many
compromises, but it is an agreement they can live with and an
agreement they can build their lives with. It is an agreement
they can pass on to their children and say that they did the
right thing, that they are building and creating their future.
1715
The member for Skeena is dead wrong when he says that it is not
a good deal for the Nisga'a people. He needs to go into that
community and talk to people. He will find out that it was
approved by a very large majority. History will show us 10 or 20
years from now that this was the right way to do something, that
it was far preferable to conflict in a legal sense and in a
political sense.
I am very proud today that I and all of our members in the
federal caucus are supporting this agreement. There has been a
lot of stuff out in the media. We have all had responses from
some people, but at the end of the day it is important to stand
up and do the right thing. The right thing here is to support
the agreement, say that it is a step forward and that it is the
right step forward.
Mr. Leon E. Benoit: Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of
order. The member for Wentworth—Burlington and I have agreed to
exchange positions on the order of precedence for my motion,
Motion No. 20 and Bill C-206 effective for private members' hour
tomorrow.
However, to do so I have to seek the unanimous consent of the
House to waive the 48 hour notice pertaining to such exchanges
and replace it with a 24 hour notice. In the spirit of
non-partisanship, we would like to ask for the unanimous consent
of the House to make this exchange. I would request that all
parties put partisan politics aside and, since this is Private
Members' Business, grant unanimous consent.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): Is there unanimous
consent to proceed in such a way?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
An hon. member: No.
Mr. Mike Scott (Skeena, Ref.): Madam Speaker, since the
member in her intervention repeatedly referred to me and things I
have said not only today but earlier on—actually I have been
involved in this issue for five and a half years—I feel it
appropriate that I respond.
I must point out to the House and to anybody who might be
watching out there that the member did exactly what I predicted
she would do. She slags anybody who disagrees not on the basis
of the issue or not on the basis of the substance of the treaty
but on the basis that we somehow have dark motives, that we are
somehow people of lower moral character because we do not agree
with the government's policy direction. That is the first thing
I predicted would happen.
She admitted in her intervention that the agreement is flawed
but did not talk at all about what the flaws are in the
agreement. She totally discounted the expert advice we received
from constitutional legal experts, such as Mel Smith, Professor
Stephen Scott, Professor Tom Flanagan and a host of others. She
glossed right over that and said that irrespective of what these
people have told us as parliamentarians that she is right, that
somehow she has elevated herself to be a constitutional expert
and an expert on the charter of rights because she says so and
that is just the way it is.
I will ask the member a legitimate question. If she is so sure
that this is not an extra-constitutional document, that this
document does not violate the constitution, which is the subject
of two separate legal challenges in British Columbia, that the
charter of rights and freedoms applies and that the charter of
rights of the Nisga'a people will not be diminished under this
agreement, why would she and her party not support the one
amendment we wanted last week above all other amendments, the
amendment to guarantee that the Constitution of Canada and the
charter of rights and freedoms would apply and that the
self-government provisions in chapter 11 would not be
constitutionally entrenched? Why did she not support the one
amendment that would have guaranteed a higher likelihood of the
charter applying and a lower likelihood of this being seen as a
back door amending of the constitution?
1720
Why was she and her party not prepared to support that one
amendment? Of all the other defects and flaws in the treaty,
that was the one we wanted. We are not happy with many of the
other defects, but that was one that we felt was important to
have so that if there are any problems in the future, and we know
there will be problems, they can be fixed. Why was she not
prepared to do that?
Ms. Libby Davies: Madam Speaker, I will agree with the
member for Skeena on one thing: I am not a constitutional
expert, just as he is not a constitutional expert. I, like other
members, rely on all of the opinions that come before us, from
the committee as well as information we receive.
I would be very surprised if there was any legal issue in Canada
where we could find a whole bunch of lawyers all agreeing on the
same thing. Of course there were other opinions, but we have to
look at the overall body of evidence. Surely that is what we do
as parliamentarians. We look at the history of our country and
come to a rational, reasonable conclusion as to whether or not
something is right in terms of the constitution. A vast majority
of the members in the House, in fact four of the political
parties present, came to that conclusion because it was logical
and reasonable.
The Reform Party can of course find someone who will disagree
with that, but the overwhelming evidence and opinion in the
country is that the Nisga'a agreement is perfectly within the
Canadian constitution.
I do not think I ever said that the agreement was flawed. I
said it was not perfect. Is anything perfect? Is anything in
the House perfect? I do not think so, but it is a pretty good
document. When we go through it and think of what it took to get
to that point, it is as near to perfect as anything can get when
there is that kind of process. It is not a flawed document. I
wish the member would not misrepresent what I said.
In terms of the amendments that came forward, we went through
that charade for many hours? There has been a lot of debate in
the House. It is clear that we make up our own minds about what
we think is right or whether or not something is constitutional.
I can inform the member that the members of the NDP believe very
strongly and firmly that the agreement is within the
constitution. We therefore did not see the need for any further
amendments. It is abundantly clear as it stands now. I wish the
member could understand that.
Mrs. Sue Barnes (London West, Lib.): Madam Speaker,
because of all the shenanigans that have gone on in the House
over the last number of days, it is likely that as chair of the
committee I will not get an opportunity to speak.
I will take this opportunity, having listened to the comments
from the member opposite, to say how much I agree with them in
most parts. I also thank not only the member's party and her
personally for her work on this file, but members from the Bloc,
members from the Conservative Party, members from our own party
and all the people who worked very patiently and hard. I also
second the fact that because negotiations took place over many,
many years, a historical context surrounds this agreement that
will long outlive noise and confusion.
I am very happy to be part of a real process that will change
history in the country. I thank the hon. member for giving voice
to some of the sentiments that many of us hold.
Ms. Libby Davies: Madam Speaker, I thank the hon. member
for her kind comments. We do not always agree with the Liberal
members but I think on this issue we see eye to eye. The member
chaired the committee in some very difficult hearings. I was
only present at some of them, but in other hearings it was very
difficult to keep a sense of order and balance with the
opposition that came forward. The member did an excellent job in
chairing those meetings.
In the committee meetings I attended, I thought the discussions,
questions and debates were of an excellent nature. It was the
best of what we can expect in terms of parliamentarians doing
their work. They listened to the criticisms.
There were criticisms as there is on everything. The thoughtful
responses and the questions that were provided were very
important. Unfortunately, I do not think that was true of the
Reform Party which played a very different kind of game. It was
executing a political agenda. Fortunately, at the end of the day,
it did not managed to get that through and this agreement will be
approved and the work of the committee and the members in the
House will see that is done. That is a good thing.
* * *
1725
POINTS OF ORDER
APPROPRIATION BILL
Mr. John Williams (St. Albert, Ref.): Madam Speaker, I
rise on a point of order with regard to the appropriation bill
that will be considered later this day in the House. I will
first refer you to subclause 3(2) of the act which states that
“the provision of each item in schedules 1 and 2 are deemed to
have been enacted by parliament on April 1, 1999”.
However on page 3 of the bill at subclause 6(2) it states:
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Act, amounts
appropriated by this Act and set out in terms of Schedule 2 may
be paid and applied at any time on or before March 31, 2001, so
long as every payment is charged first against the relevant
amount appropriated under any Act that is earliest in time until
that amount is exhausted, next against the relevant amount
appropriated under any other Act, including this Act, that is
next in time until that amount is exhausted and so on, and the
balance of amounts so appropriated by this Act that have not been
charged, subject to the adjustments referred to in section 37 of
the Financial Administration Act, lapse at the end of the fiscal
year following the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000.
Madam Speaker, as you can see, subclause 6(2)—
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): I have to advise the
hon. member that maybe it would be more opportune for him to
bring this point of order later on today when the question is
before the House. At this point I do not think it is a good time
to do it.
Mr. John Williams: Madam Speaker, there are many times
when it is not appropriate to bring a point of order from the
Chair's point of view, but it is a point of order that has to be
raised. It may require some research, at which time the Speaker
may require some additional time prior to the ruling. The voting
will be later on tonight and once the bells start to ring there
will be no opportunity to rise on a point of order and give the
Speaker time to research. Therefore, I think it is appropriate
that you hear it and hear it now.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): I will listen to the
hon. member but I will ask him to be very brief.
1730
Mr. John Williams: I appreciate your ruling, Madam
Speaker. I will continue. As we can see, subclause 6(2)
specifically allows the funds appropriated by the bill to be
spent up to and including March 31, 2001, even though the bill is
deemed effective April 1, 1999. Clearly we are being asked to
appropriate funds for a period of two years.
Citation 933 of Beauchesne's states:
The purpose of the estimates is to present to Parliament the
budgetary and non-budgetary expenditure proposals of the
Government for the next fiscal year.
You ruled last year, Madam Speaker, on a similar point of order
at page 16065 of Hansard where you stated:
The multi-year appropriation authority covered in schedule 2 of
the bill is based on legislation approved by parliament in 1998
by which Parks Canada Agency is granted the authority to carry
over to the end of the 2000-01 fiscal year the unexpended balance
of the money for the fiscal year 1999-2000.
