![]() ![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Aboriginal Initiatives Branch ![]() ![]() Enhancing the Role of Aboriginal Communities Booklet ABORIGINAL ALTERNATIVES TO INCARCERATION
AND ABORIGINAL PAROLE SUPERVISION: SECTIONS 81 AND 84 OF THE CORRECTIONS AND CONDITIONAL RELEASE ACT AN OVERVIEW The laws that govern federal corrections include specific provisions that encourage the involvement of Aboriginal communities in the correctional process. Two sections of the Corrections and Conditional Release Act (CCRA) provide the opportunity for Aboriginal communities to become active partners in the care and custody of Aboriginal offenders and the provision of correctional services. These provisions allow CSC to work in partnership with Aboriginal communities to provide Aboriginal offenders with innovative services that CSC could not itself provide in a culturally effective manner. This booklet was designed by the Correctional Service of Canada (CSC) to assist Aboriginal communities interested in pursuing this partnership by explaining these provisions. ABORIGINAL ALTERNATIVES TO INCARCERATION The first of the provisions is Section 81, which reads:
Section 81 supports a wide spectrum of custodial or service delivery arrangements for the care and custody of Aboriginal offenders. It contemplates that an offender could be transferred to the care and custody of an Aboriginal community at any time during his or her sentence, from the date of sentencing to the date of warrant expiry. This can involve the supervision of offenders in such cases as day parole, full parole, or statutory release. Services that can be provided under Section 81 fall into four categories:
Section 81 Agreements for residential arrangements are based on the following principles:
ABORIGINAL PAROLE SUPERVISION The second of the provisions is Section 84, which reads: Where an inmate who is applying for parole has expressed an interest in being released to an Aboriginal community the Service shall, if the inmate consents, give the Aboriginal community:
The majority of federal offenders will be released from custody. This is a critical time, and good release planning is essential. Section 84 encourages the participation of Aboriginal communities, by requiring CSC to seek their input, as part of the process. CSC is mandated to incarcerate offenders at a level of control that is no higher than what is necessary to protect society and the well-being of the offenders. In many instances, release planning begins the moment an offender is taken into custody. A Correctional Plan developed with the offender identifies the programs and activities in which s/he should engage to facilitate a safe release and continued law-abiding behaviour in the community. If the offender agrees, an Aboriginal community may be asked very early in the sentence if there is any interest in proposing a release plan. At this point, the release may still be two or three years off. Early planning improves the coordination of efforts and increases the likelihood of a successful release. A community that acquaints itself with the efforts the offender makes while incarcerated will both encourage those efforts and reinforce its own expectations of the offender's behaviour before and after release. WHAT IS THE RATIONALE FOR SECTIONS 81 AND 84? The successful reintegration of offenders into society depends upon a strong and effective community focus. It is in the interests of the community itself that it be involved in the corrections and reintegration process for offenders who will be living in the community. Aboriginal communities know best how to use their values, strengths, and relationships to assist offenders in reintegration. If a community-based, restorative model of justice is preferred, that cannot be imposed by CSC, it must originate in the community itself. With regard to the placement of Aboriginal offenders in Section 81 facilities, it is important to consider the first of the principles outlined earlier: "The protection of society and the safety of the community are paramount." In order to satisfy this principle, any risk presented by the offender must not exceed what can be safely managed by the community. CSC anticipates that most, but not all, offenders involved in the initial Section 81 Agreements will have been determined to have a low risk security classification and a low risk of re-offending. These offenders should also demonstrate that they are ready to move back into the community, and that they are willing to actively participate in any custody/release plan proposed by the community. Incarceration and Release The Corrections and Conditional Release Act recognizes that offenders