2004/13 CHECK AGAINST DELIVERY
NOTES FOR AN ADDRESS BY
THE HONOURABLE BILL GRAHAM,
MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS,
TO THE WORLD AFFAIRS COUNCIL
SAN FRANCISCO, California
February 20, 2004
I consider it a great privilege to be invited to speak at this Council, which has such a
long tradition of active participation in foreign affairs. It's also a great pleasure, of
course, to be here in this city, which not only has your spectacular beauty to appreciate
but also, from the perspective of this visitor, a truly spectacular lack of snow and cold.
Of course I'm not the only Canadian to find this area so appealing. Roughly 350,000 of
my fellow citizens are living in the Bay Area. And over a thousand of them are proud
members of the Digital Moose Lounge, which, I have learned, is not a hip new bar but a
social and business networking organization for Canadian expatriates in the high-tech
industry. Furthermore, as some you may know, many of the best animators in Bay Area
animation houses are graduates of Sheridan College, near my city of Toronto.
My country's performing artists are also well acquainted with the attractions of this area
on the cultural front. I've heard that this city has many fans of the wonderful Cirque du
Soleil; and I can highly recommend to you the Canadian show Cavalia, an amazing
equestrian performance that has its local premiere tonight, in fact.
Your invitation to speak here was particularly welcome in light of the fact that it's the
first chance I've had to meet with an American audience since Canada's new Prime
Minister, Paul Martin, took office in December. I'd like to talk today about two things.
The first is a Canadian perspective on the nature of the relationship between our two
countries, and what we in Canada want to do to strengthen it. The second is a related,
but less often talked about issue: how our two nations can strengthen the alliance that
unites us in North America, by working together in the pursuit of goals and interests that
we share in the wider global arena.
I start with the belief that our alliance is a special one, one that has established new
standards for the relations between states. Indeed, the ties that join our two countries
run through almost every aspect of our citizens' lives. Geography dictates our
closeness. Through NORAD, our countries are partners in the defence of North
America. Our civilian authorities, our police and others work closely together on our
security, not only from terrorism, but also from crime and other threats to our
populations. We are increasingly interdependent in matters of energy. Natural gas and
petroleum products flow back and forth across our borders, as does electricity. And as
last summer's electrical collapse taught those of us in the northeastern area, this
mutual dependence carries with it substantial risks that can be avoided only if we
develop our relationship to manage that energy interdependence together.
Our two countries also act as joint stewards of our air, water and wildlife, all of which
cross our border along with millions of our fellow citizens. Our people marry one
another, attend each other's universities, vacation in each other's countries, play on the
same sports teams and entertain one another as actors, musicians and authors. We
share bedrock commitments to many of the same values. Unlike many other countries,
Canada and the United States appreciate and treasure the amazingly diverse societies
in which we live. We both embrace democracy, good governance and respect for
human rights. This means that, naturally, we want much the same things for our own
societies, and we share a common vision of a world in which we can help to bring those
benefits of open and democratic societies to others.
When we look at our economic relationship, we clearly are each other's most important
trading partners. With over $1.4 billion worth of goods and services traded across the
Canada-U.S. border every day, ours is the largest trading relationship that has ever
existed between two countries. We in Canada are keenly aware of your importance as
a market for us. However, Americans often don't realize that we are your most
important market, or that the United States sells more than $280 billion worth of goods
and services to Canada each year. This means we absorb a quarter of all U.S. exports,
more than any other country. Indeed, the U.S. sells more to Canada than to the entire
European Union.
To put these facts in a local perspective, California is one of 39 American states that
has Canada as its number one export destination. Your state exported $8.1 billion to
Canada in 2002, with high-tech constituting the largest sector of these exports. In turn,
California bought $15.2 billion of goods from Canada in 2002, with over half of that
being auto imports.
Added to this is a great deal of cross-border investment, a fact that is brought home to
me regularly when I travel through the United States, and am told by U.S. business
people about the plants they own around Toronto or elsewhere in the country, or by
Canadians who tell me about their high-tech investments here in the Bay Area.
The complexity of all these economic, political and social elements points to some of
the places we should look when thinking about how to improve the Canada-U.S.
relationship. Prime Minister Martin has made it a top priority to strengthen dialogue and
cooperation across the border in order to expand the breadth and depth of our ties with
the U.S. I'd like to give you an overview of some of the many fronts on which this goal is
now being pursued.
