| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Vol. 140, No. 51 December 23, 2006 Remote Sensing Space Systems RegulationsStatutory authority Remote Sensing Space Systems Act Sponsoring department Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade REGULATORY IMPACT ANALYSIS STATEMENT (This statement is not part of the Regulations.) Description The proposed Regulations are an integral part of the legislative framework established by the Remote Sensing Space Systems Act (the Act) for the licensing and control of Canadian remote sensing satellites and their associated data distribution systems. In December 1998, the Canadian Space Agency and MacDonald, Dettwiler and Associates Ltd. agreed to a jointly funded, but commercially operated, RADARSAT-2 remote sensing satellite as a successor to the Agency's RADARSAT synthetic aperture radar satellite. Shortly afterwards, the Government of Canada announced that it would regulate all such commercial remote sensing satellite systems operated from Canada, in order to address Canadian security, defence and foreign policy issues that were bound to arise with increasingly higher performance satellites. The June 1999 announcement included a 20-point Canadian Access Control Policy that, among other things, reserved the Government's right to review and approve satellite systems, invoke shutter control over any satellite, and obtain priority access to satellite data. A year later, on June 16, 2000, the Agreement Between the Government of Canada and the Government of the United States of America Concerning the Operation of Commercial Remote Sensing Satellite Systems (the Treaty) was signed to facilitate the RADARSAT-2 project. The Treaty called on Canada to enact the Access Control Policy into law, and at the same time ensure that Canadian commercial satellites would be controlled in a "comparable manner" to United States systems. Bill C-25, the Remote Sensing Space Systems Act, which was enacted in November 2005, and the proposed Regulations will complete Canada's commitment under the Treaty and provide a licensing and control scheme for future Canadian remote sensing satellite systems. Alternatives The Act requires remote sensing satellite operators to obtain a licence in the form and manner prescribed by the Regulations. As a result, there is no alternative to the proposed Regulations, at least to the extent that they set out the procedure for the issuance, amendment and renewal of licences. While many provisions in the proposed Regulations, such as the listing of information required to support a licence application, mandatory licence conditions, and minimum time periods before data may be disposed of, could be dealt with by the Minister of Foreign Affairs on an ad hoc basis, it would not meet the Treaty obligation to enact them into law and would not provide potential satellite operators with fair notice of the rules at play. The Act sets out a few activities which constitute offences, but for the most part leaves it to the Regulations to describe less serious violations. The Regulations are essential in this respect to implement the preferred method of correcting and adjusting the conduct of satellite operators. Benefits and costs The benefits that derive from the remote sensing space system legislation are enormous. The Regulations permit Canadian commercial satellite operators to enter a growing international business where Canada has a leading role. The Regulations enable the Government of Canada to limit potential liability under international law for the acts of Canadian satellite operators, and to exercise control over remote sensing space systems in matters of national security, the defence of Canada, and international obligations. The Regulations are not expensive to implement and, for the most part, entail government officials monitoring the operations of satellite systems and the distribution of data and data products from these systems. It is estimated that three employees within the Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, two employees within the Department of National Defence, and two employees within the Canadian Space Agency will be assigned roles in the administration of the Act and Regulations, using existing resources. Consultation The consultation process for the development of the Regulations began with the drafting of the Act, which relies on regulations as an integral part of the legislative framework. (The Act refers to two dozen distinct instances where Regulations are authorized.) Sample draft regulations were presented publicly to the House of Commons Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade and to the Senate Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs during their review of Bill C-25, in order to give parliamentarians a sense of both their nature and level of detail. Iterations of drafting instructions for Regulations were reviewed by officials of MacDonald, Dettwiler and Associates Ltd. (who will be the first licensee under the Act with RADARSAT-2), the Canadian Space Agency, the Department of National Defence, and the Department of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness. While government officials tended to be satisfied with the draft regulations, private sector commentators offered extensive