OPENING THE DOOR
A Treatment Model for Therapy
With Male Survivors of Sexual Abuse
By: Adrienne Crowder, M.S.W.
Clinical Consultant: Rob Hawkings, M.A., M.E.S.,
M.B.A.
© Family and Children's Services of the Waterloo
Region
September, 1993
This project was funded by the Family Violence Prevention Unit
of Health and Welfare Canada under FVDS #4887-06-91-088. Findings
and opinions expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily
those of the Department.
Copies of this manual are available from:
National Clearinghouse
on Family Violence
Health and Welfare Canada
Ottawa, Ontario
K1A 1B5
Telephone:
(613) 957-2938
Toll free:
1-800-267-1291
Fax:
(613) 941-8930
TDD:
(613) 952-6396
TDD toll free: 1-800-561-5643
For TDD* users (*Telecommunication
devices for the deaf), please call (613) 952-6396 or dial no charge
1-800-561-5643
Catalogue Number: 872-21/95-1993E
ISBN
Number: 0-662-210-32-8
This book is dedicated to Christopher Crowder.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
CHAPTER 1 - INTRODUCTION
Definition Of Sexual Abuse
Language
Research Method
Limitations Of This Research
Organization Of The Text
CHAPTER 2 - PREVALENCE, IMPACTS AND ISSUES
Estimates Of Prevalence
Factors Affecting The Reporting Of Male Sexual
Abuse
1. Research-Related Factors
2. The Impact Of Cultural
Beliefs And Stereotypes
Myth Of Male Self-Reliance
Myth Of Sexual Initiation
Myth Of Female Innocence
Myth Of Contact Contamination
3. Clinically-Related
Factors
Impacts And Issues For Males Who Have Been Sexually
Abused
Variables Which Affect
The Impact Of Sexual Abuse
The Age At Which The Abuse Began
The Duration And Frequency Of The Abuse
The Type Of Activities Which Constitute The Abuse
The Nature Of The Relationship Between The Offender And the Victim
The Number And Gender Of Offenders Involved In The Abuse
The Manner In Which Disclosure Of The Abuse Occurred
Other Attenuating Circumstances In The Victim's Life
Effects Of Sexual Abuse
On Male Survivors
Physical Impacts
Mental Impacts
Emotional Impacts
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) And Dissociation
Difficulties With Male Gender Identity
Sexual Orientation Confusion And Homophobia
Abuse-Reactive Perpetration And Aggression
Sexual Addictions And Compulsions
Interpersonal Difficulties
Differences Between Male and Female Survivors
Of Sexual Abuse
CHAPTER 3 - TREATMENT MODEL AND STAGES OF HEALING
Therapeutic Model For Male Victims Of Sexual
Abuse
Basic Principles Of Male Survivor Treatment
Empowerment
Client-Focused, Client-Paced
Therapy
Linking The Past To The
Present
Growth And Learning Model
Integration
Recognition Of Grief
Safety
Recognition That Abuse
Is Both Personal And Cultural
Transference And Counter-Transference
Stages Of Therapy - A Four-Phase Model
Phase 1 - Breaking Silence
Phase 2 - The Victim
Stage
Phase 3 - The Survivor
Phase
Phase 4 - The Thriver
Phase
CHAPTER 4 - GENERAL THERAPEUTIC CONSIDERATIONS
Developing A Therapeutic Contract
Information Boundaries
Fees
Structure Of Sessions
Touch Boundaries
Crisis And Emergency
Plans
Contraindicators For Abuse-Related Therapy
Ongoing Life Crisis
Lack Of Social Support
Lack Of Motivation To
Change
Therapist's Limitations
Breaking The Therapeutic
Contract
Client Assessment
General Family/Social
History
Sexual History
Coping Strategies
Abuse-Reactive Perpetration
Treatment Motivation/Goals
Evaluating Therapy
CHAPTER 5 - INDIVIDUAL THERAPY: THE VICTIM PHASE
Interventions
Inner Child Work
Visualization
"Container" Visualization
"Place Of Safety" Visualization
Making Assumptions
Life Book
Life Story
Drawing The Abuse
Script Recognition
Focusing Techniques
CHAPTER 6 - INDIVIDUAL THERAPY: THE SURVIVOR PHASE
Revenge Perpetration And Sexual Fantasies
Revenge Fantasies
Perpetration And Deviant
Sexual Fantasies
Challenging Compulsive/Addictive Behaviours
Increasing Affective Expression
Music
Empty Chair
Write A Letter
Construct A Collage
Breathwork
Emotionally Expressive
Work
Role-Plays
Bioenergetic Anger Releases
Working With Dissociative Processes
Keeping A Journal
Grounding Techniques
Looking In A Mirror
Writing Or Telling Someone
About The Memories
Symbols Of His Adult
Identity
Therapeutic Dissociation
CHAPTER 7 - INDIVIDUAL THERAPY: THE THRIVER PHASE
Confronting The Abuser
Bodywork
Termination
CHAPTER 8 - GROUP THERAPY WITH MALE SURVIVORS OF SEXUAL ABUSE
Screening Potential Group Members
The Client's Ability
To Talk About His Abuse
Support
Motivation
Interpersonal Skills
Self-Care
Homophobia
Present Life Functioning
Abuse-Reactive Perpetration
MPD
A Two-Stage Group Treatment Model
Group Groundrules
Confidentiality
Boundaries
Affective Expression
Active Participation
Attendance
Pass Rule
Sobriety
Group Process
Check-in
Ritual Closing
Termination
Group Leadership
CHAPTER 9 - CRITICAL ISSUES IN TREATING MALE SURVIVORS
Engagement Strategies
Therapeutic Impasses
Therapist Gender Issues
CHAPTER 10 - COUNSELLING ADOLESCENT MALE SURVIVORS
The Role Of Counselling With Adolescent Male
Victims
Assessing Adolescent Victims Of Sexual Abuse
The Treatment Process With Adolescent Victims
Of Sexual Abuse
Therapist's Style
Gender of Therapist
Clear Boundaries And
Limits
Counselling Process
Group Treatment
CHAPTER 11 - THERAPIST ISSUES
Counter-Transference In Therapy With Male Survivors
Managing Counter-Transference
A Partnership Attitude
To Providing Therapy
Therapy For The Therapist
Identifying One's Personal
Limits And Boundaries
Supervision
Peer Support
Advocacy
Personal Life Satisfaction
Issues For Therapists Who Are Themselves Survivors
Of Sexual Abuse
CHAPTER 12 - RESOURCES
Video Resources
Written Resources
For Both Therapists And
Clients
For Therapists
For Clients
Training Resources
APPENDIX A - QUESTIONNAIRE
APPENDIX B - LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
APPENDIX C - DES
APPENDIX D - INTERVENTION TO MANAGE FLASHBACKS AND INTERVENTION
TO GROUND CLIENTS IN HERE-AND-NOW EXPERIENCE
APPENDIX E - BEHAVIOURS WHICH SUPPORT GROUP PROCESS
APPENDIX F - DEAN ADOLESCENT INVENTORY SCALE
APPENDIX G - REFERENCES
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Researching and writing this book would have been impossible without
the help and support of a great many people.
Generous financial support was provided by the Family Violence Prevention Unit of Health and Welfare Canada. Carole Miron and
Gisèle Lacroix administered this project on behalf of Health and
Welfare Canada with efficiency, patience and courtesy.
The management of Family and Childrens' Services of Waterloo Region
granted me a three month leave of absence to work on this book.
Jim Phillips and Del Armbruster carefully ensured that the project
stayed within its budget.
Susan Waterman and Fran Kolentsis took on the responsibility for
locating written resources on male survivors of sexual abuse and
they performed the task admirably. Rob Hawkings brought his clinical
expertise and editorial scrutiny to this project. James Morgan made
recommendations which became integral to the organization of the
text. His willingness to listen to my excitement and frustration
over the year and a half that I worked on this book, his ideas and
suggestions and his emotional support were all of inestimable value.
Susan Lawrence edited the final draft of the text and her suggestions
enhanced its overall quality. Joan Laing lent her desktop publishing
skills to the project to make the final text accessible and readable.
To all these people I give my heartfelt thanks.
Lastly, I would like to acknowledge the contribution
of the 41 therapists who generously shared their knowledge about
therapy with male survivors with me. It was always a pleasure to
talk with these clinicians about their work and I was often touched
by their compassion and skill. l believe that my most sincere thanks
is expressed by passing on their ideas to others and sharing their
collective wisdom.
CHAPTER 1 - INTRODUCTION
Sexual abuse is an activity that is perpetrated in secret. The
offender is often in a position of trust, and always in a position
of power, in relation to his or her victim. The victim acquiesces
to the authority of the offender because he or she is threatened
or seduced into compliance. Often a victim's cognitive and affective
immaturity renders him or her unable to appropriately judge the
potential risk of the behaviours which constitute the abuse.
In many ways the therapeutic process is isomorphic to that of abuse.
Therapy occurs under a mantle of confidentiality. Clients enter
therapy in good faith, with the expectation that a therapist will
have their best interests at heart. Therapists are invested with
the authority to determine the kinds of interventions that they
believe will best assist their clients' recovery. As in situations
of abuse, clients generally have no immediate way to judge the long-term
effects of their therapy or the skills of their therapist.
The difference between therapy and abuse, however, lies in the
fact that ideally therapy is driven by the clients' needs, whereas
abuse ignores the victims' needs. If therapy is to be effective
in restoring clients' autonomy and well-being, therapists must manage
treatment in ways that do not suggest or replicate the dynamics
of the original abuse.
Opening The Door has been written to assist clinicians who
work with, or are intending to work with, male survivors of sexual
abuse. Throughout the text the parallel processes of therapy and
abuse are discussed; the important distinctions between these two
processes that ensure that therapy is a healing rather than a harmful
experience form the basis of the treatment model that is presented
here.
The raw material which forms the basis of this book was gathered
by interviewing 41 therapists who have developed expertise in working
with male survivors of sexual abuse. The text discusses both the
similarities and differences in approach that these therapists bring
to their work. It also presents applied interventions that they
have developed to enhance their work.
This book is written for mental health practitioners (therapists,
social workers, psychiatric nurses, doctors, crisis centre workers,
etc.) who are offering therapeutic services to adolescent and/or
adult male survivors of sexual abuse. The information that is presented
here is not meant to be prescriptive. Rather, it is meant to stimulate
your own thinking and creativity. You are invited to take this information
and improve on it by adapting it to suit your own therapeutic style
and experience.
Throughout the text, I assume that each person's
recovery process from childhood sexual trauma is unique. In addition,
I assume that the kinds of formal treatment that are discussed here
form only one part of any individual's healing journey. Although
this text, of necessity, deals with the political and cultural components
of abuse, its primary focus is on the personal and psychological
aspects of recovery from sexual trauma.
DEFINITION OF SEXUAL ABUSE
Throughout this book, the term "sexual abuse" will be
used to describe overt or covert sexual behaviour between two individuals
when the following conditions exist:
1. the nature of the sexual act(s) is developmentally inappropriate
for at least one of the participants;
2. the balance of power and authority (meaning psychological
power, economic power, role status power, etc.) between the two
individuals is unequal; and
3. the two individuals have an established emotional connection
(such as that between a child and a caregiver, or a child and
authority figure).
Any definition of sexual abuse necessarily carries culturally determined
values and beliefs about sexuality, self-determination and social
roles. In the broadest sense, sexual abuse can be defined as:
"Sexual activities that a child does not understand, to
which a child cannot give informed consent or which violate the
social taboos of society. (Krugman, 1986)." (Banning, 1989,
p. 566).
The nature of the sexual acts which constitute sexual abuse vary
along a continuum of intrusiveness. Activities such as voyeurism,
viewing pornographic materials or age-inappropriate behaviour regarding
physical health (for instance, checking to see if a 12-year old's
penis is "growing properly") fall on one pole of the continuum.
Sadistic and ritualistic abuse constitutes the other pole.
It must be noted that a client's perception of the
intrusiveness of any specific sexual activity is subjective. His
perceptions may change as he redefines his childhood experience
through his adult understanding. It is the client's experience that
needs to be addressed in therapy rather than whether the behaviour
is considered objectively intrusive.
LANGUAGE
This text focuses on therapeutic work with male survivors of childhood
sexual trauma. For the sake of accuracy and simplicity, I use the
pronoun "he" when referring to victims or clients.
The terms "victim" and "survivor" are both
commonly used in abuse-related discussions and literature. Historically,
these terms were adopted by the feminist movement to describe victims
of rape. Rape victims are violently attacked during an incident
that is outside the normal events of their lives. With sexual abuse,
however, the trauma is usually repetitive and often seductive. Generally
the abuse is integrated into the child's life and, in one way or
another, his beliefs, feelings, behaviour and sexuality are conditioned
by the abuse. Hence to describe someone as a "victim"
or a "survivor" of sexual abuse can minimize the internalized
dysfunction that can occur as a result of the long-term and pervasive
nature of the abuse. These terms also run the risk of overgeneralizing
a client's identity as a survivor of childhood sexual trauma, thereby
discounting those aspects of the person which currently function
in healthful and productive ways.
Given the limitations of language and a need to be succinct, I
will use the terms "victim" and "survivor" throughout
this text. However, the limitations of these terms noted above cannot
be overlooked. Ultimately, both "victim" and "survivor"
perpetuate an association with a history of abuse. (Hunter, 1990).
It is to be hoped that after successful therapy, a client will identify
the impact of his abuse as only a part of his life's journey and
not as its totality; ideally he will see himself as "someone
who was abused as a child" rather than as a "victim"
or "survivor" of abuse. "The ultimate goal of therapy
ought to be to transcend survivorship.... The individuality of personhood
must be paramount." (Hunter & Gerber, 1990, p. 83). Readers
are asked to bear in mind that when the terms "victim"
or "survivor" are used, they are a convenient shorthand
rather than empirical descriptors.
Throughout the text the 41 clinicians who were interviewed
about their work with male survivors are referred to as "the
contributors" or "the clinicians participating in this
research".
RESEARCH METHOD
The material presented in this text has been complied from two
primary sources: namely, interviews with clinicians who provide
therapy to sexually abused males and the current literature (most
notably books and journal articles). The contributors who participated
in this research were a non-probability, purposive sample of clinicians
who have therapeutic experience with male survivors of sexual abuse.
Data collection occurred in the following sequence: first, computer
and library searches located relevant written materials about sexually
abused males. Second, North American authors of books or journal
articles were sent a letter outlining the nature of this research
and inviting them to participate in it. In addition, these writers
were asked to provide the names of other clinicians whom they knew
to be working with male survivors and they were also contacted.
Third, all the clinicians who agreed to participate in this research
were sent a questionnaire to gather information on their clinical
orientation, the demographics of their client population and the
resources they use when working with male survivors. (For a copy
of this questionnaire, please see Appendix A.) Fourth, the written
questionnaire was followed by a semi-structured telephone interview
to gather more in-depth information about each contributor's clinical
practice and specific interventions and techniques that he or she
uses. These phone interviews were conducted during the autumn of
1992 and the winter of 1993.
In total, 58 clinicians throughout Canada and the United States
were approached and asked to take part in this research. Of these,
41 agreed to participate. Their names and addresses are listed in
Appendix B. Thirty-one (31) contributors returned the written questionnaire.
Thirty-two of the contributors are male; nine are female. The majority
of the contributors have professional training in either psychology,
social work or marriage and family therapy; however, clinicians
with backgrounds in nursing and massage therapy are also represented.
The contributors work in a variety of mental health settings including
community mental health clinics, family therapy agencies, hospitals,
rape crisis centres, sex offender treatment programs and private
practice.
Contributors were asked to identify both their years of experience
in providing sexual abuse treatment in general and sexual abuse
treatment to male survivors in particular. As anticipated, given
the greater cultural awareness of female victimization, the contributors
had more years of clinical experience working with sexual abuse
in general (providing therapy to female victims and their families)
than with male victims in particular.
- 68% of the contributors had provided general sexual abuse treatment
for more than eight years;
- 23% had provided general sexual abuse treatment for between
six and eight years; and
- 9% had provided general sexual abuse treatment for less than
five years.
With regard to male survivors:
- 32% of the contributors had provided sexual abuse treatment
to this population for more than eight years;
- 42% had provided sexual abuse treatment to male survivors for
between six and eight years; and
- 26% had provided sexual abuse treatment to male survivors for
less than five years.
Although some contributors specialize in working with a specific
developmental group, many work with a variety of ages.
- 93% of contributors offer therapy to adult male survivors (clients
over 25 years of age);
- 90% work with young adults (aged 20 - 25 years);
- 58% work with adolescent male survivors (13 - 19 years of age);
- 35% work with latency-aged children (6 - 12 years of age); and
- 16% work with preschool boys under the age of five.
Contributors were asked to identify the different therapeutic modalities
they offer to male survivors of sexual abuse.
- 97% of the contributors offer individual therapy;
- 77% offer group therapy; and
- 52% offer couple and/or family therapy.
Some contributors also offer regular workshops for
male survivors and/or they provide regular training to other professionals
regarding the treatment of male survivors of sexual abuse.
LIMITATIONS OF THIS RESEARCH
Gathering the primary data for this book was a journalistic process
rather than a scientific one. My intention in compiling this material
was to create a practical and applied resource for clinicians who
work with male survivors of sexual abuse. Qualitative and exploratory
research methods were used to meet this goal.
The contributors were located by virtue of either having published
material on the subject of male sexual abuse survivors or by knowing
someone who had published in this area. Clearly some very knowledgeable
practitioners may have been overlooked because they have not written
about their work with male survivors or because they did not come
to my attention during the initial stages of the research. In addition,
some seasoned clinicians who were asked to participate in this research
were prevented from doing so because of other work demands.
Therapy is a dynamic human interaction. It is by
nature fluid and experiential. Translating therapeutic concepts
and experience into written form necessarily entails some loss.
Nevertheless, it is my hope that the treatment model described in
this book will assist you in your work with male survivors.
ORGANIZATION OF THE TEXT
The remainder of this text is organized into eleven chapters (with
seven appendices). Chapter 2 is called "Prevalence, Impacts
and Issues" and presents information about the frequency of
male sexual victimization, the impacts of this victimization on
the individual and the issues that victims typically bring into
therapy.
Chapter 3 presents a four-phase treatment model for male survivors.
These phases are called Breaking Silence, the Victim Phase, the
Survivor Phase and the Thriver Phase. The typical therapeutic tasks
of each of these stages of therapy are outlined and discussed.
Chapter 4 outlines essential processes that pertain to all therapeutic
modalities (individual, group, etc.) when treating male survivors
of sexual abuse. Contracting with clients, assessment guidelines
and evaluation methods are discussed.
Chapters 5, 6 and 7 focus on individual therapy with male survivors,
examining the Victim, Survivor and Thriver phases of therapy respectively.
Interventions that the contributors have developed for use during
each of these treatment phases are intertwined with general theoretical
considerations.
Chapter 8 outlines a two-stage group treatment model for male survivors.
Therapeutic issues such as contraindicators for group treatment
and interventions that can be used in male survivor groups, are
presented.
Chapter 9 looks at several critical issues that are relevant to
the treatment of male survivors. Engagement strategies, therapeutic
impasses and client/therapist gender dynamics are identified and
explicated.
Chapter 10 focuses on the therapeutic process as it applies to
adolescent male survivors. The ways in which the treatment process
needs to be tailored to the developmental needs of this group are
noted and discussed.
Because therapy is an interactive process and the therapist is
as much a player in the therapeutic journey as the client, Chapter
11 discusses issues that pertain to the therapist rather than to
the client.
Lastly, Chapter 12 presents resources (written and
video resources, as well as training resources) that both therapists
and clients can use to enhance the process of healing from sexual
trauma.
CHAPTER 2 - PREVALENCE, IMPACTS AND ISSUES
This chapter presents information about the prevalence
of male sexual victimization, and discusses many of the
reasons why attempts to establish an accurate picture of
this phenomenon are problematic. Ways in which the experience
of being sexually traumatized can impact on male victims
are discussed, and the primary variables that generally
act as predictors regarding the severity of the resultant
pathology are identified. Finally, the primary differences
between male and female sexual victimization are examined
using both empirical research and clinical experience to
inform the discussion. |
ESTIMATES OF PREVALENCE
Cultural and social myths shape our ability to acknowledge many
of the abusive and explosive realities that exist in our culture.
Sexual abuse and especially the sexual abuse of male children, has
been invisible in our society until very recently.
"In Freud's time father-daughter incest could not be accepted.
Child physical abuse was not recognized or acknowledged until
the 1960s and child sexual abuse in the mid 1970s. Not until the
1980s were male victims recognized and studied and their victimization
found to be more frequent than previously recognized." (Banning,
1989, p. 569).
It is difficult to accurately estimate the prevalence of male sexual
victimization for a variety of reasons. Researchers who " ...attempt
to determine the number of abuse cases within the general population
(prevalence), report rates varying between 3% and 31% for males...(Finklehor
et al., 1986)." (Dimock, 1988, p. 203). An increase in the
reported incidence rate of sexually abused males is also noted:
"While the reports of both male and female victims have risen,
the proportion of males rose from 15.7% of the total in 1980, to
21.7% in 1984 (American Humane Association, 1986)." (Dimock,
1988, p. 203). In Canada, in 1984, the Badgley Report found that
33% of men are sexually victimized at some point in their lives,
that 75% of these assaults occur to boys under the age of 17 and
25% of these assaults can be considered serious offenses chargeable
under the Canadian Criminal Code (Bruckner & Johnson, 1987,
p. 81).
Estimates of prevalence vary from study to study. A 1989 study
of 592 American male college students from two different geographic
regions determined that 15% of the students from the mid-western
campus and 13% of the students from the southeastern campus "described
al least one sexually abusive experience in childhood" (Fromuth
& Burkhart, 1989, p. 536). A representative national sample
of 2,972 American male college students found that:
"7.3 % of the men reported a childhood experience that met
at least one of the following three criteria for sexual abuse:
(1) existence of age discrepancy between the child and perpetrator,
(2) use of some form of coercion to obtain participation by the
victim and/or (3) a perpetrator who was a caregiver or authority
figure., (Risin & Koss, 1987, p. 309).
Clearly, although empirical studies have generated quantitative
data identifying the problem of male sexual abuse, prevalence figures
can only be estimated. The general problem of determining the extent
of male sexual abuse can be summarized as follows:
"Many or even most sex crimes are not reported. Therefore,
determining the actual number of crimes is impossible, regardless
of whether the victim is male or female." (Freeman-Longo,
1986, p. 411)
FACTORS AFFECTING THE REPORTING OF MALE SEXUAL
ABUSE
The many factors complicating the reporting process for male victims
of sexual abuse will be discussed in three categories:
(1) research-related factors;
(2) the impact of cultural beliefs and stereotypes; and
(3) clinically-related factors.
1. Research-Related Factors
Studies that attempt to determine the prevalence of male sexual
abuse arrive at different estimations partly because they operationalize
the definition of sexual abuse in study-specific ways. There is
no standard definition of sexual abuse that comprehensively addresses
sex, age, cultural and regional differences (Urquiza & Keating,
1990; Risin & Koss, 1987). Hence each study has a unique definition
of sexual abuse and in effect, measures different kinds of experience.
The samples that different studies draw upon are not standardized.
Some research uses non-clinical populations such as college students,
while other studies draw from clinical populations such as adolescents
who are currently in treatment or adults who are imprisoned for
sex-related crimes. Clearly, data describing these different populations
will reflect experiences that are biased by unique variables. In
addition, methodologies for data collection (i.e. self-reported
questionnaires, face-to-face interviews, telephone surveys, etc.)
vary from study to study thus affecting the degree of reliability
of the data. Hence "...differences in reported prevalence rates
are more a reflection of the method of data collection than of the
number of children who were sexually abused." (Urquiza and
Keating, 1990, p. 96).
2. The Impact Of Cultural Beliefs And Stereotypes
The underreporting of the sexual abuse of male children is often
a reflection of cultural beliefs about gender roles and socialization.
Certain actions, such as male sexual victimization, remain hidden
because cultural myths and values shape the ways in which they are
understood.
Myth Of Male Self-Reliance
In his discussion of this issue, Finklehor says "the male
ethic of self-reliance ... has tended to portray youthful male sexuality
in very positive, adventuresome terms... [and is] partly responsible
for the serious underreporting of sexual victimization experiences
involving boys." (Finklehor, 1984, p. 152).
The belief that males are always powerful and able to fend for
themselves has created a mythology that implies that if a boy or
man admits to being victimized he is seen as less than male. Our
culture has no mythology to identify the process of male victimization
and boy victims are emasculated by this bias. They are either seen
as being like a woman and therefore feminized, as being powerless
and therefore flawed or as being interested in sex with men and
therefore homosexual. None of these interpretations of victimization
are useful options for a boy who has been sexually abused and is
trying to make sense of this experience.
Whether male children are abused by male or female perpetrators
or both, the cultural interpretation of the event often minimizes
its impact or puts responsibility for the abuse onto the victim.
(Sepler, 1991).
Myth Of Sexual Initiation
Boys who are abused by a male are often seen as having engaged
in homosexual acts for pleasure; this interpretation can be held
by the victim himself, especially if, during the abuse, his penis
responded to the sexual stimulation by becoming erect. (Struve,
1990; Urquiza & Keating, 1990; Dimock; 1988).
It is worth noting that several journal articles (Sandfort, 1984;
Tindall, 1987) discuss the nature of sexual relations between adults
and children and argue that " ... with the right circumstances
(privacy, degree of sexual arousal, etc.), the first sexual relationship
[between a male adult and a male child] occurred as a result of
mutual desires." (Tindall, 1978, p. 380). This analysis of
sexual acts between male adults and male children as consensual
sexual experiences, without regard to the power and control issues
which are involved, emphasizes the cultural blinders that permit
continued sexual exploitation of children. Statements such as the
following actively ignore the developmental differences in sexual
needs and expression that exist between adults and children.
"Future research into pedophilia should not a priori categorize
the adults in pedosexual contacts as offenders and the children
as victims, labelling all pedosexual contact as abuse or misuse.
Pedophiliac: relationships may best be viewed by the researcher
initially as simply another variety of human relationships (Sandfort,
1984, p. 140)
Such statements clearly point out the difficulty some male victims
of sexual abuse face when they begin to identify and examine their
experience and are met with attempts to redefine this abuse as consensual
sexual activity.
Our culture promotes the belief that all sexual activity is good
for men, no matter what its context. Images from advertising, television
and cinema often portray sexual activities in which the "emotional
reactions of male victims ...are seriously distorted when compared
to those of real-life victims." (Trivelpiece, 1990, p. 67).
When sexual abuse is heterosexual and a sexually mature female victimizes
a boy, he may have difficulty recognizing this as abuse, since the
cultural interpretation of this event is that he "got lucky".
In movies such as "The Summer of '42", sexual abuse is
romanticized and represented as sexual initiation. (Trivelpiece,
1990).
Myth Of Female Innocence
Boys who are abused by women or girls also face social myths that
can prevent their abuse from being identified. Cultural gender biases
perpetuate the belief that women in general and mothers in particular,
are nurturing. Mothers have cultural permission to touch their children.
When this touch is sexualized, sometimes under the guise of medical
or caretaking rituals, a boy may have difficulty recognizing these
behaviours as abusive. Because he is also subject to the cultural
myth that women's touch is nurturing rather than sexual, he may
be unable to discern that the sexual behaviours; gratified his female
abuser's needs rather than his own.
Cultural biases skew the ways in which activities are seen and
the same activities are viewed differently depending upon whether
they are performed by a man or a woman. This double standard often
results in inappropriate sexual interaction between an adult women
and a child being ignored:
"There is a widespread societal belief that women cannot
be sexually abusive to their children and at worst their behaviour
is labelled as seductive and not harmful. The same behaviour in
a father is labelled child molestation." (Banning, 1989,
p. 567).
Myth Of Contact Contamination
The popular belief is that male victims of sexual abuse automatically
become sexual offenders. While it is true that some sexual offenders
were themselves victims of sexual abuse, committing sexual offenses
is caused by complex variables which cannot be narrowed down to
the single variable of previous sexual victimization (Freund, Watson
& Dickey, 1990). However, the cultural stereotype that victims
of sexual abuse become offenders stops some victims from disclosing
their abuse histories.
3. Clinically-Related Factors
Several aspects of the social service system act against the disclosure
of male sexual victimization. Foremost amongst these is the fact
that child protection agencies tend to deal with cases of intrafamilial
sexual abuse, where they are mandated to ensure children's safety
within their family systems. In his student survey, Finklehor found
that, "Boys are more likely than girls to be victimized by
someone outside the family." (Finklehor, 1984, p. 166). In
fact approximately 83% of the persons who victimized the male students
in this survey were non-family members (Finklehor, 1984). Thus,
acts of sexual abuse perpetrated against male victims, if they are
reported at all, tend to be reported to the police or the criminal
justice system, not to child protection or treatment agencies. This
lack of societal recognition of male victims' needs for treatment
and protection perpetuates victims' silence. Male victims are unlikely
to disclose their sexual abuse when they have little to gain from
making their experience public.
As will be discussed later in this chapter, victims of childhood
sexual trauma often repress or forget their abuse-related memories.
This primitive defence structure reduces the likelihood of disclosure
of abuse by a victim. Even when memories are recalled, if a therapist
or child protection worker is uncomfortable asking questions about
the abuse or presents questions in such a way that the child does
not connect the question to his abuse, the abuse may not be reported.
(Hunter, 1990).
Awareness of the issue of male sexual victimization in the professional
therapeutic community is limited by the same factors that affect
the culture as a whole. Until recently, professional literature
and journal articles have focused on the prevalence of male sexual
victimization rather than on the impact of sexual abuse on male
victims or models and methodologies of healing male survivors. An
absence of information about how to work with male survivors has
left many clinicians uncomfortable with or unaware of, the male
survivors on their caseloads. A lack of questioning about the possible
occurrence of abuse can result in an absence of disclosure on a
client's part.
In summary, there are many reasons why the full extent of male
sexual abuse is relatively unknown and probably underreported.
" ... with males being even more reluctant than females
to admit their own victimization, it is left to our imagination
to conclude just what the full extent of male victimization is.
Certainly it is greater than reports now indicate." (Blanchard,
1987, p. 20.)
IMPACTS AND ISSUES FOR MALES WHO HAVE BEEN SEXUALLY
ABUSED
Survivors of sexual abuse generally experience multiple and complex
repercussions from this trauma All parts of the self - physical,
mental, emotional and spiritual - are affected by the abuse and
all of these parts can express abuse-related symptoms and effects.
Abuse-related symptoms are experienced in both the short and long
term. Some symptoms (such as physical bruises and cuts, some sexually
transmitted diseases, emotional shock or misdirected aggression)
are crisis based and their impact is short-term; other symptoms
(such as distorted cognitions or low self-esteem) are more deeply
internalized by the victim and have much longer term impact. (Evans,
1990).
Often sexual abuse is accompanied by other forms of abuse and neglect,
so that the trauma from the sexual abuse cannot be viewed in isolation.
It is not always possible to determine the origin of symptoms which
have multiple roots; however, as Olsen (1990) notes:
"From either an anecdotal self-report method or using valid,
reliable instrumentation and comparative methodology, it was found
that men who sought psychotherapy and had been sexually abused
as children inside or outside their homes were far more psychologically
disturbed than were other male therapy clients.... " (Olsen,
1990, p. 148).
There are some researchers who argue that sexual interaction between
adults and children or older children and younger children, is neutral
or positive in its impact on a young child (Condy et al, 1987; Constantine,
1979; Sandfort, 1984; Tindall, 1978). 1 don't share this opinion.
Young children are not sufficiently mentally, emotionally or physically
mature to make an informed choice about whether or not to participate
in sexual activities with an adult. Hence, although certain survivors
of sexual abuse may identify this experience as positive or neutral
in its impact on them, this is certainly not the case for the majority
of victims of sexual trauma.
The specific form of expression of the effects of the sexual trauma
will vary from individual to individual. It is generally true that
while many of the effects of sexual victimization were adaptive
responses at the time of victimization, they become dysfunctional
in the victims' post-abuse environment. (Briere, 1990).
Each person who has been sexually abused has a unique story to
tell of how this event has played a part in his life. In the remainder
of this chapter, I'll describe the various ways that sexual abuse
can affect male victims. There is no single classification of impacts
that can possibly recognize all the possible outcomes of sexual
trauma; however, survivors share many common themes and issues.
The primary focus will be on long-term impacts which become integral
parts of survivor's lives, rather than on short-term acute impacts.
Remember that your clients' self-reported histories are the most
helpful guide to understanding the various impacts of abuse; the
information given here is intended to guide you in your understanding
of your clients' experience, not to replace a thorough assessment.
Variables Which Affect The Impact Of Sexual Abuse
Researchers and clinicians have observed that the severity of the
impact of sexual abuse on its victims is a function of several key
variables:
- the age at which the abuse began;
- the duration and frequency of the abuse;
- the type of activities which constituted the abuse;
- the nature of the relationship between the offender and the
victim;
- the number and gender of offenders involved in the abuse;
- the manner in which disclosure of the abuse occurred; and
- other attenuating circumstances in the victim's life.
(Condy et al, 1987; Crowder & Myers-Avis, 1993; Hunter, 1990a;
Pierce, 1987).
The Age At Which The Abuse Began
Generally the younger a victim at the time the abuse begins, the
greater the impact on his psychological development (Hunter, 1990a;
Pierce, 1987). Younger children call upon more primitive, less conscious
defences to protect the integrity of their psyche; as the child
matures, these primitive defences often lead to severe developmental
impairment (Kilgore, 1988). Defences such as denial, repression,
splitting and dissociation become problematic if the victim generalizes
these coping strategies to a variety of situations in his life.
The older a victim is at the time the abuse begins, the more able
he is to consciously decide how he will protect himself, and fewer
developmental stages in his life will be affected by his decisions.
The Duration And Frequency Of The Abuse
The more often a victim is abused and the longer the duration of
the abuse, the greater the likelihood that he will be conditioned
by the experience and, hence, the greater the severity of the impact
of the abuse (Hunter, 1990a). The psychological "air"
that a child breathes provides the nutrients on which his psyche
grows; if this "air" which surrounds him is contaminated,
his psyche will be forced to accommodate to this polluted atmosphere.
In the same way that lead in inner city environments poisons children's
neurological systems, so does repeated sexual abuse distort their
relationships with self and others.
The Type Of Activities Which Constitute The Abuse
The use of force tends to exacerbate the impact of the sexual abuse
(Pierce, 1987; Urquiza & Capra, 1990). Threats of violence or
acts of violence, threaten not only the psychological health of
a child, but also his physical existence. A child's powerlessness,
helplessness and rage are greater when an offender overpowers him
with physical force.
In some cases of ritual abuse, a victim has been forced to be an
active participant in abhorrent rituals (such as when he is forced
to hold the knife that performs a ritual sacrifice). Often the victim
will forget that adults forced or coerced him to comply with their
plans and he is overcome with self-blame and self-loathing or represses
his cognitive memories of the event. Generally, "In most cases
the more deviant the sexual act, the greater the negative impact."
(Hunter, 1990a, p. 46).
The Nature Of The Relationship Between The Offender And The
Victim
Offenders can be complete strangers or the most intimate of family
members. Because of the greater intensity of interaction when the
offender is a family member or a close friend, the victim's betrayal
is also greater. A victim's loyalties to his family members are
generally more complex than they are to strangers, so when he is
abused by a family member the breach of trust is more highly charged.
Family members often continue to be significant in the victim's
life and they are not easily avoided or forgotten; hence if the
abuse is intrafamilial the victim's sense of loss, grief and betrayal
is more severe. A victim who was seduced by a family member who
was gentle and kind during the abuse often reports greater difficulty
processing his residual feelings than does a victim who was forcefully
raped by a stranger.
Seductive abuse strategies utilized by someone with whom the victim
had an ongoing relationship create confusion and ambivalence about
the nature of the abuse for the victim. Intrafamilial abuse victims
generally have mixed loyalties to their abuser(s); their ambivalent
feelings of caring for the abuser(s) at the same time as being fearful
or rageful about his or her abusive actions can create ongoing patterns
of unstable relationships. As Dimock (1988) states:
" ...[For many male survivors] vulnerability becomes associated
with the powerlessness they experienced as a child when someone
more powerful took advantage of them. [In adult relationships]
they
are unable to separate these past experiences from the present
and [they] react emotionally as if they were still powerless when
they feel vulnerable." (Dimock, 1988, p. 217).
The Number And Gender Of Offenders Involved In The Abuse
'The greater the number of adults who take part in the actual abuse
the more likely the child is to form a view of the world as inhabited
only by dangerous peoples (Hunter, 1990a, p. 48). If, as in ritual
abuse, large parts of the child's world revolve around the abuse
and its secretive nature, the child comes to believe that there
is no other reality. Similarly, if both men and women offend against
a child, he feels less safe than if only one gender abused him.
Men who have had multiple perpetrators generally have greater difficulty
healing; the dynamics of the abuse are more complex and the process
of recovery is slower.
The Manner In Which Disclosure Of The Abuse Occurred
In general, when a victim is able to voluntarily disclose his abuse
or regains his memories of the abuse in a gradual manner, it is
less stressful than if the disclosure is involuntary or abrupt.
(Kilgore, 1988). If disclosure occurs when a victim is still living
at home, the reactions of family members will be very important.
If family members deny or refute the occurrence of the abuse, the
victim's sense of helplessness and hopelessness may be augmented.
If on the other hand a victim is believed and supported, his recovery
from the sexual trauma is assisted.
A victim's developmental stage influences the manner in which he
discloses his abuse and his abilities to process others' reactions
to his disclosure. Younger children often disclose by re-enacting
abusive behaviours; adolescents may disclose indirectly by telling
a good friend, who in turn tells a trusted authority figure. Adults
tend to be more direct in their disclosure, once they acknowledge
their abuse to themselves. In general, the sooner a victim discloses
his abuse and receives treatment for its negative impacts, the easier
his recovery.