To begin, there's a new relaxed tone in the relationship between the leaders of our two
countries. At their first meeting in Monterrey, the Prime Minister and President Bush
established an excellent rapport, and expressed renewed determination both to deal
with bilateral issues that presently complicate our relationship, such as BSE or softwood
lumber, and to examine how we can better work together on common problems.
That new atmosphere is reflected within Canada by a determination to see our relations
with your country managed through new levels of cooperation and coordination inside
our government. Prime Minister Martin has created a new Cabinet Committee charged
with that mandate, and a newly appointed Parliamentary Secretary for Canada-U.S.
relations will be consulting widely to find ways in which not only the federal but also
provincial and territorial governments can cooperate more closely on Canada-U.S.
issues. This represents a long-overdue recognition of the fact that Canada-U.S.
relations are a huge priority for our country at all levels of government.
The government is also looking at ways to help Canadian parliamentarians develop
closer links with their counterparts in the U.S. Congress, in order to improve our
outreach in both Washington and Congressional districts. The U.S.-Canada
Parliamentary Association is already one of the most successful in the world, and
extending the ties it creates more deeply and broadly among our two countries'
lawmakers is certain to produce a wealth of personal connections and initiatives that
would not otherwise come about.
Through our Enhanced Representation Initiative, Canada's diplomatic and trade
presence will be substantially expanded across the U.S. Starting from the 15 offices we
now have, there will eventually be 22 consulates and consulates general. New offices
will be located mostly in the south and southwestern parts of the country, where much
economic and political power has shifted in recent decades. I'm particularly pleased to
note that next year we'll be upgrading our San Francisco consulate to the level of a
consulate general, in recognition of the enormous importance of this region to Canada.
Our office here will roughly triple in size, and we'll be able to issue visas and passports
here instead of sending people to Los Angeles.
My confidence in predicting that the Bay Area will only continue to grow in importance
to Canada in coming years is based on more than just the thriving sectors of our trade
and investment here. More generally, Canada has undergone an economic renaissance
in the past decade, and that means that our outreach to your country as a whole will
continue to expand. Canada has recorded six consecutive budget surpluses, and the
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development projected us to be the only
G7 country with a surplus for 2003. These ongoing surpluses have enabled us to
reduce our debt by more than $47 billion since we first balanced the budget in 1997-98.
Our debt-to-GDP ratio has seen a greater improvement than any other G7 nation, and
by next year will be second only to that of Britain. With our GDP per capita growing by
20 percent between 1996 and 2002, sound fiscal management has allowed us to
withstand last year's shocks of SARS, the BSE crisis, a massive blackout and a series
of huge forest fires.
Finally, this week we welcomed the results of the 2004 KPMG Competitive Alternatives
international business cost study that, for the fifth year in a row, ranked Canada as the
lowest-cost G7 country in which to do business. So in short, Canada is moving forward
with substantial economic strength these days. We are looking forward to being an
increasingly high-profile economic and investment partner to your country and the Bay
Area in the years to come.
While economic interdependence and shared prosperity are fundamental
characteristics of our relationship, equally important is our dependence on one another
for the security of our continent. A well-known Canadian General, Charles Foulkes, put
it this way: "Canada is physically joined to the United States just like the Siamese twins.
If one of the twins gets hurt the other one suffers. It is just as impossible to separate the
defence of Canada from that of the United States as it would be to separate Siamese
twins and expect them to survive."
Since the terrible events of September 11, our countries' partnership has deepened
through our joint response to the threat of terrorism. Canada is the United States'
greatest natural ally in this fight. On the bilateral front, our security relationship is
expanding into new areas, such as a binational planning group looking at ways of
coordinating our countries' responses not only to terrorist attacks but also to national
disasters and other transborder threats. Through the 32-point Smart Border plan that
we've agreed to, we're finding ways of improving the efficient flow of people and goods
between our two countries, consistent with our new security needs. That, by the way, is
a model that many other countries are beginning to look to.
As I mentioned earlier, Canada and the U.S. have a long tradition of defending our
shared continent against attack through NORAD. We're currently building on this
security partnership through the letters we exchanged last month concerning upcoming
discussions about cooperation on ballistic missile defence. By setting out a clear path
for negotiations, these letters allow Canada to have access to information that we will
need to make a decision on whether we will participate in the missile defence of North
America. This is a project in which we will participate if we can be assured that it will
contribute to our joint security--but only if it is also consistent with Canada's important
goals of advancing global disarmament, and is not a program destined to lead to the
weaponization of space.