suggestions for simplification and reduction of information requirements, resulting in the proposed Regulations. Strategic environmental assessment A preliminary environmental assessment of the legislative proposal (i.e. the Act, which authorizes the Regulations) indicated no likelihood of significant environmental impacts and no likelihood of strong public concerns. Under the Act, the satellite operator is required to put in place a system disposal plan to look after environmental damage (among other things) that could result from launch failure or end-of-life disposal of the satellite. The satellite launch provider must comply with environmental protection requirements under the laws of the launch site. A remote sensing satellite system operating in accordance with the Act and Regulations will have a significant, albeit indirect, positive effect on the environment by providing imagery and data useful for natural resources management, land use, and environmental monitoring. Compliance and enforcement The Regulations list violations which are dealt with through administrative monetary penalties or compliance agreements. Compliance agreements are the preferred means of dealing with violations, as they focus on immediate corrective action rather than on blame and punishment. Enforcement officers (who may also be inspectors) appointed by the Minister of Foreign Affairs are responsible for serving notices of violations listed in the Regulations. An enforcement officer's decision may be appealed to the Minister of Foreign Affairs. Bruce Mann, Senior Counsel, Justice Legal Services Division, Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, Lester B. Pearson Building, 125 Sussex Drive, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0G2, 613-992-8608 (telephone), 613-992-6485 (fax), bruce.mann@international.gc.ca (email). Notice is hereby given that the Governor in Council, pursuant to section 20 of the Remote Sensing Space Systems Act (see footnote a), proposes to make the annexed Remote Sensing Space Systems Regulations. Interested persons may make representations with respect to the proposed Regulations within 30 days after the date of publication of this notice. All such representations must cite the Canada Gazette, Part I, and the date of publication of this notice, and be addressed to Bruce Mann, Senior Counsel, Justice Legal Services, Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, Lester B. Pearson Building, 125 Sussex Drive, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0G2 (fax: 613-992-6485; e-mail: bruce.mann@international.gc.ca). Ottawa, December 14, 2006
MARY O'NEILL
SCHEDULE 1 INFORMATION AND DOCUMENTS TO SUPPORT AN APPLICATION BUSINESS INFORMATION AND DOCUMENTS 1. The applicant's name, identifying information and contact information. 2. The name, identifying information and contact information of the individual proposed to be the contact person for the applicant. 3. The following completed forms for the individual proposed to be the applicant's contact person: (a) Personnel Screening, Consent and Authorization Form (TBS/SCT 330-23) of the Treasury Board Secretariat, as amended from time to time; (b) Security Screening Certificate and Briefing Form (TBS/SCT 330-47) of the Treasury Board Secretariat, as amended from time to time; (c) Security Clearance Form (TBS/SCT 330-60) of the Treasury Board Secretariat, as amended from time to time; and (d) Royal Canadian Mounted Police fingerprint form C216-C, as amended from time to time. 4. If the applicant is an entity, other than a government or government agency, (a) a certified copy of its instrument of incorporation or continuance or its business registration in its jurisdiction of operation, as the case may be; (b) the name, identifying information and contact information of the chief executive officer and each of the applicant's directors, if any; (c) the name, identifying information and contact information of each of the applicant's officers who will be responsible for the operation of the remote sensing space system; (d) the name, identifying information and contact information of each owner of an interest equal to or greater than 10% in the applicant, and the interest held by that owner; and (e) the name, identifying information and contact information of each person who exercises control over the applicant. 5. The name, identifying information and contact information of each of the applicant's secured creditors. 6. The name, identifying information, contact information and amount of indebtedness for every person to whom the applicant is indebted for more than 5% of the applicant's total indebtedness. 7. The applicant's plans for communicating raw data or providing remote sensing products, including (a) making the data or products available to governments whose territories have been sensed by the remote sensing space system; and (b) providing preferred or exclusive access to the data or products. 8. The address where the applicant's records will be maintained. GENERAL SYSTEM INFORMATION 9. The name and a short description of the remote sensing space system, including the number of remote sensing satellites in the system, the planned date that each satellite will become operational and the anticipated mission life of each satellite. 