Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

HEATHER MALLICK

Memoirs of Beijing

Admiration for Jan Wong's recollection of Maoist China

Nov. 12, 2007

Guilt and redemption are among the great themes of literature. Joseph Conrad's Lord Jim wanted a second chance at heroism, Raskolnikov would make himself pay for what he did with the hatchet and the old woman's skull, and there's a lot of hand-washing in Macbeth. But the theme has largely vanished in the current, wonderful craze for memoirs, which are almost always about the great wrongs done to the tender author. Only Jan Wong would have the ice-splitting courage to turn the memoir on its head. She did an awful thing 35 years ago, the kind of thoughtless idiotic cruelty that is the specialty of the young. Her new book, Beijing Confidential: A Tale of Comrades Lost and Found, is her quest for forgiveness.

Mea culpa

In 1972 Wong, a third-generation Chinese-Canadian McGill student, was a burning righteous Maoist with that desire to make the world a better place that is so attractive in a teenager and so sadly absent in the middle-aged and mortgaged.

She flew to China to help Mao in his quest to make a better humanity. She didn't know, as few of us did until recently, that he was a monster whose only ideology was preserving his own power and as well one of the most lavish murderers in human history, rivalling even Stalin. She was a true believer.

Wong landed in the Cultural Revolution (1965-1976), when all things peasant-like were worshipped and anything resembling intellect was despised and punished. In those years, three million people were murdered and 100 million were made to suffer a particular kind of hell in a larger Chinese ocean-sized hell.

Wong did her bit. When she was approached on campus by Yin Luoyi, an unfamiliar young woman who asked her about the West and how to get there, she snitched on the girl. The authorities took over and the girl disappeared, not only from the campus but from Wong's mind. It wasn't until she read her own student diaries in 1994 that she remembered her denunciation. When she bravely told the story in her 1997 memoir Red China Blues, a huge best-seller, it became something of a scarlet letter, especially to people who didn't like her, and an investigative journalist like Wong had plenty of enemies.

A person denounced in China could easily have been executed by the Red Guard. As far as Wong knew, Yin might have been. It haunted her. So in 2003, she flew back to China to search for the woman whose life she had ruined, if not ended. She would face the consequences.

Needle in haystack

It would be wrong to give away too much. But Wong is an unstoppable reporter in a post-post-Watergate era where corporate interests rule and speaking truth to power gets an individual journalist a kick in the teeth, a firing if he's lucky and spending the rest of his career covering the Etobicoke Ratepayers Association if he's not. This is the book she was born to write.

In a nation of 1.3 billion people with 400 million cellphones, all unlisted, and where 40 per cent of the population share 10 surnames, Wong found her woman, whose surname she did not even know, in Beijing, a city that had essentially been razed since Wong's first visit.

They met, in an extraordinary scene that brings home the hugeness of Beijing and how easily a person can be lost — as DeQuincey lost his Ann in foggy London, one of the saddest stories ever told — if a cellphone acts up or Wong goes to the "Big" West Gate when Yin is waiting at the "Small" West Gate, which is what happened.

As it turned out, Wong's denunciation was only one of about 30, all made, unlike Wong's, with the knowledge of what would happen to Yin. She was interrogated all night by the group. She attempted suicide, but failed, and was expelled at dawn, driven away from the university in a black-barred prisoners van and sent to Manchuria. Yin's life improved, obviously, but that is another part of the story.

National characters

Wong's clear prose flows like water bearing what I call "nuggets," little pieces of information and insight that catch in the reader's brain filter.

With Beijing Confidential, Wong is writing a thriller about pursuit, explaining the three tides of history — the Mongols of Kublai Khan, the Ming Dynasty and the 2008 Olympics — that flattened and rebuilt Beijing. She is drawing the astounding arcs of Yin Luoyi's life after exile from Beijing, and interweaving the narrative with the hard-won analysis of other writers.

This last, I admire most. Wong compares the Chinese love of hierarchy with Adam Gopnik's assessment of the "encyclopedic" French insistence on tiny totalitarianism. On the Cultural Revolution's taste for the group encircling and tormenting the individual Kristallnacht-style, she quotes Czeslaw Milosz on the "beguiling allure" of iron rule and how collectivism changes the physical look of a city street. She notes the government's parallels to Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four and Beijing migrant laborers' recreation of his Down and Out in Paris and London. She refers to Stasiland, by Anna Funder, and how collective amnesia has overtaken both China and the former East Germany.