I specify these qualifications because I think it is important to recognize that acts that
we take together in North America can have an impact on global issues of concern to
us both. Indeed, one area we need to explore further is the potential that our
partnership in North America provides in pursuing wider global goals outside our
continent.
It is clear that Canada and the United States play very different roles in the global
arena, but we often work together, as few other nations can, toward shared goals that
neither of us can reach alone. Averell Harriman spoke of this idea some decades ago,
when he said, "I place great emphasis on the importance of close cooperation between
Canada and the United States. Our point of view is much the same, unhandicapped by
prejudices and hatreds. Our task of closer cooperation is not as difficult as in other
parts of the world: a leadership in international cooperation should come from us."
That sentiment inspired the Prime Minister and the President at the breakfast in
Monterrey that I spoke of earlier. They both suggested that Secretary Powell and I
explore ways in which we could make common cause together in the international
arena. This we are already doing in the case of Haiti, where we have a complete
identity of views. Mr. Powell and I are committed to looking for other areas where our
efforts can complement one another.
We in Canada recognize the awesome responsibilities of the world's unique
superpower to provide the leadership, resources and force when necessary to bring
about a better global community. Americans, in turn, benefit from the fact that to your
north there is a secure border; a friendly nation from which no threat has come since
1815; an ally who shares your bedrock values and goals, but who often pursues them in
ways that a superpower cannot. And an ally who is able to promote these causes by
speaking with an independent and widely credible voice on the world stage.
As important as our partnership is, then, in advancing our common interests on this
continent, it is equally important for us to advance our goals in the world at large. I
believe that by recognizing what we share and how we can complement one another,
our two countries can collaborate to make a more secure and prosperous global
community.
Overseas, we join with you in trying to build stable societies where terrorists once found
refuge. Over 6,000 Canadian Forces fought alongside Americans in Afghanistan
immediately after September 11. Today there are some 1,900 Canadian military
personnel in Afghanistan leading the International Security Assistance Force under
NATO's mandate to eliminate terrorists and support the new Afghanistan
Administration. Their efforts are reinforced by our aid program that seeks to restore and
improve Afghan society. This year, Afghanistan will be Canada's single largest country
aid recipient, and that is because we are committed, with you and our European allies,
to ensuring that Afghanistan will no longer be a threat to our societies, whether in the
form of terrorism or the scourge of drugs.
For a long time, Canada shared concerns with the United States about the potential
threat of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. We supported the decision to take
matters to the United Nations. Through the debates that followed, we supported U.S.
efforts to obtain strong language in Resolution 1441, but we maintained that UN
engagement was essential, since disarming Iraq by force would require the greatest
possible international legitimacy. When that was not possible, we believed that it was in
Canada's interest, and in the interest of supporting the multilateral system that is so
essential to our peace and security, that we should not join the coalition in the war in
Iraq.
But that was then. Now it is in everyone's interest for Iraq to become a peaceful and
stable democracy. For that reason, Canada has pledged nearly $300 million toward
reconstruction. We have sent police trainers into Jordan to train Iraqi police officers
there, and we will provide further aid in governance, federalism, police and corrections
reform inside Iraq, when local conditions permit.
Canadians recognize, then, that Canadian and American security and prosperity are
bound together, not just here in North America but also overseas. That said, we can
often reinforce one another by taking different approaches toward those shared goals.
And different approaches are inevitable by virtue of our history and our international
perspectives.
Canada's outlook is shaped by our history as country that began as a bilingual nation
that combined French, English and Aboriginal peoples, and then added immigrants
from every part of the globe. Our distinctive social fabric underpins our citizens' support
for domestic policies that sometimes differ from your own, such as extensive gun
controls, a national, universally accessible medicare system, restrictions on campaign
financing, and family benefits, including a government-funded year-long maternity
leave.
Because our countries have divergent social attitudes and some diverging interests,
sometimes we adopt different ways of proceeding in global affairs. Our different
approach reflects the fact that Canadians tend to be highly aware of our
interdependence with the rest of the world and the need to pursue our interests in
concert with other nations. We recognize that the fight against terrorism is critically
important to our joint security. But Canadians also believe that we cannot afford to let
that issue dominate our vision to the exclusion of other global crises, such as poverty,
disease, inequities in the global economy and environmental damage to lands and
livelihoods. These issues must concern us too, not least because promoting our
security here requires having friends and allies abroad who recognize our concerns
about their urgent needs.