It is not uncommon for child victims to retract their abuse disclosures
because the family pressures evoked by the disclosure process are
so horrendous. (Summit, 1983). Children are motivated to disclose
by desires to have the abusive behaviour stop or in order to protect
the safety of another child; they are rarely prepared for the investigation
process that police and child protection agencies are required to
conduct or for the upheaval in the family structure that often results.
Other Attenuating Circumstances In The Victim's Life
Sexual abuse is not the only event that occurs in a child's life.
If it is only a minor occurrence in the midst of other relatively
benign experiences, it will have less impact than if it is one part
of a potpourri of physical and emotional abuse and neglect. Three
factors that affect a child's abilities to recover from sexual abuse
are:
"(1) the basic constitutional characteristics of the child
(for example, temperament, high self-esteem and internal locus
of control); (2) a supportive family environment (warmth, nurturence,
organization and so on); and (3) a supportive individual or agency
that provides a primary support system to assist the child in
coping and in developing a positive model for identification."
(Urquiza & Capra, 1990, p. 129).
Effects of Sexual Abuse On Male Survivors
Sexual abuse is a multi-layered assault that is often accompanied
by other forms of abuse and neglect. Therefore to isolate single
symptoms or to overlook the interrelated nature of the symptoms
that result from sexual abuse, is to present an inaccurate picture
of most survivors' experience.
This text examines the impacts of sexual abuse on male victims
from a clinical view point. General post-abuse symptoms are examined
before more complex abuse-specific symptoms, such as dissociation,
are reviewed. I'll discuss the typical effects of sexual abuse on
males under the following headings:
- physical impacts;
- mental impacts;
- emotional impacts;
- Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and dissociation;
- difficulties with male gender identity;
- sexual orientation confusion and homophobia;
- abuse-reactive perpetration and aggression;
- sexual compulsions and addictions; and
- interpersonal difficulties.
Physical Impacts
Children generally lack a vocabulary to tell others of their abuse
experiences or of the impact of those experiences on them. They
will tend to "show" others their experience, by reenacting
it or by other behavioral indicators. It is quite common for boys
who have been abused to have nightmares and sleep disturbances,
to be encopretic or enuretic or to display other physical symptoms
of distress. (Urquiza & Capra, 1990). Chronic somatic complaints
for which there are no apparent organic cause can be indicators
of abuse.
Some victims develop disgust and self-hatred for their physical
selves. (Hunter, 1990; Myers, 1989). Boys often feel betrayed by
their bodies which have responded to the perpetrator's sexual overtures;
their internal feelings of confusion or fear or anger were in conflict
with their physical arousal. This contempt for the physical self
manifests in a variety of ways, such as neglecting one's physical
needs (e.g., over or under-eating, not attending to medical needs)
or self-abuse.
Self-abusive behaviours can take a variety of forms - a readiness
to take unsafe physical risks (e.g., reckless driving, unsafe sexual
practices, etc.), alcohol or drug addictions or active self-mutilation
are some of the more common ones. Self-mutilation is often "an
attempt to block or interrupt negative cognitions or feelings...and
thus may be an attempt to survive incapacitating symptoms.... "
(Briere, 1989, p. 27). It is not uncommon for survivors to display
their self-hatred and despair in suicidal ideation or in actual
suicide attempts. (Dixon, 1978; McCormack, Janus & Burgess,
1986).
Self-harming behaviours can indicate a variety of different dynamics
and you must examine each client's personal beliefs in order to
understand the metaphoric significance of his behaviour. For example,
with clients who have Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD), self-harming
behaviour may be the domain of a particular personality; unless
you work with that specific personality, the client may not be able
to access the emotions that fuel the self-harming actions.
When sexuality has been the way to meet a variety of non-sexual
needs, a survivor may view his body and his sexuality as commodities
to trade for money or lodging. Such behaviour may become part of
a survivor's lifestyle. Male prostitutes and male runaways who learned
as child victims of sexual abuse that their sexuality can be a means
of gaining power and resources resort to using their bodies as a
means of obtaining a livelihood. (McCormack, Janus & Burgess,
1986).
To be a male victim is a counter-cultural experience since men
are not generally seen as vulnerable and powerless. Some male victims
fear that their vulnerability is transparent and that even perfect
strangers can see they have been victimized and are therefore flawed.
Sometimes they become involved in counter-phobic activities such
as body building and athletic activities, not for a love of sport,
but as a way of becoming more powerful and hiding their "weaknesses".
Mental Impacts
One of the most common cognitive distortions displayed by survivors
is that they hold themselves responsible for having been abused.
(Briere et al., 1988; McCormack, Janus & Burgess, 1986; Myers,
1987; Nielsen, 1983; Vander May, 1988). Children have a limited
understanding of the interpersonal dynamics in which they participate.
When they are abused or neglected, they understand this as being
the result of inadequacies in themselves, rather than as the result
of inadequacies in the adults who are abusing or neglecting them.
(Leehan & Wilson, 1985). This tendency to self-blame is often
exacerbated by the abuser, who may say "You made me do this..."
or "I'm doing this because I love you..." or "If
you weren't so sexy, I wouldn't have to do this...".
Many survivors, as adults, need assistance in understanding that
a child is not responsible for the behaviour of an adult, under
any circumstances. Survivors often look back on their abuse history
and project adult values and judgements onto their own involvement
in the experience; they forget that as children they were not sufficiently
mentally or emotionally mature to make decisions about the ethics
of their sexual behaviour. Helping a survivor to see himself as
the child that he was at the time of the abuse can often reduce
his sense of having been responsible for it.
Survivors commonly repress abuse-related memories or deny the impact
of having been abused. (Briere, 1989). Usually they developed these
mental defences at the time of the abuse in an attempt to cope with
the dissonant events in their lives. For instance, in cases of intrafamilial
abuse, many child victims were placed in the dilemma of being abused
by people who also expressed love and caring towards them. Trying
to understand this discordant behaviour, the child may have found
that by denying or unconsciously repressing his abuse memories,
he could tolerate his life situation.
Survivors often exhibit patterns of learned helplessness and passivity.
(Blanchard, 1986; Briere, 1989).
"Although the victim mentality begins as a useful childhood
coping mechanism, when it continues into adulthood, it becomes
obsolete. The victimized person has become an adult, with the
choices and power of a man, but he continues to think of himself
as little, helpless and at fault for all the mistreatment he receives.
He goes through his adult life training others to treat him poorly
by being passive and not standing up for himself.... The abuse
was a normal part of his childhood and nobody did anything to
stop it, so he thinks that abuse is a normal, acceptable part
of life." (Hunter, 1990a. p. 71-72).
Survivors who believe they're responsible for their abuse and unable
to do anything to change their life experience, often have very
low self-esteem. (Nielsen, 1983). They believe that the treatment
they received from adults was what they deserved and the world has
nothing better to offer them. This hopelessness and helplessness
can become a self-fulfilling prophecy if the survivor does not find
a way to change these inner beliefs.
Emotional Impacts
Men in our culture have, until recently, received little support
for the outward expression of their feelings. Survivors have often
been encouraged by their socialization to suppress or repress their
affect. Many male survivors are unable to identify, acknowledge
or disclose their feelings; they experience affective numbness.
(Hunter, 1990a; Leehan & Wilson, 1985). Some homophobic men
believe that only homosexual men express emotion and they develop
a stoic persona to confirm their "masculinity".
Some men are unaware of their emotions and they develop addictive
behaviours to ensure that these emotions are suppressed. (Urquiza
& Capra, 1990). Addictions are unconscious secondary emotional
processes that temporarily block out primary affect. The compulsive
nature of addictive behaviour is so engrossing and temporarily satisfying
that it masks the deeper emotional reality that underlies it.
Many survivors exhibit substance addictions and their relationship
to alcohol, drugs or food can consume much of their mental and emotional
energy. Other survivors develop process addictions and their relationships
with work, sports, sex or other endeavours exhibit obsessive and
addictive patterns. In this way, their work or their interest in
sports, becomes all consuming because it takes on the secondary
function of acting as a barrier to emotional processing. Process
addictions are often socially well received and may earn a survivor
the respect of his boss or his teammates. It is not usually apparent
to the people who benefit from the survivor's process addictions
that his activity is in fact driven by a need to block emotional
awareness.
When a survivor is in touch with his emotions, he is likely to
experience feelings of anxiety and fear, depression, guilt, anger,
rage and shame. (Blanchard, 1986; Briere, 1989; Bruckner & Johnson,
1987; Constantine, 1979; Hunter, 1990a; Nielsen, 1983; Olsen, 1990;
Pierce, 1987; Schacht, Kerlinsky & Carlson, 1990; Vander May,
1988; Urquiza & Capra, 1990).
Initially anger is the emotion that survivors often feel most comfortable
expressing. (Dimock, 1988). Men's rage is often connected to the
homosexuality of the abuse, rather than to its expletive aspects.
Anger is powerful and energy-filled and it is an affective state
that is egosyntonic with masculine cultural roles. Anger and rage
can become a "catch all" emotion for male victims. Because
it is an active emotion, expressing anger feels more acceptable
than displaying more vulnerable emotions.
Not all male survivors experience anger at having been abused.
Many have difficulty accessing and expressing their rage. For many
men, anger is associated with violence. Many survivors are afraid
that if they contact their angry feelings, they will express them
violently. Other survivors adopt a "victim" stance in
their lives and respond to having been exploited with passivity
and withdrawal.
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) And Dissociation
People working in the rape-crisis movement, the Vietnam War veterans
movement and the child sexual abuse movement have pooled their knowledge
to create an understanding of the effects of severe trauma on its
victims. This combined knowledge has become known as the study of
posttraumatic stress. It has provided very helpful conceptualizations
for those who work with survivors of natural disasters, wars, hostage-takings,
rape and, most recently, sexual abuse.
Victims of sexual abuse share many issues in common with victims
of other disasters. These include:
- they didn't choose the frequency or duration of the traumatic
event;
- their personal resources were overwhelmed by powerful, negative
forces;
- their physical and psychological safety was threatened;
- they didn't know when their environment was safe and when it
wasn't;
- their efforts to talk about the trauma with others are often
met with incredulity and insufficient understanding, which results
in emotional isolation, confusion and shame; and
- they're unable to process the trauma emotionally until they
feel physically and psychologically safe. (Briere, 1989; Evans,
1990).
The etiological features of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
provoke a variety of coping strategies by which a victim attempts
to preserve his integrity. The most common PTSD symptoms include
flashbacks and reexperiencing the trauma (Briere, 1989), a general
numbing of mental and affective responsiveness (Blanchard, 1986;
Briere, 1989; Myers, 1989), hypervigilance (Blanchard, 1986; Briere,
1989) and a variety of dissociative responses (Briere, 1989; Evans,
1990; Hunter, 1990a; Nielsen, 1983).
Flashbacks can involve any or all of a survivor's five senses
which have either consciously or unconsciously encoded memory of
the abuse. (Briere, 1989). Often survivors report vague recurrent
body sensations for which they have no conscious cognitive memory.
These sensations or memories occur when the survivor is triggered
by either internal or external stimuli which evoke the original
trauma. For instance, a survivor whose abuse included posing for
pornographic pictures may experience a flashback that's triggered
by the appearance of a camera; or a survivor who was left alone
for long periods of time after being abused may flashback to the
abuse experience when he feels isolated or lonely.
The more often a trauma has been repeated and the more intrusive
its nature, the deeper and stronger the survivor's neurological
memory of the event. If a trigger event occurs in the survivor's
current life that recalls previous abusive events, a chain of associations
occurs, usually unconsciously and the client begins to re-experience
the abuse incident. This re-experience will often involve a blurring
between past and present; the survivor unconsciously withdraws from
the present and projects past memories and feelings onto here-and-now
stimuli. This trance-like event is accompanied by decreased sensory
awareness and the survivor generally needs to reconnect with his
present reality in order to move through the flashback.
Repressed memories can return as flashbacks; they can also emerge
in the form of dreams and nightmares. Survivors commonly have dreams
that explicitly recall their abuse or recurrent nightmares of being
pursued that symbolically evoke themes of abuse. (Briere, 1989;
Nielsen, 1983).
Briere defines the common PTSD symptom of emotional numbing
as "... a loss of reactivity, detachment from others and/or
constricted emotionality. (Briere, 1989, p. 8). Male survivors often
report explicit details of their abuse without any emotionality,
as if they were talking about events that had happened to someone
else.
Although emotional distancing has a short-term value as a means
of coping with shock and crisis, if it's sustained over a long period
of time, it separates and isolates the survivor from his full range
of feelings. (Grubman-Black, 1990; Nielsen, 1983). It is quite common
for survivors to be afraid of identifying or expressing their feelings
because they fear that their affective responses will be so intense
that they won't be able to manage them.
Often survivors of trauma and sexual abuse become hypervigilant,
keeping themselves prepared for the next potential assault on their
personhood. (Blanchard, 1986). PTSD is typified by hypertension
and the overactivity of the sympathetic nervous system. Chronic
muscle tension, an inability to sleep, restless, disturbed sleeping
patterns and exaggerated startle responses are typical symptoms
displayed by survivors of sexual trauma. (Nielsen, 1983).
A common reaction to trauma and sexual abuse in particular, is
that the victim dissociates from the experience. A child's body
may remain present during the abuse activities, but his mind and
spirit separate themselves as a means of psychological self-protection.
Some of the symptoms of dissociation that Briere (1989) notes
are cognitive disengagement into seemingly neutral space (better
known as "spacing out"), derealization (the feeling that
things around you are false or unreal), depersonalization (feeling
that you are different from your usual self), out-of-body experiences
(the sensation of floating outside your body and travelling elsewhere)
and circumscribed blanks in otherwise continuous memory.
Dissociative behaviours fall on a continuum from daydreaming to
Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD). Mild forms of dissociation
are common everyday experiences. However, when more extreme dissociative
defences, such as splitting and repression, are used to cope with
stressors, they interfere with a sense of personal integrity.
Many survivors have dissociated their affect from their cognitive
memory. Others have a vague, uneasy feeling that they were abused,
but they cannot recollect specific abusive events. In either case,
the survivor often feels crazy and partialized. Therapy has the
task of helping him to reintegrate the full spectrum of his experience.
When a victim is abused at a young age and the abuse is severe
and prolonged and has involved several different offenders, it is
not uncommon for a victim to develop highly dissociative defences,
such as MPD. MPD is a sophisticated unconscious defence in which
the psyche paradoxically attempts to protect its coherence by partializing
its various components. Subpersonalities serve the MPD system by
taking on the tasks of protectors, aggressors or victims. Generally,
the subpersonalities are very distinct from one another, with very
different traits and characteristics. Memories held by each subpersonality
are not shared with the other parts of the system; hence, survivors
with MPD often have apparent memory loss or have been told by others
about actions they did, but don't remember doing.
Difficulties With Male Gender Identity
Our culture has created a social mythology which expects men to
be in control, self-sufficient and powerful. Men are not supposed
to need assistance in coping with their feelings. Expressions such
as "big boys don't cry" encourage males to hide their
vulnerability. Successful men in our culture are portrayed as heterosexual,
as sexual initiators and as protectors of themselves and others.
For male survivors, the social prescription for successful manhood
directly conflicts with their experience. Often survivors rewrite
their abuse history, forgetting that they were powerless children
at the time. They project their mature identities onto their memories
of the abuse and hold themselves responsible for not having stopped
their offender from abusing them. As a result of abuse, many men
report "...damage to their subjective sense of maleness or
masculinity... ." (Myers, 1989, p. 210).
Certain social attitudes increase a male survivor's alienation
from a healthy masculine gender identity; when a survivor's disclosure
of abuse is met with questions such as "Are you an offender?"
or "Are you gay?", his sense of being flawed is confirmed.
(Dimock, 1988; Myers, 1989). Prevalent among survivors is the feeling:
"that they responded sexually in circumstances in which
a normal man would have been impotent. As a result, they came
to regard themselves as abnormal, which in turn kindled or rekindled
feelings of inadequacy as a man." (Sarrel & Masters,
1982, p. 127).
In the course of therapy, male survivors need to examine how their
ability to claim their own authentic masculinity is limited by cultural
factors. Grubman-Black (1990) says therapists can help clients develop
a positive masculine gender identity by recognizing that rigid ideas
about gender roles and stereotypes based on inadequate information
are responsible for some of a survivor's personal suffering in the
aftermath of abuse. Therapists can help victims to be aware that
today there are new and emerging definitions of masculinity that
affirm emotional expression and incorporate vulnerability.
Sexual Orientation Contusion And Homophobia
Many male survivors have been abused by a male offender and this
inevitably raises questions for the survivor about his sexual orientation
and masculinity. He may be confused about whether his natural sexual
orientation is heterosexual, homosexual or bisexual. (Bruckner &
Johnson, 1987; Dimock, 1988; Hunter, 1990a; Myers, 1989). Questions
and concerns about sexual orientation are often a core issue for
male survivors. They may express confusion about their natural sexual
inclination: Dimock (1988) says that many survivors engage in sexual
activity with a partner of the sex opposite to their stated sexual
orientation or are unable to state their sexual preference.
Generally, victims have been physiologically aroused by the offender's
stimulation of their genitals. Often the sexual abuse is a victim's
first orgasmic experience with another person. In attempting to
understand their experience, many victims will use external cues
(i.e. physical arousal and orgasm) rather than internal cues (i.e.
emotional discomfort and confusion) in their attempts to identify
sexual preference and orientation. They develop a belief that "...
arousal equals pleasure and pleasure equals complicity". (Gerber,
1990, p. 173).
Children are not aware that many men who engage in same-sex behaviours
are not homosexual. They do not analyze their experience in relation
to power and control issues. Often a child will have understood
his experience of being abused as a homosexual experience rather
than as an abusive experience. He will see the perpetrator as being
"a gay man who was being sexual with a child" rather than
as "a child molester who was sexually using a child to meet
primarily non-sexual needs".
All survivors ask the questions "Why did this happen to me
and not someone else?", "What does having been sexually
abused say about me and my sexuality?" and "Why was I
chosen?" For survivors who were abused by a same-sex offender
there are further questions. Homosexual men will tend to ask themselves
"Am I gay because of having been abused?" or "Was
I abused because I am gay?" Heterosexual men will wonder "If
I was abused by a man, does this mean that I am really gay?"
Our society is very homophobic. Both heterosexual and homosexual
men who have grown up in this culture have internalized homophobic
beliefs. For gay men, the "coming out" process can be
more difficult if they are survivors of sexual abuse because of
their own uncertainty about the impact of the abuse on their sexual
orientation. Their families and friends may discount their sexual
orientation and dismiss it by saying "He's gay because he was
sexually abused". Their own internalized homophobia may encourage
them to see their abuse as having determined their sexual orientation,
because they can then believe that recovery from the abuse will
include a "cure" for being gay.
At the present time, there is no predictable relationship between
sexual orientation and childhood sexual abuse. Some researchers
have shown "a statistically strong...relationship between childhood
sexual abuse and homosexual activity in adulthood' (Dimock, 1988,
p. 205), but whether this demonstrates cause, effect or correlation
is unknown.
There is some evidence that boys who are marginalized are more
vulnerable to being abused. (Finkelhor, 1984). To the extent that
boys who depart from traditional masculine identifies (i.e. boys
who don't like sports, who are feeling-oriented, etc.) are more
marginalized, they may be more likely to be abused. Research into
this aspect of abuse is fraught with political and ethical concerns
and the researcher runs the risk of being seen as anti-gay and homophobic.
(Hunter, 1990a).
Clearly therapists (be they male, female, homosexual or heterosexual)
have an obligation to become aware of their own biases regarding
sexism, racism, classism and sexual orientation. While we are aware
that sexual orientation ranges from heterosexuality, through bisexuality,
to homosexuality, our knowledge and understanding about it focuses
on the poles of heterosexuality and homosexuality. How the continuum
between these two poles is affected by innate, situational or transitional
variables is not well understood. Clinicians need to pursue further
research into the interface between sexual abuse and subsequent
sexual identity.
Therapists must ensure that their clients' interests, not their
own, are served by the balance between therapeutic and political
concerns that occurs in therapy sessions. To optimize the usefulness
of the therapeutic process for clients, therapists need to become
consciously aware of their own cultural and political biases and
how these affect their interventions with clients.
Abuse-Reactive Perpetration And Aggression
Victims appear to have three typical unconscious responses to the
experience of sexual victimization.
1. The child knows what it feels like to be a victim and unconsciously
decides "This is who I am." He accepts his victimization
experience as a reflection of his self-worth, never defines his
boundaries and limits and is repeatedly revictimized.
2. The child knows what it feels like to be a victim, and unconsciously
decides "I'll protect others from ever becoming victims."
He pursues this belief by giving others the help and protection
he never received himself.
3. The child knows what it feels like to be a victim and unconsciously
decides "I'll never be a victim again." His way of regaining
power is to identify with the aggressor and use abusive strategies
to meet his needs.
Although male survivors can adopt more than one of these responses,
identification with one position usually predominates. Many survivors,
even if their primary identification is as a victim or protector,
worry that they will also become a perpetrator. Bruckner & Johnson
(1987) point out that it's quite common for survivors to feel afraid
of becoming sexual with children or to feel guilty for having had
sexual experiences with children when they were adolescents.
Obviously, not all victims become sexual offenders and not all
sexual offenders were victims of sexual abuse. Certain factors lessen
the likelihood that a victim will become a victimizer. Having a
strong sense of self prior to the abuse experience, having a relationship
with positive male role models, having supportive interpersonal
relationships and developing an awareness of healthy sexual expression
are some of the factors that reduce the likelihood of a victim becoming
an offender. (Gerber, 1990).
Some victims of abuse unconsciously internalize the behaviour of
their offender. Social learning theory suggests that modelling and
vicarious learning play a large part in how social behaviours are
shaped and expressed. For some victims, acting abusively becomes
a defence against being a victim, since they believe that it is
better to be powerful than weak and that you need to control others
to be powerful. Identification with the aggressor may lead some
survivors to acts of abuse against others as a maladaptive means
of meeting their needs to be powerful. (Gerber, 1990). It may represent
a misguided counter-phobic attempt to understand and gain mastery
over their victimization experience. (Hunter, 1990a).
Male socialization encourages action and tolerates aggression in
ensuring need gratification. For some survivors, their limited repertoire
of skills to meet their needs results in using controlling and manipulative
behaviours with others. Bruckner and Johnson (1987) note that members
of male survivor groups often admit to sexual aggression with adult
partners, to physical assault of partners and to general manipulation
of relationships.
When survivors have themselves perpetrated against others a thorough
assessment is needed to ascertain whether this behaviour is a patterned,
predatory, deliberate grooming process or whether it is an isolated
abuse-reactive experience resulting from behaviourial experimentation
or behaviour replication. It is not within the scope of this text
to address the assessment and treatment for repeat sexual offenders.
However, given that some survivors will have engaged in abuse-reactive
perpetration, some issues associated with offending behaviour will
be discussed.
Often survivors who have engaged in abuse-reactive sexual activity
as adolescents feel greatly ashamed of this behaviour. This double-layered
shame, about being both a victim and a victimizer, must be addressed.
Survivors often need to have their offending behaviour contextualized
vis-a-vis their own victimization. This is not an attempt to excuse
this behaviour, but rather a strategy to reduce the client's shame
about it. Reducing the level of shame empowers the client to move
into feeling appropriately guilty and taking responsibility for
having offended, thus becoming accountable for his behaviour.
Survivors need to know that a child who has been prematurely sexually
awakened has his sexual energy operating without adequate judgement
and maturity. As he matures, a survivor will have to examine his
early sexual experience and possibly correct some unconscious dysfunctional
patterns. The survivor's need to be powerful and to express his
rage at having been victimized will have to be channelled into non-abusive
behaviours.
Survivors who are both victims and victimizers present a challenge
to many mental health professionals. Therapists are often confronted
with the limitations of their fondly held theories about victims
and offenders. (Gerber, 1990). When the boundary between victims
and offenders becomes blurred, models of treatment which focus exclusively
on victimization or offending processes as discrete events are no
longer as useful. Many agencies separate services to victims and
offenders; clients who fit both categories create a service delivery
dilemma.
Sexual Addictions And Compulsions
Sexual behaviour has a strong inherent reinforcer - namely sexual
arousal and orgasm. Victims' sexual arousal patterns are conditioned
by sexual abuse; by definition, sexual abuse creates dysfunctional
conditioning. Since young children do not have the emotional, cognitive
or social orientation with which to make meaning of adult sexual
experience their abusive sexual initiation can establish patterns
of arousal and sexualized coping behaviours that can be dysfunctional
in later developmental stages.
Friedrich, Beilke and Urquiza (1988) compared the behaviour of
two groups of young boys aged three to eight years of age. One group
was conduct disordered and the other was sexually abused. They found
that they could discriminate who was in which group with a relatively
high degree of accuracy. The variable that contributed most to this
discrimination was sex problems. The sexually abused boys were significantly
more sexualized as a group. The sexual behaviour of these young
boys included excessive masturbation, a preoccupation with sex and
re-enacting their abuse with siblings. Unless victims such as these
young boys receive abuse-focused counselling at the time of disclosure,
their sexuality will develop in ways that reflects their initial
abusive sexual experience.
For males in our culture, the first orgasm is a rite of passage
and signifies entry into manhood. When this orgasm occurs in the
context of an abusive interaction, it is imbued with problematic
associations such as power, non-mutual exchange and sometimes violence.
Some survivors have built masturbatory fantasies and rituals around
the experience of their abuse and are aroused by aggressive, violent
or exploitative sexual activities.
The pairing of secrecy and sexual arousal often leave a victim
feeling very ashamed of his sexuality, especially if he senses that
his sexual expression is deviant. Some survivors are unaware that
their sexual behaviour has been shaped by abuse processes and they
believe that they are misfits or weird or crazy because of the nature
of their sexual desires and expression.
There is often an analogous pattern between a victim's abuse experience
and his subsequent sexual expression. For instance, if the abuse
experience involved acts of violence and sadism, the victim's subsequent
sexual expression may well replicate aspects of this violence. Because
of the shame surrounding this behaviour, a survivor will generally
be very reluctant to let others know about his sexuality.
Many survivors report compulsive sexual behaviours such as frequent
non-relational sexual activities with others or compulsive masturbation.
"Compulsive sexual behaviour may be simply defined as a
lack of control over one or more specific sexual activities. Such
activities are most often ego-alien and the individual feels shame
and remorse after engaging in such behaviours. In spite of a desire
to stop, he is unable to, even when it's clear that he may be
causing himself or others harm." (Dimock, 1988, p. 207).
Like other addictions, sexual addictions are usually a misguided
attempt on the part of the survivor to self-medicate. Compulsive
sexual behaviours are used to block states of mind (e.g. anxiety)
that are intolerable to the survivor. For some survivors, sexual
addictions are used to replace sexual intimacy. Masturbating with
pornographic material is less threatening than having to relate
sexually with a partner, especially since interactive sexual situations
will often bring back memories of the abuse, either consciously
or unconsciously. (Hunter, 1990a). In some cases, survivors attempt
to manage their sexual discomfort by completely avoiding sexual
contact with others. (Bruckner & Johnson, 1987).
In order for the client to be able to change his addictive behaviour,
he needs to become aware of his addictive cycle. Becoming familiar
with the sequencing of his compulsive behaviour and the states of
mind that precede his addictive behaviours, helps a survivor to
decode his compulsive actions and to develop functional behavioral
substitutes.
Interpersonal Difficulties
Sexual abuse is a human-induced trauma and it has long-lasting
repercussions on subsequent human relationships. In young children,
abuse-related reactions include aggression towards others, delinquency
and non-compliance. (McCormack, Janus & Burgess, 1986; Schacht,
Kerlinsky & Carlson, 1990; Urquiza & Capra, 1990). Often
Victims of abuse have mixed loyalties to the abuser; although they
may have disliked the one-sided aspect of the sexual relationship,
they may have liked the perpetrator's attention and interest. (Blanchard,
1986; Hunter, 1990a; Nielsen, 1893). These mixed loyalties can later
manifest as an inability to distinguish between sexuality and affection,
trust and exploitation and safe or abusive relationships. (Briere,
1989).
Victims of abuse can experience difficulty in initiating, developing
and maintaining close interpersonal intimate relationships. (Urquiza
& Capra, 1990). Often the betrayal of trust that is inherent
in sexual abuse leads the victim to withdraw from interpersonal
relationships. This social isolation exaggerates the victim's stigmatization
and leaves him less able to successfully integrate the psychosocial
crisis of abuse. (Briere, 1989; Leehan & Wilson, 1985).
Researchers and clinicians have noted that survivors of sexual
abuse are more likely to be revictimized in subsequent relationships.
(Briere, 1989; Dimock, 1988; Hunter, 1990a; Myers, 1989; Nielsen,
1983). The dynamics of this revictimization process are complex.
Some victims are not well attuned to the danger signals that indicate
potentially abusive situations: either they dissociate in the face
of them, entering a passive ego state in which their abilities to
protect themselves are absent or these signals are so much part
of their normal experience that they can't imagine non-abusive interpersonal
interactions. Other victims have difficulty discerning their personal
boundaries and limits and are unable to identify the times when
their needs for safety are not being met.
One reaction to childhood victimization is that victims become
hypervigilant to the moods and behaviours of other significant people
in their environment. (Blanchard, 1986; Briere, 1989). As a child,
attempting to predict when an abusive event was likely to occur
gave the child a marginal sense of control. Learning to read the
abuser's state of mind and moods was an integral part of developing
this false sense of control. This initially safety-based behaviour
becomes dysfunctional in later adult relationships when a survivor
cannot identify his own internal experience and is focused on the
internal state of the significant others in his life. His sense
of self worth becomes distorted and his own behaviour is shaped
in reaction to others rather than in response to his own needs.
Survivors' interactive sexual behaviour is often very problematic.
(Blanchard, 1986; Briere, 1989; Myers, 1989; Nielsen, 1983; Sarrel
& Masters, 1982). A variety of sexual dysfunctions, such as
a lack of desire, problems with erection or dissociation during
sexual activities can haunt a survivor.
Sexual abuse generally accelerates, retards or convolutes
a child's sexual development. As an abuse victim matures, his psychosexual
development will reflect his abuse-related experience. In adult
relationships, sexual partners will sometimes carry the survivor's
unconscious projections from his abuse experience and this can be
confusing and distressing for both people until such time as these
projections can be identified and addressed. For example, if an
offender rewarded a victim with post-abuse gifts, as an adult the
victim may react negatively to any gifts he receives from his lovers.
This may be confusing for his lover who expects gifts to produce
enjoyment, and also confusing for the survivor who cannot understand
his own response to his lover's behaviour.
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN MALE AND FEMALE SURVIVORS
OF SEXUAL ABUSE
Current research indicates that there are some significant differences
between the sexual victimization of boys and girls. These differences
exist both in the nature of the abuse experience itself and in how
this experience is understood and integrated.
Information about the differences between male and female survivors
will be presented in the following manner: First, I'll discuss the
research findings about these differences; second, I'll describe
some of the contributors' observations about the ways client gender
affects the therapeutic process.
Determining the prevalence rates of the sexual victimization of
boys and girls is fraught with complexities. Current research studies
indicate that in absolute numbers, more girls than boys are sexually
abused. (Bruckner & Johnson, 1987; Finklehor, 1984; Fritz, Stoll
& Wagner, 1981; Vander May, 1988). It remains to be seen whether
these findings will change as social conditions permit men to acknowledge
their victimization experiences.
Research findings consistently note that boys and girls experience
sexual abuse differently. Males often frame sexual abuse as a sexual
initiation, rather than as a violation of their personhood. (Condy
et al., 1987; Constantine, 1979; Finklehor, 1984; Fritz, Stoll &
Wagner, 1981; Risin & Koss, 1987; Sandfort, 1984; Tindall, 1978).
According to Fritz, Stoll and Wagner (1981), females tended to assign
a decidedly harmful, negative quality to their pre-pubescent sexual
experience, while males were neutral or even positive about it.
The difference in victims' perceptions of their sexual abuse is
shaped by many factors, including gender socialization, the different
physiological responses of the sexes and culturally determined expressions
of sexuality. Although male victims may not perceive their abuse
as negative, this does not mean that they weren't negatively affected.
As Finklehor (1984) discovered in his investigation of male survivors,
boys were more likely than girls to cite interest and pleasure as
their immediate reaction to being sexually abused. However, when
he looked at the long-term effects of abuse as measured by its impact
on sexual self-esteem, Finklehor noted that the boys were affected
as much, if not more, than the girls.
Male victims are more often homosexually abused than female victims.
(Finklehor, 1984; Fritz, Stoll & Wagner, 1981; Risin & Koss,
1987). The reality of victimization is that boys, like girls, are
most commonly victimized by men.
Researchers have found that female victims are more often abused
by family members, while boys are more frequently the victims of
extrafamilial abusers. (Finklehor, 1984; Fritz, Stoll & Wagner,
1981; Pierce & Pierce, 1985; Risin & Koss, 1987; Vander
May, 1988). Statistically, boys are at greater risk of being abused
by teachers, coaches, babysitters and other adult authority figures
than by members of their own family. However empirical research
shows that the absolute number of boys who are sexually abused within
the family is still very high.
Male victims live in single parent, mother-headed households more
frequently than do female victims. (Pierce & Pierce, 1985; Vander
May, 1988). Many male victims lack an active male parent or nurturing,
protective male model.
It is more common for boys to be abused in conjunction with other
children; girls are more likely to be sexually abused in isolation.
In cases where the abuse is intrafamilial, the chances of a boy
being one of several victims are greater. (Finklehor, 1984; Fritz,
Stoll & Wagner, 1981; Dixon, Arnold & Calestro, 1978; Pierce
& Pierce, 1985; Vander May, 1988).
"If a girl is abused by a parent, in 65% of the reports
she will be the only reported victim.
If a boy is abused, 60% of the time there will be another victim."
(Finklehor, 1984, p. 164).
Boys who are sexually abused are also more likely to be physically
abused than girls. (Finklehor, 1984; Dixon, Arnold & Calestro,
1978; Vander May, 1988). Not only are male sexual abuse victims
at greater risk of being physically abused, it is also more likely
that their sexual abuse will be violent. Pierce and Pierce (1985)
found that the use of force and threats occurred significantly more
often with boys than with girls.
The types of activities that constitute abuse differ between male
and female victims. (Pierce & Pierce, 1985; Risin & Koss,
1987). Male victims are much more frequently the victims of sodomy
and are more frequently participants in mutual masturbation. In
addition, male victims experience orgasm more frequently during
the abuse experience. (Fritz, Stoll & Wagner, 1978). One research
study conducted by Pierce and Pierce (1985) found that perpetrators
engaged in oral intercourse more often with boys [52% of the boys
and 17% of the girls were engaged in oral sex]. The same study found
that 40% of the perpetrators masturbated the male victim, which
is higher than the equivalent statistic for female victims. However,
boys were fondled much less frequently than girls.
Male victims are less likely to talk about their victimization
experiences with family members than are female victims. (Fritz,
Stoll, & Wagner, 1978; Risin & Koss, 1987). Upon disclosure
of the abuse, if the male victim is still a juvenile, his abuse
is more likely to be reported to the police than to a child protection
agency; if R is reported to protective services, the male victim
is less likely to be placed in protective custody. (Finklehor, 1984;
Pierce & Pierce, 1985; Vander May, 1988). After disclosure,
male victims are less likely to receive counselling than female
victims and when they do, the average length of treatment is shorter.
(Vander May, 1988).
The clinicians interviewed for this book were quick to point out
that the clinical differences between male and female victims of
sexual abuse are few compared to the similarities. Both male and
female victims of sexual trauma feel isolated and marginalized.
Both struggle with low self-esteem and a damaged sense of self.
Ultimately, healing and recovery for both male and female victims
involves embracing all aspects of one's humanity, a process which
goes beyond gender.
A difference between the genders that contributors frequently commented
upon is the reluctance that male victims display about acknowledging
their victimization. Men have greater shame attached to their victimization
than women do; being a victim is a counter-cultural experience for
a man. Admitting to having been victimized, to having been a powerless
child, is more difficult for men. Some men completely refuse to
open the door to their memories and feelings, saying "My childhood
experience is in the past". This difficulty in breaking silence
and disclosing abuse-related history to others results in fewer
men than women seeking professional assistance to help them heal
from their traumatic experiences. When men do come into therapy,
fewer of them identify their history of having been abused as a
presenting problem. Many victims of abuse seek counselling for relationship
problems or sexual problems and have not made a cognitive connection
between their present problems and their victimization history.
Contributors have observed that male survivors tend to identify
sexual concerns (i.e. sexual dysfunctions, sexual orientation issues
or gender identity issues) as presenting issues more frequently
than female survivors. Women survivors also have sexuality issues,
but these are infrequently their dominant presenting concerns; when
these issues surface during the course of therapy, they have a different
focus than male victim's sexual concerns.
It is suggested that our culture encourages men to use sexuality,
particularly their genitally-focused sexuality, as a primary component
of self identify; hence, when this aspect of a man's life is not
functioning well, he struggles with an impaired sense of self. Women
are encouraged to identify with their relationships; for women,
sexuality is only one part of other intimate behaviour. Hence, women
are focused less on their sexuality and more on the quality of their
intimate relationships.
The cultural script that supports women to know themselves through
their relationships with others and encourages men to be more self-sufficient
has other implications for abuse survivors. Bruckner and Johnson,
whose experience includes providing group treatment to both male
and female survivors, note that the men tend not to associate with
each other outside the group, whereas the female participants frequently
form relationships. Since isolation is a key issue for male survivors,
encouraging them to risk creating relationships with others, including
fellow group members, can be a critical step in their healing process.
