ACTIVE APPEALS
Appeal Case #	Appellant(s)	Respondent(s)	Act	Original Decision-maker	Tribunal Member Hearing the Case	Summary of the Appeal	Updated At
FST 05-012	Superintendent of Real Estate	Real Estate Council of British Columbia Chrystale Ashworth and Master Key Realty Ltd.	Real Estate Services Act S.B.C. 2004, c.42	Real Estate Council of British Columbia	John B. Hall	Appeal of the Real Estate Council’s decision on penalty regarding Chrystale Ashworth and Master Key Realty Ltd.	October 20, 2006
FST 05-015	Chrystale Ashworth and Master Key Realty Ltd.	Real Estate Council of British Columbia Superintendent of Real Estate (By statutory right)	Real Estate Services Act S.B.C. 2004, c.42	Real Estate Council of British Columbia	John B. Hall	Appeal of Real Estate Council’s decision on penalty; appeal of conditions imposed on the registrants; appeal of costs imposed in the original decision	October 20, 2006
FST 06-021	Grimm’s Fine Foods	Superintendent of Pensions	Pension Benefits Standards Act, R.S.B.C., c.352	Superintendent of Pensions	Dale R. Doan	Appeal of a decision of the Superintendent of Pensions – definition of “spouse” in legislation	October 20, 2006
FST 06-022	Superintendent of Real Estate	Real Estate Council of British Columbia Kenneth Scott Spong	Real Estate Services Act S.B.C. 2004, c.42	Real Estate Council of British Columbia	Professor Stanley Hamilton	Appeal of reconsideration decision by the Real Estate Council regarding the FST’s decision in appeal case 05-007	October 20, 2006
FST 06-026	Superintendent of Financial Institutions	Insurance Council of British Columbia Raymond Edward Willie	Financial Institutions Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.141	Insurance Council of BC	John B. Hall	Appeal of the Insurance Council’s decision on penalty	October 20, 2006
FST 06-028	Superintendent of Financial Institutions	Insurance Council of British Columbia William David Blackwood	Financial Institutions Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.141	Insurance Council of BC	Dale Doan	Appeal of the Insurance Council’s decision on penalty	October 20, 2006
FST 06-029	Superintendent of Financial Institutions	Insurance Council of British Columbia Dana Gabriela Ciocan	Financial Institutions Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.141	Insurance Council of BC	Robert J.Hobart	Appeal of the Insurance Council’s decision on penalty	October 20, 2006

The Tribunal Member may confirm, reverse or vary a decision under appeal, or may send it back to the original decision-maker for reconsideration. 

The Tribunal Member must provide written reasons for their decision.

All parties to a hearing will be given a copy of the decision.

Decisions are published and are available on this web site. Certain information in these documents may be withheld to protect personal privacy under BC’s Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.