Canadians also believe that there is no way of tackling any of these intertwined global
issues except by working together with other countries, since these are problems that
no country, not even a coalition of countries, can solve on its own. Establishing the
conditions for their resolution requires partnerships with other countries that, in turn,
require a respect for their perspectives as well.
This view has guided my country in promoting the establishment of NEPAD, the New
Partnership for Africa's Development, as we seek to work with Africans to alleviate
poverty and conditions of governance in their countries. And I am proud to say that
Canada recently became the first country in the world to introduce legislation that will
permit us to export affordable medicines to impoverished countries to address
epidemics such as HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis and malaria.
We also believe that to resolve these global problems, effective multilateral institutions
must be established to coordinate the efforts of those states that need to address them,
a message that no doubt resonates in the city where the United Nations was founded
60 years ago. Since World War II, Canada has worked with other countries to construct
an international system that brings common benefits by imposing rules and obligations
on all, and that allows us to accomplish by working together what none of us could
achieve by ourselves. We are often able to take a leading role in multilateral forums
because we are not embroiled in regional rivalries, and we do not have the burden of a
colonial past; hence, we are generally respected as a country that strives to advance
the common interest.
Canada's extensive memberships in global networks give us scope for efforts on many
levels. For instance, our history and commitment to the French language make us a
member of La Francophonie, and we promote the values of democracy, human rights
and good governance among the developing countries that share with us the use of the
French language. Amid current global tensions, it is particularly valuable to have this
forum for dialogue with moderate Muslim countries such as Morocco, Tunisia, Senegal
and Albania.
But while we are committed to multilateralism, we in Canada also know full well that
existing multilateral institutions are not all that they should be, and that reform is
urgently needed. It is crucial to improve the United Nations, particularly the composition
and functioning of the Security Council, however complicated obstacles to this reform
may be. We will follow with interest the work of the committee established to advise the
Secretary-General in this respect.
Over the next year, Canada's capacity to act in pursuit of our international goals will be
defined and strengthened by an international policy review that the Prime Minister has
asked me to lead. It's been 10 years since our last major review, and in that decade
much has changed in terms of the global environment and the complexity of our
country's interactions with the United States and with other countries. Global
interdependence has brought a host of problems that transcend national boundaries;
and within national boundaries, it also means that almost all branches of a federal
government now have a substantial international component to their portfolios.
For all of these reasons, Prime Minister Martin has asked us to undertake a
comprehensive review and modernization of the way we act in the world outside our
borders. The larger goal of the review is to find ways in which our country's international
leadership and initiative can be developed to make us a catalyst in efforts to strengthen
global governance, and advance equitable growth, social development and international
security.
Complementing this effort, the Prime Minister has also defined as a priority of the
review ways of reinforcing Canadian interests in building a strong Canada-U.S.
partnership in North America and globally. Many of the initiatives I've already mentioned
are part of this latter effort to strengthen our partnership with the U.S. So too will be
plans for strengthening multilateral institutions and developing new ones better suited to
solving today's global problems. So too will be our efforts to reset the rules of the global
economic game in a way that is more inclusive, and better reflects the realities of global
interdependence. And so too will be the plans we develop to build a targeted Canadian
capacity for counterterrorism and for assisting failed and failing states. In all of these
ways, a Canada that is stronger in our capacities and more focused in our international
goals is one that will be a more valuable ally and partner of the United States.
Canada's distinctive experience and independent perspective complement the U.S. as
you exercise your enormous responsibilities in the world. And where our governments
and citizens disagree about how to pursue our shared aims, our relationship is strong
enough to withstand frank discussion of these differences. That point was captured
perfectly, I think, by U.S. General Norstad in 1959, when he said, "If stones are
sometimes thrown across this friendly border, and they are, perhaps it is a good thing. It
keeps us aware of one another, compels us from time to time to reassess the
importance of our relationship, to appreciate how much we mean to one another." In
that spirit, I believe that we in Canada are a better ally, a truer friend, when we hold fast
to our convictions and advocate them with your country rather than starting from a
premise that there is no room for divergent views between us.
Honouring our countries' common values in building security and prosperity at home
and abroad is something we can and will do while advancing within each of our
countries those social, cultural and economic goals that give us our unique identities. I
can assure you that Canada will continue working with your country in the months and
years ahead, so we can build safer and stronger societies here in North America, and,
to our mutual benefit, in the greater world beyond.
Thank you.