10. The proposed launch date, vehicle and site. ORBIT INFORMATION 11. The nominal orbit and tolerances of each remote sensing satellite in the remote sensing space system, including (a) the semi-major axis, eccentricity, inclination, longitude of right ascension, argument of periapsis, argument of mean anomaly and epoch; (b) the period, repeat cycle and any subcycle; and (c) the equator crossing time of the ascending node of any sun-synchronous orbit. REMOTE SENSING SATELLITE DISPOSAL 12. The potential hazard from space debris and the strategy to mitigate that hazard for each remote sensing satellite of the remote sensing space system, including (a) the method of disposal that is proposed for each satellite and the reliability of that method; (b) the estimated duration of the satellite disposal operation; (c) the probability of loss of human life and how it was calculated; (d) the amount of debris expected to reach the surface of the Earth, the size of the impact area expressed in square metres, and how they were calculated; (e) the geographic boundaries of the likely debris re-entry impact area, the confidence level of the determination of the boundaries and how the boundaries and confidence level were calculated; (f) the identity and quantity of hazardous material and dangerous goods contained in each satellite at the end of its mission life, the quantity expected to reach the surface of the Earth on re-entry and how the quantities were calculated; (g) the orbital elements and epochs of the proposed disposal orbits; and (h) an assessment of space debris expected to be released from each satellite during normal operations by explosions, by intentional break-ups and by on-orbit collisions, and the measures proposed to mitigate the production of space debris. REMOTE SENSING SATELLITE INFORMATION AND DOCUMENTS 13. A technical description of each remote sensing satellite in the remote sensing space system, including (a) a drawing of the satellite in its on-orbit configuration; (b) its command and data handling subsystem capabilities, including its data storage technology and capacity, data transfer rate, method of access to stored data and directionality of its command, telemetry and downlink antennas; (c) its navigation, guidance and control capabilities, including the accuracy of position, velocity, acceleration and time, and the type of technology used for those capabilities; (d) its attitude control subsystem capabilities, including the jerk and jitter, and the type of technology used for those capabilities; (e) its propulsion subsystem capabilities, including the amount of propellant allocated for the disposal of the satellite; (f) its sensor technology for each sensor, including (i) the sensor modes, (ii) the spatial resolution capability of each sensor mode, and how it was calculated, (iii) the centre frequency or wavelength, bandwidth and sweep, if any, of the transmitted and received spectral bands used in each sensor mode indicating which sensor modes are co-registered by common sensor elements and which sensor modes are independent, (iv) the polarization of transmitted and received signals with respect to each sensor mode, (v) the fields of view or beam widths for each sensor mode, (vi) for each sensor mode, the range of viewing angles or angles of incidence, and their increments of change, (vii) for each sensor mode, the slew and squint angles and their rates of change, and a description of the scan mechanisms employed, (viii) the ground distance from nadir and the instantaneous swath width and potential swath width for each sensor mode, (ix) the image motion compensation parameters, including those for linear motion and drift, (x) if applicable, the characteristics of the time-delayed integration mode used within the sensor focal plane, (xi) spatial, spectral and temporal oversampling, aggregation and resampling capabilities, (xii) sensitivity, including noise-equivalent-spectral-radiance for electro-optic sensors, noise-equivalent-sigmas for synthetic aperture radar sensors and noise-equivalent-temperature-differences for thermal infrared sensors, (xiii) for each sensor mode, the signal-to-noise ratio, dynamic range and quantization, (xiv) if applicable, the range of solar illumination angles on the surface of the Earth over which the sensor can operate, (xv) the absolute and relative geolocation accuracy of the raw data and remote sensing products and how they were calculated, and (xvi) calibration methods, including absolute calibration accuracy; and (g) the time in hours between the acquisition of raw data by the satellite and the communication of the data or the provision of remote sensing products to a recipient. COMMAND PROTECTION PLAN 14. The general strategy with respect to command protection. 15. The location and function of all facilities, including mobile facilities, to be used to process sales orders or to give commands in the operation of the remote sensing space system. 16. A general description and block diagram of all facilities to be used to process sales orders or to give commands, including the longitude and latitude and station mask of each telemetry, tracking and command station. 