The now common catch-phrase "men act out; women act in"
applies to sexual abuse survivors. Contributors remarked that women
survivors show a greater tendency to be depressed and to engage
in self-harming behaviours, whereas male survivors tend to express
their anger at the abuser and exhibit aggressive tendencies toward
others. Many male survivors sublimate their anger at having been
abused into generalized anti-social behaviour.
In therapy, male survivors tend to be able to contact their anger
and rage at having been abused long before they can feel their grief.
They often display active and violent revenge fantasies. Women survivors,
on the other hand, are initially more in touch with their sadness
and depression and their rage at having been victimized usually
surfaces later in the therapeutic process.
In answer to the question "Do you detect differences in the
dissociation process between male and female survivors?", contributors
gave a variety of responses. Some said they could see no difference.
Others, however, suggested that their male clients are more dissociated
from the affective components of their abuse, while their female
clients are more dissociated from the cognitive components of their
abuse.
Male survivors often tell the story of their abuse quite matter-of-factly,
describing the behaviours involved in the abuse in detail. They
talk about these events as if they happened to someone else, expressing
little affect or compassion. Female survivors generally have more
difficulty recalling the specific events that comprised the abuse
and more difficulty telling others about it. However, they experience
intense feelings related to these events, whether or not they can
accurately recall them.
Therapists who have offered abuse-focused group
treatment to both genders note that the men were more action-oriented
than the women. Because of this readiness to take action, therapists
need to ensure that their male sexual abuse clients are emotionally
prepared for any behaviours which they are planning to undertake.
Premature confrontation of an abuser, or ill-conceived acts of angry
revenge, can be counter-therapeutic.
CHAPTER 3 - TREATMENT MODEL AND STAGES OF HEALING
This chapter presents information about the basic tenets
of therapy with male survivors. It develops a treatment
model which is based on principles of partnership between
the client and therapist and which supports the clients'
innate abilities to recover from sexual abuse. The model
describes four phases of healing, namely Breaking Silence,
The victim Phase, The Survivor Phase and The Thriver Phase.
This four-phase model is used as a framework for presenting
specific therapeutic interventions in subsequent chapters. |
The isomorphic similarity between sexual abuse and therapy was
discussed in the introductory section of this text. Abuse processes
occur over time, in a relationship in which the offender's needs
are given priority over the victim's needs. The abuse-related activities
are kept a secret because of the shame that surrounds them. The
therapeutic process has the potential to replicate these elements
of abuse and to itself become an abusive process. If the therapy
is designed to meet the therapist's needs and not the client's and
if the confidentiality of the process is used to protect the therapist
rather than the client, it can become a counter-productive experience
for the client. The client's belief that people will attempt to
use him for their own ends and that safe, intimate relationships
are not possible, at least for him, will be reinforced.
However, in a manner that echoes the principles of homeopathic
medicine, therapy, because of its structural similarities to the
abuse process, can also heal the wounds caused by abuse. When a
client can proceed through his therapeutic journey with support
to reclaim his own power, therapy can be a powerful tool for recovery.
Successful therapy will allow clients to experience respectful and
non-exploitative power dynamics which support them in reclaiming
the parts of themselves that were lost or damaged because of the
abuse.
The remainder of this book will present information
gleaned from both written resources and the contributors' interviews.
The treatment model that is presented outlines a therapeutic healing
process for male victims of sexual abuse. This chapter discusses
the general principles of this treatment model, describes the general
stages of healing and identifies issues that can hinder the therapeutic
process.
THERAPEUTIC MODEL FOR MALE VICTIMS OF SEXUAL
ABUSE
Describing a general process of recovery or healing is a difficult
task. Every recovered abuse victim has his own story to tell of
this journey. However, in order to work effectively with abuse survivors,
each therapist must develop a generic "map of recovery"
that he or she will use to guide the therapeutic process. Although
this "map" will no doubt be conceptualized in different
ways at different stages of the therapist's career, at any given
time, each therapist needs to be able to articulate the changes
that his interventions are designed to facilitate in his clients.
The model described in this text suggests that healing from sexual
trauma is a process that leads the survivor from a position of making
abuse-reactive life decisions, based on past learning, to a new
position of making pro-active life decisions and choices based on
present needs. As the survivor makes his unconscious coping strategies
conscious, his personal autonomy increases. Flashbacks of the abuse
become reclaimed memories; inexplicable fears and anxieties become
associations to present environmental triggers that echo abuse-related
experiences; and some chronic somatic complaints become the signals
for recognizing unmet physical or emotional needs.
As the survivor decodes his behaviours, thoughts and feelings he
begins to recognize how his belief system was shaped by his victimization,
and his reactions to this experience. This recognition opens the
door for him to develop new life choices and options. The experience
of learning, practising and integrating new attitudes and behaviour
is a spiralling process, not a linear one. Often old patterns have
to be revisited many times before they are replaced with new ones.
However, "With each new cycle, [the survivor's] ...capacity
to feel, to remember, to make lasting changes, is strengthened."
(Bass & Davis, 1988, p. 59).
The effects of sexual abuse are complicated by other forms of neglect
and abuse that were present in the victim's childhood and compounded
by the damage resulting from the development of initially adaptive
but ultimately self-destructive coping behaviours. Trauma of a sexual
nature shames and degrades the victim at the level of his existential
core. Given the complexities of long-term trauma, "...the process
of resolution for child sexual abuse is of a long-term rather than
a short-term nature." (Courtois, 1991, p. 51).
Survivors of abuse can never change the facts of the abuse. They
cannot eradicate the abuse from their personal histories. However
they can change their relationship to this history and they can
change the effects these events have on their lives.
For personal change to be authentic and integrated into a survivor's
life, ample time to test and explore new alternative behaviours
must be present. Contributors generally worked with their survivor
clients for a minimum of a year and often for much longer, in order
to bring about lasting and substantive change.
Not all of a survivor's problems are related to his experience
of childhood sexual abuse. Other life traumas play their part. Therapists
must be discerning in their diagnostic skills; they must take care
not to simplistically attribute their clients' issues solely to
their sexual trauma if this is not an accurate assignation.
Therapy for sexual abuse survivors has many facets.
Reducing a survivor's sense of isolation, facilitating his emotional
discharge, challenging his cognitive distortions, normalizing his
experience and educating him about abuse processes are all part
of the journey. (Briere, 1989). Nurturing his spirituality (using
this word in its most general sense) and rekindling his hope are
also important. By the end of the journey, the survivor is aware
that "...he is an adult who can care for himself in a better
way than he was cared for as a child." (Dimock, 1988, p. 217).
BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MALE SURVIVOR TREATMENT
The contributors to this study are experienced therapists who have
a broad range of both experience and theory to call upon in their
work with male survivors. They utilize a wide range of theoretical
orientations, including family systems models, feminist therapy
models, cognitive-behavioral restructuring processes, hypnosis and
psychodynamic approaches.
All of the contributors are eclectic in their theoretical approach
to working with male survivors. Although some favour one particular
theoretical model over others, none of the contributors uses one
theory base exclusively. They agree that using a theoretical model
that is suitable to the client and his presenting issues is more
important than being loyal to a theory irrespective of the client's
issues. If, for example, a client is very cognitive in his presentation,
they suggest initially using a theoretical orientation, such as
cognitive restructuring, that will join with the client's process.
More affectively focused methods of therapy, such as gestalt therapy
or psychodrama, are not used until such time as the client can experience
his affect with some comfort.
Despite the wide range in the contributor's theoretical orientations,
they agree that the following key concepts underlie successful therapy
with male survivors.
Empowerment
All the contributors agree that assisting their clients to regain
their personal power is an essential component of successful sexual
abuse treatment. Acknowledging a client's strengths and validating
the survival skills he has developed, however functional or dysfunctional
they may be in his present life context, is crucial. A survivor's
very presence in a therapist's office is living proof that he had
what it took to survive the impact of sexual abuse. However great
his need to transform his survival skills into more adaptive processes,
he needs to recognize that his present level of skill has ensured
his survival thus far.
Client-Focused, Client-Paced Therapy
The therapist and client must work in partnership while addressing
the client's abuse-related concerns. If a therapist acts as an authority
figure in the therapeutic relationship, he or she invites the transference
that was initially formed in the abuse experience when the offender
had power over the victim. Although such transference may eventually
be constructively resolved, it threatens the formulation of the
therapeutic relationship in the short-run. It imposes stresses on
both the client and therapist that are generally unduly taxing and
counterproductive.
This does not mean to say that clinicians do not bring skills and
awareness that can help their clients' recovery. They do. However
the frame in which the therapeutic process occurs is one in which
the therapist can act as a "consultant" to his client
and the client is an informed "consumer" who determines
the services he wishes to "purchase".
"... the client is the authority with regard to what postabuse
trauma feels like, what seems to help and whether therapy is progressing
as it should...." (Briere, 1989, p. 59).
Not only is the survivor the expert on his abuse-related experience,
he is also responsible for his own healing process. A therapist
can facilitate a client's recovery, but he cannot take responsibility
for it. Both the client and the therapist need to be very clear
about who is responsible for making changes in the client's life.
If this is not clear, the client can remain in a victim position
in which he doesn't claim responsibility for his life and the therapist
runs the risk of becoming either a rescuer or a persecutor as he
tries to motivate his client to change.
Linking The Past To The Present
Many survivors are not aware of a connection between their experience
of being sexually abused as a child and the problematic issues they
face in their adult lives. Because they have either repressed their
abuse memories or disowned their abuse experience and claim that
it has had no impact on them, they don't have a context for understanding
their current behaviour. Often this leaves them feeling crazy or
ashamed. When symptoms are seen as "a creative adaptation to
highly negative circumstances rather than an expression of psychopathology"
(Courtois, 1991, p. 50), survivors are able to start their journey
of healing and recovery.
As survivors reclaim their memories and discharge their repressed
affect, they can begin to understand and change dysfunctional patterns
in their lives. When they develop an understanding that all their
behaviour makes sense, they begin to decode their experience rather
than disowning or judging it. For some survivors, so-called "psychotic"
episodes are PTSD flashbacks or expressions of MPD. Seeing himself
as an abuse survivor who is exhibiting common abuse-related symptoms,
rather than as a mental patient whose only hope is medication, can
support a client in making positive change. This does not mean that
some survivors will not require psychotropic drugs or hospitalization.
However, in general, the sense of normalcy that survivors regain
when their present behaviour is connected to past events supports
the healing process.
Growth And Learning Model
The contributors agree that survivors need to be invited into the
therapeutic process with the understanding that "We all do
the best we can at all times." Skill deficits, overwhelming
emotions or confused internal states result in inappropriate or
dysfunctional responses to events in a survivor's present life.
Changing these maladaptive responses depends on learning and integrating
new skills, increasing awareness and understanding of internal processes
and acknowledging emotional states.
Replacing maladaptive patterns and beliefs with functional ones
and assimilating these changes in a supportive environment are essential
ingredients of the recovery process. Most of the challenges that
clients face in their lives do not occur in therapy sessions. Clients
need support to transfer the learning that occurs during the therapeutic
process into their daily lives. Therapists need to assist clients
to develop structures that allow them to anchor their psycho-social
growth so that it becomes habitual behaviour.
Integration
Healing from sexual abuse is, in part, a process of reclaiming
lost or "stuck" parts of the self. Survivors need to be
told: "Bad things happened to you. You were not bad."
Often, at the time of the abuse, given his cognitive, affective
and physical immaturity, the victim decided that he was being abused
because he deserved to be abused. He concluded that he himself was
responsible for being abused. He believed that shameful or dangerous
parts of himself had caused his victimization. He then, unconsciously,
repressed or dissociated those shameful or dangerous parts in a
misguided attempt to make himself normal. These undervalued parts
of self were put out of conscious awareness, only to intrude later
in unconscious form.
Most survivors need to reclaim and integrate devalued parts of
themselves. Men who deny or repress their victimization experience,
yet display abuse-related symptoms such as drug or alcohol abuse
need to become aware that they have complex and sometimes conflicting,
internal needs. They need to recognize that as well as having an
adult persona, they also incorporate a damaged internal child who
may continue to act problematically regardless of the survivor's
chronological age. When the various parts of the self are in communication
with one another and no part is devalued or ignored, the survivor
will experience greater health and balance.
Recognition Of Grief
Survivors need to acknowledge the losses that occurred in their
lives as a result of childhood sexual abuse. They lost their childhood
innocence when the abuse began. Their inherent sexual clock was
prematurely started. Often close family relationships are lost to
them. Many must cope with the aftermath of abuse without family
support. Part of the recovery process for survivors is to grieve
their losses. The stages of denial, bargaining, anger, sadness and
acceptance form part of a survivor's healing journey. (Hunter, 1990a).
Safety
The earliest stage of psycho-social development in Erickson's theory
of development is basic trust. This stage underlies all others and
forms the bedrock for further psycho-social growth. By definition,
a survivor's trust in others has been breached. Either by seductive
or aggressive means, he has been violated by another human being.
When a survivor enters therapy, he brings his lack of trust in others
with him.
At the beginning of the therapeutic process, trust in the therapist
has to be earned. The therapist will have to address the client's
lack of trust by ensuring that the therapeutic process is safe.
This means that clients will not be expected to trust either the
therapist or the therapeutic process until such time as this happens
naturally. However, each client will be expected to identify his
needs regarding safety in the therapeutic process. The therapist
helps the client by gently but persistently soliciting these
needs. In addition, clearly discussing the therapeutic groundrules
and the therapeutic contract increases safety in the therapeutic
process. (These issues will be presented in detail in Chapter 4.)
Recognition That Abuse Is Both Personal And Cultural
Although sexual abuse is a personal experience, it is intrinsicly
linked to larger cultural forces. An analysis of the cultural and
political forces that create sexual abuse is not generally part
of therapy. However, it is impossible to address a client's post-abuse
responses without acknowledging that both client and therapist are
members of a culture that permits sexual violence and exploitation.
The necessity of addressing cultural and social issues is even
stronger when victimization due to sexual abuse is compounded by
other kinds of victimization such as racial discrimination, homophobic
prejudice or poverty. In such cases, the victim's issues are likely
to be a complex outcome of concurrent victimization processes and
they must be therapeutically addressed as such.
One part of therapy with male survivors involves debunking various
social myths regarding sexual abuse. Many such myths relate to a
survivor's sense of his masculinity or questions about his sexual
orientation; the necessary "debunking" cannot occur without
examining cultural values and social expectations. Learning how
social forces have been internalized and incorporated into the survivor's
sense of self thus becomes a part of successful therapy. Often,
as either a direct or indirect outgrowth of therapy, survivors reexamine
social and cultural values. As a result, they gain greater freedom
to fully accept the realities of their own lives, including their
victimization.
Transference And Counter-Transference
Male survivors of sexual abuse, like other therapy clients, tend
to interpret and shape their therapeutic experience in ways that
conform to their world view. If a client believes that all men are
sexually inappropriate or that no one will ever be able to help
him, he will bring these beliefs into the therapeutic process. He
will unconsciously attempt to replicate his childhood beliefs with
the therapist.
Therapists need to be aware of transference and counter-transference
dynamics in order to intervene skilfully. Therapists often have
unresolved or partially resolved personal issues that coincide with
their clients' dynamics. Under these circumstances, it is easy for
a therapist to take a client's issues or "transference bait"
personally. This is not helpful. Instead the therapist must work
with the client to see how his patterns of understanding the world
and interacting with others were established. It cannot be emphasized
strongly enough how essential good supervision is in helping therapists
navigate transference/counter-transference dynamics successfully.
Contributors also noted some therapeutic stances which are counter-productive
when working with male survivors.
Survivors don't need their therapists to be models of perfection.
As a consequence of their painful childhoods, survivors have often
constructed fantasies of "perfect relationships" in which
they imagine themselves finally having all their unmet needs recognized
and addressed. These images of perfection are as dysfunctional a
map for real relationships as the abusive relationships they experienced
in childhood. Being authentic is an important quality that therapists
can model for clients.
Therapists need to respect their own human limitations - "
therapists
are human beings who inevitably make mistakes and who may not always
be able to maintain the empathic bond that guides accurate helping
behaviours." (Briere, 1989, p. 59). When therapists honestly
own their mistakes and take the new information gained from making
these mistakes into account in their subsequent work with clients,
they model a process of trial-and-error learning that helps clients
acknowledge their own human limits.
Therapists who have been trained to respond to clients
like a "blank screen" need to adjust this style when working
with male survivors. A neutral stance can be perceived by a client
as a lack of responsiveness to his pain or as a judgment about his
experience; it may leave him feeling confused, frightened and isolated.
Survivors require a responsive, psycho-educational therapeutic alliance
which validates their experience and helps them to move beyond its
negative effects. Therapists who work with male survivors need to
be overtly empathic, accepting and supportive.
STAGES OF THERAPY - A FOUR-PHASE MODEL
From the therapist's perspective, therapy with male survivors has
four distinct phases. This four-phase model of therapy is helpful
both as an analogous description of the recovery process for male
survivors and also as an analytical tool to assist in case management
and treatment planning.
The four phases are:
- 1 - Breaking Silence
- 2 - The Victim Stage
- 3 - The Survivor Phase
- 4 - The Thriver Stage
(In following chapters interventions are organized in relation
to this four-phase model and they are presented according to the
therapeutic phase in which they are most appropriately used.)
Individual clients will spend more or less time in any given phase
of healing and some phases will overlap with one another. Some clients
will stay in one phase for a long time, reaching a plateau in their
growth; it may be advisable to take a planned break from therapy
during these times. However, in general, each phase is associated
with distinct issues and demands different skills from the therapist.
At all times, the therapeutic process for male survivors needs
to be relevant to individual needs. Identifying a client's phase
of healing can help a therapist to skilfully and strategically focus
the therapy to meet this client's unique requirements.
Before beginning abuse-focused therapy, clients need information
about the therapeutic process. Knowing ahead of time that recovery
tends to be long-term rather than short-term and that the healing
journey is not a linear one, helps clients to make decisions about
their involvement with the therapeutic process. (The client engagement
process is discussed in Chapter 9.) Each client will have to decide
how to allocate his resources (e.g. time, money, etc.) to support
his recovery. Relatively accurate and candid predictions about the
therapeutic process, including the length of the journey, will help
clients make these decisions.
Giving clients a cognitive map with which to understand the healing
process can be a supportive intervention. Although the concept of
a four-phase model of healing is somewhat abstract, being able to
identify which phase he is currently in helps a client know where
he is headed and what kind of process he can anticipate en route.
Whether or not clients want such a map, it is essential that each
therapist uses one to guide his interventions. The different phases
of the four-phase model are described below:
Phase 1 - Breaking Silence
Acknowledging to himself that he was sexually abused as a child
is the first step a survivor must take to heal from this experience.
Reaching out to others for support and validation of this experience
and breaking the silence that has surrounded the secret of the abuse,
is an important step.
Survivors come to the realization that they were abused in different
ways. For some men, their memories surface during therapy for non-abuse
related issues, when they begin to realize that their patterns of
behaviour are the result of childhood sexual trauma. Other men have
never forgotten being abused, but have discounted the impact of
these events on their lives or have never labelled them as abuse.
Yet others have a sudden realization while watching a TV show about
sexual abuse, or reading a book which refers to sexual abuse, that
they have themselves been victimized.
However it happens, acknowledging his sexual victimization is the
beginning of a survivor's healing process. Some men will seek support
and help to cope with this realization by immediately going to see
a counsellor or by attending a self-help group. Many others wait
a long time before they share this information with others.
When a therapist is treating a man for other issues, but suspects
a history of abuse because of the symptoms his client is experiencing,
he is ethically bound to explore the possibility of childhood trauma
with his client. Even if the client denies a history of abuse, the
clinician must raise the possibility of childhood trauma and its
associated symptoms. (Courtois, 1991). Clearly, if the client has
no associations with having been sexually abused, the therapist
should not insist on following this line of inquiry. But as long
as the symptoms suggest childhood trauma, the clinician must continue
to leave the possibility open.
Bringing the client to awareness and acknowledgement of childhood
trauma may take some time and requires rapport and trust in the
therapist/client relationship. The client may also need to develop
life skills (e.g. communication, assertiveness, anxiety management,
etc.) before he has sufficient ego strength to manage his emotional
responses to acknowledging his sexual abuse.
Some therapists are reluctant to pursue questions about abuse if
their client has no memory of having been abused. "False Memory
Syndrome", in which therapists are thought to create their
clients' memories of abuse by planting hypnotic suggestions, is
currently a topic of much debate in therapeutic circles. I believe
that concerns about creating false memories are secondary to giving
a client feedback that his symptoms suggest a history of childhood
trauma, which may include sexual abuse. Until such time as this
possibility can be clearly eradicated, it bears examination.
Phase 2 - The Victim Stage
The main focus of this phase of therapy is to validate the client's
abuse history, to build a safe therapeutic process with the client
and to provide educational information about the effects of sexual
abuse on its victims. Unless a client has intense flashbacks or
other effectively demanding concerns, much of the work in this phase
will be cognitively focused.
Men often need support in acknowledging their victimization. Even
if they can recall the sexually intrusive events that have happened
to them, many men don't call them "abusive". Educating
clients about power differences, coercion, misrepresenting adult
reality, the use of threats and lies to gain compliance and so on,
can assist male victims to fully claim their experience.
The therapist needs to find a balance between staying focused on
abuse-related material and not pushing a client beyond his own comfort
zone. If the process becomes too intense or if the client perceives
the therapist as trying to control the therapy process, it is quite
likely that the client will shut down in the face of this replication
of an abusive dynamic.
To the extent that the client's memories permit, he will be asked
to develop a "sexual abuse autobiography" during this
phase of therapy. Remembering how he was groomed for the abuse,
who offended against him, how often the abuse occurred, what explicitly
happened, what his reactions were at the time, whether or not he
told anyone and what, if anything, he liked about the experience
are areas to investigate at this stage. Talking openly about the
abuse and continuing to challenge any denial of the experience are
primary tasks for this therapeutic phase.
Clients who have defended against their abuse memories by developing
substance or process addictions find themselves in somewhat of a
"Catch-22" situation - if they maintain their addiction,
they are unable to process their abuse history effectively; if they
give up their addiction, they are often flooded by uncontrollable
memories and feelings, which may lead to a relapse. Therapists have
to carefully monitor addictive behaviour at this phase of therapy.
If a client is not yet ready to surrender an addiction, he can
be supported by the recommendation that he develop other means of
addressing his anxiety before he begins to process his abuse history.
Occasional relapses are predictable for addicted clients - however,
when the addiction is still used as a primary coping strategy, abuse-related
therapy will be counter-productive and it is generally contra-indicated.
The therapist needs to teach stress management and self-care skills
during this phase, so that as the therapeutic focus becomes more
affective, clients have functional ways of attending to their emotions.
Ensuring that clients have active support systems in place or focusing
on building these supports, are therapeutic tasks in the Victim
Phase.
In this phase, clients will generally feel some emotional relief
at realizing that the problems they face in their lives are not
the result of being crazy, but the outcome of being sexually abused
as a child. As they gain information about dissociative processes
and other coping strategies, they begin to feel more normal and
hopeful about their futures.
The transition between the Victim and Survivor Phases of therapy
is marked by the client's ability to place full responsibility for
the abuse on the offender. When the client recognizes that he was
a victim in an abusive relationship and that the abuse was not a
reflection of his worth as a person, but of his offender's unresolved
problems, he moves into the next phase of therapy.
Phase 3 - The Survivor Phase
The Survivor Phase of therapy describes the often arduous work
of repairing clients' emotional, cognitive and behaviourial dysfunctions.
This is a push/pull stage of therapy. Client's maladaptive life
patterns are slowly replaced by functional sequences as the client
takes the risk of developing new coping strategies. Walking a fine
line between containment and expression, and finding a workable
balance of both, are the keys to success during this phase of therapy.
Often clients become discouraged in this phase. Because they are
reclaiming their previously blocked affective processes, they are
more aware of feelings of fear, pain, rage or sadness. They feel
unstable as they discard old methods of coping and substitute new
ones, which are still relatively untested and awkward to use. They
feel as if therapy has made them worse rather than better. Many
cases of premature termination occur in this phase as clients lose
their faith in ever being able to make significant changes.
At this point in therapy, clinicians must be steady and focused.
They need to remind their clients that discouragement is to be expected
in the Survivor Phase. The original momentum of addressing the abuse
has worn off and some weariness has set in. The therapist must nonetheless
continue to help the client identify his feelings and challenge
his thinking errors and distorted beliefs. Throughout this phase,
the therapist must affirm the client's strength and courage. By
validating the painfulness and difficulty of this stage of the therapeutic
work and by acknowledging the positive changes made to date, the
therapist maps out the therapeutic journey, thus supporting the
client's recovery.
The Survivor Phase of therapy is identified by particular therapeutic
tasks. Affective responses are identified and worked with during
this stage. Becoming acquainted with a wide range of emotions and
exploring ways in which these feeling states can be expressed, can
be a slow and fear-filled process. However, as survivors become
more familiar with their previously dissociated feelings, they begin
to experience a greater sense of wholeness and well-being. Habitual
dysfunctional cognitive and behavioral patterns are also worked
with during this therapeutic stage. Thinking errors and self-defeating
behaviourial sequences are identified and replaced by healthier
substitutes. New self-care skills are learned and practiced.
During the Survivor Phase, new skills need to be practised outside
of therapy sessions. Throughout this therapeutic stage sessions
may involve both spontaneous and planned abreactive processes. (Working
with abreactions will be discussed in Chapter 6.) At times, clients
may need to take a planned break from therapy and integrate their
learning before continuing the process.
The transition between the Survivor Phase and the Thriver Phase
is marked by the client's readiness to take back his own power;
this will frequently be manifested by the client's readiness to
confront his offender, either in reality or, more often, symbolically.
This is not a reactive stand taken in defiance against the offender;
instead it represents an integrated change in which the client no
longer feels that the offender has power over his life.
Phase 4 - The Thriver Phase
When the client reaches the Thriver Phase, he begins to feel hopeful
once again. From an empowered perspective of having changed previously
dysfunctional coping patterns he can articulate the ways in which
he was affected by having been abused. He realizes that the outcome
of successful therapy is not "living happily ever after",
but having the skills and resources that he needs to address the
difficulties that occur in his life.
Thrivers feel responsible for their lives and they believe that
they have many options to choose from in addressing their life problems,
both past and present. The abuse is no longer seen as a central
issue in the client's self-identification; his image of himself
has shifted into the present and he trusts his adult self.
During the Thriver Phase, the client and therapist must begin the
process of termination. Termination needs to be managed so that
the client can leave the therapeutic process at his own pace. In
addition, clients should be given plenty of permission to return
to therapy should they experience a resurgence of symptoms or should
new abuse memories surface.
The therapist must be very careful not to compromise
therapist/client boundaries by permitting double relationships to
develop. Clients need their therapists to remain available to them
for potential future consultation; any double relationship, such
as when a therapist becomes a friend, lover, landlord or business
partner to a client, jeopardizes the safety of the therapeutic relationship.
Risk of such double relationships might arise when the therapist
is himself a survivor with needs for social support from relatively
"recovered" fellow survivors or when a recovering client
is seen as a professional ally who can assist in furthering desperately
needed services for survivors.
CHAPTER 4 - GENERAL THERAPEUTIC CONSIDERATIONS
This chapter describes processes common to all modalities
of abuse-focused therapy. Therapeutic contracts, assessment
procedures and evaluation processes are discussed in some
detail. In addition, behaviours and circumstances that contraindicate
abuse-focused therapy are outlined. |
All the primary psychotherapeutic modalities - individual, group,
couple and family therapy - can be used to treat the effects of
childhood sexual abuse. For adult male survivors, individual and
group treatment are generally considered the most effective treatment
formats.
Although therapists always need to be flexible and to accommodate
to the individual needs of clients, the contributors agree that
male survivors are generally best served by first engaging in individual
therapy and then moving into group therapy with concurrent individual
work on an as-needed basis. Couple or family work may be used as
a regular adjunct to the therapeutic process, if this supports a
client's recovery. Body work may be a useful addition to a client's
heating primarily during the Thriver Phase of therapy.
Contributors were quick to point out that the ideal and the possible
are not always identical in regards to service provision to male
survivors. Circumstances often dictate the realities that both clients
and therapists face. Many clients' choices about therapeutic resources
are determined by financial considerations rather than by need.
Some geographic areas have limited clinical resources and individual
treatment is the only type of therapy available. In other areas,
group treatment is available, but there aren't enough individual
therapists.
Certain aspects of therapy are common to all therapeutic
modalities. Developing a therapeutic contract, identifying issues
that are contraindicators for therapy, conducting a thorough assessment
and evaluating therapeutic outcomes are essential ingredients of
therapy, regardless of the treatment modality. These generic components
of treatment are discussed below.
DEVELOPING A THERAPEUTIC CONTRACT
Both sexual abuse and therapy are interpersonal processes. Because
of this similarity, for therapy to be healing and not harming, it
must occur in a context of ethical and clinical integrity. Both
clients and therapists need to have clear guidelines about the relational
aspects of therapy. A therapeutic contract clarifies the roles
and rules of the therapeutic process. Because therapy is
not a static process, the contract has to be renegotiated as therapy
progresses. For many survivors, developing a therapeutic contract
is an opportunity to practice negotiating their needs.
Therapeutic contracts may be written or verbal, depending on the
therapist's and client's respective personal styles. Often the formal
aspects of the agreement (fee schedules, session times, etc.) will
be written down, while the informal, spontaneous aspects of the
therapeutic process (planning how to work with particular issues)
will be negotiated verbally. For clients who are highly dissociative,
writing down therapeutic agreements can be helpful; a written contract
provides a tangible record to refer to if they cannot recall what
happened during a session.
Some therapists use the contracting process to give their clients
information about how they work. For instance, some therapists explicitly
inform their clients that they will not become sexually or socially
involved with them or create dual roles with them. They tell clients
that it is the client's right to pace the therapeutic process and
determine its duration. They explicitly give clients permission
to debrief or question any interactions that are hurtful, puzzling
or unclear, so that the client always has an opportunity to examine
the therapeutic process. They may briefly explain their therapeutic
style, so that clients can be informed consumers when selecting
a therapist.
Spending time developing a therapeutic contract is reassuring to
new clients. A clear contract circumvents later problems since guidelines
for behaviours and actions are outlined prior to needing to use
them. Key elements that should be discussed when developing a therapeutic
contract are outlined below.
Information Boundaries
Clients need to be assured that the therapeutic process is confidential
and that their personal history will be respected by the therapist.
However, they also need to know that if they abuse themselves or
others (including the therapist) or are violent towards their surroundings,
it will be considered grounds for breaking therapeutic confidentiality.
Therapists should be knowledgeable about the legal aspects of reporting
abuse. They must share this information with their clients when
applicable. Clients must be informed that if they disclose information
about present abuse situations or abusers who have access to young
children, police and child welfare agencies must be informed. Safety
concerns always precede concerns about confidentiality.
Because the abuse occurred in secrecy, some clients are anxious
about therapeutic confidentiality. They may need to examine the
boundary of confidentiality in some detail in order to feel reassured
that therapy will not replicate the abuse process. Clients who are
afraid that they will not be able to control the therapeutic process
are often reassured when a therapist asks questions such as, "How
will you let me know if your therapy is going in a direction that
is not helpful to you?
Fees
Clients need clear information about how much a therapist charges
for his or her services and how he or she expects to be paid. Therapists
must be clear about how flexible they are willing to be about fee
collection. Clear fee policies assist both clients and therapists.
Structure Of Sessions
Clients need information about the duration and frequency of sessions.
Although these may at times need to be renegotiated to meet unique
circumstances, having clear time boundaries is an important way
to differentiate therapy from abuse.
Touch Boundaries
It is imperative for clients to control when and how they are touched
during therapy. Each client must always determine his own touch
boundary. During the abuse, the victim was not in charge of how
he was touched; therapists must take care not to replicate this
experience during therapy sessions. Even routine social rituals,
such as shaking hands, should only occur if initiated by the client.
Similarly, each therapist must ensure that his or her own comfort
zones regarding touch are not infringed; if a client requests a
hug, but the therapist is not comfortable with this contact, the
therapist needs to own and honour his or her personal boundary.
Such behaviour presents the client with a positive role model for
respectful touch boundaries.
Crisis And Emergency Plans
Prior to engaging in therapy, clients need information about the
kind of support they will receive from their therapist outside of
scheduled sessions. Clients need to know their therapist's boundaries
regarding telephone access and whether the therapist is available
for unscheduled emergency sessions. When a therapist goes on holiday,
clients need to know whether their therapist has arranged for coverage
by another therapist should an emergency arise.
Planning for possible crises can reduce a client's level of anxiety.
Should a client become sufficiently self-harming that hospitalization
is required to monitor his personal safety, he will respond to this
plan more easily if he has previously agreed to its merits. Developing
emergency contingency plans with clients before engaging in therapy
is a useful early step.
Some clinicians have a prepared handout for their
clients that outlines their policies and procedures. This can reduce
the amount of session time that is spent on this information and
it leaves the client with a concrete resource for future reference.
CONTRAINDICATORS FOR ABUSE-RELATED THERAPY
In order for abuse-related therapy to be healing rather than retraumatizing,
clients need to be ready to address their sexual victimization and
therapists need to have sufficient skill to ensure that the therapy
is emotionally corrective. Timeliness is an important variable to
consider when offering this kind of therapy. These are some of the
main reasons that abuse-related therapy would be contraindicated:
Ongoing Life Crises
If a survivor's life is currently crisis-ridden, working intensively
on past trauma will generally only exacerbate his current instability.
Clients who have difficulty keeping a job or earning enough money
to meet basic needs, or who are in the midst of a relationship breakdown,
are not good candidates for abuse-related therapy. They need to
focus on these more immediate issues before they engage in abuse-related
work.
Clients who are actively violent or in an abusive relationship
need to address these patterns before they are ready to look beyond
these symptoms at the deeper causes of their behaviours. Suicidal
or psychotic survivors need to manage these mental health issues
before focusing on their victimization.
Clients who have active substance or process addictions are not
good candidates for abuse-focused therapy until they have developed
healthier emotional coping strategies. Although some therapists
will work with clients after only six months of sobriety or drug-free
time, most therapists working with ex-addicts follow the rule-of-thumb
of "one year clean and sober".
Lack Of Social Support
If a survivor is very isolated, therapy must focus on developing
social skills and building community before moving into abuse-related
processes. Neither a therapist nor a client will be well served
if the therapist is the only source of support in the clients life.
A lack of social support reinforces clients' dysfunctional beliefs;
it supports their self-image of not being deserving of caring and
their belief that their victimization experiences are too shameful
to be shared with others.
Therapy is only a small part of a client's life. Clients need to
have companionship and caring within their natural communities as
well as in their therapy. Many clients attend 12-step programs as
a means of developing new avenues of social support. Interaction
with others, in both therapeutic and social ways, is an important
part of the recovery process.
Lack Of Motivation To Change
Some clients come to therapy because other people think it would
help them. If a client doesn't recognize that he has a problem or
that certain aspects of his life are unsatisfactory, he has no motivation
to change. Therapy that is focused on childhood sexual abuse requires
a commitment on the part of the client; he will have to address
painful issues of betrayal and loss in the course of his recovery.
If a client does not have an investment in making changes and achieving
therapeutic goals during the course of therapy, he is not a good
candidate for abuse-related work.
Therapist's Limitations
If a therapist is not available to work with a client on an ongoing
basis or does not feel competent to work with abuse-focused issues,
he or she should refer the client elsewhere. It is very traumatic
for a survivor who is beginning to explore the possibility of trusting
another person, namely his therapist, only to suddenly have this
process threatened because the therapist changes jobs or for some
other reason has to terminate the therapy. Of course unanticipated
events will occur in both therapists' and clients' lives; however,
whenever possible, therapists must respect their clients' needs
for stability and safety and try to avoid premature termination.
Breaking The Therapeutic Contract
If a client is unwilling to follow the negotiated
terms of the therapeutic contract, he is not a suitable candidate
for abuse-related work. Clients who will not accept responsibility
for their own behaviour, who threaten the safety of others, including
the therapist or who consistently break agreements about session
times or fee payment, need to address these issues before they open
the doors to their victimization experiences. The emotions that
emerge during the recovery process tend to be intense; If a client
is not willing to be accountable in his relationships with himself
and others, abuse-focused therapy can be dangerous.
CLIENT ASSESSMENT
When conducting an assessment with an abuse survivor or someone
you think may be an abuse survivor, it is very important that clinicians
actively solicit information about the abuse and its impact on the
client. If you wait for the client to raise these issues, they may
never surface. A client may interpret a therapist's lack of active
questioning about abuse as support for his own minimization or denial.
A client's shame about having been abused maintains his silence
about this event; the therapist must gently but actively support
and encourage the client to break silence and challenge his feelings
of shame.
Therapists must be careful not to make assumptions about their
clients' abuse experiences; clients must be given time and space
to tell their own story in their own words. You can generally assume
that most clients will disclose their abuse histories in chunks;
clients test their therapists' reactions to partial disclosures
before they feel safe enough to make a full and complete disclosure.
Usually the parts of the abuse experience that a client feels the
greatest shame about will be the last to be told. Therapists have
to walk a fine line between opening the door for information about
the abuse to surface and being too intrusive.
Therapists' assessment questions need to be specific and worded
in a non-judgemental way so as to elicit useful diagnostic material.
Instead of asking "Do you have a sleeping disorder?" ask
the more open-ended and less threatening question "What is
your regular sleeping pattern?" For many clients, dysfunctional
coping strategies are ego-syntonic or culturally sanctioned and
they do not appear as abnormal. Clinicians must ensure that the
questions they ask are precise, straightforward and non-threatening.
