Agriculture, Pêche et Aquaculture
 
Department of Agriculture and Aquaculture
New Brunswick's Provincial Flower:  The  Violet  (Viola  cucullata) New Brunswick's Provincial Bird:  The  Chickadee  (Parus  atricapillus)
  Conservation Tillage




Over 70% of New Brunswick's agricultural land has physical limitations due to compacted subsoil and poor structure (45.5%); steep topography (20.8%) and shallowness to bedrock (5.8%). In order for this land to achieve its productive potential, a proper level of management inputs is required. In addition to these inherent problems associated with the land base, erosion by water has become the main concern in the potato producing areas of the St. John River Valley. The major factors that have increased the risk of soil degradation are:

  • Monoculture or indifferent crop rotation with minimum use of cover crops.
  • The use of heavy equipment on wet land.
  • Exessive stone removal.
  • Up and down the hill farming on steep topography.
  • Excessive, untimely and the use of unsuited tillage equipment.
  • Minimum use of barnyard and green manures.

Our goal is now, therefore, to reduce soil erosion and keep water in the soil while improving overall crop production and productivity. Conservation tillage offers an opportunity towards achieving this goal without imposing too many changes to our production systems. Concerns over excessive soil erosion necessitate increased efforts at maintaining crop residues on the soil surface through conservation tillage.


What is Conventional Tillage?

Conventional tillage is a full tillage program combining primary and secondary tillage operations performed in preparing a seedbed for a given crop and area. Primary tillage is performed in the fall (or spring) with a mouldboard plow followed in the spring by secondary tillage (disking (twice) or disking and the use of a vibrashank or soil finisher or rotovator or spring tooth and spike tooth harrows). The system performs as indicated below:

  • Inverts the soil to form furrows.
  • Buries crop residues so that there is slow decay and no surface mulch effect.
  • Exposes bare soil to water and wind erosion. May compact the soil beneath the plow.
  • Minimal ridging effect.
  • High cost per acre.
  • Power requirement of 15 h.p. per plow bottom.
  • Ideal for sod ground.


What is Conventional Tillage?

Conservation tillage is any tillage system that reduces the number of passes over the field for land preparation and increases the surface residues to protect soil and water loss. The system includes single disking, chiselling, subsoiling, ridging and no-till. No-till, however, has not, up to this time, proven a viable alternative in New Brunswick,


Equipment Frequently Associated With Conservation Tillage:

The Subsoiler:

This consists of rigid steel shanks which do not invert the soil.

  • Pre-tillage operation.
  • Breaks up compacted layers 16"(40 cm) or more below soil surface.
  • Allows deep percolation of water.
  • Allows deeper root penetration.
  • Requires 30 h.p. per shank. Ideal where drainage tiles have been installed.
  • Must be done when the subsoil is dry.
  • A rigid Shank.
    Diesel fuel requirements:
  • Subsoiler - 2.1 gal/ac for loams (23.581/ha)
  • - 2.84 gal/ac for clays. (31.89 I/ha)
  • The Offset Disk:

    This implement consists of large concave disks mounted in two rows opposing each other. The gongs cut and throw the soil in opposite directions.

    • Primary tillage operation.
    • Breaks up soil to 8-10" (20-25 cm).
    • Shallow incorporation of residues for rapid decay.
    • Good surface mulch effect for erosion reduction,
    • Low cost per acre.
    • 12-14 h.p. needed per foot width.
      Diesel fuel requirements:
    • 0.95 gal/ac for loams (10.67 I/ha)
    • 1.28 gal/ac for clays (14.37 I/ha)

    The Chisel Plow

    This implement consists of multiple rows of staggered curved shanks mounted rigidly, with spring cushions, or with spring resets.

    • Primary tillage operation.
    • Breaks up soil to 8-10" (20-25 cm).
    • Shallow 'incorporation of residues for rapid decay.
    • Good surface mulch effect for erosion reduction.
    • Low cost per acre.
    • Good ridging effect.
    • Minimal compaction.
    • Operating speed 5 mph or higher,
    • Requires 15 h.p. per shank
      Diesel fuel requirements:
    • - .1.25 gal/ac for loams (14.04 I/ha)
    • - 1.69 gal/ac for clays (18.98 I/ha)

    The Coulter Chisel Plow

    This implement consists of chis~el plows with gangs of flat or concave disks preceding the shanks to cut surface residues and vegetation.

