From:
Michelle_Wessel@sonymusic.com[SMTP:Michelle_Wessel@sonymusic.com]Sent: October 2, 2001 4:59 PM
To: procedure@crtc.gc.ca
Cc: bell.regulatory@bell.ca
Subject: Attn: Secretary General CRTC
Review of regulatory local telephone service prices.
Dear Secretary General CRTC,
I have read the literature (small pamphlet) provided with my most recent Bell
Telephone statement and I have a few questions/ comments.
1)Can the CRTC give me a list of companies that provide competitive local
telephone services? I have never seen any advertisements and would appreciate
being informed of any companies that make this service available.
2) The literature states that "Bell Canada has filed proposals with the CRTC
that are intended to":
"Ensure that competition is maintained and encouraged..."
QUESTION: What competition does Bell Canada have for its local telephone
services?
COMMET: As far as I know, Bell Canada owns the telephone lines. This means
that other companies would have to "lease" the lines to provide local service.
How can their prices be competitive if they have to pay Bell to use the
lines?
3) It states in the "Highlights of the Bell proposal" that they want to change
prices based on the following:
"Monthly prices for basic service in rural and remote areas - where prices
today are far below the cost of providing service - could increase by no more
than $2.00 each year to a maximum monthly charge of $29.65 at the end of the
four-year period"
QUESTION: What is the basic cost of providing service to rural and remote areas?
COMMENT: I live in a rural area and my telephone service is very poor. On
windy days, I hear a lot of static noise when using the telephone. That is
because
the telephone lines are on poles and not buried in the ground and I am
sure that the lines are very old. Why would Bell charge more for this poor
service?
"On-going monitoring of the effects of price increases on affordability would
continue"
QUESTION: What does this mean? This is so vague, it sounds like it means a
whole lot of nothing. Does it matter if people can afford telephone services?
COMMENT: Most people rely on having a phone service everyday. Almost everyone
I know thinks their local service rates are too high. They just keep
paying because they need the service. I know some people who have
considered canceling their local service and instead, use their cellular
phones. This way, only people they want to talk to can call them
because their number would be unlisted. And therefore no more telemarketers!!!!
We only need yellow pages for businesses and therefore, we could
eliminate the white pages. The book would not cost as much money to make
(which we pay for through our local service charges). Bell operators
could still provide the 411 service (which we pay for anyway) so Bell would
save money. Maybe that savings could be passed on through
"competitive" prices?
Customers would receive rebates if CRTC-mandated quality of service
indicators were not met"
QUESTION: How is the CRTC going to make sure that Bell is providing "quality"
service. Define quality. How do you test for this? How do you know if a
customer is making a feasible claim?
COMMENT: My phone has static noise on windy days. Do I have to call the CRTC
every time it is windy? And who would I call?
4) In the summary it states "Through gradual and moderate increases in basic
residential service prices, service would remain affordable, while encouraging
greater competition and innovation."
COMMENT: This is an oxymoron -- "encourage greater competition" and "increases
in... prices". Competition is suppose to keep prices down.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
I would also like to request that when a price increase is approved, that Bell
Canada be upfront about it and put it in sizeable print on the statement. In
the past, Bell Canada has used fine print to indicate a CRTC-approved price
increase. I don't know of any other companies that practice business this way.
It almost seems deceitful. Like they are hoping people don't read the fine
print because they don't want any complaints.
It is really hard to truly judge a company unless you can see their financial
statements. How many local service accounts does Bell have? What is the
average charge for local service? What are Bell Canada's expenditures? How
much profit do they make? I would like to know how often prices have been
increased and by how much. I doubt I will ever see Bell Canada's financial
statements, but I would hope the CRTC does.
Thank you,
Michelle Wessel