Some clients' histories are shocking and very upsetting, so clinicians
must be prepared to hear the answers to the questions they ask.
For example, questions about sexual habits and practices that would
be embarrassing in a social context need to be asked as part of
a thorough assessment. It is essential that the therapist is comfortable
asking questions about masturbation, sexual fantasies, sexual practices,
anger, fear and other culturally-sensitive or emotionally-loaded
issues. If the therapist is uncomfortable, this will be communicated
to the client, who may then disclose only partial information in
an attempt to make the therapist feel more at ease.
In general, the more thorough the assessment, the fewer surprises
will emerge in therapy. If during the assessment process it becomes
apparent that a client is highly dissociative, then the clinician
can prepare to work with someone who has possible MPD or other related
symptoms. Client confidence and safety are increased by predictability,
so time spent in conducting a thorough assessment is generally repaid
later in the therapeutic process. Some clients exhibit symptoms
associated with abuse, but they do not have a cognitive memory of
having been victimized. In such cases, asking broad, open-ended
questions such as "I'm wondering if you experienced some trauma
in your past.? The things that you're telling me about yourself
seem to indicate that you had to learn to handle some very traumatic
situations" can support the client. It is important that clients
who have repressed memories do not feel ashamed because they're
unable to recollect their experiences and are not forced to remember
events before their unconscious is ready to do so. Therapists must
let the abuse history come from the client and not contaminate the
therapeutic process by placing expectations on the client to disclose
memories prematurely. When a client recovers repressed memories
in a timely fashion, he trusts his own recollection and doesn't
undermine his recovery by questioning the validity of his experience.
If a clinician is uncertain about the dynamics that a client is
presenting, he or she should consult with a knowledgeable colleague.
The assessment process lays the foundation for the rest of the therapy;
It is important that clients are not over or under-pathologized
as a result of this process.
Certain key areas need to be carefully assessed. These are:
General Family/Social History
Frequently victims of sexual abuse have traumatic events other
than having been sexually abused that have shaped their lives. Clinicians
need to conduct a thorough family and social history to understand
the important events (and people) in a client's life. Problematic
areas, such as violence or a lack of social support, need to be
assessed. However, clients also need a clear inventory of their
strengths and resources. Successful patterns and helpful strengths
are as important as problem areas and trauma.
The survivor's current life patterns must be carefully assessed.
The client's status vis-a-vis work, relationships, health, parenting
roles and skills and so on, need to be determined. Until a client's
day-to-day life is functioning adequately, focusing on abuse-related
events can be counter-therapeutic.
Sexual History
During the assessment, a survivor may or may not be able to disclose
specific information about his sexual victimization. If the therapist
frames his questions carefully, he can increase his client's comfort
in sharing whatever conscious memories he does have. Asking the
client to "Tell me as much about your childhood sexual experiences
as you think I need to know in order to understand what happened
to you" can sometimes elicit more information than a very direct
question because the client is less anxious when responding to the
request.
Dimock (1988) encourages clients to write down their sexual histories.
This gives the client more privacy and greater safety and control.
Information is then shared with the therapist as the client chooses,
leaving the client in charge of his disclosure process. Since many
clients are afraid that the therapist will take a voyeuristic interest
in their sexual past (as the abuser did), reducing the level of
threat and shame in presenting their sexual histories is very important.
Dimock suggests providing clients with a means of categorizing their
abuse experiences. He gives his clients a list of four categories
of sexual behaviour with several examples in each. These are:
(a) chargeable offenses (anal and oral sex, fondling, intercourse
and so on);
(b) growing up in a sexualized atmosphere (excessive interest
on the part of family members in peeping or exposing, open presence
of pornography, covert sexualized touch and the like);
(c) intrusive behaviours (sexual punishments, unusual interest
in and questions about sexuality, unnecessary enemas, supervised
baths beyond a reasonable age and applications of medication to
the genital area when the child is able to do this alone, etc.);
and
(d) inappropriate relationships where the child is placed in
an adult role with sexual implications (regular sleeping with
a parent, date-like relationships, confiding in the child especially
about sexual information, etc.).
To the extent that is possible, the survivor's sexual history should
include information about specific behaviours that occurred during
the abuse, who was present, how old the client was when the abuse
was occurring, how old his abuser(s) was, how he felt at the time
and whether he has sensory memories (taste, smell, etc.) from the
abuse. (Dimock, 1988). If the client has made previous disclosures,
he should be asked about these experiences. Whether he was believed
or not and whether he was supported or not, can have an impact on
his expectation about how you will receive his present disclosure
of victimization.
Coping Strategies
Clients need to be asked about the ways, both functional and dysfunctional,
that they have coped with the impacts of being sexually abused.
Many clients are unable to articulate their coping mechanisms; however,
it is often the dysfunctional coping strategies the client has been
using that have brought him into therapy.
Dissociative behaviours need to be assessed. Frequently, educating
clients about dissociative processes and increasing their awareness
of when they are engaging in these behaviours is a necessary step
before a full assessment. (See Appendix C for a copy of the Dissociative
Experiences Scale (DES) which can be used to assess dissociative
tendencies).
Survivors often exhibit dominant sympathetic nervous system symptoms
such as an exaggerated startle response or chronic muscle tension.
Many survivors live in a chronic state of emotional fear and anxiety.
Hence the normal balance between their sympathetic and parasympathetic
nervous systems is disturbed. Anxiety attacks, excessive irritability
and hypervigilance are common symptoms experienced by sexual trauma
survivors. Eating and sleeping patterns are often disrupted. Difficulty
in failing asleep or waking up in the middle of the night, an inability
to digest food or rapid weight loss indicate an overworked sympathetic
nervous system.
Many survivors develop addictions or compulsive behaviours in an
effort to mask their abuse-related emotions. The very issues that
the addictions were developed to cover will resurface during therapy.
As Dimock (1988) states, while occasional flight into compulsive
behaviours is expected during therapy, continuous involvement ire
these activities makes it very difficult for therapy to continue.
Abuse-Reactive Perpetration
As discussed in Chapter 2, some victims, either because of identification
with the aggressor or unconscious efforts to understand their own
victimization, will have sexually perpetrated against others. This
activity needs to be assessed in the early part of treatment. If
a survivor is currently sexually offending or has done so in the
past, he must be held accountable for his actions. In most jurisdictions
the therapist is legally bound to report any offenses his client
discloses. Even if the offending was a very infrequent event during
the client's adolescence, the client needs to acknowledge this component
of his behaviour and address it in therapy.
Asking questions about abuse-reactive perpetration can be difficult.
Many victims have not reenacted their victimization and will be
upset by any insinuation that they might have done so. Phrasing
the question in a skilful manner (such as in the following example)
can be helpful: "Often victims of abuse find that they want
to do what happened to them to someone else. Did this ever happen
to you?"
Treatment Motivation/Goals
Therapists need to assess their clients goals and
determine whether or not they are realistic. Generally, small achievable
goals are much more helpful than larger, more abstract goals. Asking
questions such as "What is the first small step that will let
you know you are on the road to recovery?" or "What do
you think your (friends, boss, significant other, etc.) will notice
about you as you heal more and more?" can help clients identify
appropriate treatment goals. (Dolan, 1991).
EVALUATING THERAPY
Both clients and therapists need a means of evaluating the therapeutic
process. When questioned about whether they use formal or informal
methods to evaluate their work, most of the contributors replied
that they used informal methods to determine the success of their
work. The small number of contributors who routinely used formal
evaluation procedures with their clients tended to use standardized
psychological tests in a pre/post test format to measure treatment
outcomes.
Contributors who use informal methods to evaluate their clients'
progress ask their clients for feedback on the therapeutic process.
Changes such as a reduction in PTSD symptoms or trauma-based intrusive
memories, increased self-awareness, affective improvements and cognitive
restructuring are used to measure the success of the therapy. Client
satisfaction and life changes, achievement of identified goals,
improved work or relationship functioning are other indicators of
improvement.
Clinicians who use formal tests need to demystify them with their
clients. Tests need to be fully explained to ensure that clients
understand their potential usefulness and give informed consent
prior to taking them. The limitations of testing (false negatives
or false positives) also need to be discussed, so that clients realize
that testing is not an infallible process.
Contributors who evaluate their clients with standardized tests
use both scales which have been specifically designed for use with
sexual abuse survivors and other generic psychological tests.
The Dissociative Experiences Scale (DES) - a screening tool to
identify survivors with high levels of dissociation - is a self-report
test that measures three main factors:
(1) amnestic dissociation;
(2) absorption and imaginative involvement; and
(3) experiences of depersonalization and derealization.
(See Appendix C for a copy of the DES).
The Trauma Symptom Checklist (TSC-33) is a 33-item checklist specifically
developed to tap post-traumatic psychological disturbance. The test
measures five clinical subscales (dissociation, anxiety, depression,
sleep disturbance and hypothesized post sexual abuse trauma) as
well as developing an overall measure of trauma. This test was developed
by John Briere and his colleagues; the TSC-33 is described in Therapy
For Adults Molested As Children. (See Chapter 12).
The non-abuse specific psychological tests that some contributors'
use to assess and evaluate their clients are the Tenessee Self-Concept
Scale, the Beck Depression Inventory, the Hudson Self-Esteem Scale
and the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI).
Some clinicians monitor and evaluate therapy on a regular basis;
every fourth or sixth session they will review the process of therapy
with their clients. Others evaluate less during the course of therapy,
but after termination they make follow-up phone calls to monitor
the stability of therapeutic changes. Therapists who work with adolescents
will sometimes elicit feedback from their clients' parents or teachers
to ascertain whether therapy is being helpful. Group clients sometimes
use a peer review process to monitor change and progress. Most clinicians
define therapeutic success by items such as increased self-esteem
in their clients. Relying on a client's self-assessment in addition
to the therapist's own observations of a client's change is generally
an adequate basis upon which to evaluate therapy.
Evaluative tools that are easy to administer are
an underdeveloped and underutilized resource in clinical work, especially
in regard to therapy with abuse survivors. Impressionistic data
is the most common form of therapeutic evaluation. As noted above,
this method certainly has merit; but it makes generalization from
case to case impossible. Improved standardized methods for evaluating
therapy are a still-needed resource for therapists working with
sexual abuse survivors.
CHAPTER 5 - INDIVIDUAL THERAPY: THE VICTIM PHASE
This chapter outlines the basic therapeutic tasks during
the Victim Phase of therapy. A variety of techniques, some
of which are expressive, and some of which focus on internal
processes, are described. These door-opening interventions
are focused on increasing the clients' abilities to become
aware of their affective experience, and on developing skills
to manage these emotions productively. |
The success of psychotherapy in general and abuse-related psychotherapy
in particular, depends on the nature of the relationship between
the therapist and the client. Clients need adequate safety in the
relationship to be able to learn and grow. Therapists need sufficient
skill and integrity to be able to enhance and support their clients'
learning.
As clients develop an awareness of their own psychological processes
and make their unconscious responses to trauma conscious, they begin
to develop options and choices in how they respond to events in
their lives. Dysfunctional patterns that were created to cope with
trauma in earlier developmental stages can be replaced by more healthful
responses that are appropriate to the client's present life circumstances.
My intention is to give a general map of individual therapy with
male survivors, rather than providing a step-by-step guide. I will
include specific examples of interventions that were supplied by
the contributors that transform theory into applied clinical process.
The reason that most clinicians suggest male survivors begin with
individual work is that an essential feature of abuse-related therapy
is safety. Without sufficient safety, a client cannot address his
past history of abuse. If he is focused on here-and-now concerns,
he cannot free sufficient psychic energy to address his past.
Individual sessions provide a client with an opportunity to develop
familiarity with both a therapist and the therapeutic process. In
individual therapy, the client is encouraged to speak about his
victimization and he is believed and supported. Individual therapy
permits a therapist to assess his client's skills and deficits and
permits a client to develop a safe and supportive relationship with
another adult. These two tasks are essential precursors to participation
in abuse-focused group therapy.
The focus of early abuse-related therapy is on reclaiming and validating
the facts and impacts of the client's victimization. The therapist
gives his or her client permission to remember and acknowledge his
sexual abuse and listens to his disclosures in a supportive, nonjudgemental
manner. The therapist gently questions the client about his past
and begins to challenge distorted abuse-generated cognitions that
the client has drawn about himself, others and the world at large.
During this stage of therapy the therapist works with the client
to ensure that therapy is a safe-enough process; this may require
teaching the client containment skills (e.g. techniques for managing
flashbacks or anxiety attacks) and expanding his understanding of
abuse-related processes by sharing psycho-educational materials.
The client's behaviours are normalized and destigmatized.
He is encouraged to openly examine his abuse experience and its
subsequent impacts on him. He is helped to befriend parts of his
experience and parts of himself that he has felt ashamed of or pushed
away. You can often facilitate this process by the use of gentle
humour. For example, challenging self-blaming cognitions by saying
"Oh - there's that old 'I'm-in-charge-of-the-world' part of
you again" can help a client recognize dysfunctional aspects
of himself without increasing his shame or anxiety.
INTERVENTIONS
Here are some interventions that contributors have used in the
Victim Phase of therapy to help clients develop their personal safety,
enhance their memory recall and access repressed affect.
I must caution readers who incorporate these interventions into
their work to be discriminating about when and with whom, they are
used. They must ensure that the use of any technique meets their
client's need rather than their own. Indiscriminate enthusiasm about
new ideas and interventions can lead to their untimely use. In addition,
"No technique can replace the mutual respect and stable affirming
relationship offered by good generic psychotherapy...." (Briere,
1989, p. 82).
Inner Child Work
During the Victim Phase of therapy the inner child metaphor can
be introduced. Most clients are helped by the discovery that they
have several different ego states. In general, the more dissociated
the client, the greater the number of his ego states. Recognizing
that different ego states can conflict with one another, or react
separately to the same stimulus, can help clients to be more self-accepting,
and to better understand their own behaviour.
When clients begin to see the "child" part of themselves
as having been traumatized and mistreated, they open the door for
developing self-loving rather than self-hating ways of being. They
begin to develop compassion for themselves, a compassion which is
experienced regardless of their affective or cognitive state. Gradually
the client is invited to accept responsibility for "reparenting"
the parts of himself that were inadequately parented in his childhood;
he is reassured that the therapist is available to act as his guide
or coach in this process, so that he has sufficient support for
the task.
For some men, the inner child metaphor is difficult to accept initially.
Being child-like or having childish ways of reacting to situations,
is seen in a negative light. This rejection of the immature components
of self can sometimes be overcome by using metaphors of captivity.
Likening an abused child to a prisoner of war whose captors used
him for their own ends can assist some men to have greater understanding
of the situation they were in as children. Acknowledging that even
battle-trained soldiers decompensate in situations of captivity
can help some victims become less self-blaming and more self-respecting
regarding their own responses to having been abused.
Other men can experience compassion for a girl more easily than
they can for a boy. These men believe that males should be more
resilient to suffering than females, no matter what their age or
situation. With such men, retelling the client's own abuse-related
history but changing the gender of the victim can elicit the compassionate
feelings that they cannot feel on their own behalf. When they express
concern on behalf of the fictional girl-victim, they can be reminded
that the very same events happened to them and that they also deserve
to be treated with compassion.
Visualization
Visualization can be a useful technique for some clients to acquaint
themselves with their "inner child". Before leading a
client into this type of visualization, ask him to identify "anchors"
for his adult-self and his present resourcefulness. These adult
reminders can be concrete objects, such as the client's wedding
ring or some other symbol of his adult status. Should the client
become anxious during the visualization, he can recathect his adult
self by touching this symbolic object.
Once the client is grounded in his present reality, lead him into
a visualization process by asking him to close his eyes and inducing
deep relaxation. If the client is not comfortable closing his eyes,
instruct him to focus on one spot in the room while paying attention
to his breathing and body sensations. Once the client is deeply
relaxed, ask him to get in touch with the child he was just before
the abuse began. (The age of the child can vary from situation to
situation to suit the client's and therapist's needs). Or your suggestion
can be more generally phrased, for example "Let a picture of
a child come into your mind.".
When the client has an image of a child, ask him to enhance it
by asking questions such as "What is the child wearing?"
and "What does the child look like?" Ask the child to
let the client's adult-self know something that is upsetting him
or to tell the client's adult-self about his state of well-being.
Then ask the client to respond to the child. This exchange between
the client's adult-self and inner child can be either silent or
spoken. It is helpful to call the child by his age-appropriate name.
If a client is called Robert, but was called "Bobby" at
the time of the abuse, his child-self should be addressed as Bobby.
When closing the visualization, ask the client's adult-self to
ensure that the child is feeling safe and protected before leaving
the imagery. There may be some imagined action that will have to
occur before the child is ready to say good-bye.
At first, many clients have difficulty contacting their inner child.
A client may feel self-conscious taking part in a visualization
process or may report that his inner child doesn't want any contact
because he feels untrusting or afraid. However, if the client is
willing to persevere and if you coach him about how to approach
an untrusting or fearful child, he will eventually make contact
with his child-self. When this occurs, the client is often surprised
at how this process can stimulate intense feelings and memories
and at how powerfully healing it is to learn to parent the child-self.
Guided imagery is a powerful tool for helping clients develop their
abilities to create safe personal boundaries. Contributors use this
technique in a variety of ways. Here are two of them.
"Container" Visualization
Clients often experience intrusive memories or find themselves
obsessively thinking about their abuse experiences. Helping them
develop an imaginary "container" in which they can place
these memories or thoughts, knowing that they will be there whenever
they want to recall them, provides relief.
After ensuring that the client is anchored to his present adult
status by some concrete anchors, lead him through a progressive
muscle relaxation exercise, until he is deeply physically relaxed.
When he shows signs of relaxation, such as rhythmic breathing or
closed eyes, instruct him to imagine a container, either a real
one or one that he creates in the moment, that is very secure and
to which only he has access. Invite him to place experiences, such
as intrusive memories and recurring thoughts, in this container
and to practice taking them in and out of the container at will.
Tell him that whenever he chooses, he can use this container to
store his thoughts or feelings. He can always retrieve them when
he chooses or he can keep them in the container for as long as he
wants.
Some therapists use this exercise to close a session during the
early stages of therapy. Just before the client leaves the session,
lead him into a trance in which he locates his container and tell
him: "Leave any thoughts you don't want to be aware of until
your next session in your container." Then gradually bring
him back into the here-and-now reality of the therapy room. Training
clients to use this technique on a regular basis makes it a familiar
way of managing intrusive internal experiences. The more this skill
is practised, the more effective it becomes.
"Place Of Safety" Visualization
As with the container visualization begin this exercise by leading
the client through a progressive relaxation exercise until he shows
signs of deep relaxation. Tell him to take himself to a place, real
or imagined, where he can be by himself in complete comfort and
security. Keep your instructions about locating this place deliberately
vague, so that the client's unconscious has the freedom to produce
a suitable image for his needs at the moment. Ask your client to
fully experience this internal place - to hear, see, smell, taste
and feel what it's like. Ask him to anchor his safe place with a
hand posture or a readily available physical object (e.g. a marble
or stone). Then, if he feels anxious, instruct him to make the hand
posture or feel the stone and to signal all levels of his consciousness
that he's relaxing and entering a safe place. Tell him that he can
return to this place whenever he chooses - no one else need know
when he's doing this.
Once the client has firmly established a safe inner sanctuary,
you can ask him, in a variation on this visualization, to invite
someone he trusts and respects to visit his place of safety. If
he wants, he can ask his visitor questions or he can receive affirmations
from his guest. At all times the client must be in charge of his
safe place and if he has any resistance to inviting someone else
into it, this must be respected.
To close this visualization, ask the client to gradually leave
his safe place, return to his body and, when ready, return to the
therapy room. Like the container exercise, this technique becomes
more effective if it is practised frequently and becomes a regular
feature of a client's self-care.
Making Assumptions
Clients project their own discomfort in discussing certain aspects
of their abuse onto the therapist and they are often reluctant to
bring these issues into therapy. To challenge the client's projections,
the therapist needs to have a direct, nonjudgemental approach when
raising difficult issues. This helps to give the client permission
to also be direct. The therapist "makes assumptions" that
his client is having certain experiences and then he elicits feedback
from the client about the accuracy of his assumptions. For instance,
in order to know more about his client's homophobic fears, a therapist
might say, "I'm not sure if this is true for you, but many
survivors are concerned about the arousal they experienced when
they were being abused. What was your experience?" This assumption
of a common experience and then questioning to elicit the client's
own experience, can be generalized to many different issues.
Life Book
Invite survivors to revisit the events of childhood with an adult's
eye by creating a "life book". Instruct your client to
buy a hard-cover lined notebook or scrapbook. The book should be
of good quality to reinforce the importance of its contents. Tell
your client to assign each page a year, starting with the year of
his birth and working up to the present. For each year, ask him
to write stories or make notes about himself at that time. The focus
is always on the client - if traumatic events happened to others
around him, tell him to write about these events as they affected
him. The client should leave space at the bottom of the page or
in the margin so that he can add later comments to his life story.
The life book is an active and concrete task that provides a way
to organize flashbacks and memories in a nonthreatening manner.
It indicates time periods in which memories are blocked or repressed.
It helps clients recognize their own survival strengths and it opens
the door for reflection on their life experience. Clients can be
as imaginative as they wish in how they create and use their life
books. When reviewing the life book with each client, ask "What
are you learning about yourself in this process?"
Life Story
A similar, but shorter, exercise is having a client tell you his
life story. It is helpful to use a structured format so that the
survivor has control of the process. Storytelling needs to be a
healing experience, not a retraumatizing one. Ask your client to
tell you about his family by drawing a genogram on a whiteboard
or by bringing in pictures of family members. Symbolic objects,
such as rocks or stones, can be used to represent family members.
As the client tells his personal history, assist him to identify
the ways that he learned to survive his abuse and to look for themes
and patterns in his life.
Drawing The Abuse
This can be an effective intervention for clients who are more
comfortable with creative media than they are with talking. Give
your client a large pad of paper - the size of the paper evokes
childhood responses - and tell him to take the paper home and "draw
the abuse". Make it clear that this is not an art exercise
but rather an opportunity for the client to recall and clarify events
that happened in his past. Tell him to draw a scene in his life
before the abuse occurred and then to draw specific scenes of his
abuse, using a comic-strip format. For instance, he can draw a bubble
coming out of his head to describe what he was thinking or feeling,
or put captions under his drawings to explain what is going on in
them.
Ask the client to bring his drawings into a therapy session and
question him about the information they contain. Don't interpret
the drawings - any interpretation that occurs should be the client's.
Often concretizing the images of his abuse makes them seem more
real to the client and brings his memories and feelings into greater
awareness. In touching the client's self-portrait, the therapist
symbolically touches the client, which can nurture the client in
a nonthreatening manner.
Script Recognition
This intervention is relatively common practice for therapists
trained in Transactional Analysis (TA) and it is well suited for
clients who were intrafamilially sexually abused. Six different
ego states are identified and each one is symbolized by a chair
or cushion.
The first ego state is the "nurturing parent" who is
competent in meeting his or her own needs and acknowledges his or
her child's needs as separate from his or her own. The second is
the "critical parent", who contaminates his or her interactions
with the child by his or her own unmet needs. This parent may be
critical and punitive, or smothering and overprotective, and does
not listen to the child's expression of his own needs. The third
is the "adult", who is the rational, logical ego state.
The adult is able to analyze situations and seek out new information
or skills to support new directions and growth.
The final three ego states are the "natural child", the
"compliant child" and the "rebellious child".
The natural child is the source of feelings, spontaneity and creativity.
It also carries the wound of the abuse. The compliant and rebellious
child ego states are reactive adaptations to the influence of the
critical parent and distortions of the natural child's energy.
Once the ego states have been described and identified, ask the
client to sit in the position representing the ego state in which
he spent most of his time as a child. The timeframe can be divided
into before and after the abuse. Encourage him to talk about his
experience of being in this place. Ask him to identify the positions
that his father and mother usually occupied and to sit in these
respective positions and role-play each parent.
This is generally an intense and useful process for clients. Recognizing
family members' scripted roles can be liberating as clients realize
their own part in maintaining the script and the options they have
to create change. The client's first step in altering these processes
is becoming clear about the overt and covert messages he absorbed
as a child and the dynamics he continues to enact in loyalty to
his family.
Focusing Techniques
During a session in which a client is talking about his history
of abuse or his current life, suggest that he sit quietly and focus
on the sensations that are occurring in his body. Ask him to notice
if one body sensation or one feeling is particularly noticeable.
If he says yes, ask him to really develop his awareness of this
sensation. After some time spent in exploring the sensation, ask
him if he has any images that come to mind that are connected with
the bodily experience he was focusing on. Any images or feelings
that surface for the client can be explored and worked with. This
technique can help clients retrieve repressed memories and honour
their kinesthetic awareness.
The above interventions are samples of the type
of work that occurs in the early stages of therapy. As the client
becomes more aware of his victimization and most importantly, the
effects it has had on his life, he begins to move out of the Victim
Phase into the Survivor Phase where the therapeutic journey often
becomes more intense. When a client stops blaming himself and starts
holding the offender accountable for the abuse, he frees up his
psychic energy to address the emotions that he has kept out of awareness.
CHAPTER 6 - INDIVIDUAL THERAPY: THE SURVIVOR
PHASE
In this chapter, I discuss the middle phase of therapy,
the Survivor Phase. During this stage of therapy, the client
reclaims dissociated parts of the self (behaviour, cognition
and/or affect) and develops new options for handling current
life stressors and past traumatic events. I present interventions
that increase survivors' affective range and describe ways
in which abuse-reactive patterns of interacting with the
self and others can be replaced by healthier coping strategies. |
The middle phase of therapy, the Survivor Phase, is generally the
longest and most difficult. During this phase the client is challenged
to identify where, in his current life, he continues to act out
the effects of his victimization and to develop more adaptive living
strategies. The client's key task at this stage is to develop and
internalize new behaviours and beliefs to replace the dysfunctional
patterns he has unconsciously developed as a result of his victimization.
Generally the client also engages in abreactive and regressive work
during this phase of therapy. These processes unlock repressed emotions
and, when well orchestrated, allow the client to integrate previously
undigested psychic material.
By the time a client enters the Survivor Phase of therapy, his
relationship with his therapist will have matured, permitting him
to take greater risks in the therapy process. Consequently, difficult
tasks such as working with the client's internalized abuser can
be addressed in this phase. The intensity of this stage of therapy
can be taxing on both client and therapist. Both parties need to
have adequate self-care skills to ensure that their stamina and
motivation are sustained throughout this often difficult time.
In this chapter I'll discuss several key therapeutic themes that
emerge in the Survivor Phase of therapy:
- Working with revenge;
- perpetration and sexual fantasies;
- working with addictive and compulsive processes;
- working to increase clients' affective range; and
- working with dissociative processes.
REVENGE, PERPETRATION AND SEXUAL FANTASIES
Your clients' fantasies contain important data about their sexual
victimization and their reactions to it. The therapeutic relationship
must provide opportunities to talk about these fantasies in a non-shaming
manner. However, survivors are often reluctant to disclose these
fantasies because they feel ashamed of them or are afraid of being
judged.
Revenge Fantasies
Most sexually abused men have active revenge fantasies in which
they imagine getting even with their abuser. Generally, when asked
about their revenge fantasies, clients will reveal their most innocuous
fantasy first, until they know they are safe to share more information.
Clients need to be supported for revealing their fantasies. They
need to know that when fantasies are owned and spoken about rather
than kept a secret, they are less likely to gain momentum and be
enacted.
Revenge fantasies expose the client's rage and anger. It can be
helpful to suggest that the client draw or symbolically act out
his fantasy in therapy, while simultaneously discharging his rageful
emotions. One symbolic enactment that has proven effective is to
cover an old cardboard box with reminders of the abuser and the
abuse and then to destroy it. This can occur either in the therapy
session or under other circumstances. However, the process should
be shared with at least one supportive companion so that the client
knows that his anger at his abuser is not shameful or secretive.
Whenever a client reveals previously hidden fantasies, he needs
to debrief both the content of the fantasy and the process of disclosure.
Subsequent to disclosing their fantasies, many clients feel very
ashamed of having exposed their private fantasy to their therapist.
They may become self-punishing or self-harming if they do not have
sufficient internal permission to express these feelings and fantasies.
Therapists need to be alert to these dynamics and to ensure that
their clients have adequate self-care skills to participate in emotionally
intense interventions. Clinicians may frequently need to remind
their clients of the difference between fantasy and actual behaviour
so that their fantasies can be acknowledged and worked with during
the therapeutic process.
Perpetration And Deviant Sexual Fantasies
If a survivor has perpetrated against another person, he must be
held accountable for his behaviour and take responsibility for having
offended. He should feel appropriate guilt for this behaviour while
simultaneously contextualizing it in relation to his own victimization
so that he can own his behaviour in a non-shaming way. If a survivor's
offenses are recent or indicate a repetitive pattern, his recovery
process will be prolonged while he engages in therapy focused on
his offending issues.
Although many survivors have never offended against another person,
they may have fantasies in which they imagine themselves abusing
a child. Some survivors are very fearful that they may become sexual
with a child and they are anxious about these deviant thoughts.
To address this issue, a therapist will need to help the client
understand where his fears of becoming a perpetrator originate.
For some clients, they stem from an over-identification with the
perpetrator (e.g. "I'm like my father, therefore I'll abuse
others too"). For other clients, they are based on having developed
"contaminated" sexual arousal patterns during the abuse
experience. Having been aroused during his victimization, the client
has created masturbatory fantasies which are based on this experience.
His subsequent sexual arousal becomes intertwined with abuse-related
fantasies.
To address the client's fears of perpetration, the therapist may
need to teach cognitive techniques such as thought stopping, so
that the client can control his fear-related thoughts or deviant
fantasies. If a client has used abuse-related fantasies to reinforce
his sexual arousal, he will need to develop other, more appropriate
fantasies.
The client will also need to reality-test his fears.
He needs to examine his current adult life to look for signs that
indicate a propensity to abuse children. Generally there are none.
The therapist may need to remind him that he has ways of meeting
his needs as an adult that were not available to him as a child
(e.g. he can express his anger or his need to feel powerful, directly,
without harming others). If the client's fears persist, with his
therapist he can develop a plan to put into place should he begin
to exhibit problematic behaviours. Developing a contingency "safety
plan" is generally very reassuring to clients who are afraid
that they may behave destructively.
CHALLENGING COMPULSIVE/ADDICTIVE BEHAVIOURS
Alcohol, drug, food and sexual addictions are common among abused
men, as are other compulsive behaviours such as overworking or compulsive
exercising. Therapists must be careful not to focus on the addictive
symptoms at the expense of the underlying issues that the addictive
behaviour was developed to mask.
Addictions serve many purposes. They can be a means of meeting
needs that are otherwise not being met or they can be a way to create
a distraction in order to avoid acknowledging certain feelings or
awarenesses. People develop addictive behaviours because, at least
in the short run, they help them cope with experiences they have
inadequate skills to address.
In order to change addictive processes, a client has to understand
the emotions that drive his behaviour and he must be willing to
recognize the cost of his addictions in his life. He must be willing
to experiment with different options for addressing the unmet needs
that have maintained his compulsive behaviour.
Therapists must be careful not to engage in a power struggle with
an addicted client. A client must be invested in changing his compulsive
behaviour if he intends to develop alternative coping mechanisms.
If the therapist is more invested in this change than his or her
client, the therapist will become frustrated. The therapist must
always be aware that only the client has the power to change his
behaviour.
Many therapists recommend that their addicted clients attend appropriate
12-step programs; these groups offer support, information and a
predictable structure that can greatly enhance a client's progress
in managing his addictive patterns. Towards this end, therapists
must keep themselves informed about 12-step self-help recovery and
maintain connections with their local 12-step fellowships.
As the client becomes aware of the state of mind,
or feelings, that he has been blocking with his compulsive behaviour,
he needs support to tackle them directly and develop healthy alternatives
for self-care. Often a client will have an abreactive experience
as he lets himself feel the affect that he has been blocking with
his addictive behaviour. This abreaction may generate information
about the seed of the addiction. This may enable the client, either
gradually or suddenly, to come to terms with the previously unacceptable
state of mind or feeling.
INCREASING AFFECTIVE EXPRESSION
Many male survivors have difficulty contacting their feelings.
They equate the expression of emotion with vulnerability and powerlessness.
Men often believe that they can rely on their physical strength
to protect themselves from feeling fearful or vulnerable. Some victims
have an inner monologue that says, "If someone were to try
to victimize me now, I'd show them who's in charge". These
men cover their vulnerability with a display of power. They may
become angry with therapists who suggest that they will benefit
from befriending their vulnerability. In their minds, they believe
these therapists are asking them to become powerless and to risk
being revictimized.
Other survivors fear that if they open the door to the expression
of their feelings, they will be flooded by uncontrolled affect.
"Because repressed emotions are often quite powerful, and,
given that the survivor equates feelings with (in some sense)
nonsurvival, the former abuse victim may actually believe that
emotional release is dangerous." (Briere, 1989, p. 86).
It is important that therapists do not push their clients into
affective expression before they are ready. To do so would be counter-productive
because it invites resistance and creates a power struggle. Entering
intense emotions too quickly may scare some clients away from therapy.
Expressing repressed emotions is a natural outcome of the healing
process. Therapists and clients must trust that a client will know
when he is ready to experience his feelings about the abuse directly.
For some clients, strong emotional release will not be a necessary
aspect of their healing. For others, especially those who are unconsciously
acting out their emotions in their current relationships, active
expressive work will be crucial for them to make the link between
their repressed emotions and their current behaviour.
Whenever intense affective work or abreactive work, occurs in therapy,
it is important that it is structured in ways that increase the
client's power and mastery. Recreating the original trauma without
making therapeutic gains is countertherapeutic for the client.
Clients need to be taught skills for identifying and handling their
emotional processes. Many somatic experiences, such as migraine
headaches or chronic back pain, cover unexpressed emotions. As the
client develops his full capacity to express his emotions, his physical
complaints diminish. Leehan and Wilson (1985) state that many former
abuse victims have so effectively blocked feelings out of their
lives that they do not even know they are having them. Often clinicians
need to ask "Do you feel tension in your shoulders? Knots in
your stomach? Do you get headaches?" Once such physiological
reactions have been identified, you can discuss their meaning and
possible relationship to specific emotions.
Many survivors experience their emotional lives in an all-or-nothing
manner. They either block their feelings and push them out of their
awareness, or they let their feelings explode and are overwhelmed
by them. Until clients learn healthy affective containment skills
and develop functional ways of expressing feelings, they are likely
to continue all-or-nothing emotional response patterns. Predicting
this likelihood can assist clients in managing their emotional inconsistencies
while they are developing healthier patterns of managing their emotions.
Many clients need support in developing a vocabulary for identifying
their different emotions. Therapists can teach clients that their
emotions fall on a continuum and that they can have varying degrees
of fear, anger, joy and sadness. Clients can be asked to become
keen observers of others to see how different people express their
emotions. The therapist can often reintroduce lost feelings to the
client by making statements such as "I'm making an assumption
that you are feeling some sadness (or anger or whatever) about what
you're telling me".
Personal and cultural injunctions that limit men's expression of
feeling can be identified and challenged. Parental injunctions such
as "Stop crying or I'll give you something to cry about"
need to be identified. Often parts of a client are still loyal to
these old messages and until they are brought to consciousness they
continue to shape his behaviour. Social prescriptions about male
emotional expression can be deconstructed by asking questions such
as "What are men taught in this culture about handling their
feelings?", "What messages are men given about being vulnerable?'
and "Do the messages that you've taken in from society about
how men should express emotions fit for you and your life?"
Challenging these outdated injunctions give clients new permission
to acknowledge their full range of feelings.
Anger is a feeling that most men have cultural permission to express;
It often becomes a unidimensional expression of feeling that consumes
all other emotions. Other emotions, such as fear or sadness, can
become distorted into anger and rage. In order to discover the feelings
that underlie their anger, clients must first be helped to fully
experience their angry feelings. For this to happen, men need to
make a clear distinction between anger and violence. Permission
to feel and express anger must never be confused with permission
to behave violently.
Usually survivors find that the emotion they most need to express
is not the anger they are feeling, but the fear or another underlying
feeling (such as profound sadness), that has been hidden by this
mask of anger. Separating primary and secondary feeling processes
is part of the therapeutic journey in the survivor phase. For example,
when a survivor begins to realize that he gets into fights with
others when he is trying to avoid feeling fearful, he can begin
to address his fear directly.
For men who are very afraid of uncovering their emotional responses,
creating distance from the intensity of their feelings can, paradoxically,
help them to contact their affect. Asking men to talk about their
feelings in the third person, as if they were talking about a good
friend, can help them reclaim this aspect of their lives.
If survivors have very ambivalent feelings, such as feeling both
intense love and intense rage at their abuser, therapists must be
careful to support both these emotions. Premature efforts towards
integration of ambivalence can slow the course of healing. Although
the client may be frustrated by the apparently contrary feelings
that he experiences, both his conflicting emotions speak to his
emotional truth, and both must be honoured. Many abused clients
need to learn that both love and anger can be felt simultaneously
and that the two feelings are not mutually exclusive.
Since the repressed or disowned feelings that survivors bring into
therapy are based on past experience, it is helpful for the therapist
to suggest future possibilities to the client to help him change
his present emotional patterns. Talking about a future in which
the client feels emotionally integrated and his feelings are in
harmony with his thoughts and behaviours, can seed the expectation
that this is an achievable goal for the client to work towards.
Contributors have used a variety of techniques to assist their
clients to increase their affective expression. Some use music
to elicit their client's feelings, playing a love song during a
session and asking the client to imagine singing it to himself.
This exercise may reveal resistance to loving oneself or cynicism
about the concept of love. Whatever specific response emerges, it
will be a doorway to further exploration of affective responses.
