Story Tools: E-MAIL | PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

Charkaoui argues no 'reasonable' grounds for arrest

Last Updated: Monday, February 21, 2005 | 8:19 PM ET

Three days after being freed on bail following a 21-month imprisonment, Adil Charkaoui returned to court in Montreal on Monday to argue he should never have been detained in the first place.

Lawyers for the alleged al-Qaeda sleeper agent are challenging whether the ministerial security certificate that led to his May 2003 arrest was issued on the basis of "reasonable" grounds.

The judge hearing the case does not have to determine the truth of the government's allegations that Charkaoui, 31, is an al-Qaeda agent who could carry out an attack at any time.

On Monday morning, the court heard from a Canadian Security Intelligence Service agent identified only as Jean-Paul, to protect his identity.

He has not investigated Charkaoui in detail, but was called as a terrorism expert.

At his bail hearing last week, Charkaoui said he did not necessarily believe that al-Qaeda and its leader Osama bin Laden – whom he called "some guy living in a cave" – were responsible for the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks against the United States.

The CSIS agent testified about the strong evidence that al-Qaeda did indeed plot and carry out the airplane hijackings that killed about 3,000 people.

Charkaoui was released from a detention centre on Friday, after spending almost two years there without being charged.

A variety of high-profile Canadians contributed to the $50,000 bail, including Oscar-winning filmmaker Denys Arcand, Alexandre Trudeau, son of former prime minister Pierre Trudeau, singer Bruce Cockburn and former cabinet ministers Warren Allmand and Flora MacDonald.

Federal Court Judge Simon Noel set a number of conditions on Charkaoui's release.

He must respect a curfew, stay with his family and wear an electronic monitoring bracelet. The judge also placed limits on whom he can contact and on his use of computers.

Security certificates allow detention

Issued with the authority of a little-used section of the Immigration Act, ministerial security certificates allow the federal government to detain non-citizens without charges, and to withhold evidence the government says could threaten national security.

Such certificates must be signed by both the federal minister of immigration and the solicitor general.

A bid by Charkaoui's legal team to have the certificates declared unconstitutional failed in December 2004, when the Supreme Court of Canada ruled on the case.

Several other people are also being held on security certificates, including Algerian-born Ottawa resident Mohamed Harkat and Mahmoud Jaballah, an Egyptian man who had been living in the Toronto area.

Related

Audio

Steve Rukavina reports for CBC Radio (Runs: 1:09)
play:  RealMedia »

Video

Matthew Pace reports for CBC-TV
(Runs: 1:37)

play: RealMedia »
play: RealVideo »
play: QuickTime »

More Canada Headlines »

125,000 still without power after B.C. storm
About 125,000 people remain without power on B.C.'s South Coast Thursday after a storm tossed trees onto power lines and dumped enough rain to push rivers to near flood levels.
Harper to meet Chinese president after all
Prime Minister Stephen Harper is expected to meet Chinese President Hu Jintao during an international summit in Vietnam this week despite earlier reports that Beijing had snubbed Canada.
Top court delays Karlheinz Schreiber decision
Canada's top court said Thursday it is delaying its decision on whether to hear an extradition appeal from Karlheinz Schreiber to give the German-Canadian businessman more time to provide information.
'Semi-trailers were blowing over on the highway'
Winds gusting up to 110 kilometres an hour fanned a huge grass fire and blew over trees and semi-trailers in parts of southwestern Alberta.
Quebec's Black Coalition files racial profiling complaint for Alouettes players
The Black Coalition of Quebec has filed a racial profiling complaint with the provincial government and the Montreal police department in response to a traffic incident involving two Alouettes football players.
Story Tools: E-MAIL | PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

Harper to meet Chinese president after all
Prime Minister Stephen Harper is expected to meet Chinese President Hu Jintao during an international summit in Vietnam this week despite earlier reports that Beijing had snubbed Canada.
Canada-based gangs dominate U.S. ecstasy trade: report
Canadian-based gangs are taking control of the production and sale of the illegal drug ecstasy in the United States, according to a U.S. government report.
Vatican reaffirms celibacy for priests
The Pope and top Vatican officials have reconfirmed the Catholic Church's rule of celibacy for priests after considering an excommunicated archbishop's demand that it be dropped.
more »