Most importantly, she notes that in none of the cases have the tormentors come forward to apologize to their victims. All those Nazis, and what did the Germans say? I was just following orders. Wong meets her victim and apologizes humbly and repeatedly, while the other senior Communists just smile uneasily, unable to look Yin in the eye, continuing the lie.

This is a new kind of writing, a work of courage and humility. The small, compact book is like a pastille, a pharmaceutical. Read it and confront your own nature: Did you ever do something in your life that haunts you, perhaps merits an apology? We all have, not just Brian Mulroney.

The book is a classic, very much in the tradition of The Railway Man, Eric Lomax's confrontation with the Japanese soldier who waterboarded him in the Second World War, another small book of immense pain.

It's a ridiculous thing to say, as nationality is irrelevant to the matter of great writing, but I'm proud that Jan Wong is a Canadian. She does credit to this country.

This Week

So many people I respect are mad for the novelist Graham Greene, as much for his personality as his books. All my life I have yearned to admire him, but haven't managed it.

Michael Shelden wrote an almost psychotically unfair biography that won Greene my sympathy. Then I read two volumes of Norman Sherry's massive biography but after finding what I thought was the final volume only took us up to 1955, I gave up. Now University of Toronto professor Richard Greene (no relation) has published a collection of Greene's letters that has won me over.

Greene was a passionate man, generous to other writers and absolutely steadfast in his defence of individuals and nations under attack. I always felt his Catholicism was a prop for his energetic sexuality — guilt made the sex better — and that's reason enough. But he genuinely liked women and treated them well. When he sent a cheque to impoverished writers, he'd send a few bottles of wine with it. What warmth, what style.

And his perceptions were dead on. Nobody else has suggested that the Blitz made London look like Mexico. It was all those ruined churches, you see. And seeing the photographs, I see that he was right, as he was about so many things.

Go to the Top

ABOUT THIS AUTHOR

Biography

Heather Mallick

Heather Mallick has a nice old-fashioned M.A. in English literature from the University of Toronto. She has worked as a reporter, copy editor and book review editor at various Toronto newspapers and most recently wrote a column called As If for the Globe and Mail. She has won National Newspaper Awards for critical writing and feature writing. Her first book, Pearls in Vinegar, based on an ancient Japanese form of diary, appeared in 2004. Her second, an essay collection called Cake or Death: The Excruciating Choices of Everyday Life, was published by Knopf in April 2007.

More From This Author

More From
HEATHER MALLICK »
Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

Passengers rescued from Canadian-owned ship in Antarctic
All passengers and crew members aboard a Canadian-owned cruise ship were rescued Friday after the vessel struck ice in Antarctic waters near Argentina.
November 23, 2007 | 11:37 AM EST
Lebanon declares state of emergency as political crisis looms
Lebanese President Emile Lahoud declared a state of emergency and gave control of the country to the army on Friday night, less than four hours before his term was set to expire.
November 23, 2007 | 3:54 PM EST
Howard seeks 5th term in Saturday's Australian elections
Polls suggest Australian Prime Minister John Howard's re-election is in doubt, despite a sound economy and near record-low unemployment rates under his leadership.
November 23, 2007 | 3:46 PM EST
more »

Canada »

Flaherty mulls budget help for manufacturers
Finance Minister Jim Flaherty said Friday he may be preparing some relief for the country's hard-hit manufacturing sector in the next federal budget.
November 23, 2007 | 4:31 PM EST
Man jolted with Taser needed help, widow says
The Nova Scotia man who died the day after he was shocked with a Taser should have been medicated for his mental illness, his wife says.
November 23, 2007 | 9:34 AM EST
$620M for Quebec manufacturers hit by loonie rise
Quebec's Liberal government has announced a $620 million aid package for the province's bruised manufacturing sector.
November 23, 2007 | 3:45 PM EST
more »

Health »