Using the gestalt empty chair technique is a method that
some contributors use to assist their clients to discover their
feeling responses. Clients who are concrete and practical in their
orientation may have difficulty engaging in this type of activity.
Clients who are willing to participate in this intervention can
have their entry into the exercise "primed" by having
them write a letter to the person or the part of themselves,
that they want to put in the empty chair. They can then start the
dialogue by reading this letter out loud. It is important that clients
understand that the letters they write in therapy are not intended
to be sent to the actual person to whom they are addressed; rather
they are directed to the internalized image of that person which
the client carries in his mind.
Clients who are comfortable with nonverbal media can be asked to
construct a collage to show what it feels like to be victimized,
angry or grieving. During the process of making the collage, or
while it is being discussed in therapy, the client will generally
contact the affect associated with the events shown in the collage.
Some contributors use breathwork as an intervention in emotional
release. Increasing the frequency of the breathing pattern, as in
holotropic breathwork, can encourage a client to regress. Therapists
who use these types of techniques require considerable training
in them before they can use them expertly.
Less technical forms of breathwork can occur that assist survivors
to develop skills to manage their emotions. Clients can be asked
to become aware of their breath while they are focused on a train
of associative events that elicit emotional responses. This ensures
that they do not start to hold their breath as the intensity of
feeling increases. Clients can be coached to send their breath to
a particular part of their body or to give a sound to their breath,
in order to shift their emotional awareness to a deeper level. The
suggestion that a client let his breath carry out the feelings that
are flooding him as he remembers a traumatic memory can give a survivor
a new option of being able to hold the memory in his awareness without
being traumatized by it. Practising breathing techniques which induce
physical relaxation gives a client confidence that he can be present
with his memories of the abuse without being overwhelmed by them.
Various forms of emotionally expressive work are used by
contributors to support their client's affective growth. The purpose
of this kind of work is to recathect the original feelings that
were dissociated during the abuse and to externalize them in concrete
form so that the client can increase his comfort with, or reduce
his fear of, these emotions. For instance, if a client is feeling
loss and sadness about his lack of self-esteem, he can be asked
to engage in a tug-of-war (using a towel or some other suitable
prop) to take back his self-esteem. During the tug-of-war, coach
the client to verbalize and vocalize his anger at having his self-esteem
damaged by his abuser. Similarly, if a client wants to rid himself
of his feelings of sexual shame, he can be helped to construct a
way of literally pushing these feelings away from himself. The key
in such dramatizations is to be alert for clues and cues from the
client that suggest a way of concretizing and externalizing feelings
and affective processes.
Role-plays can be a very effective way to elicit emotions.
If a scene from a client's abuse is role-played, it is advisable
to subsequently role play scenes which give the client nurturing
and protective messages so that the client can develop a supportive
and caring inner script. Clients should not be asked to role-play
their perpetrators during the survivor phase of therapy. If this
is done at all, it should not occur until the thriver phase. If
a client plays his perpetrator before he has thoroughly addressed
his own emotional reactions to the abuse, he can become too aware
of the offender's vulnerabilities and prematurely forgive his perpetrator
without fully exploring his own emotional processes.
Bioenergetic anger releases are used by some contributors
to help clients find a powerful, but safe, outlet for their rage.
Therapists must ensure that prior to engaging in this type of intervention
they make a contract with their clients to stop this work should
either the therapist or the client become concerned about the direction
it starts to take. Therapists need to be familiar with this type
of work so that they are emotionally available to the client during
the emotional release and not preoccupied with their own reaction
to the client's intense feelings. Clients who engage in anger-focused
work need to be coached to keep their eyes open and feet firmly
grounded so that they don't move into a blind rage. After this kind
of work, the client needs to debrief it thoroughly so that he can
integrate any new insights that he gains through the process.
Any props that a therapist needs to support active emotional release
work, such as tennis racquets, towels, pillows, etc., need to be
readily available in his or her office. Tactile comforters should
also be available so that clients can nurture themselves as needed.
Many men are reluctant to pick up a teddy bear or other childish
symbols of comfort, but they will use a stuffed basketball or a
blanket for the same purpose.
If emotional releases occur in the presence of other
people, such as in a group session, the observers need to be warned
that the process can trigger their own reactions. They need permission
to take care of themselves during the process. For some men, this
will mean covering their eyes and ears. Others may need to change
their seating arrangement so that they can sit close to someone
they trust. The observers will also need time after the emotional
release so that they, too, can debrief the experience.
WORKING WITH DISSOCIATIVE PROCESSES
Children are generally honest and forthright, unless they believe
that it is not safe for them to tell the truth. When they are told
not to talk about something that has happened in their lives, such
as being sexually abused, in order not to lie, they have to "forget"
what has happened. In technical jargon, they learn to dissociate
from their behaviours, feelings, sensations and/or cognitions.
If a child is likened to a house, a child who is dissociative has
closed the door on some rooms in his house and acts as if they do
not exist. Memories of being abused are kept behind metaphoric locked
doors, blocked from his conscious awareness. The abused-self is,
in effect, split off and dissociated from the child's self-identity.
Although an adult survivor may not have conscious memories of the
events that he has stored behind locked doors, he may exhibit behaviours
that hint at these ghosts. For example, a man who was abused in
a basement may have no memory of the abuse, but may become very
anxious whenever he has to enter a basement. Some men feel sexually
aroused until the point at which the sexual behaviour becomes interactive.
Although they do not recall being abused, their behaviour speaks
to the reality of their victimization. Patterns of behaviour or
thinking and feeling that do not belong in the present circumstances
of the survivor's life often indicate the presence of dissociated
experiences. In many ways
"...unassimilated trauma... [causes] flashbacks, overreaction
to stimuli, distortions of perceptions and high levels of internal
stress." (Steele & Colrain, 1991, p.1).
Dissociative survivors need to educate themselves about their dissociative
processes. They must begin to notice when and where they dissociate.
Keeping a journal and making daily entries that help them
to track their dissociative episodes is informative. As clients
begin to learn what triggers their dissociative states (i.e. certain
times of day, parts of a house, kinds of activities, etc.) they
have the option of staying dissociated or developing other ways
of dealing with the situation that is stress inducing.
As clients become conscious of their dissociative patterns, when
finding themselves dissociated they can ask themselves "What
part of me is needing to leave now?" Learning grounding
techniques can be helpful to survivors who dissociate to bring
them back into their present reality and present identity. Looking
in a mirror reminds a client that he is an adult and not a powerless
child. Writing about the situation that is eliciting traumatic memories
and writing or telling someone about the memories can validate
a survivor's experience and reduce his isolation. Keeping symbols
of his adult identity available can also reconnect a survivor
to his current self and break his dissociative state. Some survivors
are uncomfortable with these interventions because by engaging in
them acknowledges their abuse, which can be painful.
The most extreme type of dissociation is MPD. Clients who develop
MPD are overdifferentiated and their therapy is focused on assisting
them to reintegrate fragmented parts of self (called "alters").
To continue with the analogy of a house, clients who have MPD live
in many separate rooms with no corridors to link them together.
Therapy needs to help the client reconnect the rooms.
MPD is a coping strategy created to deal with abusive situations
that are too overwhelming for a child's immature ego to integrate.
Although the original intent of the defence was to secure the child's
survival, this unconscious coping strategy no longer works well
in an adult client's life. Parts of the self are identified with
a time that is no longer current and act in ways that are no longer
functional. The barriers between the different alters need to be
dismantled and the functions that they serve need to be integrated
and updated.
In general, if MPD is pathologized, clients tend to act in pathological
ways; if MPD is normalized, clients tend to act in normal ways and
carry on attending school, going to work and so on. In order for
the different parts of the self to fuse, clients need adequate stability
in their lives. Therapeutic safety has to be established with all
the alter personalities, one at a time, and the specific role of
each alter and the information that he or she carries must be brought
into awareness.
During the survivor stage of therapy, provided that a client feels
secure within the therapeutic alliance and is not consumed with
current life crises, dissociated experiences are invited back into
conscious awareness. This reclamation is often accompanied by the
release of intense repressed emotion. The client temporarily enters
an altered state of consciousness and, in effect, relives the incidents
that he has dissociated. This process is called abreaction.
Traumatic memories may need to be abreacted several times in order
to access all the missing pieces. (Steele & Colrain, 1991).
Steele and Colrain (1991) have developed a list of changes in behaviour
that indicate when abreactive work is finished. These are:
1. The client has a relatively continuous memory of the traumatic
time period(s).
2. He is not currently dissociating in an uncontrolled or dysfunctional
way.
3. He is not experiencing flashbacks or reliving the trauma in
other ways.
4. He can remember and talk about the trauma without intolerable
affect.
5. He has developed a subjective sense of the personal meaning
of the trauma.
6. He expresses interest in and hope for the future rather than
feeling overwhelmed by the past.
Survivors fall on a continuum of memory repression. On one end
of the continuum are those survivors who have total recall of their
abuse; on the other end are those who have no memory of their abuse.
The majority of survivors fall in between these two poles; they
have some conscious memories and some memory gaps. It is not necessary
for a survivor to reclaim all or even most, of his repressed memories
to heal. Survivors need only have sufficient memory recall to counter
their own denial.
When clients are doing abreactive work in therapy, it is often
necessary to schedule therapy sessions more frequently to give the
client adequate support and safety. Healing occurs when old traumatic
memories are revisited and new affective and cognitive associations
to them are forged. After successful abuse-related therapy, when
traumatic memories are stimulated this occurs in the context of
powerful new associations. The client has a new context and new
skills for processing his past experience. For instance, a new association
is made when a therapist witnesses a client's abreaction, so that
the abuse memory no longer connotes isolation and shame. Another
new association occurs when a client has permission to fully express
the feelings that his abuse memory invokes, without having to temper
their expression to meet other people's (i.e. the abuser's) needs.
(For more information about working with abreactive processes,
see Katherine Steele and Joanna Colrain's excellent chapter called
"Abreactive Work with Sexual Abuse Survivors: Concepts and
Techniques" in The Sexually Abused Male, Volume 2.)
Therapeutic Dissociation
Therapeutic dissociation, which can also be called trance-work
or hypnosis, is a powerful tool that can help clients manage their
unconscious dissociation. This intervention works paradoxically
- unconscious dissociative behaviours developed during the abuse
are managed and assimilated in therapy by the use of conscious dissociation.
Trance-work in therapy is an extension of a natural process. Daydreaming,
highway hypnosis and systematic relaxation techniques are common
everyday trance experiences trance that are familiar to most clients.
Before engaging in trance-work with clients, it is important to
educate the client about this kind of intervention. Therapeutic
dissociation is a natural process, but often it needs to be normalized
and demythologized for clients. Clients can be told that hypnosis
is a method of asking the subconscious mind to help the client in
his healing journey. The client need only remember events that will
be helpful to his healing process.
Before entering a trance, the client is grounded or anchored in
his present adult reality. This grounding is made in as many representational
systems as possible, so that the client can call on all of his senses
to assist him to leave the trance, should he wish to do so. Clients
are advised that spontaneous age regressions can occur in trance
states. This is a normal and common occurrence.
Using hypnosis, clients can often connect with thoughts and beliefs
that they developed as a child that are not available to their normal
consciousness. If the client has dissociated core negative beliefs
that he developed as a child, this information can often be reclaimed
during trance-states and brought into consciousness. (This process
is called state-dependent learning.) Thought errors and mistaken
beliefs can then be challenged by the client's adult mind.
Therapeutic dissociation invites less conscious aspects of the
client's mind to support his conscious mind in actively creating
change. It helps the client gain mastery over processes he has previously
used in unconscious and dysfunctional ways. As abuse survivors become
skilful at entering trance states at will, they begin to notice
the times in their lives when they unconsciously enter a trance
state. This new awareness brings an opportunity to develop more
functional methods of addressing stressful situations in their present
reality.
Two specific therapeutic dissociation interventions that were originally
developed by Yvonne Dolan are presented in Appendix D (see page
129). Because of their length, they are not included in the text.
One intervention helps clients in a dissociated state to ground
themselves; it is also an effective induction for physical relaxation.
The second intervention provides survivors with a format for processing
flashbacks and clarifying which aspects of their present reality
are or aren't threatening.
Contributors agreed that therapeutic dissociation is a very useful
tool to help clients manage their traumatic memories, but less useful
as a method of recalling repressed memories. Clients who recall
lost memories under hypnotic suggestion often don't feel confident
that the memories are valid. The contributors also agreed that therapists
who intend to use hypnosis with their clients must obtain adequate
training and supervision in this work.
Therapeutic dissociation is not a suitable intervention
for clients whose motivation to use hypnosis is non-therapeutic
(e.g. a client who is not really interested in working through his
abuse, but wants more information with which to blame others for
making his life miserable). It is also not advisable to use this
type of intervention with clients who are psychotic or with clients
who are taking legal action against their perpetrator. The reason
for this later prohibition is that hypnotically recalled memories
are not permissible evidence in court and a client could risk losing
his case on this technicality.
CHAPTER 7 - INDIVIDUAL THERAPY: THE THRIVER PHASE
With a few exceptions, such as when an abused client
either symbolically or actually confronts his abuser(s),
many of the issues addressed in this final phase of therapy
are the same as those addressed with clients who haven't
been sexually abused. I discuss the usefulness and appropriateness
of body-focused therapy in this stage of treatment for some
clients. Finally, I address the termination of abuse-focused
therapy and make suggestions for making this transition
successful. |
By the time a client enters the thriver phase of therapy, most
of the work that occurs in therapy sessions is similar to that conducted
with non-abused clients. The hardest part of the client's healing
journey is generally completed by this stage.
Often this phase is a satisfying and enjoyable time for both the
client and the therapist; dysfunctional abuse-created patterns have
been replaced with healthier ones, and the client's self-esteem
is dramatically increased.
Issues typically brought into therapy by thrivers focus on relational
difficulties with their partners, children or extended family, sexual
difficulties and dysfunctions, and personal safety and self-care
concerns. (Courtois, 1991). Typically, therapy to address these
issues is no different for clients who have been sexually abused
than for other clients.
By this stage of therapy clients should be able to identify and
manage their personal boundaries. Some clients choose to engage
in body-focused therapies in this stage of their recovery, a task
for which they should by now be sufficiently prepared.
For some survivors, body-focused therapy techniques
reach wounds that would otherwise be overlooked. Body-focused therapies
directly raise issues that are central to survivors' sense of safety,
such as their degree of comfort with their bodies, and with touching
and being touched. This chapter discusses these issues in greater
detail in a section called "Bodywork".
CONFRONTING THE ABUSER
One piece of therapeutic work that belongs in the thriver stage
and is unique to sexually abused clients is the need to fully reclaim
their personal power. This can occur by having the client confront
his abuser, either symbolically or, in a few cases, in person. In
cases of intrafamilial abuse, some clients express a desire to confront
several members of their extended family. A client's family is involved
only if his safety is not jeopardized by such a plan. Which family
members are invited to sessions focused on confrontation depends
upon their readiness to attend, the nature of the client's current
relationship with them and the nature of his relationship with them
in the past.
Before a confrontation session can take place, a client must be
completely confident of his own childhood memories and experiences.
Whether a family meeting is real or symbolic, several sessions need
to be used to prepare for it. The therapist must ensure that the
client's expectations for the confrontation session are realistic
and achievable. Possible outcomes of the session must be predicted
and strategies that support the client must be developed for every
eventuality. The key to successful confrontation is the client's
definition of his goals. Goals need to be stated in such a way that
achieving them depends on the client's own process, not on any desired
response from others.
For some clients, family sessions are disappointing. Their secret
illusion that if they speak about the problems in the family these
problems will be cured is shattered. Family members may react to
information about the client's abuse with denial, minimization or
rationalization. If the client is not adequately prepared for these
eventualities, he can be very upset.
Other clients find family sessions very confirming,
whether or not they progress smoothly. The opportunity to reality-test
beliefs about family members can be affirming as the client witnesses
their predictable behaviour patterns. Seeing his own growth and
acknowledging his ability to differentiate from his family can be
empowering. Sometimes a client's previous beliefs about his family
are disconfirmed and he finds that he can see his family more realistically.
BODYWORK
Information and memory about abuse is held not only in the survivor's
mind but also in his body. Some clients find that as part of their
recovery process they need to augment traditional psychotherapy
with non verbal body-focused therapies. They intuitively realize
that the trauma that occurred to their bodies needs to be addressed
by physical as well as symbolic interventions for their full recovery.
Bodywork consists of a continuum of interventions ranging from
those in which the client is fully dressed and no physical touch
occurs, through breathwork and yoga-like stretches, to full massage.
The types of healing processes that can occur as a result of bodywork
are myriad. They can be both physiological and psychological. A
trained bodyworker must be skilful in both physical process therapy
and psychological therapy. It is quite common for survivors to reclaim
abuse-related memories during bodywork. A trained bodyworker should
be prepared to assist his or her clients to work through abreactions
should they occur.
A physiological benefit of bodywork is that it helps clients to
become aware of any chronic unconscious physical tension that they
have developed as a defence structure. The body's defence systems
are unconsciously controlled. As a result of chronic nervous tension,
muscle fascia can become locked into defensive body armouring. Bodywork
helps clients become aware of these areas of chronic tension. This
opens opportunities to create change as they learn to relax and
discharge repressed affect.
The trauma of abuse often causes psychosomatic responses that unbalance
the nervous system. Overactive nerve stimulation results in hypertonic
reactions such as extreme tension and an inability to relax. On
the other hand, hypotonic reactions result in depression and lethargy.
Therapists can train survivors in relaxation techniques and assist
them to experience deeper and deeper levels of relaxation, gradually
restructuring both their emotional and physical responses.
Psychologically, bodywork has many benefits for survivors. Working
with a trained bodyworker may be the first time that a survivor
negotiates safe, contractual touch with another person. Bodywork
is an opportunity to practice receiving nurturing, nonsexual touch
in which the client controls the type of contact he receives. This
lets the client experience and define his own autonomous physical
boundaries.
Many abuse survivors have either avoided physical contact with
others or been hypersexualized and had indiscriminate physical contact.
In either case, they have experienced little real choice about the
degree of touch they receive and the circumstances under which it
is obtained. Learning to determine the type of touch they desire
by responding to internally defined needs can be very important.
Bodywork can be the circumstance under which this learning takes
place.
Many abuse survivors have distorted images of their bodies or they
have developed an avoidant relationship with their physical selves.
Some survivors feel very marginally connected to their bodies. Others
experience great discomfort with their bodies or their body processes.
Bodywork can help clients to reclaim and reconnect with their bodies
on their own terms. Many clients begin to feel their feelings
for the first time as previously dissociated physical sensations
and processes are brought into awareness.
Whether or not to engage in bodywork must always be the client's
decision. The therapist should not raise the possibility of bodywork
until the client himself indicates an awareness of the physical
aspects of his abuse-related experience. If a client feels too threatened
by bodywork, he will not follow through on any suggestions to pursue
this option.
With some exceptions, the bodyworker and psychotherapist should
generally be two different people to reduce the possibility of developing
negative transference in the psychotherapeutic process. This separation
of roles gives the client an opportunity to process his experience
in body-focused therapy or any transference reactions he may have
to the body worker, with a neutral and supportive third party, namely,
his therapist. An exception to this dual role for the therapist
occurs when bodywork takes place in a group setting and the psychotherapist
is not alone with the client.
As discussed previously, touch boundaries need to be very carefully
observed in psychotherapy. When a therapist has developed a relationship
with a client and the client subsequently expresses interest in
bodywork, a psychotherapist who begins to work physically with the
client, can be seen as inviting the client to repeat the original
abuse dynamic. The client may see the work that has occurred in
therapy prior to the bodywork as an elaborate grooming process.
The client's belief that authority figures will eventually attempt
to become physical or sexual with him is reconfirmed.
Although the two people who provide psychotherapy and bodywork
should be distinct individuals, their work needs to be connected.
Clients who are working with more than one therapist must be asked
to give consent for information to be shared between the various
service providers to ensure that the client receives the best possible
treatment. Working with more than one professional can lead to their
roles being unproductively split or insufficient information being
shared among all the parties.
Clients who have active addictions or suffer from psychotic breaks
are not candidates for bodywork. Neither are clients who have unrealistic
or inappropriate expectations about the bodywork process. Some clients
who have little memory of their abuse engage in bodywork because
they assume that this will unlock their repressed memories. Although
this may occur, there is no guarantee that it will. Clients may
end up dismissing the usefulness of bodywork, not because it couldn't
help them but because it did not conform to their expectations.
If a client decides to engage in bodywork, it is advisable for
him to ask other survivors and clinicians for a referral to a bodyworker
who has experience working with abuse survivors. He should also
rely on his intuitive responses; if he does not feel comfortable
with a bodyworker he should not work with him or her.
A client's first meeting with a bodyworker should focus on building
a working contract focused on the issues the client brings to this
type of therapy. The bodyworker needs to assess the client's needs
and determine if they are appropriate for his or her practice. Although
the bodyworker should not intrusively question the client about
his abuse, he or she needs to gather sufficient information to ensure
that his or her interventions are appropriate. Asking the client
to "Tell me only what I need to know about your abuse history
in order to help you heal" ensures that the client has control
over what he does or does not choose to disclose.
The bodyworker should explicitly tell the client that sexual touch
or sexual stimulation will not be a part of their relationship.
He or she should also inform the client that should the client experience
sexual feelings during the session, the client should signal the
bodyworker and they will renegotiate the work they are doing together.
At all times the client must be in charge of the kind of contact
he has with the bodyworker and he must be able to stop the process
whenever he chooses.
A skilful bodyworker will always ask the client's permission before
proceeding with any form of physical contact. If the bodyworker
notices any nonverbal client discomfort, he or she should say, "I
see you tense up when I approach your shoulder (or another body
part). Do you want me to continue? How would you like me to touch
you there?" The client's feedback should always guide the kind
of work that the bodyworker does.
It is important that bodywork occur in a forum in which the highest
ethical standards prevail. Both the potential for revictimization
and the potential for more complete recovery are present when a
survivor decides to pursue nonverbal therapy. A bodyworker must
operate with a very high degree of integrity to ensure that the
process of bodywork is safe and healing.
"Concerns about possible sexual implications of touch have
caused many psychotherapists to avoid bodywork altogether. The
solution is professional growth and education, not avoidance."
(Timms and Connors, 1990, p. 130).
TERMINATION
The final step of therapy for a thriver is to plan the termination
of his therapy. This final task deserves the same thoughtful consideration
that was given to all previous therapeutic tasks. Celebrating a
client's successes and acknowledging his ongoing skills and strengths
are part of this final process. A thorough review of the client's
therapeutic progress and an open acknowledgement of the importance
of the therapeutic relationship to both the client and the therapist
is essential. The client should leave therapy cleanly without any
unresolved loose ends or unfinished business about the therapeutic
process itself.
Clients indicate their readiness for termination by consistently
behaving in self-supporting ways that indicate that they are ready
to become the architects of their own recovery. This does not necessarily
mean that they no longer exhibit abuse-related symptoms; however,
when such symptoms are present, the client feels confident and capable
in addressing them.
It is important that the client who is terminating
knows that the therapist's door is open should he need to return.
Some clients are reassured by infrequent check-ups with the therapist
and use irregularly scheduled follow-up sessions to stabilize their
therapeutic gains. Other clients need to know that they can reestablish
therapeutic support without any loss of face or shame if unexpected
events occur, such as recalling previously repressed abuse memories.
Leaving the client with an option of renewing his contract with
the therapist, should the need arise, creates safety within the
termination process.
CHAPTER 8 - GROUP THERAPY WITH MALE SURVIVORS
OF SEXUAL ABUSE
This chapter describes a two-stage group process for
adult male survivors. Screening criteria and general groundrules
for the group are presented. The psycho-educational focus
of the first-stage group and the process-focused nature
of the second-stage group are described and differentiated.
I recommend a co-leadership model of group facilitation
and discuss issues relating to the gender of the leaders. |
Individual therapy provides male survivors with a safe and supportive
forum where they can identify and examine their abuse-related history.
An individual therapist is often the first person whom a survivor
has entrusted with information about his childhood sexual abuse
and how he subsequently handled this experience. Although individual
therapy has a central place to play in the recovery process, it
is enhanced and complimented by group treatment.
Abuse-focused group therapy provides survivors with opportunities
to normalize their experiences and reduce their isolation. Many
adult survivors are empowered by the realization that they were
not alone in having been abused by a trusted adult. Survivor groups
provide clients with an opportunity to experience a social milieu
where respect for personal boundaries is paramount and they can
practice new skills for relating to the self and others. Group members
model healing for one another and catalyze each others' growth.
Male survivor groups assist their members by providing a safe,
structured and nurturing environment in which to learn new skills
and resolve the trauma of sexual abuse. For many survivors this
is the first opportunity they have ever had to talk with other men
about hawing been vulnerable and hurt. A survivor who joins a survivors'
group is openly declaring that he was abused. Joining a group is
a tangible sign that his denial is over and he is willing to work
with his abuse issues more directly. (Timms & Connors, 1990).
The support survivors receive from their fellow group members takes
a number of forms. Being listened to and believed is a powerful
validation of each survivors' victimization experience. Hearing
other members' abuse-related stories often evokes previously repressed
feelings of compassion or anger within survivors. Initially these
feelings are projected onto other group members; eventually, they
are reclaimed and integrated into the self. Sharing emotionally
with other men without this intimacy being fraught with sexual undertones
opens new possibilities of male friendship for many survivors.
Group membership gives survivors opportunities to become aware
of maladaptive interactive processes and to practice new inter-personal
skills. Either by direct interactions with other group members or
through role-playing in the group, members learn how to resolve
conflict nonviolently, how to get their needs met and how to give
and receive nonsexual affection. Giving as well as receiving help
enhances clients' self-esteem and counteracts their sense of powerlessness.
Group members model both effective and ineffective coping strategies
for one another. They give each other direct and indirect feedback
on many levels. Frequently, group interventions occur indirectly.
Group members experience vicarious learning as they witness their
peers grow and change. "Each time someone takes more charge
of his life, it underscores the reality of recovery for everyone."
(Lew, 1988, p. 212).
However, group treatment is not a panacea for all
survivors. For some clients, a group experience can be overwhelming.
If a client's internal resources are not strong enough to counter
the weight of the group process, a group experience can be counter-therapeutic.
Each individual client has much less control of his experience in
a group than he does in individual therapy. The fact that clients
spark one anothers' memories and catalyze one anothers' growth can
be either positive or negative, depending on the client's readiness.
SCREENING POTENTIAL GROUP MEMBERS
The assessment process for potential group clients sets a tone
for subsequent group experiences. Time spent on a thorough and comprehensive
assessment is time well invested. In order to obtain useful information,
assessment questions need to be direct, concrete and behaviourial.
Group screening serves a function for both client and therapist.
Clients can use the assessment interview as an opportunity to find
out about group treatment and to gather the information they need
to make a decision about whether or not to engage in this process.
Clinicians use screening interviews to solicit data about potential
clients' abuse histories and their recovery process to date in order
to assess their potential readiness for a group experience.
During the screening interview, a client is expected to tell the
group therapists about his abuse history in sufficient detail for
the therapists to have enough information to be able to skilfully
facilitate the client's growth in the group. Clients should also
receive information about the group's treatment goals, philosophy
and process. It's helpful to give clients handouts about the group,
such as a list of acceptable and unacceptable behaviours; in the
group, or information about the group's purpose and structure. (For
an example of a list of behaviours that support group process see
Appendix E).
The contributors assess the following specific issues to determine
a client's readiness to participate in an abuse-related therapy
group:
The Client's Ability To Talk About His Abuse
Survivors must be able to talk about their abuse with some degree
of comfort before joining an abuse-related group. They should have
at least one clear memory of having been abused. If they talk about
their abuse as "it", or are unable to say or hear words
that refer specifically to abusive processes, they are not ready
to join a group.
Support
Clients who have no supports outside of the therapy group are not
good candidates for group treatment. A group member should have
access to at least one close friend or a 12-step support network
to supply social support outside of the group. Ideally a client
engaged in group treatment should also be engaged in concurrent
individual therapy, at least on an as-needed basis. Group therapists
should obtain a release of information from clients during the assessment
process, so that they have permission to contact the client's individual
therapist if necessary.
In some situations, a shortage of suitable individual therapists
or a client's lack of financial resources may rule out the possibility
of concurrent individual therapy. In such cases, before admitting
a client to their group, the leaders need to be very sure that the
client's self-care skills and social supports are sufficient to
meet the demands of group membership.
Motivation
Group clients should be able to discuss how their sexual victimization
is currently a problem in their lives. They should also be able
to articulate desired goals they intend to work toward during the
group process. If clients are referred to group treatment by their
individual therapist, it is important to ensure that the interest
in group therapy belongs to the client and not his therapist. Clients
who attend a group because someone else thinks they should are not
good candidates for group treatment.
Interpersonal Skills
Group members need to have adequate interpersonal skills to be
able to participate in a group. A client who is scapegoated by other
group members because of poor social skills is only revictimized
or patronized by group treatment. Until such time as a client has
sufficient social skills to fully participate in a group, he is
better served by other treatment modalities.
Self-Care
Potential group members should be able to describe self-care strategies
to deal with both their own pain and the pain of listening to others.
They must demonstrate that they not only are aware of such strategies,
but that they actually put them into practice.
Homophobia
Actively homophobic clients are not well-suited to abuse-related
group treatment. Abused men need to have space to explore their
sexual orientation and masculine identity during group treatment
and adamantly heterosexist attitudes curtail this exploration.
Both gay and straight men are treated in the same abuse-focused
groups. Some contributors said that they used to separate groups
into gay and straight, but noted that they no longer observe this
practice. The focus in male survivor group treatment is on the common
human experience of having been abused, not on the issue of sexual
orientation.
Contributors discussed a paradox - although many male survivors
are very concerned about the implications of having been abused
by a man (if their perpetrator was male) and many of them are quite
homophobic, they have a strong desire to establish closer relationships
with men. They noted that having both gay and straight men in a
group initially causes consternation. At first, the men are very
sensitive to each other's sexual orientation, as they establish
their own comfort in the group. However, when clients come to know
one another, and to understand the differences between pedophiles
and homosexuals, this tension eases. By the end of the group sexual
orientation has become an irrelevant issue as the group members
open up to one another and share their humanity.
Present Life Functioning
Clients who are actively addicted or very recently recovered addicts
are not suitable candidates for group treatment. Suicidal or homicidal
clients are too emotionally unstable to join a group. Clients currently
in physically or sexually abusive relationships need to address
these issues directly before they enter a survivors' group. A client
who is actively psychotic or currently processing a major life crisis
is not a candidate for group treatment.
Abuse-Reactive Perpetration
Therapists must ask clients if they have engaged in abuse-reactive
perpetration. You will have to determine how to evaluate acts of
abuse that happened when a client was an adolescent. A general rule-of-thumb
is that a client who has committed any patterned, repetitive acts
of perpetration, or who has committed acts of perpetration in the
last five years, is disqualified from participating in a survivors's
group.
MPD
Clients who have MPD can be suitable group members,
provided they have sufficient control of their various alter personalities.
Clients who can develop therapeutic contracts about how they manage
their dissociation and who can ensure that their persecutor alters
will not be brought into the group, can be group members. The group
therapists need to educate the other group members about MPD and
the process of splitting into after personalities, in order to normalize
this process.
A TWO-STAGE GROUP TREATMENT MODEL
The contributors have developed a variety of group models to work
with sexually abused males: single-leader groups, dual-leader groups,
structured and unstructured groups, open and closed groups are all
offered by different therapists in different locations. Some of
these models are based on theoretical principles, others are based
on practical necessities. However, whether or not they facilitated
a group themselves, all the contributors agreed on the usefulness
of group treatment. The group treatment model presented here reflects
both the contributors' experiences with group therapy and my own.
I recommend a two-stage group process. The first stage is a closed,
structured eight to 10 week psycho-educational group, which suits
clients who are in the victim phase of therapy. Clients who wish
to pursue group treatment further, are well served by a second stage,
open-ended, unstructured group which focuses on resolving abuse-related
trauma and developing functional life skills. The level of processing
and the intensity of this second-stage group are suited to clients
in the survivor phase of therapy.
There are many reasons why this model is suitable for survivors
of sexual abuse. As with individual therapy, safety is the guiding
principle in offering group treatment to survivors. Initially, when
survivors begin to attend an abuse-focused group, they are nervous
and hesitant. They feel anxious about discussing their victimization
with others. A structured psycho-educational group, in which the
focus of the group is known in advance, is a safe entry into an
unfamiliar group process.
Each week the psycho-educational group focuses on a selected theme,
such as sexuality, coping strategies, self-care, abuse dynamics
and so on. Clients are given written materials before each group
or exercises which they are asked to complete prior to the group
session. The group structure is flexible and the leader tells clients
to ask for time in the group to address their personal concerns
on an "as-needed" basis. No one expects any group member
to self-disclose unless he chooses to do so.
All the clients in the psycho-educational group begin the group
and end the group at the same time. This structure provides newcomers
to group therapy with an equal opportunity to develop safe and predictable
relationships in a group context. It also means that the group members
move through the various stages of group development on the same
schedule. The initial session focuses on group rules and procedures,
the middle sessions focus on abuse-related material and developing
group process and the final session acts as a celebration of growth
and sharing.
This gentle entry into abuse-focused material supports and empowers
clients. It also provides the therapists with an opportunity to
fully assess the group members' capacity to handle group process
within a contained structure. The psycho-educational group permits
clients who are not yet ready to move into a more intense process-focused
group to successfully complete a group experience. They can then
concentrate on enhancing their skills until they're fully prepared
to continue in a process group.
The second-stage group is more demanding of both clients and therapists.
This group is unstructured, in the sense that it relies on the clients
to generate the material that is addressed each week. It is less
predictable for both clients and therapists since the agenda cannot
be known in advance. It is also more fluid and more interactive
than the psycho-educational group. Clients may be asked to participate
in each other's work and they are expected to be active participants
in the group process.
The second-stage group is open-ended. This means that clients determine
how long they stay in the group based on its usefulness to them.
Contributors who run groups for male survivors estimate the average
length of time a client stays in a group is generally between one
and two years. Because group members have different entry times
into the group, the established group members take on the role of
enculturating and supporting new members.
Abuse-focused groups are a hybrid of self-help and therapist-led
processes. The sharing and support clients offer one another are
essential components of recovery. However, at certain times, the
therapists' skills in handling abreactive situations or helping
clients decode their transference reactions, are crucial to clients'
healing. Therapists must develop discernment about when to facilitate
the group process and when to sit back and let the group members
carry the ball.
The groups that contributors work with have from six to 10 members.
A group with eight members is ideal; however, one or two members
more or less will not interfere with the delivery of quality service.
The contributors run their group sessions for differing lengths
of time; 1 1½ hours was the shortest group session and three
hours the longest. I recommend theft group sessions be 2
2½ hours in order to give all group members sufficient time to fully
engage in the process. Group sessions should be held weekly, although
the second-stage process may take several scheduled breaks throughout
the year.
This two-stage model recommends that group membership
be reserved for male survivors only. I think most survivors, both
male and female, initially benefit from working with group members
of the same sex with whom they can more easily let shame and embarrassment
surface. However, some contributors work with mixed-gender groups
and report success with this model. Mixed-gender groups are best
reserved for clients who wish to pursue further group therapy after
they have completed an all-male second-stage group. A mixed-gender
group is best able to help a client who's in the thriver phase of
therapy.
GROUP GROUNDRULES
Both first and second-stage groups need to develop a set of groundrules
to provide safety and structure to the group process. Although many
groundrules are common among different groups, each group needs
to ensure that it's groundrules fit its unique identity. Spending
time during the first session of a psycho-educational group to develop
a set of groundrules is an essential task. In a second-stage group,
the groundrules need to be reviewed each time a new member joins
the group. Although certain groundrules remain consistent throughout
a group's life, others change with the group's developmental stage.
Many survivors will at first be unable to articulate their needs
in regards to making the group a safe environment. They are unused
to thinking of their needs and unused to having an opportunity to
voice them. Negotiating conflicting needs can also be a foreign
experience for many survivors. Because of these factors, the groundrules
need to be revisited from time to time to ensure that they're still
appropriate and timely.
Here are some of the key groundrules that contributors use to make
their groups safe environments for their members. It is very important
that group leaders use the groundrules to hold the group members
accountable to the group process. Violations of the groundrules
must be addressed. Many survivors come from families which were
chaotic. Having predictable and consistent limits set within the
group is an essential step in preparing the ground for the client
to take risks and begin to heal.
Confidentiality
Group members are expected to keep information about other group
members confidential. They can talk about their own experiences
in the group to their friends or their individual therapist, but
they must not identify other group members in their conversations.
Boundaries
Any invasion of another group member's boundaries is unacceptable.
Touching can happen only with the agreement of both parties. Sexual
relationships between group members are prohibited, at least for
the duration of the group.
Affective Expression
All feelings are acceptable in the group. However, they cannot
be expressed in ways that threaten anyone's safety - either the
safety of the survivor who is having the feelings or anyone else's.
Active Participation
Members are expected to be active participants in the group process.
Issues between group members are expected to be processed in the
group.
Attendance
Group members are expected to attend all group sessions. If a group
member is going to be absent from a session, he should notify the
group leaders before the meeting. If a client misses more than two
consecutive sessions, he has to renegotiate his membership in the
group. If a client decides to withdraw from the group, he is asked
to announce this to the group and return to the next group session
to say "goodbye".
Pass Rule
Any group member can choose not to participate in any part of the
group process, other than the check-in. He is asked to say that
he is "choosing to pass" so that the other group members
know he is making an active choice and not dissociating or avoiding
responsibility.
Sobriety
Group members should not attend the group drunk or stoned, or otherwise
unable to engage in the group process.