    • Primary tillage operation.
    • Breaks up soil to 8-10 in, (20-25 cm).
    • Shallow residue incorporation.
    • Good surface mulch effect for erosion reduction.
    • Good ridging effect.
    • Minimal compaction.
    • Low cost/acre.
    • Requires 15 h.p. per shank.
    • Operating speed 5 mph The Coulter Chisel Plow or higher.
      Diesel fuel requirements:
    • - 1.30 gal/ac for loams (14.60 I/ha)
    • - 1.70 gal/ac for clays (19.09 1/ha)


    Conservation Tillage Systems

    A prerequisite for any conservation tillage program requires a building up and balancing of soil nutrients and the judicious use of limestone to adjust soil pH, based on soil tests. With conservation tillage, all residues from a harvesting operation including straw and chaff on sloping land must be evenly distributed over the acreage being treated. Stubble cannot be plowed down at a time when erosion is likely to be most severe. However, the stubble may be chisel plowed or vibrashanked with one pass across the slope in the fall. The following systems may be considered in a conservation tillage system.

    • Fall vibrashank, spring vibrashank - this provides shallow incorporation or residues for rapid decay, maximum surface mulch effect, minimal compaction, minimal ridging effect and low cost per acre. This should be used only on potato fields or clean-tilled grain fields where straw has been chopped and scattered.
    • Fall disking, spring disking1 - this provides shallow incorporation of crop residues for rapid decay, good surface mulch effect, good ridging effect, minimal compaction, low cost per acre and can be used only on potato fields, or clean-tilled grain where straw has been chopped and scattered.
    • Fall chisel plow, spring vibrashankl- this provides shallow incorporation of crop residues for rapid decay, good surface mulch effect, good ridging effect, minimal compaction, low cost per acre and can be used only on potato fields, or clean-tilled grain where straw has been chopped and scattered.
    • Fall coulter chisel plow, spring vibrashank1 -this allows shallow residue incorporation for rapid decay, good surface mulch effect, good ridging effect, minimal compaction, low cost per acre and can be used on all but sod fields.
    • Fall subsoiling - on severely compacted ground subsoiling will break up compacted layers beneath the normal tillage zone to improve percolation of water.

    A conservation tillage system would also involve planting a cover crop (winter cereal) on land which was left bare in the fall.

    NOTE: Before you decide on a tillage system or the purchase of new tillage implements, you should develop a Soil Management Plan for your forming operations reflecting the needs of your farm. The plan should tell the previous usages of the soil, the present status of the soil, what future use will be and what needs to be done to achieve these objectives.

    Benefits of Conservation Tillage over Conventional Tillage: Reduction of soil erosion and nutrient loss from soil erosion as is evident in this table below.

    • Increased retention of soil moisture.
    • Increased infiltration.
    • Increased O.M. content in soil.
    • Increased soil surface protection from crop residues.
    • Lower cost per acre.
    • Decreased compaction.


    Problems Associated With Conservation Tillage
    • Tractor speeds must be greater than 5 mph to effectively plow the field and achieve the desired ridging effect.
    • Losses of N by denitrification and/or volatilization are potential problems that require some more research. The increased moisture, surface residue and reduced bulk density with conservation tillage are more conducive to denitrification losses.
    • As soil mixing is reduced, both P and K should, be applied in the row at planting. The row K is especially important in soils that compact easily.
    • Lime must be applied as required by soil tests, to prevent the formation of an acid surface layer that could reduce herbicide activity, root development and nutrient availability.
    • Populations of Rhizoctonia solani in topsoil survive in colonized plant debris, Deep turning the soil (20-30 cm) with a mouldboard plow which buries the debris, effectively removes the fungal populases from the root zone. In contrast, chisel plows, etc. leave most of the plant debris and the pathogen in the topsoil. Thus, seedling tissues may come into contact with the pathogen and be invaded a few days after planting, resulting in poor stands or deformed plants.

    Current weed control practices are less effective under conservation tillage.


    Why Change From Conventional Tillage to Conservation Tillage?

    Some farmers may resist change in tillage practices even though economic and other benefits (e.g. reduced soil erosion) indicate a need for change, because they feel their current methods are successful. Certainly, change solely for the sake of change can be counterproductive. One must look at the overall cropping system to determine if a change is needed, and if so, what that change should be. Some factors to consider in this regard are:

    • Is soil erosion a major concern on your farm operation?
    • Are you experiencing reduced yields?
    • Is soil compaction becoming a major problem on your farm?
    • Are high operational costs eating away at your profits?
    • Are you carrying out a review of your equipment needs?
    • Is the organic matter level content of your soil being depleted?

    If the answers to the above questions are yes, then you should consider Conservation Tillage.

    There are many benefits to be achieved through conservation tillage but successful application of conservation tillage systems requires good management by the farmer. Yield reductions could result if fertility and other management programs are neglected.


    More Information

Agriculture and Aquaculture
E-mail | Contacts |
Disclaimer | Privacy Statement