Canadian Flag Transport Canada / Transports Canada Government of Canada
Common menu bar (access key: M)
Skip to specific page links (access key: 1)
Transport Canada
Table of Contents
Terms of Reference
West Coast Towing Operations
Fleet Database
Applicable Regulations
Vessel Incident Data
Impact of Regulations on Safety Outcomes
Risk Analysis
Cost Impact of Regulations
Conclusions and Recommendations
Suggested Modifications to Canadian Regulations


PDF Version



Marine Safety Publications
Marine Safety Home Page
Skip all menus (access key: 2)
Transport Canada > Marine Safety Home Page > Transport Publications | Marine Safety > The Impact of Regulations on Towing Vessel Safety: A Comparative Evaluation of Canadian and American West Coast Tug and Barge Operations (2004) | TP 14315 | Marine Safety

PREVIOUS | TABLE OF CONTENTS | NEXT

3.0  FLEET DATABASES

3.1 Canadian Tug Fleet

  • Total number of tugs (> 10 metres length) = 412

  • More than half of the tugs registered in BC are under 15 GRT

  • More than two-thirds of the BC tug fleet is under 15 metres in length

  • More than half of the BC tug fleet has less than 500 bhp

  • The majority of the BC tug fleet is more than 30 years old, and many are more than 50 years old

3.2 USA Tug Fleet

  • The total number of tugs in the US west coast fleet is 534 (2000)

  • The distribution of tugs by length is much more "normal" in the US than in Canada, but is still skewed predominantly to smaller vessels in the 15-25 metre range

  • There are many more larger tugs (> 30 metres) in the USA than in Canada

3.3 Fleet Comparisons

  • Due to extreme differences in Tonnage Measurement systems between Canada and the USA, a direct comparison between GRT in the two countries cannot be made. An analysis of the actual volume of the tug fleets by Cubic Number (Nc) indicates that:

    - GRT (Canada) = approx. 1.5 GRT (US)

  • The Power/Size ratio of Canadian tugs is much higher than the US counterparts, as witnessed by the following analysis results:

    - Canada    - Power = 1.958 x NC + 304 (fleet average)
    - USA         - Power = 0.295 x NC + 44 (fleet average)

  • The Power/Length ratio of Canadian tugs is broadly linear, with high randomness:

    - Power = (95.3 x Length) - 597

  • The Power/Length ratio of US tugs is much more parabolic, but again with high scatter:

    - Power = 127.25 x e (0.1002 x L)

    PREVIOUS | TABLE OF CONTENTS | NEXT


Last updated: 2006 02 10 Top of Page Important Notices