need to be adequately prepared for their return to the community (whether it be their community of origin or another community), and that programs and services must be provided to support them upon release. In most cases, an offender serving a term of federal incarceration of two years or longer will spend part of this time in the community. (Exceptions to this depend on the risk the offender may present to people in the community and on the type of sentence s/he is serving. Some offenders will not be released until they have completed their full sentence. Terms of parole for those serving life sentences are established at the time of sentencing.) Generally, an offender is considered for release on full parole after having served one-third or seven years, whichever is less, of his or her sentence. Full parole allows the offender to complete the sentence in the community, under supervision. S/he must abide by certain conditions, and may be required to complete specific programs. Offenders on full parole live independently, much like anyone else, on their own, or with family or friends. Day parole is a transitional form of release normally granted 6 months before full parole eligibility, wherein an offender lives in a community-based facility or residence. In most cases, s/he is free to leave during the day to work or participate in programs, but must return to the facility or residence at night. Offenders who fail to fulfill the conditions of parole, or who pose an unacceptably high risk, may have their parole suspended or revoked, and may be returned to a federal institution. Preparing Offenders for Release While in CSC facilities, offenders are encouraged to begin addressing the causes and issues that led to their criminal behaviour. CSC programs and services address addictions, violent behaviour ethnocultural issues, women issues and sex offenses. Opportunities are provided for Aboriginal offenders to improve their education and employment skills as well as their living skills. Offenders are also given the opportunity to turn to Elders for counseling and spiritual teaching. When an offender expresses interest in returning to an Aboriginal community, Section 84 requires CSC to seek the community's involvement. The needs of an offender who wishes to correct his or her behaviour will be assessed, and s/he will then participate in developing a Correctional Plan. In addition to specifying programs and activities that the offender will pursue, the plan will outline what the community must undertake to ensure that his or her reintegration is successful. The community will outline resources available in their community, and describe what they can offer offenders entering their community. Communities may have different resources available, examples include instruction in traditional values and spiritual practices, healing circles, addictions treatment, family programming, and vocational training. This is the most critical time for the offender, whose successful return to society will depend to a large degree on the involvement of the community. Section 81 residential facilities may accept persons on conditional release as described above, so as to provide special programs. As well, these programs may be available to offenders who are transferred to the care and custody of the residential facility. This way, Aboriginal communities provide a residential environment, which facilitates the eventual reintegration of offenders. INVOLVEMENT OF THE ABORIGINAL COMMUNITY SECTION 81 of the CCRA Communities interested in pursuing agreements under Section 81 should consider the following factors:
For additional information and assistance in developing their plans, communities are encouraged to contact CSC Regional Headquarters, as follows:
SECTION 84 of the CCRA Section 84 requires CSC to involve Aboriginal communities in conditional release planning for Aboriginal offenders. This can occur during one of two phases:
Thus, if a community wishes to participate, it will have time to work closely with the offender and the parole officer to develop an effective release plan that complements the work undertaken in the institution. It is important that this plan be acceptable to the community, the offender, and CSC. Aboriginal communities are encouraged to develop specific services and resources, which address the needs of Aboriginal women offenders. This would provide Aboriginal women with increased opportunity to participate in section 84 agreements. A typical Section 84 process might look like this. (Remember that the goal, even for those sentenced to lengthy terms of federal incarceration, is a safe and successful reintegration into the community.)