Growing up poor means more illness, shorter lifespan: Quebec report
Children raised in poverty are more likely to get sick, and in adulthood die at a younger age, than those raised in more affluent surroundings, suggests a report released Thursday.
November 23, 2007 | 1:22 PM EST
Mental health association wants training for emergency responders
The Canadian Mental Health Association is trying to start a training program for emergency responders in New Brunswick so they can better respond to calls involving mentally ill people.
November 23, 2007 | 2:50 PM EST
Doctors, not judges, should control patient care: appeal
In a case that could set a precedent for end-of-life decisions, the Calgary Health Region is fighting a court order that went against doctors' diagnosis that a comatose patient could not be saved.
November 23, 2007 | 1:49 PM EST
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

J.K. Rowling named year's top entertainer by U.S. magazine
J.K. Rowling's magical Midas touch has landed her on the cover of Entertainment Weekly as the magazine's entertainer of the year.
November 23, 2007 | 4:34 PM EST
Pullman books under review by 2 more Catholic boards
Two other Toronto-area Catholic boards of education are studying copies of Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy after the Halton District Catholic School Board removed the children's books from its library shelves.
November 23, 2007 | 12:52 PM EST
Broadcasting watchdog keeps ears perked for changes in CBC Radio
CBC Radio is "a national treasure" and audiences across the country will be listening carefully for any changes following the announcement of CBC's integration plans, a Canadian broadcasting watchdog said on Friday.
November 23, 2007 | 4:30 PM EST
more »

Technology & Science »

San Fran oil spill hurts Canadian sea duck population
An oil spill in San Francisco Bay two weeks ago killed and oiled thousands of birds, with a Canadian sea duck among the largest casualties.
November 23, 2007 | 11:25 AM EST
2006 a record year for greenhouse gases: UN
Levels of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere hit new heights in 2006, the United Nation's weather agency said in a report released Friday.
November 23, 2007 | 1:27 PM EST
Online Chinese youth caught in web, survey suggests
Chinese youth on the internet are more likely to use it to expand their social circles and increase self-expression ? and to feel addicted to it ? than American young people, a study released Friday suggests.
November 23, 2007 | 4:43 PM EST
more »

Money »

U.S. cash registers ring on 'Black Friday'
U.S. stores ushered in the start of the holiday shopping season Friday with midnight openings and a blitz of door busters.
November 23, 2007 | 11:14 AM EST
Federal surplus keeps on growing
The federal budget surplus rose by $700 million in September as the treasury continued to bring in more money than it paid out.
November 23, 2007 | 2:35 PM EST
ATB Financial takes $79.6M in credit crunch charges
ATB Financial ? an Alberta Crown corporation ? revealed Friday that its second-quarter profits plunged by 91 per cent because of a $79.6 million charge for writedowns related to the credit crunch.
November 23, 2007 | 3:51 PM EST
more »

Consumer Life »

Men motivated by earning more than colleagues, study finds
The size of their paycheques isn't the sole motivation for men who also consider besting their colleagues as a key measure of the reward, according to a new study published in the journal Science.
November 23, 2007 | 4:48 PM EST
Resist temptation to spend on 'Buy Nothing Day,' May says
Friday is an important day for many North American environment groups as they are marking 'Buy Nothing Day,' to signify the need to cut back on excess consumption.
November 23, 2007 | 11:01 AM EST
Couple ties knot at Tim's
When Adam Paoletic popped the question he picked his bride-to-be's favourite spot ? a Tim Hortons coffee shop. They ended up marrying there as well, feasting on doughnuts and cradling mugs of coffee.
November 23, 2007 | 1:58 PM EST
more »

Sports »

Scores: CFL MLB MLS

Canadiens seek revenge in Buffalo
The Montreal Canadiens will try to avenge their loss exactly one week ago when they return to Buffalo to begin a home-and-home with the resurgent Sabres on Friday (7:30 p.m. ET).
November 23, 2007 | 11:34 AM EST
Former Jays pitcher Kennedy dies
Major-league pitcher Joe Kennedy, who finished last season with the Toronto Blue Jays, died early Friday morning. He was 28.
November 23, 2007 | 3:03 PM EST
Hudec tops in downhill training
Calgary's Jan Hudec skied the fastest time and led three Canadians in the top 15 Friday in the final training run for this weekend's opening World Cup downhill race in Lake Louise, Alta.
November 23, 2007 | 4:21 PM EST
more »