The difference with this bill—
Hon. David Anderson: Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of
order. The practice of the Reform Party is to filibuster the
Nisga'a treaty as it has been doing consistently throughout these
debates. It is nevertheless the time of the hon. member of the
Conservative Party for South Shore.
The hon. member has been told to be brief. He was told that he
was out of order, but he is still persevering. Why is he allowed
to take the time—
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): The hon. member is
making an argument and he is sticking strictly to the point. I
think we will have to give him two or three minutes.
Mr. John Williams: I appreciate that ruling as well. As
I said, the difference with this bill is that clause 6 makes no
reference to a carryover but instead provides for a two year
window to spend from April 1, 1999 to March 31, 2001. This is
against our financial procedures as explained in Beauchesne's
citation 933.
The Public Accounts of Canada must refer back to the authorities
voted by parliament if the public accounts are to make any sense
to parliamentarians and the appropriation which they voted to the
crown. If parliament approves two years together then how can
parliamentarians properly examine spending for one fiscal year?
I am trying to be brief but I have to get the complex argument
on the record. The President of the Treasury Board said in the
House on April 24, 1996, at page 1903 of Debates:
However, in Your Honour's ruling of June 8, 1999, you said that
the notions of fiscal year and annual appropriation are the
cornerstones of our parliamentary financial process. The
government wants to change our practice and exceed its authority
by seeking multi-year appropriation.
In addition, the title does not reflect what is in the bill. The
title reads “an act for granting to Her Majesty certain sums of
money for the public service of Canada for the financial year
ending March 31, 2000”. Yet the bill contains the specific
authority to spend funds up to and including March 31, 2001, with
no reference whatsoever that it pertains to funds to be carried
over from the year ending March 31, 2000. Beauchesne's citation
626 states:
Although there is no specific set of rules or guidelines
governing the content of a bill, there should be a theme of
relevancy among the contents of a bill. They must be relevant to
and subject to the umbrella, which is raised by the terminology
of the long title of the bill.
I am almost finished.
Mr. David Iftody: Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of
order. Over three and a half or four minutes ago and into this
long dissertation you asked the gentleman to be brief and
courteous to the rest of us in the House with his comments.
If the rules of the House suggest that he has to make this
comment, would you please use the discretion of the Chair and ask
him to conclude or cut him off?
1735
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): I am sure the hon.
member will be finishing his remarks very shortly.
Mr. John Williams: Madam Speaker, I appreciate your
ruling. To sum up, since citation 626 claimed that the title is
an essential part of the bill, this bill is flawed and should be
ruled out of order because it includes appropriation for more
than one fiscal year. Yet the long title would lead us to
believe that it is only for one fiscal year.
I would therefore ask, that you rule the
appropriation bill out of order because it clearly contradicts
the practices and procedures of the House as contained in our
standing orders and in Beauchesne's.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): The Chair will
take the matter under advisement and come back with a ruling at
an opportune time.
* * *
NISGA'A FINAL AGREEMENT ACT
The House resumed consideration of the motion that Bill C-9, an
Act to give effect to the Nisga'a Final Agreement, be read the
third time and passed.
Mr. Ted McWhinney (Vancouver Quadra, Lib.): Madam
Speaker, the hon. member for Vancouver East gave us an
interesting and valuable historical record.
Would she include in that the agreement between the Prime
Minister of Canada, Mr. Mulroney, and the Premier of British
Columbia, Mr. Vander Zalm, in 1990 that the issue of minority
rights was not an appropriate subject for referendum and the
guarantee that they gave?
Would she agree that the constitutional principle of good faith,
which is judicially enforceable, would require present
administrations to honour their undertaking?
Ms. Libby Davies: Mr. Speaker, because I know there are
other members who want to speak I will answer very briefly. Those
comments are very good and obviously concur that minority rights
should not be subject to a referendum. I will just leave it at
that because I know there are other members who wish to speak.
[Translation]
Mr. Pierre de Savoye (Portneuf, BQ): Madam Speaker, I have a
very brief question to ask and, since the NDP member is very
familiar with this issue, I am sure she will be able to give me
an answer.
We know that the treaty which is about to be ratified has gone
through a long negotiation process carried out even before a
referendum was held. Can the hon. member answer the following?
How did the Nisga'a people, for whom I am very happy to see that
this treaty is about to come true, manage to be better treated
that the people of Quebec?
[English]
Ms. Libby Davies: Madam Speaker, I think that is a
subject for another day. What is before us today is the Nisga'a
treaty and the process that was conducted there. I think the
member has other opportunities to raise the other matters, so I
will leave my reply at that because I know the other parties also
want to speak to this issue.
Mr. Gerald Keddy (South Shore, PC): Madam Speaker, it has
been a long day. Many of us have waited in the House to speak to
this very important piece of legislation. I am certainly proud
on behalf of the Progressive Conservative Party to speak to Bill
C-9.
With respect to the intervention by the hon. member who spoke
previously, which I am sure was an enlightened and intelligent
intervention, I would like to comment that the only time I ever
heard a sound like that it came out of the south end of a dog
that was headed north.
It is time that we debated this issue. It is past time that we
debated this issue. We have stood in the House on numerous
occasions and talked about the substance of the Nisga'a bill. We
have talked about the legislation. We have talked about how it
affects taxation, how it affects the charter of rights and
freedoms, and how it affects the constitution of Canada.
I listened to the hon. member for Skeena speak about the
constitution of Canada. I heard him state in this place that
this changes the constitution of Canada.
That is exactly what was said, and I have heard it from other
members of parliament.
1740
For the members of parliament who have read the legislation, I
ask them to turn to page 17 where it references the constitution
of Canada. It states in section 8 that this agreement does not
alter the constitution of Canada. That is fairly
straightforward, clear and pertinent to this discussion.
In subsection 8(a) it goes on to explain it further. This is
the type of debate that should be raised. Members should read
the statements and the sections of the agreement with which hon.
members have a problem. They should be put before the country so
that Canadians will hear what we are all listening to and make a
reasoned and rational decision. I have no fear whatsoever about
depending upon the good, common sense of Canadians when they hear
all the points in this issue.
I will read some of the points in the legislation that have been
singled out and have been, I think, misinterpreted by members of
parliament. I will also describe why I believe they have been
misinterpreted. Subsection 8(a) says:
This Agreement does not alter the Constitution of Canada,
including: a. the distribution of powers between Canada and
British Columbia; b. the identity of the Nisga'a Nation as an
aboriginal people of Canada within the meaning of the
Constitution Act, 1982; and c. sections 25 and 35 of the
Constitution Act, 1982.
It says further:
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms applies to
Nisga'a Government in respect of all matters within its
authority, bearing in mind the free and democratic nature of
Nisga'a Government as set out in this Agreement.
That is the same way that the charter of rights and freedoms
applies to all democratic societies and governments in the
country. There is nothing new there. There is no hidden design.
I said in debate before that the earth will not open up and
swallow British Columbia, not for a moment.
There have been other discussions on the bill. It is very
important that we take those discussions a step further, that we
look at them in the cold, clear light of day and debate them.
I have no problem with debating the bill. I will debate the
bill until Easter without any problem whatsoever but I want to
debate the bill. I do not want to debate some fictional
caricature of this piece of legislation that on a good day is
misleading and on a bad day totally affects the hard work
starting in 1887 of the Nisga'a people, the province of British
Columbia, the Nisga'a chiefs and successive governments of
Canada. Negotiations were entered into in good faith.
The legislation deals with all those issues. Like any series of
negotiations there is some give and take. The Nisga'a did not
get the agreement they started out asking for, and perhaps on the
government side it did not get the agreement either. However in
negotiations we ended up with an agreement that is workable. The
key ingredient for me is that we ended with an agreement that has
some flexibility. This is not entrenched in the proverbial
constitutional concrete that we keep hearing about. This
agreement is protected by the constitution. It is not a part of
the constitution of Canada.
I do not know how many times that has to be said in this place
before someone will actually listen to the argument. It is easy
to say no. It is easy to say I do not believe that, but if we
look at the facts, study the legislation, talk to the legal
experts, listen to the informed and often very good debate that
occurred in the House on the treaty, we will come to understand
that there are significant issues within the treaty that I
believe are a template for other treaties.
There are parts of this treaty that I would hope will become a
template for further treaties in the country.
There are parts of this treaty that we should have as a template.
1745
There is the fact that the Constitution of Canada prevails. The
charter of rights and freedoms prevails. The interests of women
and children are protected. The Nisga'a will own their land, and
let me be very clear about this, fee simple.
There is no such thing as fee simple common. I do not know what
that is. That term has been made up. That is one of the myths
about this legislation that has been thrown out in debate. Hon.
members use it and never have to back it up. They can sit down
after they are finished in debate and say, “I have said it and I
don't have to back it up. I don't have to go anywhere and defend
what I am saying”. I have defended what I have said on this
bill on numerous occasions and I am very happy to defend it one
more time.