COMMONLY ASKED QUESTIONS ON SECTIONS 81 AND 84 OF THE Corrections and Conditional Release Act (CCRA)
1. What is a "correctional service?" A "correctional service" is a service which provides opportunities for offenders to correct their behaviour, and facilitates their safe and successful return to society. For example CSC offers:
2. What does Section 81(3) really mean? Section 81(3) states that CSC can transfer an offender to the care and custody of an Aboriginal community. Before this can happen, certain conditions must be met:
Section 81 Agreements require appropriate measures to be in place or created for the safe care and custody of offenders. Aboriginal communities establish rules in accordance with standards that both the community and CSC have agreed will promote safe custody of the inmate; the safety of the public and victims; and the successful and timely reintegration of the offender in the community. The Aboriginal community has authority to enact rules and ensure offenders in their care follow them. As a partner in the agreement, CSC's interest is that the rules and enforcement, established by Aboriginal communities, achieve the objective of safe and secure custody, and successful reintegration into the community. Aboriginal communities that agree to partake in this partnership must provide an account of the actions they will take upon undertaking this role. This requirement involves a number of constituents:
3. What facilities are required to enter into a Section 81 agreement? Section 81 allows several options for care and custody, including:
4. How does a community enter into a Section 81 agreement? Communities interested in a Section 81 agreement should consider the following questions:
If a community wants to negotiate a Section 81 agreement, it must present a proposal to CSC that addresses these issues. CSC must determine the offenders' needs and evaluate the project's financial viability. Community support is essential for the success of the project. The community must ensure that its members understand the issues and that their questions and concerns have been addressed. CSC can participate in this aspect of the proposal development. Once it has been determined that the proposal is feasible, that community members support it, and that the community has the necessary resources to manage the initiative, discussions can begin on the shape of the agreement, the standards that must be followed, the selection criteria for offenders, and the costs for providing the services. The requirements for concluding a successful agreement will vary, depending on the nature of the service provided. More detail is required for a facility-based agreement than for a non-facility-based initiative. 5. How would Section 81 be established in an urban setting? A Section 81 agreement is in place in Edmonton with the Native Counselling Services of Alberta. The designated facility, Stan Daniels, has been operated for many years by Native Counselling Services and has housed offenders on conditional release through contract with CSC. The establishment of an agreement now permits Stan Daniels to house offenders, which make up approximately 20% of the offender population. A Section 81 agreement for an urban setting must meet the same requirements as an agreement for a rural setting. One important consideration is whether adequate services and programs are available for offenders.
1. How does an offender apply for Section 84? To start the process, the offender writes to a community representative previously identified to CSC as the appropriate contact person, to request the community's involvement in the release planning process. CSC will then formally notify the community representative of the offender's upcoming parole dates. If no contact person has been designated, the offender's letter and CSC notification will be directed to the Chief and Council. It is important that there be a contact person in the community who is responsible for coordinating the development of release plans. This person (or group) may be the Justice Worker, or someone involved in Justice Committees, and must be authorized to speak on the community's behalf. Their selection should be based on their role in the community, and their experience with justice and/or corrections issues. 2. When Section 84 is invoked, at what point should the community interact with the offender? The earlier the offender contacts the community and the community agrees to take part, the better. Ideally, the community's participation should begin when CSC conducts the Intake Assessment. Good release planning is easiest when the community is involved throughout the sentence, beginning with the creation of the Correctional Plan. This identifies the activities the offender will pursue not only within the institution but also during the portion of the sentence that will be served in the community. CSC must meet strict time lines in presenting applications to the National Parole Board. As the release plan prepared by the community forms part of an offender's application, the community should be informed and involved at least by the time the offender begins to prepare his or her case for parole. 3. Can an offender be escorted temporarily into the community before being released? Yes, as long as legal and security requirements are met. This provision gives the offender and the community an opportunity to prepare good release plans. A Circle process may be used so that the community can learn from the parole officer and the offender about the healing efforts s/he has undertaken in the institution. The process could involve more than one temporary absence from the institution. 4. What elements need to be in a release plan? To whom is it submitted? To prepare a good release plan, communities should consider questions like these:
The plan is submitted to the Parole Officer. 5. How can communities ensure that an offender isn't released into their midst without their knowledge? CSC recognizes its responsibility to keep Aboriginal communities informed. To help in this effort, it is important that the community designate a representative who is willing to act as a contact point. A community that is developing a plan under Section 84 will know, through their involvement in the process, when an offender is to be released. If the community was not involved in developing the release plan, a Community Assessment will be conducted by CSC prior to the offender's release. Once a community representative has been identified, CSC can consult him or her as part of the Community Assessment. At the same time, arrangements can be made to inform the community of the results of the parole hearing. Offenders may also be released automatically by law on Statutory Release, after serving two thirds of their sentence. In these cases, a release plan may not have been established with the community. Furthermore, offenders on parole may seek permission to move to a First Nation, or to travel there to visit someone. Sometimes travel arrangements are made on short notice. When offenders do arrive in a community unexpectedly, we encourage the community representative to contact the Area Parole Office to discuss the situation. 6. Can the community participate in parole hearings in other ways? Yes. The parole board welcomes observers at hearings. The offender can also ask to have assistants present. These might include community members who have been involved in the release planning. Under certain circumstances, the parole board will conduct Community Panels in Aboriginal communities. A Circle process can be used for these hearings, which can involve input by community members. 7. If a community has made a Section 84 arrangement with one offender, is it obligated to accept applications from others in the future? No. Section 84 arrangements are considered on a case-by-case basis. 8. Can the costs associated with the programs or services that an offender may require be included in a proposal (e.g., course fees or, in the case of programs offered in a municipality near a reserve, transportation to town)? Provision can be made to pay for services when a release plan requires that an offender on conditional release have access to them. If the offender must pay a fee to participate, that cost should be itemized in the plan. Transportation costs should also be included. Listing these costs in the proposal will not guarantee that they will be covered. This decision will be based on how well the course or program addresses the offender's needs and on the availability of funds. 9. When Section 84 is invoked, how can a community involve the victim(s) in the process? When the community determines that this is important, CSC and the National Parole Board will work to involve the victim(s). The community may propose the manner in which this will be done. Any legal responsibilities CSC and the parole board have to victim(s) must be respected. It is important that any interaction between the victim(s) and offender be planned carefully by the community and CSC to ensure that the safety and rights of both parties are protected. If a meeting between the victim(s) and the offender is involved, factors that must be considered include, at minimum:
When a written request is made by the victim(s) to receive information only, CSC or the National Parole Board will keep them informed of hearing and release dates. 10. How long does it usually take to invoke either section, from the time a community first becomes involved to the time an offender is released into its care? There is no average length of time. It depends upon when the community becomes involved and, to some extent, the length of the offender's sentence. CSC must follow specific time lines before a case is presented to the National Parole Board. When the Board receives an application for parole or begins an automatic review, a six-month review date is set. Simultaneously, a meeting is scheduled with the offender for the month prior to that date. Furthermore, the Board must receive review information no later than 21 days before the hearing is held. 11. What courses of action are possible if an offender violates one of the less serious conditions of his parole in the community under Section 84? (For example, what if s/he stops attending AA or NA meetings?) In other words, what is the authority vested in the community (CJC or band council)? When an offender is granted a conditional release, CSC is normally responsible for parole supervision. The parole officer has some authority to suspend a conditional release, but the final authority to end it rests with the National Parole Board. In cases where parole supervision is provided under contract, the specific responsibilities and authorities are established in the contract. When an offender is living in a community through a Section 84 arrangement, the respective responsibilities and authorities of the community must be established with the Area Parole Office. These will vary, depending on the circumstances and the wishes of the community. In all cases, the community needs to work closely with the parole officer responsible for supervising the offender. When an offender violates the conditions of parole, CSC has several options, including suspending parole. The primary consideration in weighing these is determining whether the chosen measure will correct the behaviour and prevent the commission of another offence. These options might include:
12. How would Section 84 be applied in an urban setting? The Corrections and Conditional Release Act defines an "Aboriginal community" as "a first nation, tribal council, band, community organization, or other group with a predominantly aboriginal leadership." This means that a nonprofit community agency, for example, could be asked to prepare a release plan. It is up to the offender to identify the agency or group. Remember that the intent of this legislation is to promote the involvement of the Aboriginal community in the release process. The goal is to ensure that this proceeds in a manner that protects the community and increases the offender's chance of success. CSC will work with any urban organization or group that wishes to present a plan that will achieve these objectives. In an urban setting, such an organization may not necessarily represent the larger community, but the important consideration is that the group be a credible one, and that the plan promote safe reintegration. 13. What funding does CSC provide for the application of Section 84? Section 84 was established in law and governs CSC. The statute was developed to respond to concerns that the Aboriginal community was not being given the opportunity to become involved in corrections issues that affect Aboriginal people. Section 84 is based on the premise that encouraging community participation in the reintegration of offenders is an effective way to restore balance and make reparation for harm done. It allows principles of restorative justice to be applied in cases that involve Aboriginal offenders and communities. CSC will work with communities as their plans develop, and will provide whatever support, training, and assistance it can. The Mission of the Correctional Service of Canada reads as follows:
|
![]() |
![]() | |
![]() |
Last Updated:
2003.05.23
|