Canada »

125,000 still without power after B.C. storm
About 125,000 people remain without power on B.C.'s South Coast Thursday after a storm tossed trees onto power lines and dumped enough rain to push rivers to near flood levels.
Harper to meet Chinese president after all
Prime Minister Stephen Harper is expected to meet Chinese President Hu Jintao during an international summit in Vietnam this week despite earlier reports that Beijing had snubbed Canada.
Top court delays Karlheinz Schreiber decision
Canada's top court said Thursday it is delaying its decision on whether to hear an extradition appeal from Karlheinz Schreiber to give the German-Canadian businessman more time to provide information.
more »

Health »

Europeans approve anti-obesity charter
European health ministers from 53 countries approved Thursday the world's first charter to fight obesity, vowing greater action against the epidemic of expanding waistlines across the continent.
Antibiotics no help for most bronchitis cases
Taking antibiotics for short-term bronchitis is unnecessary, say U.S. researchers who reviewed published studies on the effectiveness of the practice.
Researchers find quick test for viruses
Researchers have found a quick and cheap way to test for viruses using nanotechnology, according to a report in a journal published Thursday.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Andrew Lloyd Webber's Sound of Music draws rave reviews
The reality TV contest winner turned in a winning performance on the opening night of Andrew Lloyd Webber's London production of The Sound of Music on Thursday, as critics hailed the troubled show.
New record prices set for Warhol, de Kooning
New records were set for works by Andy Warhol and Willem de Kooning on Wednesday at an auction of contemporary art at Christie's in New York.
The Echo Maker winner of U.S. National Book Award
The Echo Maker by Richard Powers won the U.S. National Book Award for fiction on Wednesday night, as relatively unknown and unexpected authors took home the top prizes.
more »

Technology & Science »

YouTube laces up deal to show NHL clips
Hockey fans will soon be able to see highlights from NHL games on the popular video-sharing website YouTube under a groundbreaking deal between the company and the league.
Revamped MP3.com takes aim at MySpace
MP3.com is reopening its servers, nearly a decade after it helped usher in the online music era by letting largely unknown bands submit files for computer users to download.
Thailand to install tsunami detectors
Thai and U.S. experts will install the Indian Ocean's first state-of-the-art deep-water tsunami detection buoy next month, two years after massive waves killed at least 216,000 people around the region largely without warning.
more »

Money »

Loblaw to close 19 stores; reports higher Q3 earnings
Loblaw Cos. Ltd. reported slightly higher Q3 earnings Thursday, but said it would close 19 Quebec stores as part of an ongoing restructuring program.
Dell delays Q3 results, SEC launches investigation
Dell Inc. has delayed the release of its third-quarter results and said federal regulators had begun a formal investigation into the computer giant.
Canadian Pacific Railway boosts 2007 outlook
Canadian Pacific Railway nudged up its 2007 earnings outlook on Thursday by nine to 13 per cent and boosted its revenue projection by four to six per cent.
more »

Consumer Life »

Cosmetics makers to list ingredients on packaging
Consumers will be able to select their cosmetics more carefully thanks to new regulations requiring manufacturers to list ingredients.
Donating old electronics helps needy, environment, say recycling groups
Among the decaying Christmas trees and garbage bags filled with wrapping paper and turkey bones, there will no doubt be a lot of old electronic equipment this post-holiday season.
Europeans approve anti-obesity charter
European health ministers from 53 countries approved Thursday the world's first charter to fight obesity, vowing greater action against the epidemic of expanding waistlines across the continent.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL CFL MLB

Simon favoured for CFL MVP
The CFL hands out its year-end awards on Thursday, with B.C. Lions receiver Geroy Simon favoured to beat out Winnipeg Blue Bombers running back Charles Roberts for most valuable player.
CFL to ban suspended NFL players
With the Grey Cup only a few days away, CFL commissioner Tom Wright said the league will ban players suspended from the NFL starting in 2007.
Leafs surviving without Sundin
The Toronto Maple Leafs shoot for a season-high fifth straight victory as they take on the Bruins in Boston on Thursday.
more »