The issue of jurisdiction is extremely important. It is
important for parliamentarians to protect the jurisdiction of the
crown. It is important for parliamentarians to protect the
jurisdiction of the province of British Columbia. Because we
have entered into a treaty process with first nations in this
country, it is important to protect future jurisdictions that
will look at this treaty. It is not a template but we can look
at many parts of this treaty with satisfaction and a great deal
of pride and say we have done our duty as parliamentarians. We
have protected the interests of Canadians.
We have put aside a historic wrong against the Nisga'a people.
It started in 1887 when the Nisga'a chiefs paddled their canoes
to the B.C. legislature. Hon. members should picture this in
their minds. The chiefs dragged the canoes up on the beach,
walked to the legislature, knocked on the door and were refused
entry. It is unbelievable.
We have continued under the auspices of the Indian Act and other
pieces of legislation to, I believe, inhibit opportunities for
first nations.
An hon. member referred to Bill C-49. What a novel thought in
Bill C-49 that first nations would be in charge, in control of
and responsible for the land on their reserves. Several cases
have arisen out of some of the legislation in Bill C-49, but here
is the principle that land that we own or any first nation owns
is their land to do with what they want to, as long as they obey
the laws of Canada and the territory or province they are in,
that they recognize stewardship and that they look after the
environment.
None of us have a spotless record in this place, no group, no
party, no individual. We can only work with the facts in front
of us. We can only deal with one point at a time. It is great
to shove all these points together and somehow throw them out, as
if they were broadcasting grain to see which ones will grow and
which ones will take root. They nourish those and divide them,
spreading fear and innuendo and causing Canadians to ask if there
is something wrong with this. Have we passed a piece of
legislation in the House of Commons that does not protect the
interests of ordinary Canadians? Absolutely not. We have not.
That has not been done.
There is the issue of jurisdiction. There is the very important
issue of overlap between the Gitksan and the Nisga'a, and the
possible overlap with the Gitanyow.
I sat in Smithers and listened to the debate. The record was
quoted earlier today. Any Canadian who would like to look at
that debate should get a copy of the record and read it. They
should read the questions that were asked about possible conflict
and if there could be violence. Everything was done that could
be done to get one first nation to take a stand against another,
one Canadian against another Canadian, one community against
another community, sowing the seeds of discontent.
1750
As a private landowner and as a farmer I have been in numerous
land disputes. Some of them were not very pretty. In some of
those disputes harsh words were said, but at the end of the day
there was never any intent on anyone's part not to somehow
negotiate a fair and equitable settlement for everyone.
Canadians respect the rule of law. The Nisga'a people respect
the rule of law. The province of British Columbia respects the
rule of law. At the end of the day the issues of division that
still lay undecided in this treaty will be settled because there
is a process to settle them. It is not a complicated process and
it is clearly laid out in the agreement. On every issue the
Nisga'a final agreement prevails. Even if that part of the
legislation is not carried over to the government's legislation,
it still goes back to the Nisga'a final agreement and the Nisga'a
final agreement prevails.
For those of us who have debated it, studied it and worked on it
literally for months and months, there is nothing shocking here.
There is nothing untoward. Hon. members talk about 14 areas where
the Nisga'a will have more jurisdiction than the province of
British Columbia or the Government of Canada. I would suggest
that members read those issues, read those 14 areas. There is
absolutely nothing shocking in the agreement. There is nothing
there that takes away rights from ordinary Canadians. There is
nothing there that allows for taxation without representation.
That is patently untrue.
The taxation agreement with Canada and the province of British
Columbia will allow the Nisga'a government to tax Nisga'a
citizens. It absolutely does not allow the Nisga'a government to
tax non-Nisga'a citizens. It is pretty simple. It even goes so
far as to state that in the event that the Nisga'a sell a piece
of their property to a non-Nisga'a, because Nisga'a property will
be owned fee simple and the band or a member has every right to
sell a piece of Nisga'a land, that is their land, they own it,
then we go back to the agreement and the jurisdiction will rest
for taxation in the hands of the province of British Columbia,
not with the Nisga'a government. There is no way we can have
taxation without representation. It goes on and on and on.
Most of us were here the other night and we voted. Certainly we
showed up for the final vote. Reform members have made a big
ruckus of party solidarity on this. I counted the votes on
Motion No. 471. I was in the House. Thirty-nine members of the
Reform Party voted. I believe if we check the record there are
more Reform members than that. I know some of them were tired and
I understand that. It is not inconceivable that members of
parliament missed that last vote because it was tough. There is
no question about it. Thirty-nine members voted. I do not think
it is all love and apple pie in the Reform caucus either. I
think there are some serious problems there.
We have dealt with jurisdiction. We have dealt with a number of
issues. Let us talk for a moment about the fishery. Let us look
at the fishery agreement which allows the Nisga'a government 27%
of the TAC on the Nass River and 16% of the total TAC, that is
offshore TAC.
I have heard this called a race based fishery. I would have to
agree with that if the Nisga'a had 100% of the fishery on the
Nass River. As long as they do not have 100%—and they do not,
they have 27%—it cannot be a race based fishery.
Other people will benefit from the stewardship programs
introduced by the Nisga'a.
1755
As I have said in the House before, having 27% of the total
salmon catch on the Nass River is the same as having 27% of
nothing, unless the stock is nurtured and allowed to reproduce
and the government does not allow them to be caught on the high
seas and they actually get to return to the rivers and spawn. If
the resource is looked after, if the salmon population were to
double, 27% is very significant. However, the remaining 73% for
everyone else would also double.
It is a very fair agreement. It was worked out over time and
with great difficulty. If we used this agreement as a template
and applied it to every river in B.C., it would still keep the
native fishery at 27%. It might be divided between five or six
bands. It might be more. It might be 40%. This is why we have
negotiations.
This is not a race based fishery. We as members of parliament
are not encouraging some type of apartheid system. It is
completely and unequivocally irresponsible and patently wrong and
misleading to state that.
What is nonsense about this treaty is the number of people I
have talked to who are adamantly against it yet they have not
read it. They do not understand it and have not listened to one
single word of debate. There is always give and take in
negotiations. There is always give and take in debate. A good
point can always be made. However, it is a lot easier to take
cheap shots, to make an outlandish statement and say this treaty
is apartheid. That is repugnant to the majority of Canadians.
After listening to a member of parliament who should be respected
by all Canadians use that word, how many Canadians would feel
their skin crawl or their hair stand up on the back of their
neck? I would suggest every single one.
This treaty deals with all of the pertinent issues which affect
first nations in Canada. It is a tribute to the Nisga'a chiefs
and their predecessors who worked long and hard on this treaty. I
think it is a tribute to the Parliament of Canada. Many members
of parliament were against this treaty and I do not have a
problem with that. I have a problem with the fact that it was
not debated. I have a problem with closure. I would have
continued debating it until Easter without a problem and if we
had to go longer than that, we would do so.
When we answer questions one at a time, and after reading the
treaty, a lot of substance is removed from that argument. A lot
of substance leaves the argument that people are mad and they can
drive wedges into society and they can take a wrecking ball to
public policy platforms.
On behalf of the Conservative Party, I am happy to support the
treaty. Our party will continue to support the treaty. I expect
that in 10 years we will look back and say that this was a great
treaty.
Mr. Darrel Stinson (Okanagan—Shuswap, Ref.): Madam
Speaker, I listened to the member's speech. I have one question
for the hon. member with regard to the treaty and land. What does
the member say to the Gitanyow with regard to their land claims
being lost over this treaty? What does he say to those people
now that we have taken their land away from them?
Mr. Gerald Keddy: Madam Speaker, with great respect to
the Gitanyow, I will say to them what I have said already.
Sections 33, 34 and 35 in the treaty allow for overlap. The
treaty allows for a negotiated settlement. It also allows for
the Nisga'a to be compensated by the Government of Canada and the
province of B.C. should they lose property.
1800
It is very clearly stated. The oval issue is recognized in the
NFA. It is 1.5 kilometres, a fair amount of property for
individuals. I respect both parties here and I hope that they
would sit down and negotiate an agreeable settlement between the
two first nations. With respect, I stated that very thing to the
Gitanyow chiefs who presented their case extremely well.
Hon. David Anderson (Minister of the Environment, Lib.):
Madam Speaker, with this legislation we have one of those
welcomed occasions when two worthy goals can be reached at the
same time; on the one hand, pragmatic economics to help the
economy of British Columbia, and on the other, the regaining of a
people's dignity. These two are bound together in this one piece
of legislation. We will vote on it in one vote.
Mr. Ken Epp: Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I
may be wrong but I am suspicious that the minister is beginning a
speech. I think he may not be aware that we are still in
questions and comments.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): We will qualify the
matter right away. Is the hon. minister asking a question or
commenting?