(Appendix E, "Behaviours Which Support Group
Process", lists group groundrules developed by one agency to
help group members create a positive group environment.)
GROUP PROCESS
Each individual session should have a predictable opening, middle
and ending stage. Establishing some predictability is a way of making
the group into a safe and healing environment.
Most groups begin with a check-in, where every group member
takes some time to speak to the rest of the group. The focus of
this time can be to let the group know how he has been doing since
the last session or to identify issues he wants to address in the
current session. Some facilitators start groups with questions such
as, "What small signs of healing are you noticing in yourself?"
or "What part of your body do you like the best and why?"
and ask every group member to give his answer as part of his check-in.
The questions change every session.
However the check-in is conducted, it needs to be predictable.
It also needs to have clear time and content boundaries so that
members do not use the check-in to start to do therapy-focused work.
Runaway check-ins that become the focus of an entire session reinforce
dysfunctional crisis-focused behaviour. Even when a client is in
crisis, he needs to be supported and contained through the check-in
so that everyone has the opportunity to address the group before
any one member takes the floor.
The middle section of the session will vary depending on whether
it is a first or second-stage group. In a first-stage group, unless
a client has requested time to process an issue, the group will
focus on psycho-educational material. Although some affective work
may occur, this is not the primary purpose of the group process.
A listing of topics that contributors have used with their first-stage
groups includes:
- legal and criminal aspects of sexual abuse
- typical roles in sexually abusive families
- types of offenders
- sex education and information about normal sexual development
- sexual and non-sexual intimacy
- assertiveness
- relationship styles - codependency vs. interdependency
- conflict resolution
- domestic violence - physical, sexual and emotional abuse
- child development
- parenting skills - consequences vs. punishments
- building self esteem
- self-care and stress-reduction techniques
- self-defeating behaviours
In an eight to ten week group, it would be impossible to address
all aspects of abuse-related behaviour. The members of the first-stage
group should be asked to select the topics that are the most salient
to them and these should be the focus of the sessions.
In a second-stage group, the middle stage of the session is unpredictable.
This time is used to work with issues that clients identify during
the check-in. The exact format this takes will depend upon the style
and skills of the group leaders. Whether the focus remains on the
individual who raised an issue, or whether an issue is worked on
by the group as a whole, tends to be a function of the group leadership
style, the nature of the issue, the level of safety and trust within
the group and the respective ego-strengths of individual group members.
For instance, if a client identifies feelings of shame during check-in,
it might be suggested that he work on this individually. This would
mean that he would discuss the times when he feels ashamed and he
would be offered interventions that would assist him to move through
his shame. These interventions may or may not involve the other
group members directly. For instance, group members could be asked
to act as a mirror for the client and to feed him back both his
views of himself and the group members' respective views of him.
Alternatively, all the group members could be enlisted in a shame-focused
exercise. They could be asked to write down five of their most shameful
experiences on separate pieces of paper. These pieces of paper are
placed in an envelope, which is circulated through the group. Each
member is asked to pull out one sheet of paper and to read it out
aloud. The men's reactions to these anonymous disclosures are then
processed. In this case attention is not put on one individual group
member; rather an issue is dealt with by the group as a whole.
Whichever style occurs in the group, after any intense processing
it is important that everyone has a chance to debrief his
experience. Acknowledging the importance of all group members, be
they quiet or vocal, close to the end of their healing journey or
just starting it, is very important.
In a second-stage group, although the process must be safe, it
may not be comfortable. Leehan and Wilson (1985) note that group
members form alliances or define their role in the group based on
their former family roles. The group leaders will challenge these
transferential patterns that clients bring into the group. Clients
may be distressed as their habitual ways of interacting with others
are challenged and brought into consciousness.
Group leaders need to monitor the types of issues that clients
bring into the group and to ensure that there is a reasonable balance
of intense process-focused work and enjoyable social interaction.
Clients' successes need to be celebrated and shared in equal measure
with their pain. The group must not only concentrate its energies
on resolving old traumas, but also on building functional new behaviours,
such as acknowledging positive events and effective outcomes.
At the close of every session, it is recommended that clients participate
in a ritual closing. Survivors need time to pull themselves
together before they leave the group and return to their regular
lives. If the group (or some of its members) has been involved in
intense processing, the members need time to debrief this work.
Bringing closure to the group process is important. Ritualized questions,
such as, "Is there anything you want to say before leaving
tonight?" or "What are you going to do for yourself when
you get home?' can be part of this closure. After intensive processing,
some groups give a group howl or another appropriate vocalization,
before closing the session.
Some contributors offer a weekend retreat for their second-stage
groups. The group spends a weekend together and stays in a relaxed,
comfortable setting. Having a longer time together allows the group
members to enter a deeper and more sustained emotional process.
Often, as the members speak of their abuse-related histories, new
content and feelings emerge. The longer timeframe permits the group
to engage in powerful expressive and symbolic work.
When the time comes for clients to terminate the
group process, whether the group is a first or second-stage group,
their departure must be conducted in a thoughtful and appropriate
way. Clients need to be well prepared for termination. They
need plenty of time to replace the support they have received within
the group with other non-group resources. They need to have permission
to return to group or other therapeutic processes, should the need
arise. Most importantly, however, they need to be aware of the changes
they have made by having participated in the group and they need
to celebrate their successes. Many clients are reluctant to fully
embrace their triumphs because they fear that this will somehow
tempt fate. Unintentionally, they discount their own hard-won achievements.
The group leaders must address this subtle discounting and support
clients in honouring their accomplishments.
GROUP LEADERSHIP
In abuse-focused group therapy, it is important to have two group
leaders, especially in a second-stage group. Survivors trigger one
another's responses in a group and often more work occurs than one
therapist can handle alone. With two therapists in each session,
one can take the role of being the primary leader and the other
can monitor the less active group members. Quiet clients may in
fact be quite dissociated and may need support and assistance to
return to the here-and-now process of the group.
The two group leaders need to be well matched in their knowledge
and skills. Both need to be able to nurture, challenge and confront
clients as the need arises. They need to work together as a team,
because group members will often unconsciously try to split them
into good therapist and bad therapist, replicating old family patterns.
Both therapists should expect transference reactions from clients
from time to time; this may run the gamut from being hated to being
adored. Group leaders must ensure that they have adequate time between
group sessions to examine these reactions and process their own
counter-transferential responses. Good supervision is essential
to assist the group leaders to separate here-and-now processes from
there-and-then transference.
Some contributors argue that the two group leaders should be male,
whereas others believe that a male/female co-leadership team is
a more appropriate model of group leadership. Both points of view
have merit. A male/female team gives the group members opportunities
to practice self-disclosure with both sexes and to observe mutually
respectful. male/female interactions. Indeed, role-modelling a healthy
male/female working relationship is often cited as one of the most
important benefits of male/female co-leadership. A male/male team
challenges group members' beliefs about men. Seeing two male leaders
working cooperatively and being either nurturing or confronting
as the situation demands, challenges clients' preconceived ideas
about masculine behaviour.
Most contributors agree that the skilfullness of
the therapists in working with abuse-related issues is the most
important factor. The fact that they work well as a team and are
knowledgeable and experienced outweighs considerations of gender.
Prior to joining a group, potential members should meet both leaders.
If a client is unprepared to work with a male/male team or a mixed
gender team, he can be helped to find other treatment resources.
CHAPTER 9 - CRITICAL ISSUES IN TREATING MALE
SURVIVORS
This chapter discusses three critical therapeutic issues.
Strategies that contributors have developed to engage male
survivors in treatment are presented. Some typical therapeutic
impasses that the contributors have encountered are discussed,
and finally, opinions about the complex issue of the respective
gender of the client and the therapist are examined. |
Contributors identified several common themes that recur in their
work with male survivors. Many potential clients don't seek therapeutic
help because they minimize the impact of having been abused on their
adult lives. When male survivors turn to professional services for
assistance, they often expect a "quick fix" for their
problems and are unprepared for the lengthy self-examination that
is an inherent part of abuse recovery.
Negative transference onto authority figures or
onto all adults the same sex as the abuser, can also contaminate
the therapeutic process. Until these dynamics are consciously examined,
clients may refuse to engage in treatment because they generalize
previous negative experiences to many situations, including therapy.
ENGAGEMENT STRATEGIES
Engaging male sexual abuse survivors in therapy can be difficult.
In fact, some contributors said that this is often the hardest therapeutic
task. Since many men don't think of their childhood sexual experience
as abusive, they experience cognitive dissonance when a therapist
uses sexual abuse terminology in response to their stories. If the
client has made no connection between his sexual abuse and his current
problems, abuse-focused language seems incongruent to him. If you
suspect a client is an abuse survivor, but he is not ready to identify
his experience as "abuse" or himself as a "victim",
you should use the more generic term "childhood trauma"
when referring to the client's past.
Educating male survivors about the ways in which their vulnerable
feelings (such as pain, sadness, loss and abandonment) are disallowed
because of cultural factors, and encouraging them to fully experience
their lives, gives them permission to redefine their understanding
of masculinity.
Personal change and being willing to face one's wounds takes courage
and conviction. These qualities fit with traditional models of masculinity;
affirming them in the client can make the engagement process proceed
more smoothly.
For obvious reasons, survivors have problems trusting others. Clients
need to be told that trust is not a prerequisite for recovery -
in fact it is more likely an outcome of recovery. The ability to
discern who is trustworthy and who isn't and to withhold trust until
it is earned should develop during the course of therapy. Safety,
however, is a prerequisite for successful therapy. Clear agreements
between therapists and their clients are essential; and clients
need to have ongoing support to explicitly state their needs regarding
safety-related issues. Because these needs are likely to change
many times during the course of therapy, clients need to know that
safety-focused issues are always open for discussion.
Encouraging clients to adopt a consumer attitude towards therapy
gives them permission to choose the person with whom they will work.
You can reassure potential clients by suggesting that they interview
several clinicians before they make a final choice about which one
to engage. During childhood abuse, victims experienced only one
option - namely, to go along with the offender. In therapy, clients
need to know that they have many options about whom they work with,
for what purpose and for how long.
Therapists should be prepared to be asked "Are you a survivor
yourself?" "What is your sexual orientation?" and
"Why do you do this work?" In many forms of therapy, clinicians
are expected to respond to such questions by deflecting them back
to the client. Although this kind of response certainly has its
place in therapy with male survivors, I suggest that before refocusing
on the client, clinicians give simple, direct and honest answers
to these questions. Survivors are likely to test your sincerity;
ordinarily you can enhance engagement process by straightforward
answers to direct questions.
Predicting certain possible therapeutic occurrences, such as periods
of stagnation, or actual set backs, helps clients to accept these
events when they occur. If you tell clients in advance that they
have a variety of ego states, some of which will operate at an age
or stage that doesn't match their chronological age, it gives clients
permission to let these repressed parts-of-self to emerge. Clients
may regress during flashbacks or hypnotic interventions; normalizing
and predicting these kinds of incidents makes them less frightening
if and when they occur.
Most survivors need to understand the here-and-now benefits they
can expect from therapy. Clients come into therapy expecting progress
and relief. They are not prepared for the intense, seemingly negative
affects that emerge during abuse-related therapy. Spelling out the
present and future benefits of doing therapy can help clients "hang-in"
when they're feeling discouraged.
Some clients have little experience with therapy and think that
it's like going to see the doctor. They expect a "quick fix"
with little or no effort on their part. Educating clients about
the therapeutic process and inviting them to weigh its costs and
benefits are crucial steps in the early phases of therapy.
Part of educating clients is giving them reasonable estimates of
the timeframe they can anticipate for therapy. Although most abuse-related
therapy requires at least a year's commitment, the therapeutic process
can start with a short contract of four to six sessions. This allows
a client to gauge the usefulness of the process and develop some
familiarity with it before he makes a decision about committing
his time and money to therapy. Offering time-limited and focused
contracts can greatly reduce clients' concerns about being overwhelmed
by the therapeutic process.
Working with clients to pace and plan the therapy in conjunction
with their internal and external resources is a very important part
of this work. They need to have sufficient personal resources (e.g.
time, money, social support) to engage in the therapeutic process.
If therapy becomes a further drain on a survivor's limited resources,
he may have to terminate the therapy prematurely, possibly during
the Survivor Phase, when he is actually more vulnerable than he
was prior to entering therapy.
When beginning therapy with male survivors, clinicians must find
each client's most comfortable form of processing information and
join with it. If a client is very concrete in his orientation, the
clinician will also need to be concrete. Frequently this means that
therapy with male survivors begins cognitively.
Initially, some survivors are very fearful and don't know what
to expect from the therapeutic process. To assist these clients
to engage in therapy, clinicians have a responsibility to model
willingness and comfort when talking about difficult issues and
to provide normalizing information to the client.
Other clients will come into therapy with their emotions worn "on
their sleeve". During initial sessions, these clients will
need assistance containing their feelings until they have a more
secure relationship with the therapist and can process their vulnerability
more safety.
When taking a client's abuse-related history, it's very important
to give each client permission to pace his disclosure process. If
he does not feel safe talking about his abuse experiences, he will
probably become dissociative or evasive which is counter-therapeutic.
Disclosure about the explicit events that constituted the abuse
is generally an on-going process rather than a one-time event. The
parts of the abuse in which the client was active or where he felt
the greatest shame are generally the last to be disclosed.
In Resolving Sexual Abuse, Yvonne Dolan talks about her
style of history-taking with abused clients:
"The therapist must communicate a state of concerned attentiveness
that is neither voyeuristic in its attention to detail nor minimizing
or inadvertently dismissive through lack of sufficient exploration
of the actual facts of the victimization. I like to begin by gently
asking my client to "please tell me everything that you feel
I need to know in order for you to know that I understand."
(Dolan, 1991, p. 26).
This type of respectful inquiry will reassure the client that the
therapist has his best interests at heart when asking about anxiety-provoking
material. Permission from the therapist to "Tell me as much
as you need for me to understand what happened to you" empowers
the client to make decisions about what information to disclose.
Men in recovery are advised not to change their personal relationships
until they have reached the Thriver Phase unless the relationship
is abusive. Usually relationships are enhanced by the process of
recovery as the client's self-esteem and interpersonal skills undergo
positive change.
It's wise to tell clients that they don't have to
be better before they start to enjoy life. Enjoying life should
be an ongoing process, not a future goal. Taking part in life-enhancing
activities which are not focused on recovery assists clients to
maintain a balance in their lives.
THERAPEUTIC IMPASSES
Despite clinicians' best efforts to engage their clients in the
therapeutic process, there are still occasions when clients reject
therapy or terminate prematurely. Certain themes emerged when the
contributors were asked to identify the circumstances in which clients
are most likely to leave therapy in an untimely fashion.
Experienced clinicians know that for many survivors, subjective
life experience worsens during the course of therapy, as memories
and feelings that were previous dissociated are reclaimed.
A client has no way of knowing that once he has let go of his maladaptive
coping strategies and developed functional coping skills, he will
find life much more fulfilling. Instead, in the short-run, he may
perceive therapy as making his life worse rather than better. Consequently
many clients prematurely drop out of therapy during the survivor
phase.
Predicting this experience can help a client to have faith in his
own healing and to continue with therapy. Using the metaphor of
a trapeze artist can be helpful. A trapeze artist has to let go
of one trapeze before he can catch the next one. For a period of
time he is hanging in the air without the support of either trapeze;
he has to have faith in the momentum that he as built up to carry
him successfully to his destination. The therapist may extend the
metaphor by pointing out that he or she acts as a safety net throughout
the process.
Some survivors have unrealistic expectations about therapy. They
enter the therapeutic process believing that it will compensate
for all their previous losses and hurts. When the process is unable
to meet these expectations, they terminate therapy.
Some survivors have unrealistic expectations about the time it
takes to make emotional changes. They want a "quick fix"
for depression for example and give up in despair when this does
not materialize. They may develop an angry transference to the therapist
who is not "fixing" them. The therapist needs to be adept
in identifying such a transference and relating it back to its traumatic
roots.
Other survivors confuse crisis resolution with recovery and healing.
Having entered therapy because of problematic life events, such
as a relationship breakdown or problems with authority figures at
work, they leave therapy as soon as the immediate crisis associated
with this problem is over. They don't realize that although the
immediate symptoms may have disappeared, the underlying dynamics
are unchanged. Believing that symptom relief is equated with a cure
leads many clients to leave therapy prematurely. However, if the
problems recur, which they typically do, some clients become more
willing to explore the issues which lie at the foundation of their
behaviour. Hence, it is advisable for therapists to make an early
and clear invitation - free of judgment - to their clients to return
to therapy at any time.
There is a symmetry between the injunctions (orders received as
a child) that a victim received during the abuse and his adult functioning.
When a client is not prepared to confront and change an injunction,
his loyalty to this injunction can result in his leaving therapy.
For instance, if a victim was told by his abuser that his life would
be in danger if he ever talked about the abuse, it's possible that
talking about the abuse in therapy may create too much anxiety for
him to be able to continue.
For clients who were severely and/or ritualistically abused, prohibitive
injunctions can lessen their abilities to process abuse-related
material. Engaging MPD clients whose "persecutor alters"
remain loyal to the abuser(s) can be a complex and sensitive task.
For clients who were less severely sexually abused, you need to
identify injunctions both in terms of their content and the person
who issued them. Cognitive reality testing and empowering expressive
work that challenges the old injunction is generally effective in
reducing its power.
Certain survivors have developed secondary gains
from their victim-based identities, and they may resist therapy
because they want to avoid changing dysfunctional life patterns.
If they do not see the benefits of changing, and can see only the
accompanying anxiety and effort, they will not invest in the therapeutic
process. Often such survivors have inadequate social or work-related
skills; before they can anticipate making substantive changes in
their lives, they first have to acquire skills that will support
such changes. For example, if a victim has projected his anger at
his abuser onto his bosses, and has continually lost jobs by getting
into power struggles with his employers, he may need to develop
anger control and conflict resolution skills before he can stabilize
his life sufficiently to begin abuse-focused therapy.
THERAPIST GENDER ISSUES
Clients who have been abused will unconsciously project their past
experience onto the present; in many cases, their relationship with
the abuser, or some aspects of it, will be projected onto the therapist.
These projections, or transferences, need to be decoded and understood
in order for the client to become aware of his unconscious patterns.
The therapist's gender as well as the therapist's personal behaviour
or characteristics can be responsible for eliciting transferential
projections. Gender-focused transference will have unique aspects
for each client, depending on his perpetrator's gender, his own
sexual orientation, and idiosyncratic aspects of the abuse experience.
There is some debate in the treatment community about the importance
of the gender of the therapist who treats male survivors. Some say
that men who have been abused by a male must be treated by other
men in order to restore a healthy sense of masculinity; others,
and I am one, believe that the gender of the therapist is a minor
issue compared to his or her competence.
Therapists who believe male survivors are best served by male clinicians
put forward arguments based in social learning theory and gender
politics. They believe that men who have been injured by other men
need to heal from these injuries by receiving nurturance and skilful
assistance from a male clinician. An implicit message of male support
is present when a male client works with a male therapist, and the
male therapist is a role model for appropriate, non-abusive male
caring. A male clinician has a similar set of cultural gender experiences
to inform his work with male clients, and this makes him a more
appropriate helping agent than a female clinician. When a male client
works through his issues about his sexual vulnerability, or his
discomfort with his gender identity with a male clinician, these
issues can, according to this position, be more deeply resolved
than they would be if the therapist were female. (Female clinicians
who work with female survivors have used almost identical arguments
to support a female client/female therapist model of treatment.)
In some cases, practical rather than theoretical reasons are given
to support the position that male clients are better served by male
therapists. Since many males, including male survivors, have internalized
misogynist, or sexist, cultural beliefs, it is proposed that men
enter the therapeutic process more easily when they can engage with
another man. According to these views, a woman therapist will not
have the same credibility in the client's eyes, and clients will
either dismiss the therapy process as "feminine" or attempt
to turn it into a social event. Some suggest that adolescent clients
are too embarrassed to discuss their sexuality or sexual abuse with
a female therapist and that such clients are better served by male
clinicians.
Clinicians who believe that the therapist's gender is an irrelevant
or minor variable in the healing process tend to use humanist arguments
to endorse their practices. Their position is based on the belief
that the safety, respect, empathy, integrity, openness, competence
and experience that a therapist brings to his or her work are more
important than his or her gender. For these clinicians, everything
a client presents is grist for the mill of therapy. When a client's
transference is elicited by a clinician, male or female, the transference
provides good therapeutic material to work with.
In group therapy, members of this school of thought use a mixed
gender leadership team because they believe that such a team has
the added benefit of modelling appropriate male/female relationship
and that both leaders can provide nurturing, respectful support
irrespective of their gender.
There is a range of opinion about the importance of the respective
genders of the therapist and the client amongst the contributors
to this study. Some firmly believe that although the therapeutic
process may initially be slower, a survivor who was abused by a
male will ultimately be better served if therapy is provided by
a male clinician. Others are adamant that gender issues are political
rather than therapeutic; their over-riding concern is that clients
receive good therapy.
All theoretical considerations aside, decisions about which clients
receive therapy from which clinicians often reflect administrative
rather than therapeutic concerns. A client's financial circumstances
may limit his therapeutic choices. Some agencies process clients
on a "first come, first served" basis, and decisions about
client/therapist fit are accordingly compromised. In other agencies,
the only staff who are knowledgeable about sexual abuse issues are
female and, for better or worse, these are the clinicians who serve
male survivors.
Ideally, each client should have free choice about the gender of
his therapist. Clients fears, conscious or unconscious, about revictimization,
and their sense of who they feel safe with, are very idiosyncratic.
Both client and therapist need to trust the client's intuition about
which gender initially feels the most comfortable, because therapy
needs to begin with the greatest possible sense of safety.
Eventually, survivors need to embrace both genders; at some time
in the recovery process, they will probably find it helpful to work
with their less preferred gender. The only rule that must be followed
is that a client must never be forced to work with a clinician they
don't feel safe with, be this gender-based or otherwise, because
this replicates the original abuse dynamic.
Gender fit between a client and a therapist should
ideally be based on the client's needs. In a similar fashion, a
client's sexual orientation is another variable that must be considered
when selecting a therapist. The gay subculture has unique norms
governing sexuality and relationships. Given the heterosexist nature
of our culture, many therapists are unfamiliar with the mores and
nuances of gay subculture. Therapists who are working with gay clients
must be willing to examine their own heterosexist attitudes and
assumptions and to learn about their clients' subculture.
CHAPTER 10 COUNSELLING ADOLESCENT MALE
SURVIVORS
This chapter focuses on therapy for adolescent male
survivors of sexual abuse. Difficulties with engaging this
population in treatment are discussed, and some means of
increasing the likelihood of therapeutic engagement are
provided. Issues regarding the assessment process with adolescents,
including their motivational level and their maturity, are
discussed. Guidelines for working with this population are
presented, and several interventions that contributors have
developed to work with this population are outlined. Finally,
group treatment is recommended as a treatment modality of
choice for this population because of its developmental
appropriateness. |
Adolescent victims of sexual abuse are no different from adult
survivors in the ways they are affected. Both feel betrayal, stigmatization,
shame and anger. Both have questions about masculinity and sexual
identity. Developmentally, however, adolescent victims are different
from adults, and their therapy must reflect these differences.
Adolescents are still forming their physical, psychological and
sexual identities. They have more changeable personas than adults,
and are more willing to experiment with a variety of different,
and often contrary, psycho-social styles. Adolescents are very influenced
by their peers. For most teenagers, being accepted by their peer
culture is paramount; the parts of self that they most consciously
identify with generally reflect the values of their current peer
group.
Adolescent males who have been sexually abused are reluctant to
incorporate experiences they consider deviant (such as their sexual
abuse) into their sexual personas. Adolescent boys tend to accept
the myth that says they are expected to know all about sexual matters,
no matter what the limits of their personal knowledge. Admitting
they have concerns about sexuality is considered "uncool".
For many adolescent victims, the power of culturally approved mythologies
about sexuality and masculinity overwhelms their own experience.
Because of this, many of them deny their victimization. They either
repress their memories of having been abused, or rewrite their histories
and describe the abuse as consensual. Since many offenders are skilful
at giving responsibility for their actions to their victims, this
misconstruction of reality is generally also supported by the perpetrator.
Other victims clearly see their abuse as exploitive, but deny its
having had any impact on them. (Froning & Mayman, 1990).
Ironically, it is often easier for adolescent victims to discuss
their sexual offences against others than it is to discuss their
own victimization because offending behaviours conform better to
cultural expectations about masculine power and control. Many adolescent
victims who participate in counselling first enter treatment facilities
as adolescent sexual offenders. Adolescent victims who do not act
out their abuse-reactive behaviours in ways that cause concern to
others are frequently never treated, especially if their discomfort
with their victimization keeps them silent.
Adolescents tend to think of themselves as invincible.
They are not usually aware of the circumstances and/or needs of
their childhood that left them vulnerable to being abused. They
blame themselves for their victimization. Still forming their identities,
they don't see their relationship difficulties or dysfunctional
behaviours as being related to sexually victimization. They don't
have an extensive history of intimacy problems to motivate them
to examine the origin of these difficulties. Instead, they tend
to see themselves as secretly flawed or they accept their difficulties
as inevitable, characterological traits.
THE ROLE OF COUNSELLING WITH ADOLESCENT MALE
VICTIMS
Therapy is a counter-cultural experience for adolescent males.
Male self-reliance, independence and action-based behaviours are
challenged by the therapeutic process. For many adolescent victims,
participating in therapy has connotations of "being crazy"
or "sick". It's a challenge for clinicians to package
therapy so that it can be a helpful and non-stigmatizing experience
for adolescent victims.
Whether his sexual abuse was intrafamilial or extrafamilial will
have an impact on an adolescent victim's therapeutic experience.
In either circumstance, the adolescent victim's family needs to
be involved in treatment if he is living at home. If the abuse was
intrafamilial, other family members will also need to be involved
in extensive counselling processes. It the family members want to
remain together, their treatment will involve intensive individual,
group and family therapy. Even when families have responded appropriately
to the disclosure of abuse, the adolescent male victim's recovery
will be enhanced by family therapy.
For adolescent clients who live independently from their families,
family therapy may be impossible. Adolescents in foster or residential
care, or those living on their own, need support within their immediate
community if they are going to address their victimization. If this
support does not exist or if there are other more pressing issues
that are preoccupying the adolescent, focusing on abuse-related
events is counter-therapeutic. Waiting until an adolescent is ready
to address his victimization is a very important aspect of the therapeutic
process.
An adolescent needs the support and caring of his family and community
to fully integrate and resolve his victimization. The victim's family
(or community) also needs assistance. If inadequate parental supervision
contributed to the boy's victimization, the clinician must address
this, especially if there are young children in the family. Some
families overprotect children who have been victimized; they excuse
all aberrant behaviours, no matter what its origin, because of the
abuse.
Counselling adolescent male survivors of sexual abuse takes a different
focus from that taken with adults. Counselling is the operative
word, rather than therapy, since the process concentrates on skill
building rather than trauma resolution. This does not mean that
trauma resolution does not occur. It does. However, with adolescent
clients, abreactive-type processes are not invoked in the same way
that they are with adult survivors. Very few adolescent victims
have a sufficiently mature personality, or sufficiently well-developed
ego strengths to undertake voluntary abreactive processing. However,
in their favour, adolescent victims have rarely built up the same
entrenched dissociative processes which cause abreactions and hence
they can often process their abuse-related experiences more directly.
Adolescent clients need to deal with the impacts of having been
abused which are currently affecting their lives. Often this means
that treatment focuses on issues such as sexual expression and sexual
identity. They need to be helped to see that sexuality is, in itself,
a positive force in their lives, but that non-consensual sex is
damaging. They need to be helped to distinguish between peer contacts
and power contacts in regards to sex. Their understanding of sexuality
needs to be expanded to include more than genital sexual arousal.
Clinicians also need to prepare adolescents for
the possibility that they may need to re-visit their sexual abuse
and its impact on their lives as they pass through different developmental
stages. This possibility must be handled with a light touch to ensure
that it doesn't become a self-fulfilling prophecy. However, it is
common for sexual abuse victims to examine their abuse-related experiences
as they mature. For instance, when an abuse victim becomes a father
and fully understands the vulnerability of children in the face
of adult power, his grief for his own lost childhood may be reactivated.
Hence, counselling needs to be a positive experience for adolescent
clients to keep the door open for future therapy, should the need
arise.
ASSESSING ADOLESCENT VICTIMS OF SEXUAL ABUSE
Assessing adolescent clients requires a skilful and light touch
on the part of the assessing clinician. If assessments are to provide
useful diagnostic information, clients must co-operate by giving
truthful and detailed answers to the questions asked. In order for
this to happen, the client must be confident that the assessment
process will help him.
Some adolescents respond to an invitation to "lift the burden
of secrecy" that has surrounded their abuse. If they see talking
about their abuse as a means of relieving their feelings of stigmatization
and low self-esteem, they will co-operate more easily with the assessment
process.
Most adolescent males are not used to talking explicitly with adults
about their sexuality. In fact, if this has happened at all, it
has generally occurred within the context of being sexually abused.
Hence, an assessing clinician must make his or her role and intent
very clear to abused clients, so that they don't think that the
assessment is an elaborate new grooming procedure.
Explaining the assessment procedure and the assessor's role to
adolescent clients is an essential first step in establishing a
trusting relationship. This is especially important if the assessor
will not be the client's ongoing therapist. Clients need to know
in advance if they will be assessed by one clinician, but treated
by another.
Using a medical analogy can help adolescent victims understand
why they have to reveal intimate information about their abuse.
The assessing clinician can tell the client that if someone experiencing
severe stomach cramps were taken to an emergency ward, the doctor
who examined him would need to know why he was having so much pain
before treating him, otherwise the patient might be subjected to
surgery when in reality he only needed to get rid of some stomach
gas. In the same way an assessment enables the clinician to be skilful
in his interventions. The information that he receives from the
client assists him to formulate an effective treatment plan.
During a good assessment the clinician will educate the client
about both abuse and treatment processes. Since adolescent male
victims often feel a great deal of shame about having repeatedly
been involved in abuse, they need to be reassured about the normalcy
of their behaviour. If an assessing clinician tells the client that
abuse victims usually have very good reasons for not telling
anyone about the abuse, and asks the client if he had reasons for
not telling, this eases the clients shame for not having told when
the abuse began.
Adolescent clients also carry shame about their physical arousal
during the abuse. Sharing basic physiological information can assist
the assessment process. When an adolescent client understands that
if his penis is stimulated, it will become erect, no matter who
is stimulating it or why, he feels less ashamed discussing his arousal.
In a humorous way, the assessing clinician can remind an adolescent
client that his penis doesn't have eyes or a brain or any other
way to determine who is stimulating it.
The clinician needs to show adolescents that when an event happens,
it can be understood in many different ways. They may have interpreted
their physiological response to the abuse by thinking "I'm
very sexy" or "I'm gay" or "I'm a pervert";
these interpretations may have limited their understanding of the
abuse. Helping clients to see how they made sense of being victimized
can give them permission to become less self-blaming in their interpretation
of these events. This can increase their ease in discussing abuse-related
matters. Often a simple analogy can help clients see how interpretation
changes our understanding of an event. For example, if you have
been expecting a telephone call from a friend who doesn't call,
you'll react differently if you think your friend has had an accident
from the way you'll act if you think your friend is mad at you.
Adolescent clients need to know that their strengths as well as
their weaknesses are important to the assessing clinician. The assessment
process should focus on gathering information in as much detail
as possible. This includes information about the clients successes
and positive coping skills.
If a client displays cognitive errors, such as being very self-blaming,
these need to be noted, but not challenged, during the assessment.
The treatment stage of therapy is the time to change thinking errors,
not the assessment stage. (Gerber, 1990). If the assessor prematurely
challenges dysfunctional cognitive patterns, the client may feel
unheard or misunderstood; and may subsequently withdraw from disclosing
any further personal information.
Frequently everyone in an adolescent's life, except the adolescent
himself, wants him to get treatment. If an adolescent is not motivated
to address his abuse-related issues, treatment will only reinforce
his experience of dysfunctional power dynamics. An adolescent client
needs to know that he is a partner in the treatment process that
he is in charge of what he will tell the clinician about himself,
and when he will do so.
Forcing an adolescent into treatment before he is motivated is
counter-therapeutic. The only exception to this rule occurs when
an adolescent is abusing younger children and must be held accountable
so that he doesn't continue to endanger others.
During the assessment process, an adolescent client's ego strengths
and ability to handle anxiety must be determined. If focusing on
his sexual abuse will increase his destructive behaviour towards
himself or others, it is not advisable to proceed. Many adolescents
do not have sufficiently sophisticated coping strategies to contain
the emotions that surface when they recall their abuse. If this
is the case, their treatment must focus on building self care skills,
rather than on abuse-related material per se.
An adolescent client's dissociative tendencies need to be assessed
prior to treatment. Dissociative adolescents are often self-destructive,
experience drastic mood swings, and act out behaviourally in ways
that are inconsistent with their primary personas. (A test to assess
adolescent dissociation called the Dean Adolescent Inventory Scale
is included in Appendix F, page 133).
(For more detailed information about assessment
issues for adolescent male victims of sexual abuse, including specific
assessment questions, see "The Assessment Interview for Young
Male Victims" by Paul Gerber. A reference for this article
can be found in Appendix G.)
THE TREATMENT PROCESS WITH ADOLESCENT VICTIMS
OF SEXUAL ABUSE
Adolescent victims of sexual abuse exhibit the same wide range
of symptoms and strengths as their adult counterparts. However,
due to their youth, adolescents have had less opportunity to internalize
dysfunctional coping mechanisms. They are at a developmental stage
that encourages experimentation, and are often more willing than
adult to try out new behaviours provided they don't feel embarrassed
or humiliated doing so.
Therapist's Style
Therapists who work with adolescents must be comfortable with this
age group. They need to be able to work with erratic mood swings
and attitudinal challenges without becoming parental. The therapist
needs to be confidant in his or her own role, but not authoritarian.
The therapist must be comfortable with adolescent clients' jargon
and language. Adolescent communication styles and sexual nomenclature
come in and out of fashion; the therapist needs to keep abreast
of these trends.
Gender of Therapist
Adolescent male victims are generally more at ease discussing their
sexuality with a male therapist. Knowing that the therapist has
a similar psycho-physiological reality from which to discuss sexuality
enhances the clients' level of comfort. However, if an adolescent
client was abused by a male, discussing the abuse with a female
therapist may initially feel safer. It is important that clients'
preferences about the gender of their therapist be respected and
honoured.
Clear Boundaries and Limits
Therapists must explicitly state that during the course of counselling,
adolescent clients will be expected to talk about their sexuality,
but that they will always be in charge of how much, or how little,
they say. Therapists who work with adolescent survivors need to
approach sexuality with a "no big deal" attitude and convey
a direct and relaxed approach to sexual issues.
Typically, adolescent clients will test their therapists' abilities
to handle sexual material. The therapists' responses will determine
the extent to which the client engages in the therapeutic process.
Therapists can assume that a client won't disclose the full extent
of his abuse until he feels confident that he is safe to do so.
Asking questions such as "What else happened?", or "Is
there something more to tell me about what happened to you?"
can help the client make a full disclosure. Asking "What kind
of sexual experiences have you had?" is a non-stigmatizing
way to ask about abuse and will generally elicit more information
than questions which contain the words "sexual abuse".
Not only must the therapist be explicit regarding his or her expectations
that the client's sexuality will be discussed during his counselling,
but he or she must also be explicit in regards to other therapeutic
boundaries and limits.
Adolescent clients need to know the therapist's boundary of confidentiality.
Therapists must state that they will break therapeutic confidentiality
if they're concerned about the safety of the client or anyone else.
For instance, if the client discloses information about other abusive
incidents, the therapist is legally bound to report them. If other
members of the client's family are also in treatment, the client
needs to know how information will be shared between the different
treatment providers. You also need to clarify whether your client
will be given information from other family members' sessions, and
vice versa.
Counselling Process
Treatment with adolescent victims generally proceeds best if it
is short-term. It needs to clearly focus on the presenting problem
or issue that is most pertinent to the client. Partializing treatment
so that it deals with one piece of work at a time is a good strategy
to use with adolescent survivors. Creating a succession of small
successes boosts clients' self-esteem. It also ensures that the
treatment process is a positive experience for the client, thus
increasing the likelihood that he will use therapeutic resources
in the future.
For example, if an adolescent victim is acting out by being aggressive
with authority figures (unconsciously displacing his anger at his
abuser onto other adult figures), his therapeutic contract might
focus on anger expression and developing safe and effective ways
to manage his angry feelings. The therapist might make some attempt
to connect his present anger with his past betrayal, but the primary
focus of therapy would be on assisting the client to address his
here-and-now concerns. Once he had learned and integrated these
new skills the contract would end. The therapist would encourage
the client to renew therapy if in future he developed new psycho-social
problems or showed other symptoms related to his sexually abuse.
Adolescents often engage more quickly with the therapeutic process
if they can approach abuse-specific issues with a little distance.
This can occur in a variety of ways. One method is to use externalizing
techniques, such as drawing or other art media.
Asking an adolescent male survivor to draw what he would like to
do to his perpetrator can be a door opener to discussing anger,
and constructive means of channelling intense feelings. Often boys
have chosen dangerous or socially unacceptable ways to express their
anger (such as putting a fist through a window), and they need to
find safe ways to discharge this emotion. Some boys are so afraid
of the power of their rage that they have shut down their angry
responses, and their anger is sublimated into other areas of their
life. For clients like these, ft is very beneficial to develop assertiveness
skills and learn to separate anger and violence.
Psycho-educational materials help adolescent clients process their
abuse. They not only fill in information deficits that the clients
may have, they also act as door openers for more personal disclosures.