FST DECISIONS Appeal Case # Appellant(s) Respondent(s) Act Original Decision-maker Tribunal Member Hearing the Case Preliminary Decision Appeal Decision Supplemental Decision Date FST 06-026 Superintendent of Financial Institutions Insurance Council of British Columbia Special Risk Insurance Brokers Ltd. and Raymond Edward Willie Financial Institutions Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c.141 Insurance Council of British Columbia John B. Hall PDF Format November 10, 2006 (PREL) FST 06-025 Robert Matick Registrar of Mortgage Brokers Mortgage Brokers Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c.313 Registrar of Mortgage Brokers Robert J. Hobart PDF Format PDF Format October 13, 2006 November 6, 2006 (SUPL) FST 06-023 Donald Tymchuk and New Way Realty Inc. Real Estate Council of BC Real Estate Services Act and the Council Rules S.B.C. 2004, c.42 Real Estate Council Robert J. Hobart PDF Format PDF Format PDF Format September 6, 2006 October 13, 2006(SUPL) June 06, 2006 (PREL) FST 06-024 Eugenio Pugliese Registrar of Mortgage Brokers Mortgage Brokers Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c.313 Registrar of Mortgage Brokers Dale R. Doan PDF Format   September 5, 2006 FST 06-020 Superintendent of Financial Institutions Insurance Council of British Columbia Richard Jones Financial Institutions Act, RSBC 1996, c.141 as amended Insurance Council of British Columbia Dale R. Doan PDF Format   June 29, 2006 FST 05-019 Jagjit Singh Cheema Insurance Council of British Columbia, Financial Institutions Commission Financial Institutions Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.141 Insurance Council of British Columbia John B. Hall PDF Format   June 15, 2006 FST 05:018 John Winston Carson Registrar of Mortgage Brokers Mortgage Brokers Act R.S.B.C. 1996, as amended Registrar of Mortgage Brokers John. B. Hall PDF Format   May 10, 2006 FST 05:017 Keith Bryan Westergaard and GET Acceptance Corporation Registrar of Mortgage Brokers Mortgage Brokers Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.313 Registrar of Mortgage Brokers Dale R. Doan PDF Format   March 14, 2006 FST 04-003 Superintendent of Real Estate Sherry Shohreh Moallem Real Estate Council of British Columbia Real Estate Services Act S.B.C. 2004, c.42 Real Estate Council of British Columbia Professor Stanley Hamilton PDF Format   February 22, 2006 FST 05-013 05-014 Sandra Jean Stinson, Keith Grant Nelson Real Estate Council of British Columbia Real Estate Services Act S.B.C. 2004, c.42 Real Estate Council of British Columbia Robert J. Hobart PDF Format   February 15, 2006 FST 05-016 William David Blackall Real Estate Council of British Columbia The Real Estate Services Act and the Council Rules S.B.C. 2004, c.42 Real Estate Council of British Columbia Robert J. Hobart PDF Format   February 8, 2006 FST 05-007 Superintendent of Real Estate Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Kenneth Scott Spong Real Estate Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.397 as amended Real Estate Council of BC John B. Hall PDF Format   January 13, 2006 FST 05-011 Ronald Patrick Thomson Superintendent of Real Estate Real Estate Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.397, as amended Superintendent of Real Estate Dale R. Doan PDF Format   December 22, 2005 FST 05-015 Chrystale Ashworth and Master Key Realty Ltd. Real Estate Council of British Columbia The Superintendent of Real Estate The Real Estate Services Act S.B.C. 2004, c.42 and The Real Estate Act R.S.B.C., 1996, c.397, as amended Real Estate Council of British Columbia John B. Hall PDF Format     December 14, 2005 (PREL) FST 05-012 The Superintendent of Real Estate Real Estate Council of British Columbia Chrystale Ashworth and Master Key Realty Ltd. The Real Estate Services Act S.B.C. 2004, c.42 and The Real Estate Act R.S.B.C., 1996, c.397, as amended Real Estate Council of British Columbia John B. Hall PDF Format     December 14, 2005 (PREL) FST 05-009 Financial Institutions Commission Insurance Council of British Columbia and Maria Pavicic Financial Institutions Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.141, amended Insurance Council of British Columbia Professor Stanley Hamilton PDF Format   November 22, 2005 FST 05-010 Jeff Chambers Real Estate Council of British Columbia Real Estate Services Act and Council Rules Real Estate Council of British Columbia Professor Stanley Hamilton   PDF Format   October 31, 2005 FST 05-008 Financial Institutions Commission Branislav Novko and Insurance Council of British Columbia Financial Institutions Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.141, amended Insurance Council of British Columbia Dale R. Doan   PDF Format August 22, 2005 FST 04-002 Mr. Sudarshan Rana Real Estate Council of British Columbia Real Estate Act, R.S.B.C., 1996, c.397, as amended Real Estate Council of British Columbia John B. Hall   PDF Format August 22, 2005 FST 05-004 Danh Vanh Nguyen and Express Mortgages Ltd. Registrar of Mortgage Brokers Mortgage Brokers Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.313, Section 8 Registrar of Mortgage Brokers Dale R. Doan   PDF Format July 20, 2005 FST 04-001 Ronald Patrick Thomson Superintendent of Real Estate Real Estate Act R.S.B.C. 1996, c.397, as amended Superintendent of Real Estate John. B. Hall   PDF Format PDF Format April 4, 2005 May 16, 2005(SUPL)

FST CHAIR DECISIONS
Request	Decision	Date of Decision	Remarks	PDF of Decision	Updated At
Application for Leave to File a Late Notice of Appeal	Application for Leave to File a Late Notice of Appeal - Denied by the Chair	January 19, 2006	Certain information has been redacted to protect personal privacy under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c.165	PDF Format	December 12, 2006

JUDICIAL REVIEWS OF FST DECISIONS
Appeal Case #	Appellant(s)	Respondent(s)	FST Decision	Date	Judicial Review Petition to Court Filed On	Supreme Court Link to Judicial Review Decision
FST 06-025	Robert Matick	Registrar of Mortgage Brokers	PDF Format PDF Format	October 13, 2006 November 6, 2006 (SUPL)	December 12, 2006	Link will be provided when available
FST 06-024	Eugenio Pugliese	Registrar of Mortgage Brokers	PDF Format	September 5, 2006	October 26, 2006	Link will be provided when available
FST 06-020	Superintendent of Financial Institutions	Insurance Council of British Columbia Richard Jones	PDF Format	June 29, 2006	August 17, 2006	Link will be provided when available
FST 04-002	Sudarshan Rana	Real Estate Council of BC	PDF Format	August 22, 2005	October 21, 2005	Link will be provided when available