Hon. David Anderson: Madam Speaker, I was recognized by
you as starting my concluding speech for the last 10 minutes of
the debate.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): I am afraid that I
did call for questions and comments. There is still about eight
minutes left for questions and comments following the speech from
the hon. member for South Shore.
Mr. David Iftody (Parliamentary Secretary to Minister of
Indian Affairs and Northern Development, Lib.): Madam
Speaker, I thank the member for his work on this committee and
his travel with us to British Columbia. I wonder if those
watching the debate, when the cameras shift from one side to the
other, know which party the member belongs to. He is a
Progressive Conservative member and that party has properly
supported this piece of legislation throughout the debate. The
member has done an excellent job for his constituents and I
commend him on that.
I appreciate very much what he said, but I want him to go a
little bit deeper. He talked about the myths being proposed by
the Reform Party members and about some of the ridiculous and
foolish things that they have said and argued, notwithstanding
testimony by Canada's leading constitutional experts about the
fact that the charter does apply and that the constitution is not
abridged or broken in any way or offended even slightly by this
process.
I ask the member what the interests are of the Reform Party
members from British Columbia. Why are they pushing this? Why
are they hammering this deal? What is in it for them that they
would go to these great extremes to stand up against 80% of the
people voting in the House, and therefore Canada, to oppose this
deal? Why?
Mr. Gerald Keddy: Madam Speaker, I must admit that the
hon. member and I have had many good discussions about this piece
of legislation. When the Liberals say that we have done a good
thing, our spider sense has to tingle a little bit. We are on
different sides here.
With respect, it was obviously a treaty that we could all agree
on. The greatest thing about this particular piece of
legislation and the greatest mistruths that have been stated by
the Reform members was to compare the fear that Canadians have
that there will possibly be one group of Canadians that will have
more rights than another group. They threw that bone out, it did
not go anywhere and they tried it again. In my opinion, this
treaty does not do that.
It is the fear people have in eastern Canada when they look at a
very difficult situation going on with the Mi'kmaq over the 1760
treaty. They feel that somehow this will not be settled in an
amicable way and we will not be able to negotiate it. What this
treaty does is clearly lay out the rules for negotiation. It
protects the interest of Canadians, as the hon. member said. It
allows for taxation of first nations. It removes that particular
first nation from the Indian Act, which certainly all hon.
members would have to agree is a good thing. I do not think that
even the Reform members can say it is a bad thing to have the
Nisga'a nation no longer under the auspices of the Indian Act.
1805
The fear I have with misrepresentation is if we try to move the
issue over and say, “look what is going on in Nova Scotia”.
What is going on in Nova Scotia is because there is no treaty, an
aboriginal title has not been settled. We are depending on
something that went on in 1760 that is a page and a half long and
that is open to very wide interpretation. Let us settle these
issues. Let us negotiate real self-government for first nations
in Canada. Let us understand that all first nations want to be
real partners in the Canadian federation. Let us open that door
and allow them in. Unlike the Victoria legislature, let us open
the door and invite them in.
Mr. Mike Scott (Skeena, Ref.): Madam Speaker, there you
have it. Self-congratulations is the basis for public policy in
this country. The other party members all have a well worn spot
between their shoulder blades where they have been patting
themselves on the back.
The hon. member discounts out of hand the expert advice we
received. He is a member of the committee and he sat there and
listened to the advice from the likes of Professor Stephen Scott,
a professor of the law faculty at McGill University; Mel Smith,
former constitutional adviser to no less than three premiers in
British Columbia; Gordon Gibson, the former leader of the Liberal
Party in British Columbia; Gordon Campbell, the current leader of
the official opposition, the Liberal Party of British Columbia;
and Professor Tom Flanagan from the University of Alberta. They
are recognized experts in their fields who have said that this is
indeed a violation of Canada's constitution. It is the subject
of two lawsuits in British Columbia brought by the B.C.
opposition Liberal Party and by the Fishery Survival Coalition.
The member stands up and completely discounts this out of hand.
Along with the remarks that he has made about the Reform Party
and the aspersions he has cast on us, is he casting aspersions on
these people as well? Does he put them all in the same boat as
the Reform Party? Is he suggesting that these constitutional
legal experts are deliberately attempting to mislead Canadians by
fabricating myths?
Mr. Gerald Keddy: Madam Speaker, the answer is very
simple. There are two cases before the Supreme Court of Canada.
The supreme court will rule on those cases. I have no fear at
all about how that ruling will go.
I ask anyone who may be listening to this debate or anyone who
is remotely interested in it to check the record. There were
arguments for and against. Those arguments are on the record.
People can decide for themselves. I have a point of view. People
may disagree with it, which is fine, but I will defend what I
have said any day. If the hon. member wants to check the record
I challenge him to check it.
Mr. Derrek Konrad (Prince Albert, Ref.): Madam Speaker,
I have one quick comment. The biggest waste of money in the
House is the appropriations for research for the other opposition
parties.
An hon. member: Out of order.
Mr. Derrek Konrad: It is not out of order to make a fair
comment.
They only use the press releases by the government for their
research and think they have done a job for the Canadian public.
I could say a lot of things but I am really disappointed in the
opposition members of the House who just bow and scrape and, as
my hon. colleague said, pat themselves on the back and call it
public debate.
Mr. Gerald Keddy: Madam Speaker, I will be perfectly
honest. I never read any press releases by the government and
did not have to. I studied this issue, found out the information
on it, was prepared to defend it and have on several occasions,
and will continue to do that.
As far as the point he started to make about the Marshall
decision, the outcome of the Marshall decision is exactly the
outcome that will continue in this country as long as we do not
have negotiated treaties. A treaty that was passed in 1760 is
inappropriate for today. We need to sit down and deal with the
serious issues before us in a responsible way for the benefit of
all.
1810
Hon. David Anderson (Minister of the Environment, Lib.):
Madam Speaker, in the five minutes that remain, I do not have
enough time to complete the speech that I had outlined here which
indicated the great economic benefits that come from the
certainty of having the Nisga'a treaty in place in British
Columbia.
There are two major sources of economic uncertainty in British
Columbia. One is the unfortunate policies of the provincial NDP
government. The other is the fact that aboriginal title in so
many parts of the province is uncertain. This treaty is a major
step in the right direction in dealing with that second
uncertainty. I strongly welcome it on behalf of all those who
are interested in B.C.'s economic future.
The opportunity to speak is fast evaporating. However, I would
like to suggest that it has been known since the very beginning
by non-Nisga'a that this was an injustice done to the Nisga'a
people. Let me refer to my own family history.
My grandfather, born in 1880, was a small boy at the time of the
1887 arrival in Victoria of the Tsimsean and the Nisga'a people
who came to plead for the land. Later, when I was much his age,
he told me based on his experiences and his time in northern
British Columbia of that injustice. At that time, when I was a
small boy, he persuaded me—an easy job—that in fact there was
an injustice to right. I must say how proud I am after all this
time that I am here in the House with the privilege of being the
last speaker in this debate as the senior minister for British
Columbia, pointing out that we will now right that injustice done
all those years ago.
Many things have been said about this treaty in the heat of
debate which hon. members of the official opposition will not
only regret but will be deeply ashamed of in the years to come.
They know that if we do not settle this treaty now, which has
been discussed, debated and argued in meeting after meeting
throughout the province, in the legislature of British Columbia
in its longest ever debate, in this House for hour after hour,
then it is a case of going directly to the courts.
There is no opportunity for starting the negotiations again.
They hold that out as a hope that somehow negotiations will take
place and will result in the Nisga'a giving up some of the things
they have negotiated for and fairly won in this treaty process.
If we do not wish to go back to court and have these matters
determined by the courts alone but to have them determined
instead by fair discussion, debate and honest analysis of one
another's positions, as has taken place, then we had better
approve this treaty. That is the crux of the Nisga'a treaty that
is before us today.
[Translation]
The treaty is fair and practical. It will contribute to peace
and prosperity in British Columbia. It will facilitate long
awaited reconciliation that has been sought for over a century.
[English]
As the justices in the Delgamuukw decision said, we are all here
to stay so we—
Mr. Richard M. Harris: Madam Speaker, I rise on a point
of order. I would like to ask for unanimous consent to ask the
minister if he knows that over 90% of his own constituents oppose
the Nisga'a treaty.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): That is not a point
of order.
Hon. David Anderson: Madam Speaker, that is clearly
debate. It is clearly out of order and it is clearly typical of
the way the Reform Party has approached this debate day after
day, week after week, month after month. Every opportunity to
divert attention from the actual facts of the treaty Reform
members have jumped on because they know that faced with a clear
examination of this treaty the people of British Columbia know it
is in their best interests. We recognize that. The Reform Party
does not. It is attempting to conceal this fact and therefore
Reform members come up with phoney points of order and phoney—
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): Order, please. It being
6.15 p.m., pursuant to order made on Monday, December 9, 1999, it is
my duty to interrupt the proceedings and put forthwith every
question necessary to dispose of the third reading stage of the
bill now before the House.