For example, if a client is reluctant to share any information about
the specifics of his abuse you can give him a set of flash cards
that have different types of touching described on them. (The cards
can include behaviours such as hugging, kissing on the cheek, French
kissing, touching someone's breasts, shaking hands, fellatio, punching
someone, etc.). Ask the client to sort the cards into three piles:
OK touch, not-OK touch and unclear touch. His choices, and his reasons
for making these choices can then be discussed. You can ask more
participatory clients to generate their own list of different types
of touch.
Sometimes reading adolescents stories which were originally intended
for younger children can stimulate discussion about events in their
childhood. The client's developmental age is often younger than
his chronological age. Provided that he doesn't experience being
read to as condescending, his inner child will often be activated
by more juvenile reading material. This kind of stimulation can
"unfreeze" parts of the self that shut down at the time
of the sexual abuse. In a similar manner, showing videos and movies
that deal with abuse can be an indirect way of accessing abuse-related
material. (See Chapter 12 for a listing of video and written resources.)
Separating the parts of self that a client accepts from those that
he rejects or is uncomfortable with, can be a first step in working
towards integration. It may help to refer the different parts of
the clients as "sad Bob", "angry Bob" or "scared
Bob" and talk about them as if they were separate.
To reshape a client's sexual behaviour into more age-appropriate
forms, it's often necessary to work with the clients' sexual fantasies.
Using guided imagery can be helpful in this regard. For example,
after bringing your client into deep relaxation, ask him to imagine
a place of safety for himself that is the most beautiful place that
he knows. Tell him that he will have complete privacy in this place
and ask him to think about what he'd like to do sexually that would
give him the biggest possible turn-on. Ask him if it involves anyone
else. It he says "yes", ask him to note the person's name.
(Be careful not to specify an age or gender in order to give the
client room to fully develop his own fantasy.) Ask your client to
thank the person for joining him in his fantasy and to let the person
leave the fantasy in the smoothest possible way. (Actually imagining
the sexual behaviour with the other person is discouraged because
this only reinforces possibly deviant behaviour.) Then you gradually
bring the client back into the counselling session. The fantasy
and the role of the person or persons the client called into his
fantasy are debriefed. If the client's arousal patterns are based
on deviant behaviours, he is helped to develop more orthodox associations
to sexual stimulation.
Adolescent clients need help to develop safety plans to reduce
the possibility of being revictimized, or to put in place should
they actually become revictimized. This is especially important
for clients who were intrafamilially abused and who continue to
live at home. In cases where the abuse was intrafamilial, all the
family members need to be involved in developing "fire drills"
to put into effect should any member of the family have concerns
about either their own, or another family member's safety. These
"fire drills" can consist of ensuring that all family
members, especially the victim, has a trusted person to whom they
can turn if they have safety concerns. In some cases, they involve
family contracts about how certain family members agree to interact
with one another. Whatever form they take, they're essential to
ensure that adolescent clients are familiar with both preventative
and crisis-based self care strategies.
Group Treatment
Group treatment is a particularly effective treatment modality
for adolescent victims of sexual abuse. Given that adolescents are
peer-focused and many have negative associations with one-to-one
contact with an adult because of their victimization, group treatment
is a safe and effective form of treatment. The group process breaks
the adolescent victim's isolation and helps them to destigmatize
their victimization. Peer contact with other victims encourages
adolescent survivors to openly acknowledge their abuse experience.
A group format gives clients options about how much or how little
of themselves they disclose, since they are no longer the single
focus of a therapists' attention. For many adolescent victims, being
able to move in and out of the spotlight makes the group process
more comfortable than individual counselling sessions, where they're
always the centre of attention. The control this gives adolescent
clients generally increases their feelings of safety and hence they
participate more freely in the treatment process.
It is recommended that therapists provide the same
two-stage group treatment model to their adolescent clients that
was described for adult survivors in Chapter 8. Although the discussion
in an adolescent group will reflect the developmental concerns of
this population, the therapeutic issues regarding assessment and
group processes are the same as for an adult group.
CHAPTER 11 - THERAPIST ISSUES
Because therapy is an interactive process, the well-being
and integrity of the therapist has a fundamental impact
on the course of therapy for the client. Clients will intuitively
be aware of inconsistencies between what a therapist says
and what he or she does. This section of the text describes
important self care strategies for therapists to incorporate
into their work and lives. It suggests seven ways to recognize
and manage therapists' counter-transference. Finally, I
briefly mention some special concerns for therapists who
are themselves survivors of childhood sexual abuse. |
Providing therapy to male survivors has many intrinsic rewards.
The intimacy of the therapeutic process and the chance to participate
in a client's heating and growth provides a therapist with both
professional and personal satisfaction. A therapist's confidence
and effectiveness build as he or she develops specialized skills
for working with survivors and as his or her intuition in applying
these skills becomes more finely tuned.
However, empathetic listening to survivors' experiences leaves
the therapist open to vicarious experience of trauma and loss. Ironically,
Briere (1989) suggests that the therapeutic empathy of clinicians
makes them especially vulnerable to personally incorporating the
trauma expressed by their clients, thereby creating secondary victims
of the therapist.
The phenomenon of vicarious traumatization, or traumatization by
proxy, is one that all therapists who work extensively with clients
who have experienced childhood trauma must learn to manage. Finding
the balance between being able to absorb and respond therapeutically
to the events that clients disclose, and distancing themselves from
this information as a means of self protection, is an ongoing issue
for therapists.
Not only do therapists vicariously experience their clients' trauma,
but they may be directly affected if a client's story triggers unresolved
issues from the therapist's past history. Some therapists report
violent and disturbing dreams after working with survivors. (Briere,
1989). Clinicians who work with abuse survivors need to have ongoing
supervision to help them process their responses to their clients;
in some cases, personal therapy is an important component of therapist
self care.
Therapists who work with clients who have been sexually abused
often become more vigilant about their own, or their childrens'
personal safety. Several contributors commented that after working
with many survivors of sexual abuse they view the world more cynically
and less trustingly than before. There are certainly some personal
costs for the therapist who works extensively with abuse survivors.
Because therapy is an interactive process between two people, both
are subject to being influenced by the other. However, given the
nature of the therapeutic contract, it is essential for therapists
to develop strategies to handle their own counter-transference so
that they don't act it out in therapy. In addition, therapists must
become aware of their own thematic life issues so that they don't
unconsciously play them out with clients.
Here are some common counter-transferential concerns
that therapists experience and procedures to reduce their negative
impact on both client and therapist.
COUNTER-TRANSFERENCE IN THERAPY WITH MALE SURVIVORS
Therapists, as well as clients, internalize cultural attitudes
and gender scripts. To the extent that the therapists are unconsciously
acting out such scripts and attitudes, they may unknowingly project
them onto their client relationships. Such contamination of the
therapeutic process needs to be identified, challenged and transformed.
Just as therapists support their clients in challenging ways of
living that are no longer useful, so they themselves need to be
challenged and supported in developing and enhancing their therapeutic
skills.
The emotions and dysfunctional behaviours that male survivors present
can elicit a range of responses in the therapist. It is not unusual
for therapists to begin to develop the same kinds of defences shown
by their clients during their work together. Therapist dissociation,
minimization, avoidance, helplessness and other similar parallel
processes can occur.
Generally, a change in the therapist's affective state or behaviour
indicates the presence of counter-transferential dynamics. For example,
some therapists start to feel sleepy when their clients discuss
material that echoes their own thematic issues. Other therapists
will redirect their client's attention to less emotionally charged
material when their own anxiety levels begin to rise. If a therapist
starts to dread his sessions with a particular client, or begins
to feel overwhelmed and incompetent in the face of a client's issues,
he or she is probably experiencing counter-transference. Learning
to notice these cues and using them as signals for self-examination
can reduce the negative impact of these dynamics on the therapy.
Another aspect of counter-transference occurs when a therapist
begins to see a client as "special' and deserving extra attention.
Extending the length of sessions at no extra cost to the client,
or meeting with a client outside of scheduled sessions or in other
ways changing the normal boundaries of the therapeutic relationship,
indicate that the therapist is exhibiting counter-transferential
dynamics that need to be addressed in the therapist's supervision.
At times it is necessary to change the normal boundaries
of the therapeutic relationship and hold longer sessions or meet
more frequently. However, the therapist needs to ensure that these
changes are the result of sound clinical judgement, not unconscious
counter-transference. Whenever a therapist's interaction with a
client is driven by his or her own needs, rather than by the clients'
needs, he or she is opening the possibility of replicating the original
abuse dynamics. Being aware of this potential hazard, and working
to avoid it is an important aspect of therapy with survivors.
MANAGING COUNTER-TRANSFERENCE
Contributor's suggestions for managing counter-transference and
providing self care:
- a partnership attitude to providing therapy;
- personal therapy for the therapist;
- identifying one's personal limits and boundaries;
- supervision;
- peer support;
- advocacy; and
- personal life satisfaction.
A Partnership Attitude To Providing Therapy
Therapists who work with male survivors often need to remind themselves
that the power to heal from childhood trauma lies in the client,
not in the therapist. Like a good gardener, a therapist can nurture
and fertilize his clients' growth. They may assist in removing noxious
weeds or other hindrances to full recovery. However, as with growing
plants, the therapists need to trust that their clients have an
inherent ability to respond favourably to appropriate interventions.
Victims of abuse need to be in control of pacing their recovery
process. A therapist who adopts an authoritarian stand with clients
will generally elicit counter-therapeutic transference. Therapists
who see themselves as facilitators who can guide their clients'
recovery, rather than as experts who can prescribe cures, are more
likely to help their clients. Not only is sharing power in therapy
an essential component of restoring the clients' capacity to make
autonomous decisions, but letting go of a need to control the process
reduces therapists' work-related stress.
Several contributors commented on the importance of therapists
being responsive to their clients, and the issues they present,
without taking responsibility for them. Clients need to be given
complete ownership of their own actions, beliefs, behaviours and
cognitions. The therapist's task is to be able to respond to all
aspects of the client non-judgmentally. Therapists must avoid taking
a parental stance with clients since this will generally counteract
the desired outcome of increasing the client's autonomy.
Therapists express a partnership attitude toward their clients
when they own their own shortcomings and imperfections. Inevitably,
all therapists make mistakes with their clients. For instance, a
therapist may misjudge the timing of an intervention, or he may
interrupt a client prematurely to give well-intentioned feedback.
To the extent that therapists can claim mistakes such as these,
they provides their clients with a model for honest human interaction.
Therapist's personal integrity and the congruence between their
words and deeds influence the success of therapy as much as their
professional knowledge and expertise.
Therapy For The Therapist
There are several important reasons why therapists who work with
adult survivors of childhood trauma should have undergone, or be
engaged in, psychotherapy. Probably foremost of these is that by
coming to terms with their own psychological scripts, therapists
are less likely to project their own injuries onto others - most
notably their clients. It is important to understand the process
of therapeutic change not just intellectually, but also experientially,
in order to genuinely engage and track his or her clients.
Due to the intense nature of therapy with survivors of childhood
sexual trauma, it is likely that therapists will face their own
psychological vulnerabilities. Each therapist will have idiosyncratic
triggers that particular clients will provoke. For instance, one
therapist may typically overwork on behalf of clients who are very
depressed, in response to his own family script about how to handle
depressed feelings. Another therapist may become angry or afraid
when clients identify issues similar to his or her own childhood
trauma, thereby unconsciously inhibiting the clients safety to work
on these issues.
Personal therapy helps therapists to more easily separate their
own processes from those of their clients. Therapists will be better
able to identify their own vulnerable areas and to work more effectively
with clients who provoke them.
Good personal therapy should assist therapists in developing skills
that make him more fully present in both their work and personal
lives. It should provide them with skills to respond to their own
personal process should a client unknowingly trigger a problematic
association. For example, if during a session a therapist's child
ego state is evoked by a client, the therapist can hold a brief
inner dialogue with his or her own inner child to negotiate how
to address the issue after the session. In this way, the therapy
session remains client focused, while the person of the therapist
is also respected.
If a therapist is conducting therapy with clients while in personal
therapy, it is essential that he or she have good clinical supervision
to keep personal issues distinct from client issues. Therapists
need to be respectful of themselves and to structure their time
in self-supporting ways. For instance, personal therapy appointments
need to be scheduled at a time when you can be self-focused and
do not immediately have to return to client-focused concerns. There
may be times when you will have to lighten your workload if you're
working intensely on personal issues.
Identifying One's Personal Limits and Boundaries
Therapists who work with survivors of childhood trauma need to
create clear and predictable boundaries in their work to support
both their clients and themselves. For clients, knowing the therapist's
groundrules about issues such as scheduling extra sessions or handling
unpaid fees provides safety and predictability. For the therapist,
setting up clear boundaries is good self care.
Therapists must have clear policies about missed appointments,
receiving crisis phone calls, extended sessions, fee payments and
so on. When to schedule vacations and the length of a typical work
day are decisions that need to be tailored to a therapist's personal
taste and style.
Other boundaries are more general in nature and focus on broader
issues. Managing case-load composition in ways that respect your
own needs is a vital aspect of boundary setting. When determining
what types of clients the therapist will work with and the size
of his or her caseload, the therapist must be thoughtful and realistic
about his or her circumstances. In general, it is advisable for
therapists who work with sexual abuse survivors to maintain a mixed
case load. Clients who are recovering from childhood sexual trauma
are usually candidates for long-term therapy. Having opportunities
to work with short-term cases and a variety of presenting problems,
can help to keep the therapist refreshed and energized.
It is important that the boundaries that a therapist makes are
flexible enough to change to meet new eventualities, but rigid enough
to meet the purpose for which they were intended. Ensuring that
clients are aware of their therapists' work-related boundaries is
a key ingredient of ensuring that therapy is a safe and predictable
process.
Almost inevitably, clients will ask their therapist why they do
the work they do. Therapists who choose to work with sexual abuse
survivors have a multitude of reasons for doing so. These reasons
need to be clear to the therapist; often they emerge during the
course of the therapist's own therapy. Although a therapist must
be judicious about the personal information they tell clients, you
should be prepared to honestly answer your clients' inquiries about
why you work with sexual abuse survivors.
Sexual abuse, by definition, has involved a violation of a client's
personal boundary. In the therapeutic process, therefore, the therapist
must be vigilant about respecting his or her clients' boundaries
while simultaneously respecting his or her own. Providing clients,
and therapists, with a safe environment in which to engage in the
therapeutic process is paramount and any lapse in maintaining clear
boundaries which may jeopardize this safety must be avoided.
Supervision
Regular supervision with a therapist who is knowledgeable about
the dynamics of sexual abuse and recovery from this trauma is an
essential aspect of therapist self care. Several contributors noted
that no matter how skilful they have become in providing therapeutic
services to survivors, they continue to schedule regular supervision
and consultation sessions on a weekly or a bi-weekly basis.
Good clinical supervision can serve a variety of functions. It
is an opportunity for therapists to share their own responses to
their clients' issues and to assess their own needs. A supervisor
can also reflect aspects of the therapeutic relationship (such as
counter-transference and transference) that the therapist is not
aware of. Given the emotional intensity of therapy, the therapist's
ability to objectively assess each case can be lost. His or her
supervisor, who is not directly involved, can maintain the role
of an objective observer. A supervisor can help a therapist identify
recurrent themes that emerge across several cases. These themes
may reflect the therapist's unresolved personal issues or work style
rather than his clients' clinical needs. For instance, clients often
present with a "let's-get-this-over-with-quickly" attitude.
Therapists with their own issues about getting things done quickly
may collude with the client's impatience even though it's counter-therapeutic
to rush into abreactive work before establishing therapeutic rapport
and building a client's self care skills. A skilful supervisor can
help a therapist recognize his or her tendency to proceed too quickly,
thus assisting both therapist and client in the process. In ways
such as this, supervision provides therapists with instruction,
ideas and support for their work.
Peer Support
In addition to the support of formal supervision, both formal and
informal peer support enhance a therapist's abilities and enthusiasm.
It is not unusual for clinicians to experience isolation in their
work, especially if they work privately without team support. Creating
opportunities to discuss cases, and their personal and professional
impact with peers who are engaged in similar work is very rewarding.
Many contributors are members of peer support groups which meet
regularly and they say these collegial networks are of great value
to them.
Some contributors note that although the work they do is serious,
it need not be solemn. It's important to find humour, both in the
therapeutic process and in interactions with peers. Several contributors
remarked that a valued feature of their peer support group is that
it provides a safe forum to express humour or make politically incorrect
statements about their work. Being able to make jokes about therapy
in a safe environment helps these therapists to unload work-related
stress.
Advocacy
For many therapists, incorporating a preventative or educational
component into their work acts as a good counterbalance to their
therapeutic work with clients. When therapists focus solely on helping
individual clients to recover from childhood sexual trauma, they
can loose sight of the social and cultural aspects of this problem.
Creating opportunities to work at social change can remind a therapist
of the political, ethical or spiritual reasons that motivate his
or her career choice.
Contributors mentioned a variety of ways that they work toward
social change. Many are involved in public education; they write
articles and books on abuse-related issues or present workshops
about abuse to the general public or other professionals. Others
see their work as part of the global struggle for improving human
rights and give time and energy to political or humanistic organizations.
Regardless of the specific avenue of expression, working within
social networks to curtail sexual abuse can boost your sense of
purpose and reaffirm the importance of your work.
Personal Life Satisfaction
It is important that therapists working with survivors of childhood
trauma have non-work outlets for developing their self-esteem and
self-worth. Without these, they may bring these personal needs into
their work, which is counter-therapeutic for their clients.
Keeping a balance between personal and work-related interests supports
therapists in their work and keeps them energized and vital. Therapists
who have poor self care skills may bring less energy to the therapy,
which can become a clinical issue. Clients are very quick to pick
up incongruencies between a therapist's advice about self care and
his or her own behaviour in this regard. Such incongruence echoes
the denial and hypocracy that surrounded the client's abuse experience
and must, therefore, be avoided.
Some of the specific ways that contributors reported exercising
good self care include:
- reading novels and listening to music;
- having lots of friends who are not therapists;
- attending to spiritual needs;
- scheduling regular physical exercise;
- having supportive intimate relationships, but not using these
relationships to process work-related stressors;
- going into personal therapy when necessary;
- taking regular vacations;
- limiting their work week to four days a week; and
- doing volunteer work for interesting organizations.
Clearly each therapist's recreational and creative
interests will change over time. The point is that whatever your
interests are, they need to be cultivated and supported.
ISSUES FOR THERAPISTS WHO ARE THEMSELVES SURVIVORS
OF SEXUAL ABUSE
Therapists who are also survivors of sexual abuse bring both assets
and liabilities to their work. Having personal experience of the
recovery process can help the therapist to join with clients in
a profound way. Clients often feel reassured that they will be understood
when they share their experience with another survivor. However,
there is a risk that the therapist who is a survivor will over-
or under-identify with clients whose experiences echo his or her
own abuse history. This may result in over- or under-working on
behalf of certain clients.
The major issue for therapists who are survivors is that they not
project their own issues onto their clients. Good clinical supervision
is essential so that therapists can clearly assess when an issue
is their own and when it belongs to their client.
It is not advisable for therapists who are survivors to provide
therapy to other survivors until they are sufficiently familiar
with their own abuse-related psychology that they can predict the
kinds of counter-transference that could arise. Knowing these vulnerabilities
enables the therapist to anticipate which clients they will find
most difficult to work with; when necessary, such clients can be
referred to another therapist.
Therapists who are survivors must develop clear self care strategies
to support themselves should they find they're being triggered by
their clients' abuse-related material. These strategies include
thoughtful caseload management and scheduling, supervision, techniques
for bracketing personal feelings and responses during sessions with
clients and a well-developed and intimate peer support network.
Therapists who are also survivors will need to give
some thought to the issue of self-disclosure. Clients will frequently
want to know if their therapist was abused as a child. The question
for therapists to ask themselves is "What is the therapeutic
gain for my client if I disclose information about myself?"
The therapist should disclose only as much information as is helpful
to the client. In general, brief honest answers will satisfy the
client's need for information about you and the session can then
refocus on your client's agenda.
CHAPTER 12 - RESOURCES
This final chapter identifies resources that contributors
have used to enhance their clinical practice with male survivors
and that they recommend to their clients who are recovering
from sexual abuse. it is divided into three sections: video
resources, written resources and training resources. The
written resources section contains materials for both therapists
and clients. |
This listing of resources is by no means definitive. New resources
are always being created. In addition, many resources that were
created with female sexual abuse survivors in mind can be effective
tools for male survivors.
In order to keep the lists succinct, only those
written resources that were recommended by two or more contributors
have been included.
VIDEO RESOURCES
(Order of information: title & description followed
by distributor)
"Abuse"
Nineteen-year-old Jeff describes the pattern of his sexual abuse
which began before he was five. After seeking professional help,
he is now able to enjoy life and is restoring his self-esteem.
Jeff's story shows how enduring abuse can severely damage self-esteem
and impair the ability to relate to others in healthy ways. This
program defines four kinds of abuse: physical, emotional, sexual
and neglect. (20 minutes)
Kidsrights
10100 Park Cedar Drive
Charlotte, North Carolina
28210
Tel: 704-541-0100
or 1-800-892-KIDS
"Big Boys Don't Cry"
This excellent made-for-TV documentary explores the lives of
several members of an adult male survivors group and the impact
of childhood sexual victimization on them. Members share information
about changes they have made in their lives since beginning therapy.
Scenes from an adolescent victim/perpetrator group are interspersed
with adult footage to reinforce the importance of early intervention.
(60 minutes)
Public Affairs
KGW TV
1501 South West Jefferson
Street
Portland, Oregon 97201
Tel: 503-226-5000
"Both Sides Of The Coin"
A pioneering video that brings together an adult victim of child
sexual abuse and a convicted pedophile. The result is an insightful,
well-rounded and balanced examination of the causes and effects
of child abuse. Two men explore the impact of child abuse on their
respective lives. (47 minutes)
Kinetic Inc.
408 Dundas Street East
Toronto, Ontario
M5A 2A5
Tel: 416-963-0653
"Breaking Silence"
This moving and personal documentary focuses on adults who were
abused as children struggling to come to terms with their long-secret
pasts. Although only adults are interviewed, their stories are
interwoven with photographs of their childhood. The film deals
with realities of the sexual abuse of children such as the frequency
of transgenerational transmission of abusive behaviour. This documentary
demonstrates the difficulties abused children face as adults in
integrating their painful experiences. (58 minutes)
Video and Film Rental
Library
American Psychiatric
Association
1400 K Street Northwest
Washington, D.C. 20005
Tel: 202-682-6173
"Coming Home: A Spiritual Recovery from Satanic Ritual
Abuse"
This four-part video is an edited version of a workshop on spiritual
recovery that was sponsored by the Grace Institute. The subject
of satanic ritual abuse is examined from both personal and theological
points of view. A survivor of satanic abuse discusses her experience
of rediscovering the sacred. (120 minutes)
Varied Directions
International
69 Elm Street
Camden, Maine 04843
Tel: 207-236-8506
or 1-800-888-5236
"Dr. Frank Ochberg on Victimization and PTSD"
This tape features an overview of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
(PTSD) by Dr. Frank Ochberg, psychiatrist and internationally
noted expert on victimization and PTSD. It is an excellent program
for people suffering from PTSD, their co-workers and family members.
(15 minutes)
Varied Direction International
69 Elm Street
Camden, Maine 04848
Tel: 207-236-8506
or 1-800-888-5236
"Four Men Speak Out On Surviving Child Sexual Abuse"
Four male survivors, some survivors of violent, isolated assaults,
others of lengthy molestations, discuss their abuse and recovery
processes. The perpetrators include a father, known trusted adults,
and other adolescents. The men talk about homophobia, the fear
of becoming a perpetrator and relationship issues in their adult
years. Recognizing that recovery brings confusion, pain and relief,
these four men share what has been meaningful in their own healing
process. (28 minutes)
Varied Directions
International
69 Elm Street
Camden, Maine 04843
Tel: 207-236-8506
or 1-800-888-5236
"Healing Sexual Abuse: The Recovery Process"
Dan Sexton, director of Child Help, U.S.A., and Ellen Bass, co-author
of The Courage To Heal, discuss topics such as dissociation,
addictions, regaining trust, confronting the offender and grief.
This Video is recommended for both male and female survivors.
(60 minutes)
Varied Directions
International
69 Elm Street
Camden, Maine 04843
Tel: 207-236-8506
or 1-800-888-5236
"Partners In Healing"
This video explores the dynamics of couples in various stages
of therapy working together to heal the emotional scars of incest.
It can help incest survivors and therapists learn how incest affects
sexuality, how both partners are affected by the intimacy problems
that result from incest and how both can work together to become
partners in healing. (43 minutes)
Varied Directions
International
69 Elm Street
Camden, Maine 04843
Tel: 207-236-8506
or 1-800-888-5236
WRITTEN RESOURCES
(In addition to the books listed below, see Appendix
G - References to locate written resources on male sexual abuse.)
FOR BOTH THERAPISTS AND CLIENTS
Abused Boys - The Neglected Victims of Sexual Abuse.
Mic Hunter, (Fawcett Columbine, 1990).
This book is divided into two sections - the first addresses
the theoretical aspects of sexual abuse and recovery and the second
lets 13 male survivors speak for themselves about these issues.
It is written for both clients and therapists.
FOR THERAPISTS
Grown-Up Abused Children. James Leehan and Laura
Pistone Wilson, (Charles C. Thomas Publishers, 1985).
This book is a readable and concise presentation of issues and
clinical experience in group work with adult abuse survivors of
both genders. It includes descriptions of typical inter- and intra-psychic
dynamics of grown-up abused children, how these dynamics emerge
and are expressed in therapy groups, and group interventions to
help clients change.
Healing The Incest Wound: Adult Survivors In Therapy.
Christine Courtois, (W.W. Norton and Company, 1988).
Christine Courtois's book provides an eloquent and thorough examination
of intrafamilial abuse dynamics and incest therapy. It focuses
on female survivors; however, much of the theoretical information
it contains is equally applicable to both males or females.
Resolving Sexual Abuse. Yvonne Dolan, (W.W. Norton
& Co., 1991).
This readable and informative book discusses Ericksonian and
solution-focused approaches to working with survivors. Although
case examples are generally female, methods and techniques are
gender-neutral.
The Sexually Abuse Male, Volumes 1 and 2. Mic Hunter
(ed.), (Lexington Books, 1990).
This two volume work comprehensively examines male sexual abuse
from many points of view. Both theoretical and applied information
on sexual abuse dynamics and treatment are presented. One of this
two-volume set's great strengths is that the chapters are written
by a variety of authors, so that an eclectic array of information
and therapeutic styles are presented.
Therapy For Adults Molested As Children: Beyond Survival.
John Briere, (Springer Publishing Company, 1989).
This book is a very useful resource for therapists working with
male and female abuse survivors. It presents a thoughtful analysis
of the impacts of childhood sexual abuse and detailed discussions
of treatment models and methods. It includes informative sections
on client/therapist gender issues and therapist self care.
FOR CLIENTS
Adults Molested As Children: A Survivor's Manual For Men
And Women. Euan Bear with Peter Dimock, (Safer Society Press,
1988).
This book is a simple and clearly written manual for adult survivors
that helps them to connect here-and-now behaviours with there-and-then
events. It contains excellent advice about how to choose a therapist.
Allies In Healing. Laura Davis, (Harper Collins,
1991).
This excellent and essential guide for partners of sexually abused
adults also contains a great deal of informative information for
survivors.
Broken Boys/Mending Men. Stephen Grubman-Black,
(Ballintine Books, 1990).
This personal and informative book speaks to the issues that
survivors must face as they change from broken boys into mending
men. The author's style is open, colloquial and easy to read.
The Courage to Heal: A Guide for Women Survivors of Child
Sexual Abuse. Ellen Bass and Laura Davis, (Harper &
Row, 1988).
Although intended for women survivors, this book has become a
bible for both male and female survivors and their therapists.
It is a comprehensive and empowering resource which clearly describes
how childhood defences can become dysfunctional in adulthood.
The tone of the book is friendly and open.
The Courage To Heal Workbook: For Women and Men Survivors
of Child Sexual Abuse. Laura Davis, (Harper and Row, 1990).
This excellent self-help workbook can be used alone or in conjunction
with therapy. It presents exercises to lead survivors along the
road to self-awareness and recovery. Survivors often enjoy the
workbook format of this text and its structured presentation.
Don't Call It Love: Recovery From Sexual Addiction.
Patrick Carnes, (Bantam Books, 1991).
This book describes both the activities and recovery processes
of sexual addictions. It includes exercises that clients can use
to increase their self-awareness and to enhance positive changes.
Male Sexuality. Bernie Zilbergeld and John Ullman,
(Little Brown, 1978).
This book examines some myths about male sexuality and presents
alternative information to assist men to develop their own authentic
sexual identity. Its contents extend beyond sexuality into relationship
dynamics and the role of sexuality in creating intimacy. The drawback
of this book is that it only discusses heterosexual sex.
Once Upon A Time
Therapeutic Stories. Nancy
Davis, (Psychological Associates of Oxon Hill, 1990).
Inspired by Ericksonian therapeutic methods, this book contains
stories aimed at restoring a client's sense of power, health,
wholeness and joy. They are tailored to specific populations e.g.
victims who become abusers, or children who were ritually abused.
The stories are written for adolescents or children, but with
some adaptations, they can be used with adults.
Outgrowing The Pain: A Book For and About Adults Abused
As Children. Eliana Gil, (Dell Publishing, 1983).
This is a small pocket book which describes abuse and its impacts
in concise and readable terms. It also briefly describes actions
survivors can take to help heal themselves. This is an excellent
resource for clients in the beginning phases of therapy.
Victims No Longer: Men Recovering From Incest and Other
Sexual Child Abuse. Mike Lew, (Nevraumont Publishing Company,
1988). (Reprinted by Harper & Row, Publishers, Inc., New York,
1990.)
This friendly and informative book focuses specifically on male
survivors. The after-effects of childhood sexual abuse and the
recovery process are discussed, alongside survivor's own stories.
This book can become a "good friend" to male survivors
throughout their healing process.
TRAINING RESOURCES
Training resources for therapists who work with male survivors
are still scarce. However, two international conferences that focus
exclusively on male sexual abuse are held each year in the United
States: For information on the four-day National Male Survivors
Conference, held since 1989, contact:
Shunomi Creek Consultants
2801 Buford Highway
Suite 400
Atlanta, Georgia 30329
Tel: 404-321-4954
For information on the three-day conference "It Happens To
Boys Too..." contact:
Mr. Daniel P. Moriarty
Administrator For Personnel and Training
St. Aloysius Home
40 Austin Avenue
Greenville, Rhode Island 02828
Tel: 401-949-1300
APPENDIX A - QUESTIONNAIRE
MALE SURVIVORS OF SEXUAL ABUSE
Please answer the following questions by placing a checkmark
beside the appropriate answer or by writing your answer in the space
provided. Use the margins or the back of the paper if you require
additional space.
Any reference to clients in the questionnaire refers to male survivors
of sexual abuse.
SECTION 1: THERAPIST INFORMATION
1. Name:
2. Occupation/Position:
3. Employer (if applicable):
4. Address:
Phone(s):
5a. Number of years experience of working directly with sexual
abuse clients (female or made):
__0-2 years
___3-5 years
___6-8 years
___more than 8 years
5b. Number of years experience of working with male survivors
of sexual abuse:
___0-2 years
___3-5 years
___6-8 years
___more than 8 years
6a. Modalities in which treatment is provided to male survivors
of sexual abuse:
___individual therapy
___group therapy
___couple therapy
___family therapy
___other (please specify)
6b. Ideally, how do you sequence the above-noted treatment modalities
(see question 6a) in providing treatment to male survivors of sexual
abuse? In practice, do you often alter this sequence? Please discuss
this bellow.
7. Briefly describe the model(s) and/or theory(s) which best
describe your therapeutic approach with male survivors of sexual
abuse:
8. Briefly discuss the impact of the relative gender of the
therapist and client in working with male survivors of sexual abuse,
as noted in your clinical experience:
9. Which types of education/training have you used to support
your therapeutic work with male survivors of sexual abuse:
___self-learning (i.e. reading journals, books, etc.)
___workshops & training sessions given by other
professionals
___professional conferences
___formal classroom education
___other (please specify)
10. Please list any resources (written resources, videos, films,
audio cassettes, training programs, workshop presenters, conferences,
peer consultation groups, etc.) that have been particularly useful
to you in supporting your work with male survivors of sexual abuse:
11. Please indicate how you evaluate/assess; the effectiveness
of your therapeutic work with your clients:
______________________formal evaluation methods (please
specify)
_________________informal evaluation methods (please
specify)
SECTION II: CLIENT INFORMATION
12. Please indicate the age groupings of male survivors of sexual
abuse that you work with:
___preschool (0-5 years)
___latency age (6-12 years)
___adolescent (13-19 years)
___early adult (20-25 years)
___adult (25 and over)
13. Please describe the treatment issues that you most commonly
identify in male survivors of sexual abuse (e.g. impaired relationships,
lack of trust in others, substance addictions, sexual identity issues)
during the course of therapy:
14. Please list resources (written resources, videos, films
music, audio cassettes, etc.) that you use in your clinical work
with clients, or recommend to them to use on their own:
SECTION III: OTHER INFORMATION
15. Please use the space below to make any further comments
on your work with male survivors of sexual abuse that the previous
questions have not addressed:
Thank you for filling out this questionnaire. Please
return it in the attached envelope to Adrienne Crowder, B.A., M.S.W.,
Family and Children's Services of Waterloo Region, 200 Ardelt Avenue,
Kitchener, Ontario, N2C 2L9.
APPENDIX B - LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Mr. Paul Antrobus
Luther College
University of Regina
Regina, Saskatchewan
S4S 0A2 |
1-306-585-5444 |
Dr. Dick Berry
Safe-T
Thistletown Regional Centre
51 Panorama Court
Rexdale, Ontario
M9V 4L8 |
1-416-326-0647 |
Dr. George Bilotta
2306 Taraval Street
Suite 102
San Francisco, CA 94116 |
1-415-664-5007 |
Ms. Debbie Bruckner
Senior Counsellor
Alberta Vocational College
332 Sixth Avenue S.E.
Calgary, Alberta
T2G 4S6 |
1-403-297-4020 |
Mr. Leonard Burnstein
Royal Ottawa Hospital
1145 Carling Avenue
Ottawa, Ontario
K1Z 7K4 |
1-613-722-6521 |
Mr. Ray Chapman
1753 Dansey Avenue
Coquitlam, B.C.
V3K 3J4 |
1-604-936-9460 |
Mr. Lou Coppola
Family Counselling Service of Peterborough
318 Stewart Street
Peterborough, Ontario
K9J 3M1 |
1-705-742-4258 |
Mr. Harry Dudley
Calgary Family Service Bureau
Suite 200
707-10th Avenue South West
Calgary, Alberta
T2G 0B3 |
1-403-233-2370 |
Mr. Grant Fair
161 Franklin Avenue
Willowdale, Ontario
M2N 1C6 |
1-416-224-2227 |
Mr. Paul Gerber
Hennepin County Home School
Juvenile Sex Offender Program
14300 County Highway 62
Minnetonka, Minnesota 55345 |
1-612-949-4500 |
Mr. Peter Goodman
Eastwind Associates
2176 Windsor Street
Halifax, Nova Scotia
B3K 5B6 |
1-902-422-3760 |
Mr. Charlie Greenman
Rape and Sexual Assault Centre
2431 Hennepin Avenue South
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55405 |
1-612-825-2409 |
Ms. Anne Gresham
Family Life Mental Health Center
1428 5th Avenue South
Anoka, Minnesota 55303 |
1-612-427-7964 |
Mr. Stephen D. Grubman-Black
P.O. Box 1504
Wickford, Rhode Island 02852 |
1-401-792-4743 |
Ms. Judith Halpern
First Virginia Plaza
64 Arlington Blvd.
Suite 634
Falls Church, Virginia 22042 |
1-703-534-1633 |
Mr. Doug Harder
Harder and Associates
Suite 200
Regency Centre
333-25th Street East
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
S7K 0L4 |
1-306-242-1010 |
Mr. Arthur Harold
Family Counselling Services of Peterborough
318 Stewart Street
Peterborough, Ontario
K9J 3M1 |
1-705-742-4258 |
Mr. Rob Hawkings
94 Clifton Downs Road
Hamilton, Ontario
L9C 2P3 |
1-416-385-9483 |
Ms. Bobbi Hoover
544 Mansion Park Drive
Santa Clara, California 95054 |
1-408-496-6464 |
Mr. Mic Hunter
2469 University Avenue West
Upper Northeast Suite
St. Paul, Minnesota 55114 |
1-612-649-1408 |
Mr. Michael Irving
274 Rhodes Avenue
Toronto, Ontario
M4L 3A3 |
1-416-469-4764 |
Dr. David Jackson
Department of Psychiatry
Saskatoon City Hospital
701 Queen Street
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
S7K 0M7 |
1-306-934-0272 |
Mr. Peter E. Johnson
Alberta Vocational College
332 6th Avenue SE
Calgary, Alberta
T2J 4S6 |
1-403-297-4085 |
Mr. Merlin Kobsa
Halton Sexual Abuse Program
461 North Service Road West
Unit B6
Oakville, Ontario
L6M 2V6 |
1-416-825-3242 |
Mr. Len Kushnier
Supervisor
Family and Children's Services
P.O. Box 848
Station B
London, Ontario
N6A 4Z5 |
1-519-434-8461 |
Ms. Joan Lee
Executive Director
Family Counselling Service of Peterborough
318 Stewart Street
Peterborough, Ontario
K9J 3N1 |
1-705-742-4258 |
Mr. Mike Lew
The Next Step Counselling
10 Langley Road
Suite 200
Newton Centre, Massachusetts 02159 |
1-617-332-6601 |
Mr. Donald L. Mann
Clinical Social Worker
811 N.W. 20th Street
Suite 102
Portland, Oregon 97209 |
1-503-228-1939 |
Mr. Michael McGrenra
2306 Taraval Street
Suite 102
San Francisco, CA 94116 |
1-415-664-5007 |
Mr. Paul McIntosh
424 Princess Street
London, Ontario |
1-519-432-9385 |
Ms. Mary Meining
200 West Mercer
Suite 202
Seattle, Washington 98119 |
1-206-284-3125 |
Ms. Karen Nielson
Family Service Association of Edmonton
9912-106 Street
Edmonton, Alberta
T5K 1C5 |
1-403-423-2831 |
Ms. Kay Rice
2469 University Avenue
St. Paul, Minnesota 55114 |
1-612-642-1709 |
Ms. Deb Ruppert
Community Justice Iniatives
39 Stirling Avenue North
Kitchener, Ontario |
1-519-744-6549 |
Mr. Jack Rusinoff
PHASE
425 Aldine Street
St. Paul, Minnesota 55104 |
1-612-641-5584 |
Mr. John Stasio
75 Rutland Street
Boston, Massachusetts
02118-1525 |
1-617-859-8827 |
Mr. Paul Sterlocci
City Line Association Psychotherapists
2469 University Avenue
St. Paul, Minnesota 55114 |
1-612-642-1709 |
Dr. Robert Timms
Atlanta Centre for Integrative Therapy
Suite 508
20 Executive Park West
Atlanta, Georgia |
1-404-321-5533 |
Mr. Timothy Wall
Counselling Co-ordinator
Klinic Community Health Centre
870 Portage Street
Winnipeg, Manitoba
R3G 0P1 |
1-204-784-4090 |
Mr. Steve Wardikowski
Family Service Bureau of Regina
2020 Halifax Street
Regina, Saskatchewan
S4P 1T7 |
1-306-757-6675 |
Mr. Don Wright
Vancouver Society for Male Survivors of Sexual Abuse
847 Hamilton Street
Vancouver, B.C.
