Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada - Government of Canada
,
Menu (access key: M)  Français  Contact Us  Help  Search  Canada Site
Skip all menus (access key: 2)    Home  Site Map  Program
 Guides
 Program
 News
 On-line
 Services
   About NSERC  Funding
Skip first menu (access key: 1) Science and Engineering Research Canada

,
 For Professors
 For Students
 and Fellows
 For Industry
 For Institutions
 What's New
 Regional Offices
 Proactive Disclosure
 Related Sites

NSERC

New Initiatives
Find out more...

,

Conflict of Interest/Conflict of Commitment – An Issues Paper
,

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Summary of the topic
3. Objectives of COI/COC policies
4. Principal issues related to COI/COC policies
4.1. Definition of key terms
4.2. Applicability
4.3. Scope
4.4. Significant financial interests
4.5. Relationships between principal investigators and trainees (students and postdoctoral fellows)
4.6. Relationships between principal investigators and support staff
4.7. Administrators
4.8. Human subject research and clinical trials
5. Institutional processes
6. Compliance
7. Conclusion
8. Appendix 1. Selected Conflict of Interest and Conflict of Commitment Policies of Associations, Government Bodies and Universities
8.1. Canada
8.2. USA
8.3. UK
8.4. Other
9. Appendix 2. Composition of the Tri-Agency Working Group
10. Appendix 3. Definitions
10.1. Conflict of Interest
10.2. Conflicts of Commitment
11. Appendix 4. Agencies' Existing Statements on Conflicts of Interest
11.1. Policy on Conflict of Interest (NSERC)
11.2. Guidelines for Organizations Participating in Research Partnerships Programs (NSERC)
11.3. General Guidelines for the University-Industry Program (CIHR)
11.4. Tri-Council Policy Statement: Ethical Conduct for Research Involving Humans
11.5. Research involving humans NSERC Guide

1. Introduction

The three Federal Granting Agencies (Tri-Agency, Agencies), Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR), Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC) and Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC), have developed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) on Expectations/Roles and Responsibilities. This MOU aims at codifying, clarifying and harmonizing the roles and responsibilities of the Agencies and of recipient Institutions in the management of federal grants and awards. Institutions must sign the MOU to remain eligible for Agency funding. Eight Schedules have been developed already, which define issues, such as the ethical review of research involving humans, the ethical review of research involving animals, and integrity in research. The Agencies want to add a Schedule dealing with Conflict of Interest and Conflict of Commitment (COI/COC) to the series.

Prior to drafting the issues paper, the COI/COC policies of a number of institutions (associations, government agencies and universities) in Canada, the USA and the UK were reviewed (see Appendix 1). An issues paper was drafted and a Working Group composed of Agency staff and academics (see Appendix 2) was convened to discuss the various issues raised, raise additional ones and propose the Framework for a Schedule on COI. The first draft of a COI Schedule was discussed by the Working Group to arrive at a final version to be distributed to the broad community for comments.

The present paper reflects this process and it is distributed to the research community as a means to inform and to provide models to institutions in setting or revising their own COI/COC policies.


,
Created:
Updated: 
2004-05-19
2004-08-27

Top of Page

Important Notices