1815
The question is on the motion. Is it the pleasure of the House
to adopt the motion?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): All those in favour
of the motion will please say yea.
Some hon. members: Yea.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): All those opposed
will please say nay.
Some hon. members: Nay.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): In my opinion the
yeas have it.
And more than five members having risen:
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): Call in the members.
1845
(The House divided on the motion, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alarie
| Alcock
| Anderson
|
Assad
| Assadourian
| Asselin
| Augustine
|
Axworthy
| Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Baker
| Bakopanos
|
Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
| Bélanger
|
Bellehumeur
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bergeron
|
Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bertrand
| Bevilacqua
|
Bigras
| Blaikie
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
|
Bonwick
| Borotsik
| Boudria
| Bradshaw
|
Brien
| Brison
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Canuel
| Caplan
| Cardin
| Carroll
|
Casey
| Catterall
| Cauchon
| Chamberlain
|
Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Copps
|
Cotler
| Crête
| Cullen
| Dalphond - Guiral
|
Davies
| de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
|
DeVillers
| Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
|
Dockrill
| Doyle
| Dromisky
| Drouin
|
Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Duhamel
| Dumas
|
Earle
| Easter
| Eggleton
| Finlay
|
Folco
| Fontana
| Fournier
| Gagliano
|
Gagnon
| Gallaway
| Gauthier
| Girard - Bujold
|
Godfrey
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goodale
|
Graham
| Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Gruending
|
Guarnieri
| Guay
| Guimond
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Harvey
| Hubbard
| Ianno
|
Iftody
| Jackson
| Jennings
| Jones
|
Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
| Keddy
(South Shore)
| Keyes
|
Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
| Kraft Sloan
|
Lalonde
| Lastewka
| Laurin
| Lebel
|
Lee
| Leung
| Lill
| Limoges
|
Lincoln
| Longfield
| Loubier
| MacAulay
|
MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
|
Mancini
| Manley
| Marceau
| Marleau
|
Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McDonough
| McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
|
McTeague
| McWhinney
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
| Minna
|
Mitchell
| Muise
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nystrom
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Perron
| Peterson
|
Pettigrew
| Phinney
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Pillitteri
|
Plamondon
| Power
| Pratt
| Proctor
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Riis
| Robillard
|
Robinson
| Rocheleau
| Rock
| Saada
|
Sauvageau
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Solomon
| Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Hilaire
|
St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
| Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Stoffer
|
Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
|
Torsney
| Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Ur
|
Valeri
| Vanclief
| Venne
| Volpe
|
Wappel
| Wasylycia - Leis
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 217
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Anders
| Bailey
| Benoit
|
Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Cadman
| Casson
| Chatters
|
Cummins
| Duncan
| Elley
| Epp
|
Gilmour
| Goldring
| Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
|
Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
| Hill
(Macleod)
|
Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
| Jaffer
| Johnston
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lowther
| Lunn
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Mayfield
| McNally
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Nunziata
|
Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
| Reynolds
|
Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
| Solberg
| Stinson
|
Strahl
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
| White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 48
|
PAIRED
Members
The Speaker: I declare the motion carried.
(Bill read the third time and passed)
[Editor's Note: Members sang the national anthem]
* * *
1850
POINTS OF ORDER
APPROPRIATION BILL—SPEAKER'S RULING
The Speaker: Before proceeding to the next vote on
supply I want to make a ruling on a point of order that was
raised by the hon. member for St. Albert.
The hon. member raises about the same point that he raised on
the consideration of the main estimates last June. He is
concerned that the supplementary estimates under consideration
today authorize expenditure for the next fiscal year, namely
2000-01.
As I indicated in my ruling on this point on June 8, 1999, at
page 16065 of Hansard, the “fiscal year” runs from April
to March and a “yearly appropriation” bill must be based on the
estimates for the fiscal year to which it relates and must be
adopted by parliament to cover the government's expenses for that
fiscal year.
I thank the hon. member for bringing up the point earlier in the
day so it would give me a chance to look it over. I have looked
carefully at the supply bill which is now before the House and I
am satisfied that indeed it is based on the supplementary
estimates for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000. As in the
previous appropriation bill, this appropriation bill provides the
same short title “Appropriation Act No. 3, 1999-2000”.
The so-called multi-year appropriation authority provided in
schedule 2 of the bill is based on legislation approved by
parliament in 1998, by which the Parks Canada Agency and the
Canada Customs and Revenue Agency are granted authority to carry
over to the end of the 2000-01 fiscal year any unexpended balance
of money remaining at the end of the fiscal year 1999-2000.
As was the case last June so also it is the case now. This
money is being appropriated for the 1999-2000 fiscal year. It
might all be spent in this fiscal year and, if so, it must be
authorized by an appropriation for this year. We are talking
here about a yearly appropriation bill for the fiscal year
1999-2000.
The hon. member refers to subclause 6(2) of the supply bill now
before the House and compares it against the language of
carryover that I used last June with reference to the enabling
legislation relating to Parks Canada. In my view subclause 6(2)
serves the same purpose as did subclause 6(2) in Bill C-86 on
June 8, 1999, namely, to reflect the authorization provided in
the enabling legislation and a process whereby multi-year
spending is to be applied to the applicable appropriations act in
sequence.
1855
Accordingly what is included in schedule 2 is already authorized
by parliament and is referred to in clause 2 for information
purposes only. My ruling is therefore that the supply bill is
properly before the House.
[Translation]
I would like to thank the honourable member for his interest in
the business of supply. I encourage him to keep on being
vigilant and I thank him.
* * *
[English]
SUPPLY
SUPPLEMENTARY ESTIMATES (A), 1999-2000
The House resumed from December 10 consideration of the business
of supply.
The Speaker: The House will now proceed to the taking of
the deferred division on opposed vote 1, and pursuant to the
order made on Thursday, December 7, 1999, the result of that
division will be applied to all the remaining motions necessary
to dispose of the business of supply.
Mr. John Nunziata: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a question of
privilege. I would like to address the motion that was passed by
the House on December 7, which in the result would apply a series
of votes, some 120 votes, with regard to supplementary estimates.
I submit that would in effect breach the privileges of
independent members of parliament.
The House leaders of the various political parties came together
and decided that with regard to their respective political
parties the votes could be applied. This motion presumes to
anticipate how independent members of parliament would vote on
each and every motion before the House.
For that reason I submit that it breaches the privileges,
because how could the House know in advance how I would vote on
the 120 motions before the House?
If I might conclude, technically it would be my submission that
unanimous consent would be required in order to avoid a roll call
vote on each of the votes, and if it is the will of the House in
effect to apply votes then again unanimous consent would be
required.
However, having said that, and in the spirit of Christmas, I am
prepared to give my unanimous consent so that all votes can be
applied.
The Speaker: The question is on Motion No. 1.
1905
(The House divided on Motion No. 1, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
The Speaker: I declare Motion No. 1 carried.
Pursuant to order made on Tuesday, December 7, 1999, the
remaining motions relating to concurrence in Supplementary
Estimates (A), the motion for first reading for the supply bill
and the motion for second reading and reference to a committee of
the whole are carried by the same division. Accordingly, the
Supplementary Estimates (A) are concurred in, the bill is read a
first time, read a second time and referred to committee of the
whole.