V6B 2R7 |
1-604-682-6482 |
APPENDIX C DES
DES
Eve Bernstein Carlson, Ph.D. |
Frank W. Putnam, M.D. |
DIRECTIONS
This questionnaire consists of twenty-eight questions
about experiences that you may have in your daily life. We are interested
in how often you have these experiences. It is important, however,
that your answers show how often these experiences happen to you
when you are not under the influence of alcohol or drugs.
To answer the questions, please determine to what degree the experience
described in the question applies to you and mark the line with
a vertical slash at the appropriate place, as shown in the example
below.
Example:
0% ½ ___/___½ 100%
Date:
Age: __ Sex:
M F _
- Some people have the experience of driving a car and suddenly
realizing that they don't remember what has happened during all
or part of the trip. Mark the line to show what percentage of
the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people find that sometimes they are listening to someone
talk and they suddenly realize that they did not hear all or part
of what was said. Mark the line to show what percentage of the
time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people have the experience of finding themselves in a place
and having no idea how they got there. Mark the line to show what
percentage of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people have the experience of finding themselves dressed
in clothes that they don't remember putting on. Mark the line
to show what percentage of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people have the experience of finding new things among
their belongings that they do not remember buying. Mark the line
to show what percentage of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people sometimes find that they are approached by people
that they do not know who call them by another name or insist
that they have met them before. Mark the line to show what percentage
of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people sometimes have the experience of feeling as though
they are standing next to themselves or watching themselves do
something and they actually see themselves as if they were looking
at another person.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people are told that they sometimes do not recognize friends
or family members. Mark the line to show what percentage of the
time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people find that they have no memory for some important
events in their lives (for example, a wedding or graduation).
Mark the line to show what percentage of the important events
in your life you have no memory for.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people have the experience of being accused of lying when
they do not think that they have lied. Mark the line to show what
percentage of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people have the experience of looking in a mirror and not
recognizing themselves. Mark the line to show what percentage
of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people have the experience of feeling that other people,
objects, and the world around them are not real. Mark the line
to show what percentage of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people have the experience of feeling that their body does
not seem to belong to them. Mark the line to show what percentage
of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people have the experience of sometimes remembering a past
event so vividly that they feel as if they were reliving that
event. Mark the line to show what percentage of the time this
happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people have the experience of not being sure whether things
that they remember happening really did happen or whether they
just dreamed them. Mark the line to show what percentage of the
time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people have the experience of being in a familiar place
but finding it strange and unfamiliar. Mark the line to show what
percentage of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people find that when they are watching television or a
movie they become so absorbed in the story that they are unaware
of other events happening around them. Mark the line to show what
percentage of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people find that they become so involved in a fantasy or
daydream that it feels as though it were really happening to them.
Mark the line to show what percentage of the time this happens
to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people find that they sometimes are able to ignore pain.
Mark the line to show what percentage of the time this happens
to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people find that they sometimes sit staring off into space,
thinking of nothing, and are not aware of the passage of time.
Mark the line to show what percentage of the time this happens
to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people find that when they are alone they talk out loud
to themselves. Mark the line to show what percentage of the time
this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people find that in one situation they may act so differently
compared with another situation that they feel almost as if they
were two different people. Mark the line to show what percentage
of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people find that sometimes in certain situations they are
able to do things with amazing ease and spontaneity that would
usually be difficult for them (for example, sports, work, social
situations, etc.). Mark the line to show what percentage of the
time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people sometimes find that they cannot remember whether
they have done something or have just thought about doing that
thing. (for example, not knowing whether they have just mailed
a letter or have just thought about mailing it). Mark the line
to show what percentage of the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people find evidence that they have done things that they
do not remember doing. Mark the line to show what percentage of
the time this happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people sometimes find writings, drawings, or notes among
their belongings that they must have done but cannot remember
doing. Mark the line to show what percentage of the time this
happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people sometimes find that they hear voices inside their
head that tell them to do things or comment on things that they
are doing. Mark the line to show what percentage of the time this
happens to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
- Some people sometimes feel as if they are looking at the world
through a fog so that people and objects appear far away or unclear.
Mark the line to show what percentage of the time this happens
to you.
0% ½ ½ 100%
APPENDIX D - INTERVENTION TO MANAGE FLASHBACKS
AND INTERVENTION TO GROUND CLIENTS IN HERE-AND-NOW EXPERIENCE
The following interventions were presented by Yvonne Dolan at a
conference in Baltimore, Maryland in November, 1992.
Intervention to Manage Flashbacks
(Four Step Approach for Dealing With Flashbacks in Daily Life)
The following four steps will help the client experience more understanding
and resulting control of her flashbacks experiences both in and
outside the therapy setting:
- "Describe what you are experiencing. When have you felt
this way before? What situation were you in the last time you
felt this way?"*
- "In what ways are this current situation and your past
situation similar? For example, is the setting, time of year,
or the sights, sounds, sensations in any way similar to the past
situation where you felt this way? If there is another person
involved, is she or he similar to a person from the past who elicited
similar feelings?"
- "How is your current situation different from the situation
in which you felt similar feelings in the past? What is different
about you, your sensory experience, your current life circumstances,
and personal resources? What is different about this current setting?
If another person or persons are involved, what is different about
them compared to the person(s) in the past situation?"
- "What action, if any, do you want to take now to feel better
in the present?" For example, a flashback may indicate that
a person is once again in a situation that is in some way unsafe.
If this is the case, self protective actions should be taken to
alter the current situation. On the other hand, a flashback may
simply mean that an old memory has been triggered by an inconsequential
but highly evocative resemblance to the past such as a certain
color, smell, sound, etc. In such cases, corrective messages of
reassurance and comfort need to be given to the self to counteract
old traumatic memories. Associational cues for comfort and security
are useful for this purpose.
* If the client is unable to identify when she has felt this
way before, unconscious resources can be elicited to help her
gain the necessary information and understanding for resolution.
Intervention to Ground Clients in Here-And-Now Experience
This intervention uses clients' hyperviligence to assist them to
relax and become centered in their present environment.
Clients who are dissociated, or who wish to induce physical relaxation,
are instructed to:
- Name 5 things that you see
- Name 5 things that you hear
- Name 5 things that you feel
- Name 4 things that you see
- Name 4 things that you hear
- Name 4 things that you feel
- Name 3 things that you see, Etc.
- Name 2 things that you see, Etc.
- Name 1 thing that you see, Etc.
Each time the client identifies something that he sees, hears,
or feels, he should say "I see
, I see ..., I see ...,
I see ..., I see ..., I hear ..., I hear ..., I hear
,, etc.".
This rhythmic repetition is relaxing and calming.
The same object, sound or feeling can be named twice, or more,
in a row. This is quite acceptable. The exercise can be done in
silence or out loud. It can be repeated as often as necessary. The
client can lose his place in the exercise; he just begins again
where he thinks that he left off.
This technique works best if the client is sitting
down or stationary. It can be conducted in busy or quiet surroundings.
It should not be conducted while driving a vehicle.
APPENDIX E - BEHAVIOURS WHICH SUPPORT GROUP PROCESS
GOOD GROUP EXPERIENCES DON'T JUST HAPPEN! They are the result
of the commitment and involvement of the participants. We will be
spending a number of hours together. You will be free to talk about
yourself as much or as little as you wish. No effort will be made
to force anyone to tell more about himself that he wishes to. Would
you, therefore, read, think about, and discuss the qualities of
good group interchange listed below?
- SHARING IS ESSENTIAL. Your thoughts, feelings, and experiences
are the life-stuff of this group. We all need them in order that
insights may be discovered, understanding deepened, and growth
achieved.
- Express FEELINGS, not just ideas. Feelings are the best
indicators of what people value. To do this, you must be in touch
with your feelings. Take time to reflect on them and try to identify
them clearly.
- Expressing NEGATIVE FEELINGS can, on occasion, also be helpful.
Unexpressed feelings simply set up blocks or dribble away in unproductive
ways.
- Respect, care about, and SUPPORT EACH PERSON IN THE GROUP.
The more confidence each feels, the more anxiety diminishes and
the more deeply we can explore the topics before us.
- SUPPORT NEEDS TO BE EXPRESSED. Don't presume that people
somehow know you are feeling supportive. They won't, unless you
show that you are.
- PUTTING PEOPLE DOWN CLOSES PEOPLE UP and is counterproductive.
- POSITIVE CONFRONTATION IS ACCEPTABLE and needed. To confront
means to present someone with a new or opposing idea for the sake
of acknowledgement, agreement, contradiction, or clarification.
It identifies where people stand and shows what they consider
important.
- Confront others with their unused STRENGTHS as well as their
weaknesses. Confront in order to help another grow.
- Accusation and ridicule will only engender HOSTILITY and
set up blocks. Avoid them.
- AVOID FORCING YOUR VIEWPOINT BY AN OVERBEARING ATTITUDE or
barrage of arguments.
- OUR GROUP GOAL IS NOT WINNING BUT GROWING. Don't water
down your positions, but do state them in a way that allows people
room for manoeuvre and positive response.
- Try to AVOID BECOMING DEFENSIVE. Realize you are among
friends. View confrontations as an invitation to self-exploration.
- Fruitful discussion requires OPENNESS TO CHANGE.
- STICK TO THE POINT. Don't wander.
- SPEAK FOR YOURSELF. Avoid using "we" when you
mean "I". Don't speak for the group without giving others
a chance to agree or disagree.
- DON'T USE "I" SUBSTITUTES such as "one
would think" or "any rational person would agree."
Take responsibility for what you say.
- MOSTLY SPEAK ABOUT' YOURSELF. Growth occurs chiefly when
the group applies the topic to their own lives.
- MOSTLY SPEAK TO INDIVIDUALS. A series of monologues to
the entire group can be deadly.
- HELP OTHERS EXPLORE AND DEVELOP the ideas and feelings
they are expressing.
- YOU ARE NEITHER THERAPIST NOR JUDGE. Your role is not
to set other people straight or to solve their problems, but to
share, help, and encourage.
- EXPRESS DISAGREEMENTS AS YOUR IDEA, not as absolute truth.
Find common ground and areas of agreement before setting forth
points of difference.
- SAY IT IN THE GROUP. The things you say to your friends
about the group before, after, or between meetings are often the
very things which should be said in the group. There should be
only one conversation at a time going on in the group.
- MAKE THE MEETINGS. If one person misses a meeting, the
dynamics of the group change; and it often happens that the one
who was absent cannot be brought up-to-date because he did not
experience what really happened. The group needs to have you present.
- ENJOY YOURSELVES. Life is too short to spend time doing
things you don't like. Help others enjoy themselves through warmth,
friendship, and caring.
(This handout was developed by the Halton Sexual
Abuse Treatment Program, in Oakville, Ontario.)
APPENDIX F - DEAN ADOLESCENT INVENTORY SCALE
|
|
Circle One |
1. |
I have been afraid to tell anybody about some
of my experiences. |
TRUE FALSE |
2. |
Sometimes I hear arguing in my head and if confuses
me. |
TRUE FALSE |
3. |
When I was very young, I pretended to have a
playmate that nobody knew about. |
TRUE FALSE |
4. |
Sometimes when I am writing I feel like someone
else is guiding my hand. |
TRUE FALSE |
5. |
Often times when I look into the mirror my haircolor
seems to change. |
TRUE FALSE |
6. |
When I am eating food, there are times that "I"
cannot taste the food. |
TRUE FALSE |
7. |
When I am playing sports with friends, sometimes
I can do real well in one game and then the next time I play
it I feel like the game is new to me. |
TRUE FALSE |
8. |
Sometimes when I sleep at night I feel like I
am awake and I am having conversations with people. |
TRUE FALSE |
9. |
I am upset when people claim they know me and
I have never met them before. |
TRUE FALSE |
10. |
My handwriting changes often. |
TRUE FALSE |
11. |
I have looked into the mirror and have seen someone
other than myself. |
TRUE FALSE |
12. |
Something terrible happened to me but I don't
know what it was. |
TRUE FALSE |
13. |
I don't remember a lot of things that other people
tell me happened to me. |
TRUE FALSE |
14. |
Sometimes I will be with friends and I can't
remember how I got there. |
TRUE FALSE |
15. |
I feel like I have totally lost a portion of
my memory. |
TRUE FALSE |
16. |
When I get dressed I have a difficult time deciding
what to wear because it seems like parts of me want to wear
something different than what I want to wear. |
TRUE FALSE |
17. |
I have heard that people who hear voices in their
heads are crazy and sometimes I think I may be crazy because
I have heard voices too. |
TRUE FALSE |
18. |
I feel like nobody has ever been able to help
me. |
TRUE FALSE |
19. |
I have bad headaches and nobody has been able
to find out why. |
TRUE FALSE |
20. |
I feel that there are things that happened to
me that I could never tell anyone, but I don't know what they
are. |
TRUE FALSE |
21. |
My legs and arms and sometimes my hands move
and I don't move them. |
TRUE FALSE |
22. |
I have watched myself doing things and talking
to people but could not talk. |
TRUE FALSE |
23. |
Time is discontinuous for me. |
TRUE FALSE |
24. |
I do lots of things at once and don't really
understand how I can do this. |
TRUE FALSE |
25. |
I have been accused of stealing but I know that
I have never stolen anything. |
TRUE FALSE |
26. |
Things have appeared in my room that I am accused
of stealing but I know that I did not steal them. |
TRUE FALSE |
27. |
My parents tell me I lie all the time. |
TRUE FALSE |
28. |
I like to lie. |
TRUE FALSE |
29. |
I have stolen things to get my parents mad. |
TRUE FALSE |
30. |
I like to cause trouble for people. |
TRUE FALSE |
31. |
Sometimes I can watch myself getting into trouble
and I can't stop it. |
TRUE FALSE |
32. |
My vision changes all the time but nobody believes
me. |
TRUE FALSE |
33. |
I have eaten entire meals and don't remember
eating. |
TRUE FALSE |
34. |
I have favorite things in my room at home, but
I feel some of the things belong to someone else. |
TRUE FALSE |
35. |
My parents have accused me of talking to myself. |
TRUE FALSE |
36. |
I have been abused by many people. |
TRUE FALSE |
37. |
Sometimes when I go to school I am not aware
of what the teacher is talking about as if I had lost part of
the lecture. |
TRUE FALSE |
38. |
In school I have a bad memory for subjects that
I thought I knew well. |
TRUE FALSE |
39. |
There is a violent part of me that I have not
told my doctor about. |
TRUE FALSE |
40. |
Sometimes I feel like I may have done something
terrible but I don't know what it could be. |
TRUE FALSE |
41. |
I panic when I get around certain people and
I don't know why. |
TRUE FALSE |
42. |
I have had several times when I was not
sure who I was or even what my name was. |
TRUE FALSE |
43. |
Sometimes I call myself by another name. |
TRUE FALSE |
44. |
I always pretend that I remember things even
though I just can't remember them. |
TRUE FALSE |
45. |
Sometimes I am talking to a friend and I don't
know what happens but I just disappear and come out later somewhere
else. |
TRUE FALSE |
46. |
People tell me I stare a lot. |
TRUE FALSE |
47. |
My teachers in school are always trying to get
my attention. |
TRUE FALSE |
48. |
Many times I feel that when people are talking
to me they are talking to someone else. |
TRUE FALSE |
49. |
Once I saw a person killed in real life. |
TRUE FALSE |
50. |
I hide things from myself all the time. |
TRUE FALSE |
```
51. |
My friends don't really care about me because
they don't really know who I am. |
TRUE FALSE |
52. |
I have witnessed someone dying in real life. |
TRUE FALSE |
53. |
I don't like to talk about anything that causes
me to get upset because sometimes it makes me disappear into
myself. |
TRUE FALSE |
54. |
When I disappear into myself I can hear people
calling me but I have no control to speak out, and this scares
me a lot. |
TRUE FALSE |
55. |
I have been raped and can't talk about it. |
TRUE FALSE |
56. |
My biggest fear is that someone will hurt me. |
TRUE FALSE |
57. |
Sometimes I am working on an activity and then
I just can't think at all about what I was doing because my
mind is blank |
TRUE FALSE |
58. |
I have become full of rage and have not been
able to understand why. |
TRUE FALSE |
59. |
I have been told that I roll my eyes |
TRUE FALSE |
60. |
Sometimes I want to do one thing and my body
seems to want to do another thing. |
TRUE FALSE |
61. |
If I can ever find out what is wrong with me
I will work hard to get better. |
TRUE FALSE |
62. |
Some people think I am a problem to society but
they can't help me either. |
TRUE FALSE |
63. |
Sometimes I find myself eating food that I don't
like. |
TRUE FALSE |
64. |
I can't always smell odors even when I don't
have a cold. |
TRUE FALSE |
65. |
Sometimes I answer questions on exams and don't
know where the answer comes from. |
TRUE FALSE |
66. |
I have been involved in cult activities and it
scares me to admit it. |
TRUE FALSE |
67. |
I have been threatened to keep a big secret. |
TRUE FALSE |
68. |
I have lost days at a time and have no explanation
for it. |
TRUE FALSE |
69. |
Most people that have tried to help me don't
ask me the right questions about myself. |
TRUE FALSE |
70. |
I have been constantly present during the taking
of this test. |
TRUE FALSE |
71. |
There is a part of me that is childlike and I
am embarrassed when people tell me I acted that way again. |
TRUE FALSE |
72. |
I have been told my someone in me to do things
that I am not willing to do. |
TRUE FALSE |
73. |
I rarely see things that aren't there. |
TRUE FALSE |
74. |
Voices in my head sometimes are so clear I am
frightened by them. |
TRUE FALSE |
75. |
I feel good about taking this test because I
feel like you may be able to help me. |
TRUE FALSE |
76. |
Sometimes I feel like there are many different
parts to me. |
TRUE FALSE |
77. |
I get upset when I am extremely angry with someone
I love and I can't explain what happened because I don't know. |
TRUE FALSE |
78. |
I have tried to use drugs to cover up my experiences. |
TRUE FALSE |
79. |
There is one part of me who wants to use drugs
and I try to keep that part under control. |
TRUE FALSE |
80. |
I have heard voices in my head that have convinced
me to kill myself. |
TRUE FALSE |
81. |
Sometimes I burst out laughing and can't stop. |
TRUE FALSE |
82. |
I find myself crying and don't understand why my eyes are
wet because "I" wasn't crying. |
TRUE FALSE |
83. |
Many times I have no feeling in part of my body
and I can't explain why. |
TRUE FALSE |
84. |
I have found letters that I don't remember writing
but they were signed by me. |
TRUE FALSE |
85. |
The question that upset me the most was question
No. ________. |
TRUE FALSE |
86. |
I don't remember taking this test before. |
TRUE FALSE |
87. |
My biggest fear today is that nobody will find
out what is wrong with me then I will think I really am crazy. |
TRUE FALSE |
88. |
I believe that when I was a small child something
happened to me that may have caused me to do these strange things. |
TRUE FALSE |
89. |
I have to be reminded many times about things
that I should have done that I thought I did. |
TRUE FALSE |
90. |
There are some people that I need to stay away
from because I have thought about killing them. |
TRUE FALSE |
91. |
I have been beaten severely. |
TRUE FALSE |
92. |
Part of my body works at times and I can't get
the other part to move. |
TRUE FALSE |
93. |
I cover up a lot for myself because I don't know
the truth anymore. |
TRUE FALSE |
94. |
I don't think anybody has my experiences and
knowing that frightens me. |
TRUE FALSE |
95. |
I know that I do not lie to my parents, but they
tell me I lie all the time. |
TRUE FALSE |
96. |
Sometimes I feel like I am asleep all day and
another part of me took over and participated in the day for
me. |
TRUE FALSE |
97. |
I will be very happy if you find out what is
wrong with me. |
TRUE FALSE |
98. |
I don't want any of my friends to know about
my problem. |
TRUE FALSE |
99. |
I have never really felt a feeling, I just pretend
I do. |
TRUE FALSE |
100. |
I feel I have lost control over myself and I
need help. |
TRUE FALSE |
Please write out any statements about your experience that you
want your doctor to know.
Date of Birth:
Sex: M F
Height: ______
Weight: ______
Last Grade Completed: ____
Dale Test Taken: _________
Gwen L. Dean, Ph.D.
(213)373-1630
©Gwen L. Dean, Ph.D., 1985
APPENDIX G - REFERENCES
Adams-Tucker, Christine. "Proximate Effects of Sexual Abuse
in Childhood: A Report on 28 Children." American Journal
of Psychiatry. v. 139. 1982. 1252-1256.
Alexander, Pamela C. and Shirley L. Lupfer. "Family Characteristics
and Long-term Consequences Associated with Sexual Abuse." Archives
of Sexual Behaviour. v.16. 1987. 235-245.
Awad, George A. "Father-Son Incest: A Case Report" Journal
of Nervous and Mental Disease. v.162. 1976. 135-139.
Badgley, Robin, et al. Sexual Offences in Canada: A Summary
Report of the Committee on Sexual Offences Against Children and
Youths. (Ottawa, Ontario: Supply and Services) 1984.
Baker, Anthony W. "Child Sexual Abuse: A Study of Prevalence
in Great Britain." Child Abuse and Neglect. v.9. 1985.
457-467.
Banning, Anne. "Mother-Son Incest: Confronting a Prejudice."
Child Abuse and Neglect. v.13. 1989. 563-570.
Bass, Ellyn and Laura Davis. The Courage to Heal. Harper
& Row: New York 1988.
Blanchard, Geral. "Male Victims of Child Sexual Abuse: A Portent
of Things to Come." Journal of Independent Social Work.
v.1. 1986. 19-27.
Briere, John. Therapy for Adults Molested as Children: Beyond
Survival. New York: Springer Publishing Company, 1989.
Briere, John, Diane Evans, Marsha Runtz and Timothy Wall. "Symptomatology
in Men Who Were Molested as Children: A Comparison Study."
American Journal of Orthopsychiatry. v.58. 1988. 457-461.
Briere, John and Marsha Runtz. "Symptomatology Associated
with Childhood Sexual Victimization in a Nonclinical Adult Sample."
Child Abuse and Neglect. v.12.1988. 51-59.
Brown, Jeff. "The Treatment of Male Victims with Mixed Gender,
Short-Term Group Psychotherapy." ch.7 in The Sexually Abused
Male. v.2. (Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books,
1990.
Bruckner, Debra F. and Peter E. Johnson. "Treatment for Adult
Male Victims of Childhood Sexual Abuse." Social Casework.
Feb. 1987. 81-87.
Carlson, Eve Bernstein and Frank W. Putnam. Manual for the Dissociative
Experiences Scale. Aug. 1992.
Carlson, Shirley "The Victim/Perpetrator: Turning Points."
ch.12 in The Sexually Abused Male. v.2. (Mic Hunter, ed.)
Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books, 1990.
Condy, Sylvia Robbins, Donald I. Templer, Ric Brown and Lelia Veaco
"Parameters of Sexual Contact of Boys with Women." Archives
of Sexual Behavior. v.16.1987. 379-394.
Constantine, Larry L. "The Effects of Early Sexual Experiences:
A Review and Synthesis of Research." ch. 17 in Children
and Sex: New Findings, New Perspectives. (L.L. Constantine and
F.M. Martinson, eds.) Boston: Little, Brown & Co., 1981.
Courtois, Christine A. Healing the Incest Wound: Adult Survivors
in Therapy. New York: W.W. Norton & Co., 1988.
Courtois, Christine A. "Theory, Sequencing and Strategy in
Treating Adult Survivors." New Directions for Mental Health
Services. Fall, 1991. 47-59.
Crowder, Adrienne and Judy Myers-Avis. Group Treatment for Sexually
Abused Adolescents. Holmes Beach, Florida: Learning Publications,
1993.
Davis, Laura. Allies in Healing. New York: Harper Collins,
1991.
Davis, Laura. The Courage to Heal Workbook. New York: Harper
& Raw, 1990.
Davis, Nancy. Once Upon a Time - Therapeutic Stories. Oxon
Hill, Maryland: Psychological Associates of Oxon Hill, 1990.
deYoung, Mary. "Self-Injurious Behaviour in Incest Victims:
A Research Note", Child Welfare. v.61-1982. 577-583.
Dimock, Peter T. "Adult Males Sexually Abused as Children."
Journal of Interpersonal Violence. v.3. 1988. 203-221.
Dixon, Katharine N., Eugene Arnold and Kenneth Calestro. "Father-Son
Incest: Under-reported Psychiatric Problem?" American Journal
of Psychiatry. v.135. July, 1978. 835-838.
Dolan, Yvonne. Resolving Sexual Abuse. New York: W.W. Norton
& Co., 1991.
Doll, Lynda S., Dan Joy, Brad N. Bartholow, Janet S. Harrison,
Gail Bolan, John M. Douglas, Linda E. Saltzman, Patricia M. Moss
and Wanda Delgado. "Self-Reported Childhood and Adolescent
Sexual Abuse Among Adult Homosexual and Bisexual Men." Child
Abuse and Neglect. v.16.1992. 855-864.
Evans, Mark C. "Brother to Brother: Integrating Concepts of
Healing Regarding Male Sexual Assault Survivors and Vietnam Veterans."
ch.12 in The Sexually Abused Male. v.2. (Mic Hunter, ed.)
Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books, 1990.
Everstine, Diana Sullivan and Louis Everstine. Sexual Trauma
in Children and Adolescents: Dynamics and Treatment. New York:
Brunner/Mazel Inc., 1989.
Finkelhor, David. "Boys as Victims." ch. 10 in Child
Sexual Abuse New Theory and Research. New York: Free Press,
1984.
Forseth, Laura B. and Art Brown. "A Survey of Interfamilial
Sexual Abuse Treatment Centres: Implications for Intervention."
Child Abuse and Neglect. v.5. 1981. 177-186.
Freeman-Longo, Robert E. 'The Impact of Sexual Victimization on
Males." Child Abuse & Neglect. V.10. 1988. 411-414.
Freund, Kurt, Robin Watson and Robert Dickey. "Does Sexual
Abuse in Childhood Cause Pedophilia: An Exploratory Study."
Archives of Sexual Behaviour. v.19. 1990. 557-568.
Friedrich, William N., Robert L. Beilke and Anthony J. Urquiza.
"Behaviour Problems in Young Sexually Abused Boys." Journal
of Interpersonal Violence. v.3.1988. 21-28.
Fritz, Gregory S., Kim Stoll and Nathaniel N. Wagner. "A Comparison
of Males and Females Who were Sexually Molested as Children."
Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy. v.7. 1981. 54-59.
Fromuth, Mary Ellen and Barry R. Burkhart. "Long-term Psychological
Correlates of Childhood Sexual Abuse in Two Samples of College Men."
Child Abuse & Neglect. v.13.1989. 533-542.
Froning, Mary L and Susan B. Mayman. "Identification and Treatment
of Child and Adolescent Male Victims of Sexual Abuse." ch.
10 in The Sexually Abused Male. v.2. (Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington,
Mass: Lexington Books, 1990.
Frosh, Stephen. "No Man's Land?: The Role of Men Working with
Sexually Abused Children." British Journal of Guidance and
Counselling. v.16.1988. 1-10.
Gerber, Paul N. "The Assessment Interview for Young Male Victims"
ch. 11 in The Sexually Abused Male. v.1. (Mic Hunter, ed.)
Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books, 1990.
Gerber, Paul N. "Victims Becoming Offenders: A Study of Ambiguities."
ch.7 in The Sexually Abused Male. v.1. (Mic Hunter, ed.)
Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books, 1990.
Gordon, Linda & Paul O'Keefe. "Incest as a Form of Family
Violence: Evidence from Historical Case Records." Journal
of Marriage and the Family. 1984. 27-34.
Gresham, Anne M. "The Role of the Nonoffending Parent When
the Incest Victim is Male." ch.8 in The Sexually Abused
Male. v.2. (Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books,
1990.
Groth, Nicholas and Ann Wolbert Burgess. "Male Rape: Offenders
and Victims." American Journal of Psychiatry. v.137.
1980. 806-810.
Grubman-Black, Stephen D. Broken Boys/Mending Men: Recovery
from Childhood Sexual Abuse. New York: Ballantine Books, 1990.
Halpern, Judith. "Family Therapy in Father-Son Incest: A Case
Study." Social Casework. 1987. 88-93.
Hunter, Mic. Abused Boys - The Neglected Victims of Sexual Abuse.
New York: Fawcett Columbine, 1990a.
Hunter, Mic. ed. The Sexually Abused Male. 2 vols. Lexington,
Mass: Lexington Books, 1990.
Hunter, Mic and Paul N. Gerber. "Use of the Terms 'Victim'
and 'Survivor' in the Grief Stages Commonly Seen During Recovery
from Sexual Abuse." ch.3 in The Sexually Abused Male.
v.2. (Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books, 1990.
Janus, Mark-David, Ann W. Burgess and Arlene McCormack. "Histories
of Sexual Abuse in Adolescent Male Runaways." Adolescence.
v.22. 1987. 405-417.
Johnson, Robert L. and Diane Shrier. "Past Sexual Victimization
by Females of Male Patients in an Adolescent Medicine Clinic Population."
American Journal of Psychiatry. v.144. 1987. 650-652.
Jones, Robert J., Kenneth J. Gruber and Mary H. Freeman. "Reactions
of Adolescents to Being Interviewed About Their Sexual Assault Experiences."
Journal of Sex Research. v.19.1983.160-172.
Kaplan, Meg S., Judith V. Becker and Craig E. Tenke. "Influence
of Abuse History on Male Adolescent Self-Reported Comfort with Interviewer
Gender." Journal of Interpersonal Violence. v.6. 1991.
3-11.
Kaufman, Arthur, Peter Divasto, Rebecca Jackson, Dayton Voorhees
and Joan Christy. "Male Rape Victims: Non-institutionalized
Assault." American Journal of Psychiatry. v.137. 1980.
221-223.
Kilgore, Laurie C. "Effect of Early Childhood Sexual Abuse
on Self and Ego Development" Social Casework. April,
1988. 224-230.
Langevin, Ron, P. Wright and L. Handy. "Characteristics of
Sex Offenders Who Were Sexually Victimized as Children" Annals
of Sex Research. v.2. 227-253.
Leehan, James and Laura Pistone Wilson. Grown-up Abused Children.
Springfield, Illinois: Charles C. Thomas, 1985.
Lew, Mike. Victims No Longer: Men Recovering from Incest and
Other Sexual Child Abuse. New York: Harper & Row, 1988.
Marshall, W. L., H. E. Barbaree and Jennifer Butt. "Sexual
Offenders Against Male Children: Sexual Preferences." Behavioral
Research and Theory. v.26. 1988. 383-391.
McCormack, Arlene, Mark-David Janus and Ann Wolbert Burgess. "Runaway
Youths and Sexual Victimization: Gender Differences in an Adolescent
Runaway Population." Child Abuse and Neglect. v.10.
1986. 387-395.
Metcalfe, Michael, Rhonda Oppenheimer, Andree Dignon and R. L.
Palmer. "Childhood Sexual Experiences Reported by Male Psychiatric
Patients." Psychological Medicine. v.20. 1990. 925-929.
Myers, Michael F. "Men Sexually assaulted as Adults and Sexually
Abused as Boys." Archives of Sexual Behaviour. v.18.
no.3. 1989. 203-215.
Nielsen, Terry Ann. "Sexually Abuse of Boys: Current Perspectives."
The Personnel and Guidance Journal. November 1983. 139-142.
O'Connor, Art. "Female Sex Offenders." British Journal
of Psychiatry. v.150. 1987. 615-620.
Olson, Peter E. "The Sexual Abuse of Boys: A Study of the
Long-Term Psychological Effects" ch.6 in The Sexually Abused
Male. v.1. (Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books,
1990.
Paitich, D., R. Langevin, R. Freeman, K. Mann and L. Handy. "The
Clarke SHQ: A Clinical Sex History Questionnaire for Males."
Archives of Sexual Behaviour. v.6. 1977, 421-436.
Parker, Stephen. "Healing Abuse in Gay Men: The Group Component."
ch. 9 in The Sexually Abused Male. v.2. (Mic Hunter, ed.)
Lexington Mass: Lexington Books, 1990.
Pierce, Lois H. "Father-Son Incest: Using the Literature to
Guide Practice." Social Casework. Feb. 1987. 67-74.
Pierce, Robert and Lois Hauck Pierce. "The Sexually Abused
Child: A Comparison of Male and Female Victims." Child Abuse
and Neglect. v.9. 1985. 191-199.
Reinhart, Michael A. "Sexually Abused Boys." Child
Abuse and Neglect. v.11. 1987. 229-235.
Risin, Leslie and Mary P. Koss. "The Sexual Abuse of Boys:
Prevalence and Descriptive Characteristics of Childhood Victimizations."
Journal of Interpersonal Violence. v.2.1987. 309-323.
Rose, Deborah S. "'Worse than Death': Psychodynamics of Rape
Victims and the Need for Psychotherapy." The American Journal
of Psychiatry. v.143. 1986. 817-824.
Sandfort, Theodorus G.M. "Sex in Pedophiliac Relationships:
An Empirical Investigation Among a Non-representative Group of Boys."
Journal of Sex Research. v.20. 1984. 123-142.
Sarrel, Philip and William H. Masters. "Sexual Molestation
of Men by Women." Archives of Sexual Behaviour. v.11.
1982. 117-131.
Schacht, Anita J., Daniel Kerlinsky and Cindy Carlson. "Group
Therapy with Sexually Abused Boys: Leadership, Projective Identification
and Countertransference Issues." International Journal of
Group Psychotherapy. v.40. 1990. 401-417.
Sebold, John. "Indicators of Child Sexual Abuse in Males."
The Journal of Contemporary Social Work. February 1987. 75-80.
Sepler, Fran. "Victim Advocacy and Young Male Victims of Sexual
Abuse: An Evolutionary Model." ch. 3 in The Sexually Abused
Male. v.1. (Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books,
1991.
Steele, Katherine and Joanna Colrain. "Abreactive Work with
Sexual Abuse Survivors: Concepts and Techniques." ch.1 in The
Sexually Abused Male. v.2. (Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington, Mass:
Lexington Books, 1990.
Struve, Jim. "Dancing with the Patriarchy: The Politics of
Sexual Abuse." ch.1 in The Sexually Abused Male. v.1.
(Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books, 1990.
Summit, Roland C. "The Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome."
Child Abuse and Neglect. v.7. 1983.177-193.
Swift, Carolyn. "The Prevention of Sexual Child Abuse: Focus
on the Perpetrator." Journal of Clinical Child Psychology.
Summer 1979.133-136.
Timms, Robert and Patrick Connors. "Integrating Psychotherapy
and Body Work for Abuse Survivors: A Psychological Model."
ch.6 in The Sexually Abused Male. v.2. (Mic Hunter, ed.)
Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books, 1990.
Tindall, Ralph H. "The Male Adolescent Involved with a Pederast
Becomes an Adult." Journal of Homosexuality. v.3. 1978.
373-382.
Trivelpiece, James W. "Adjusting the Frame: Cinematic Treatment
of Sexual Abuse and Rape of Men and Boys." ch.2 in The Sexually
Abused Male. v.1. (Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington, Mass: Lexington
Books. 1990.
Urquiza, Anthony J. and Lisa Marie Keating. "The Prevalence
of Sexual Victimization of Males." ch.4 in The Sexually
Abused Male. v.1. (Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington, Mass: Lexington
Books, 1990.
Urquiza, Anthony J. and Maria Capra. "The Impact of Sexual
Abuse: Initial and Long-Term Effects." ch.5 in The Sexually
Abused Male. v.1. (Mic Hunter, ed.) Lexington, Mass: Lexington
Books, 1990.
Vandermey, Brenda J. "The Sexual Victimization of Male Children:
A Review of Previous Research." Child Abuse and Neglect.
v.12.1988. 61-72.
Zilbergeld, Bernie and John Ullman. Male Sexuality. Boston:
Little, Brown. 1978.
|