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—AGRICULTURE AND AGRI-FOOD
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $468,000,
under AGRICULTURE AND AGRI-FOOD—Capital expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 2, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—AGRICULTURE AND AGRI-FOOD
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of $40,076,870,
under AGRICULTURE AND AGRI-FOOD—Grants and contributions, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 3, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 15A—AGRICULTURE AND AGRI-FOOD
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 15a in the amount of $137,980, under AGRICULTURE AND
AGRI-FOOD—Canadian Dairy Commission—Program expenditures, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 4, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 20A—AGRICULTURE AND AGRI-FOOD
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 20a in the amount of $27,072,272, under AGRICULTURE
AND AGRI-FOOD—Canadian Food Inspection Agency—Operating
expenditures and contributions, in the Supplementary Estimates
(A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 5, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 25A—AGRICULTURE AND AGRI-FOOD
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 25a in the amount of $6,040,629, under AGRICULTURE AND
AGRI-FOOD—Canadian Food Inspection Agency—Capital expenditures,
in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending
March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 6, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—CANADA CUSTOMS AND REVENUE AGENCY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $219,056,271,
under CANADA CUSTOMS AND REVENUE AGENCY—Operating expenditures,
in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending
March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 7, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $23,157,750,
under CANADIAN HERITAGE—Operating expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 8, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $116,459,253,
under CANADIAN HERITAGE—Grants and contributions, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 9, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 50A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 50a in the amount of $494,000,
under CANADIAN HERITAGE—Canadian Museum of Nature—Operating
and capital expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for
the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 10, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 60A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 60a in the amount of $1,432,864,
under CANADIAN HERITAGE—National Archives of Canada—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 11, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 65A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 65a in the amount of $1,057,000,
under CANADIAN HERITAGE—National Arts Centre Corporation, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 12, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 70A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 70a in the amount of $1,932,000, under CANADIAN
HERITAGE—National Battlefields Commission—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 13, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 75A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 75a in the amount of $500,000,
under CANADIAN HERITAGE—National Capital Commission—Operating
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 14, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 80A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 80a in the amount of
$45,350,000, under CANADIAN HERITAGE—National Capital
Commission—Capital expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates
(A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 15, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 90A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 90a in the amount of $2,430,490,
under CANADIAN HERITAGE—National Film Board—Revolving Fund,
in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending
March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 16, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 110A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 110a in the amount of $400,000,
under CANADIAN HERITAGE—National Museum of Science and
Technology—Operating and capital expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 17, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 115A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 115a in the amount of $15,677,250, under CANADIAN
HERITAGE—Parks Canada Agency—Program expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 18, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 125A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 125a in the amount of
$4,497,500, under CANADIAN HERITAGE—Public Service Commission
of Canada—Program expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates
(A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 19, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 130A—CANADIAN HERITAGE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 130a in the amount of $732,950,
under CANADIAN HERITAGE—Status of Women—Office of the Co-
ordinator—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 20, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $91,634,800,
under CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION—Operating expenditures, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 21, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of
$100,617,900, under CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION—Grants and
contributions, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 22, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—ENVIRONMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $13,951,554,
under ENVIRONMENT—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 23, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—ENVIRONMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $5,266,124,
under ENVIRONMENT—Capital expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 24, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—ENVIRONMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of
$10,590,069, under ENVIRONMENT—Grants and contributions, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 25, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 15A—ENVIRONMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 15a in the amount of $384,550, under
ENVIRONMENT—Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 26, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—FINANCE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $3,821,100,
under FINANCE—Program expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 27, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 6A—FINANCE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 6a in the amount of $600,000
under FINANCE—Economic, Social and Financial Policies, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 28, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE NO. 25A—FINANCE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 25a in the amount of $2,076,257,
under FINANCE—Auditor General—Program expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 29, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—FISHERIES AND OCEANS
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $99,167,647,
under FISHERIES AND OCEANS—Operating expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 30, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—FISHERIES AND OCEANS
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $7,201,000,
under FISHERIES AND OCEANS—Capital expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 31, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—FISHERIES AND OCEANS
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of
$50,795,773, under FISHERIES AND OCEANS—Grants and
contributions, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 32, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $80,206,553,
under FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE—Operating
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 33, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $43,875,400,
under FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE—Capital
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 34, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of $111,983,945, under FOREIGN
AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE—Grants and contributions, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 35, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 11A—FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 11a in the amount of $45,000,000
under FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE—Grants and
contributions, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 36, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 20A—FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 20a in the amount of $5,739,152,
under FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE—Canadian
International Development Agency—Operating expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 37, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 25A—FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 25a in the amount of $3,000,000,
under FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE—Canadian
International Development Agency—Capital expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 38, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 30A—FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 30a in the amount of $89,482,266, under FOREIGN
AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE—Canadian International
Development Agency—Grants and Contributions, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 39, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 41A—FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 41a in the amount of $1, under
FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE—Export Development
Corporation, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 40, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENT IN VOTE 45A—FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 45a in the amount of $4,307,000,
under FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE—International
Development Research Centre, in the Supplementary Estimates (A)
for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 41, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 50A—FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 50a in the amount of $354,000,
under FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE—International
Joint Commission—Program expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 42, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—GOVERNOR GENERAL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $1,774,105,
under GOVERNOR GENERAL—Program expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 43, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—HEALTH
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $59,940,557,
under HEALTH—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 44, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—HEALTH
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $7,285,972,
under HEALTH—Grants and contributions, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 45, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—HEALTH
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of $682,526, under HEALTH—Hazardous
Materials Information Review Commission—Program expenditures, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 46, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 15A—HEALTH
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 15a in the amount of $1,956,355,
under HEALTH—Medical Research Council of Canada—Operating
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 47, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 20A—HEALTH
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 20a in the amount of $26,100,000, under
HEALTH—Medical Research Council of Canada—Grants, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 48, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 25A—HEALTH
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 25a in the amount of $533,769,
under HEALTH—Patented Medicine Prices Review Board—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 49, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $41,158,557,
under HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT—Corporate Services—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 50, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $61,197,045,
under HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT—Human Resources Investment
and Insurance—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 51, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of
$207,418,952, under HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT—Human Resources
Investment and Insurance—Grants and contributions, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 52, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 15A—HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 15a in the amount of $1,690,100,
under HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT—Labour—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 53, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 20A—HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 20a in the amount of $13,664,716, under HUMAN
RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT—Income Security—Program expenditures, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 54, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 25A—HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 25a in the amount of $309,152,
under HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT—Canada Industrial Relations
Board—Program expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A)
for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 55, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 35A—HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 35a in the amount of $569,911,
under HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT—Canadian Centre for
Occupational Health and Safety—Program expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 56, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN
DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $3,140,700,
under INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN DEVELOPMENT—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 57, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN
DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $17,645,508,
under INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN DEVELOPMENT—Indian and Inuit
Affairs—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates
(A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 58, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 6A—INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN
DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 6a in the amount of $1, under
INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN DEVELOPMENT—Indian and Inuit
Affairs—Loans, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the
fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 59, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
[Translation]
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN
DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of $1,253,000,
under INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN DEVELOPMENT—Indian and Inuit
Affairs Program—Capital expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 60, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 15A—INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN
DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 15a in the amount of $58,546,352, under INDIAN AFFAIRS
AND NORTHERN DEVELOPMENT—Indian and Inuit Affairs—Grants and
contributions, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 61, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 35A—INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN
DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 35a in the amount of $36,675,350, under INDIAN AFFAIRS
AND NORTHERN DEVELOPMENT—Northern Affairs—Operating
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 62, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 50A—INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN
DEVELOPMENT
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 50a in the amount of $42,000,
under INDIAN AFFAIRS AND NORTHERN DEVELOPMENT—Canadian Polar
Commission—Program expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates
(A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 63, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $94,894,960,
under INDUSTRY—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 64, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $49,708,000,
under INDUSTRY—Grants and contributions, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 65, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 20A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 20a in the amount of $6,639,297,
under INDUSTRY—Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency—Operating
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 66, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 25A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 25a in the amount of
$10,310,100, under INDUSTRY—Atlantic Canada Opportunities
Agency—Grants and contributions, in the Supplementary Estimates
(A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 67, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 30A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 30a in the amount of
$37,110,406, under INDUSTRY—Canadian Space Agency—Operating
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 68, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 40A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 40a in the amount of $4,625,000,
under INDUSTRY—Canadian Space Agency—Grants and
contributions, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 69, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 50A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 50a in the amount of $811,000,
under INDUSTRY—Copyright Board—Program expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 70, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 55A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 55a in the amount of $1,313,646,
under INDUSTRY—Economic Development Agency of Canada for the
Region of Quebec—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 71, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 70A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 70a in the amount of $13,926,810, under
INDUSTRY—National Research Council of Canada—Operating
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 72, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 75A—JUSTICE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 75a in the amount of $1 under
INDUSTRY—National Research Council of Canada—Capital
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 73, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 85A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 85a in the amount of $1,923,980,
under INDUSTRY—Natural Sciences and Engineering Research
Council—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates
(A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 74, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 90A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 90a in the amount of
$37,941,0 76, under INDUSTRY—Natural Sciences and Engineering
Research Council—Grants, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for
the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 75, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 95A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 95a in the amount of $1,485,921, under
INDUSTRY—Social Sciences and Humanities Research
Council—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates
(A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 76, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 100A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 100a in the amount of
$15,125,000, under INDUSTRY—Social Sciences and Humanities
Research Council—Grants, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for
the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 77, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 110A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 110a in the amount of
$33,545,757, under INDUSTRY—Statistics Canada—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 78, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 115A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 115a in the amount of $7,709,180, under
INDUSTRY—Western Economic Diversification—Operating
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 79, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 120A—INDUSTRY
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 120a in the amount of $33,501,900, under
INDUSTRY—Western Economic Diversification—Grants and
contributions, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 80, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—JUSTICE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $94,698,913,
under JUSTICE—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 81, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—JUSTICE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $27,162,000,
under JUSTICE—Grants and contributions, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 82, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—JUSTICE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of $1,775,100,
under JUSTICE—Canadian Human Rights Commission—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 83, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 15A—JUSTICE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 15a in the amount of $733,233,
under JUSTICE—Human Rights Tribunal Panel—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 84, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 30A—JUSTICE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 30a in the amount of $1,270,100,
under JUSTICE—Federal Court of Canada—Program expenditures,
in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending
March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 85, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 40A—JUSTICE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 40a in the amount of $2,792,070,
under JUSTICE—Office of the Information and Privacy
Commissioners of Canada—Program expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 86, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 45A—JUSTICE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 45a in the amount of $774,650,
under JUSTICE—Supreme Court of Canada—Program expenditures,
in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending
March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 87, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 50A—JUSTICE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 50a in the amount of $235,175,
under JUSTICE—Tax Court of Canada—Program expenditures, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 88, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—NATIONAL DEFENCE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of
$758,372,230, under NATIONAL DEFENCE—Operating expenditures, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 89, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—NATIONAL DEFENCE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $68,442,771,
under NATIONAL DEFENCE—Capital expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 90, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—NATIONAL DEFENCE
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of $1 under
NATIONAL DEFENCE—Grants and contributions, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 91, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—NATURAL RESOURCES
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $38,809,393,
under NATURAL RESOURCES—Operating expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 92, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—NATURAL RESOURCES
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $25,170,000,
under NATURAL RESOURCES—Grants and contributions, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 93, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 15A—NATURAL RESOURCES
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 15a in the amount of $4,147,133,
under NATURAL RESOURCES—Atomic Energy Control Board—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 94, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 20A—NATURAL RESOURCES
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 20a in the amount of
$19,000,000, under NATURAL RESOURCES—Atomic Energy of Canada
Limited—Operating and capital expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 95, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 22A—NATURAL RESOURCES
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 22a in the amount of
$11,000,000, under NATURAL RESOURCES—Atomic Energy of Canada
Limited—Operating and capital expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 96, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 25A—NATURAL RESOURCES
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 25a in the amount of $1,217,150,
under NATURAL RESOURCES—National Energy Board—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 97, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—PRIVY COUNCIL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $6,098,824,
under PRIVY COUNCIL—Program expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 98, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—PRIVY COUNCIL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $932,565, under PRIVY
COUNCIL—Canadian Centre for Management Development—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 99, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—PRIVY COUNCIL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of $478,049, under PRIVY
COUNCIL—Canadian Centre for Management Development—Canadian
Intergovernmental Conference Secretariat—Program expenditures,
in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending
March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 100, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 15A—PRIVY COUNCIL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 15a in the amount of
$15,371,850, under PRIVY COUNCIL—Canadian Transportation
Accident Investigastion and Safety Board—Program expenditures,
in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending
March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 101, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 25A—PRIVY COUNCIL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 25a in the amount of $445,600, under PRIVY
COUNCIL—Commissioner of Official Languages—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 102, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 30A—PRIVY COUNCIL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 30a in the amount of $1 under
PRIVY COUNCIL—Millennium Bureau of Canada—Operating
Expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 103, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 55A—PRIVY COUNCIL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 55a in the amount of $385,750,
under PRIVY COUNCIL—The Leadership Network—Program
expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 104, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—PUBLIC WORKS AND GOVERNMENT SERVICES
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $123,138,676, under PUBLIC WORKS
AND GOVERNMENT SERVICES CANADA—Operating expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 105, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—PUBLIC WORKS AND GOVERNMENT SERVICES
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
Vote 10a in the amount of $16,570,000, under PUBLIC WORKS
AND GOVERNMENT SERVICES CANADA—Old Port of Montreal Corporation
Inc. in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year
ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 106, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—SOLICITOR GENERAL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $2,917,278,
under SOLICITOR GENERAL—Operating expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 107, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—SOLICITOR GENERAL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of
$4,248,143, under SOLICITOR GENERAL—Canadian Security
Intelligence Service—Program expenditures, in the Supplementary
Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be
concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 108, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 15A—SOLICITOR GENERAL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 15a in the amount of $42,963,667, under SOLICITOR
GENERAL—Correctional Service—Operating expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 109, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 25A—SOLICITOR GENERAL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 25a in the amount of $1,073,637, under SOLICITOR
GENERAL—National Parole Board—Program expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 110, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 35A—SOLICITOR GENERAL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 35a in the amount of
$52,545,571, under SOLICITOR GENERAL—Royal Canadian Mounted
Police—Operating expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates
(A) for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 111, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 40A—SOLICITOR GENERAL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 40a in the amount of
$4,734,000, under SOLICITOR GENERAL—Royal Canadian Mounted
Police—Capital expenditures, in the Supplementary Estimates (A)
for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 112, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 50A—SOLICITOR GENERAL
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 50a in the amount of
$3,163,512, under SOLICITOR GENERAL—Royal Canadian Mounted
Police Public Complaints Commission—Program expenditures, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 113, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—TREASURY BOARD
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of
$22,224,700, under TREASURY BOARD—Operating expenditures, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 114, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—TREASURY BOARD
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of
$4,082,500, under TREASURY BOARD—Government-wide initiatives,
in the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending
March 31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 115, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 15A—TREASURY BOARD
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 15a in the amount of
$199,429,230, under TREASURY BOARD—Collective Agreements, in
the Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 116, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 1A—VETERANS AFFAIRS
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 1a in the amount of $8,662,302,
under VETERANS AFFAIRS—Operating expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 117, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 5A—VETERANS AFFAIRS
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 5a in the amount of $3,500,000,
under VETERANS AFFAIRS—Grants and contributions, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 118, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
CONCURRENCE IN VOTE 10A—VETERANS AFFAIRS
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Vote 10a in the amount of $785,928,
under VETERANS AFFAIRS—Program expenditures, in the
Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2000, be concurred in.
(The House divided on Motion No. 119, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
[English]
Hon. Lucienne Robillard (President of the Treasury Board and
Minister responsible for Infrastructure, Lib.) moved:
That Supplementary Estimates (A) for the fiscal year ending March
31, 2000, except any vote disposed of earlier today, be concurred
in.
(The House divided on the motion, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
Hon. Lucienne Robillard moved that Bill C-21, an act for
granting Her Majesty certain sums of money for the Public Service
of Canada for the financial year ending March 31, 2000, be read
the first time.
(Motion deemed adopted and bill read the first time)
Hon. Lucienne Robillard moved that the bill be read the
second time and referred to committee of the whole.
(The House divided on the motion, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
(Bill read the second time and the House went into committee
thereon, Mr. Milliken in the chair)
The Chairman: Pursuant to order made on Tuesday, December
7, 1999, clauses 1 to 7, schedules 1 and 2, the preamble, the
title, the bill and the motion that I rise and report are carried
by the same division taken earlier this day on Motion No. 1.
Mr. John Williams: Mr. Chairman,
could the President of the Treasury Board please confirm that
this bill is in the usual form?
Hon. Lucienne Robillard: Mr. Chairman,
the form of this bill is the same as that passed in the previous
supply period, including a separate schedule for those agencies
with multi-year lapsing appropriations.
(Clauses 1 to 7 agreed to)
(Schedules 1 and 2 agreed to)
(Preamble agreed to)
(Title agreed to)
(Bill reported)
Hon. Lucienne Robillard moved that the bill be concurred
in.
(The House divided on the motion, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
Hon. Lucienne Robillard moved that the bill be read the
third time and passed.
(The House divided on the motion, which was agreed to on the
following division:)
YEAS
Members
Adams
| Alcock
| Anderson
| Assad
|
Assadourian
| Augustine
| Axworthy
| Baker
|
Bakopanos
| Barnes
| Beaumier
| Bélair
|
Bélanger
| Bellemare
| Bennett
| Bertrand
|
Bevilacqua
| Blondin - Andrew
| Bonin
| Bonwick
|
Boudria
| Bradshaw
| Brown
| Bryden
|
Bulte
| Caccia
| Calder
| Cannis
|
Caplan
| Carroll
| Catterall
| Cauchon
|
Chamberlain
| Chan
| Charbonneau
| Chrétien
(Saint - Maurice)
|
Clouthier
| Coderre
| Collenette
| Comuzzi
|
Copps
| Cotler
| Cullen
| DeVillers
|
Dhaliwal
| Dion
| Discepola
| Dromisky
|
Drouin
| Duhamel
| Easter
| Eggleton
|
Finlay
| Folco
| Fontana
| Gagliano
|
Gallaway
| Godfrey
| Goodale
| Graham
|
Gray
(Windsor West)
| Grose
| Guarnieri
| Harb
|
Harvard
| Hubbard
| Ianno
| Iftody
|
Jackson
| Jennings
| Jordan
| Karetak - Lindell
|
Keyes
| Kilger
(Stormont – Dundas – Charlottenburgh)
| Kilgour
(Edmonton Southeast)
| Knutson
|
Kraft Sloan
| Lastewka
| Lee
| Leung
|
Limoges
| Lincoln
| Longfield
| MacAulay
|
Mahoney
| Malhi
| Maloney
| Manley
|
Marleau
| Martin
(LaSalle – Émard)
| Matthews
| McCormick
|
McGuire
| McKay
(Scarborough East)
| McLellan
(Edmonton West)
| McTeague
|
McWhinney
| Mifflin
| Milliken
| Mills
(Broadview – Greenwood)
|
Minna
| Mitchell
| Murray
| Myers
|
Nault
| Normand
| Nunziata
| O'Brien
(Labrador)
|
O'Brien
(London – Fanshawe)
| O'Reilly
| Pagtakhan
| Paradis
|
Parrish
| Patry
| Peterson
| Pettigrew
|
Phinney
| Pickard
(Chatham – Kent Essex)
| Pillitteri
| Pratt
|
Proud
| Proulx
| Provenzano
| Redman
|
Reed
| Richardson
| Robillard
| Rock
|
Saada
| Scott
(Fredericton)
| Serré
| Sgro
|
Speller
| St. Denis
| St - Julien
| Stewart
(Brant)
|
Stewart
(Northumberland)
| Szabo
| Telegdi
| Thibeault
|
Torsney
| Ur
| Valeri
| Vanclief
|
Volpe
| Wappel
| Whelan
| Wilfert
|
Wood – 149
|
NAYS
Members
Abbott
| Alarie
| Anders
| Asselin
|
Bachand
(Saint - Jean)
| Bailey
| Bellehumeur
| Benoit
|
Bergeron
| Bernier
(Bonaventure – Gaspé – Îles - de - la - Madeleine – Pabok)
| Bernier
(Tobique – Mactaquac)
| Bigras
|
Blaikie
| Borotsik
| Breitkreuz
(Yorkton – Melville)
| Brien
|
Brison
| Cadman
| Canuel
| Cardin
|
Casey
| Casson
| Chatters
| Chrétien
(Frontenac – Mégantic)
|
Crête
| Cummins
| Dalphond - Guiral
| Davies
|
de Savoye
| Debien
| Desrochers
| Dockrill
|
Doyle
| Dubé
(Lévis - et - Chutes - de - la - Chaudière)
| Duceppe
| Dumas
|
Duncan
| Earle
| Elley
| Epp
|
Fournier
| Gagnon
| Gauthier
| Gilmour
|
Girard - Bujold
| Godin
(Acadie – Bathurst)
| Godin
(Châteauguay)
| Goldring
|
Grewal
| Grey
(Edmonton North)
| Gruending
| Guay
|
Guimond
| Hanger
| Harris
| Hart
|
Harvey
| Hill
(Macleod)
| Hill
(Prince George – Peace River)
| Hilstrom
|
Jaffer
| Johnston
| Jones
| Keddy
(South Shore)
|
Kenney
(Calgary Southeast)
| Konrad
| Lalonde
| Laurin
|
Lebel
| Lill
| Loubier
| Lowther
|
Lunn
| MacKay
(Pictou – Antigonish – Guysborough)
| Mancini
| Marceau
|
Mark
| Martin
(Esquimalt – Juan de Fuca)
| Martin
(Winnipeg Centre)
| Mayfield
|
McDonough
| McNally
| Ménard
| Mercier
|
Meredith
| Mills
(Red Deer)
| Morrison
| Muise
|
Nystrom
| Obhrai
| Pankiw
| Penson
|
Perron
| Picard
(Drummond)
| Plamondon
| Power
|
Proctor
| Reynolds
| Riis
| Robinson
|
Rocheleau
| Sauvageau
| Schmidt
| Scott
(Skeena)
|
Solberg
| Solomon
| St - Hilaire
| Stinson
|
Stoffer
| Strahl
| Thompson
(New Brunswick Southwest)
| Thompson
(Wild Rose)
|
Tremblay
(Lac - Saint - Jean)
| Turp
| Venne
| Wasylycia - Leis
|
White
(Langley – Abbotsford)
| Williams – 118
|
PAIRED
Members
The Speaker: Pursuant to order made on Tuesday, December
7, 1999, the supply bill is concurred in at report stage, read
the third time and passed by the same division taken earlier this
day on Motion No. 1. Accordingly, the bill is concurred in at
report stage, read a third time and passed.
(Bill read the third time and passed)
ADJOURNMENT PROCEEDINGS
1910
[English]
A motion to adjourn the House under Standing Order 38 deemed to
have been moved.
FISHERIES
Mr. Peter Stoffer (Sackville—Musquodoboit Valley—Eastern
Shore, NDP): Madam Speaker, for over two and a half years my
party and I have been arguing with the Government of Canada that
the Department of Fisheries and Oceans is one of the most out of
control departments in the entire country. Here are a few
examples of where that department is completely out of control.
Recently the amalgamation of the coast guard resulted in one of
the coast guard vessels going into Saint John harbour to hold a
gala party for correctional officers. Also, since 1988 $4.2
billion has been spent restructuring the east coast fishery to no
avail.
When the Marshall decision came down, it was quite obvious that
DFO did not have a plan. We said from the beginning when the
decision came down that DFO and the Government of Canada should
have been prepared. Now we know from internal documents acquired
through access to information by reporter Kevin Carmichael that
the government had a plan but it did not want to present it to
anyone because it did not want to affect, fear or shame anyone in
its decision.
It is quite obvious that the government abrogated its
responsibility and abrogated its duty to the people of Canada and
the aboriginal people of Atlantic Canada.
The current Minister of Fisheries and Oceans has constantly
stated in the House that it is better to negotiate than it is to
litigate. After the Sparrow decision, the Delgamuukw decision
and now the Marshall decision, it seems the only recourse that
aboriginal people have is constantly to go to the courts to meet
their end means.
If the government truly believed in the fact that it is better
to negotiate than to litigate, then I tell the government right
now that it had better deal with the issue of non-status
aboriginal people when it comes to status aboriginal people,
especially in my home province of Nova Scotia. The non-status
aboriginals believe quite firmly that the Marshall decision
applies to them. There is legal opinion that says it may very
well apply to them as well.
As well, the government is focusing on just the inshore aspects
of the Marshall decision. We put it quite clearly to the
government, and we wish it would stand up in the House and speak
to the fact that the Marshall decision should apply to the
inshore, the midshore and the offshore sectors. It should not be
just one sector of the fishing community that bears the brunt of
the decision. It should be a more co-operative approach toward
all the fishing regimes so that the aboriginal people can feel
like full partners in this industry with fisheries and oceans.
It was no surprise when the former Minister of Fisheries and
Oceans left the department fairly quickly. I have said it before
and I will say it again that if DFO was on the stock exchange,
one could almost accuse the former Minister of Fisheries and
Oceans of insider trading because he seemed to leave in such a
hurry. We know very well that the former minister, who is now
the Minister of the Environment, was fully aware of how the
Marshall decision may have come about for the people of Nova
Scotia and especially the aboriginal communities of Atlantic
Canada.
Because the government was not showing leadership or foresight
in the decision making process, there were incidents in West
Nova. There were incidents down in Miramichi at Burnt Church.
People threatened one another. Boats were burned. It was a
really ugly scene in the maritime provinces.
It all could have been avoided had the government only shown
some leadership. We have asked time and time again for the
government, especially the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, to
show leadership when it comes to fishing concerns in Atlantic
Canada, especially when it comes to the integration of aboriginal
and non-aboriginal people and a common property resource.
1915
We have many ideas on this side of the House on how it should
go. We only wish that the government would listen to what we are
saying so that all people in Atlantic Canada could share in a
common property resource.
Mr. Lawrence D. O'Brien (Parliamentary Secretary to Minister
of Fisheries and Oceans, Lib.): Madam Speaker, I am pleased
to have the opportunity to speak about the approach the Minister
of Fisheries and Oceans has taken to address the Marshall
decision.
Much has been made by the opposition about the fact that the
Minister of Fisheries and Oceans has not been on the east coast
personally dealing with first nations on commercial access.
The Minister of Fisheries and Oceans appointed Mr. MacKenzie and
Mr. Thériault as chief federal representative and assistant
federal representative respectively, not because he wanted to
send a B team to the Atlantic, as the opposition has
suggested, but because these gentlemen bring to the task
outstanding qualifications that are so important to the
negotiation process.
Mr. MacKenzie has a background in negotiations with aboriginal
groups, having been involved in land claims negotiations in my
riding of Labrador as the chief federal negotiator for the
Labrador Inuit land claims process. He also has extensive
experience in holding consultations with diverse groups
throughout Atlantic Canada and so is familiar with the issues
these stakeholders are faced with.
Mr. Thériault has been involved with the Atlantic commercial
fishery in a variety of capacities for the past 25 years. He has
been a spokesperson, an adviser and a consultant in a variety of
fora related to fisheries issues.
It is for these reasons that the Minister of Fisheries and
Oceans determined that they could provide a very important
function in negotiating arrangements for the next fishing season
that will accommodate the Marshall decision while taking into
account the concerns and issues of the existing commercial
fishing sector.
Mr. MacKenzie and Mr. Thériault are now engaged in the process
of discussing with aboriginal leaders—
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Thibeault): I am sorry but I must
interrupt the hon. parliamentary secretary. The motion to
adjourn the House is now deemed to have been adopted.
Accordingly, the House stands adjourned until tomorrow
at 10 a.m., pursuant to Standing Order 24(1).
(The House adjourned at 7.17 p.m.)