17. (1) A general description and block diagram of the communication architecture that includes descriptions of (a) each system supporting the facilities that are to be used to process sales orders or to give commands to the remote sensing satellite; (b) links between the facilities and the satellite; (c) links for relaying sales orders or satellite commands between facilities on the ground; and (d) crosslinks between satellites. (2) The radio-frequency link information for command uplinks, including the characterization of each link and the type of information carried by each communication channel. (3) The protocols to be used in the communication architecture. (4) A description of the encryption to be used on all communication channels, including keying and rekeying schemes. (5) Management plans for the keys to be used in satellite uplinks, in command relays and in facilities for command generation and the processing of sales orders. 18. A general description of (a) the content and format of the proposed sales orders and the commands to be given in the operation of the remote sensing space system; and (b) the process used to determine the commands given to the remote sensing satellite that sets out the priority of conflicting sales orders requiring the same resources of the satellite. 19. A diagram that (a) shows each step to be taken by the applicant or proposed system participant from the placement of a sales order for raw data or a remote sensing product to the communication of the raw data to a recipient or the provision of the remote sensing product to a recipient; and (b) indicates the command protection measures proposed for each step. 20. A description of the command protection measures proposed for each step of the business process, including (a) the measures proposed for each facility to be used to process sales orders or to give commands to the remote sensing satellite, including measures relating to (i) the security screening of personnel, (ii) the physical security of the facility, and (iii) the information assurance, within the facility, of sales orders and satellite commands; (b) the measures proposed for the communication of sales orders and satellite commands between the facilities of the remote sensing space system, including measures relating to physical and electronic protection and information assurance; and (c) the measures proposed for the communication of commands to remote sensing satellites, including measures relating to electronic protection and information assurance. 21. Proposed measures to comply with (a) the conditions in paragraphs 8(4)(a) to (f) of the Act; (b) an order that may be made under section 14 or 15 of the Act; and (c) section 16 of the Act. DATA PROTECTION PLAN 22. The general strategy with respect to data protection. 23. The location and function of all facilities, including mobile facilities, to be used to handle raw data and remote sensing products in the operation of the remote sensing space system. 24. A general description and block diagram of all facilities to be used to handle raw data and remote sensing products, including the longitude and latitude and station mask of each ground station. 25. (1) A general description and block diagram of the proposed communication architecture that includes descriptions of (a) each system supporting the facilities that are to be used to handle raw data and remote sensing products; (b) links between the facilities and the remote sensing satellite; (c) links for the relaying of raw data and remote sensing products between facilities on the ground; and (d) crosslinks between remote sensing satellites. (2) The radio-frequency downlink information, including the characterization of each link and the type of information carried by each communication channel. (3) The protocols to be used in the communication architecture. (4) A description of the encryption to be used on all communication channels including keying and rekeying schemes. (5) Management plans for the keys to be used in satellite downlinks and relays and in facilities used to handle raw data and remote sensing products. 26. A general description of (a) the content and format of raw data and remote sensing products; and (b) the processes to be employed to alter image quality and information content at each step from the acquisition of raw data to the provision of a remote sensing product, including such processes as spatial or spectral pixel aggregation discarding low order analog-to-digital bits and data compression. 27. A diagram that (a) shows each step to be taken by the applicant or proposed system participant from the placement of a sales order for raw data or a remote sensing product to the communication of raw data to a recipient or the provision of the remote sensing product to a recipient; and (b) indicates the data protection measures proposed for each step. 28. A description of the data protection measures proposed for each step of the business process, including (a) the measures proposed for each facility to be used to handle raw data and remote sensing products, including measures relating to (i) the security screening of personnel, (ii) the physical security of the facility, and (iii) the information assurance, within the facility, in respect of raw data and remote sensing products; (b) the measures proposed for the transfer of raw data and remote sensing products between the facilities of the remote sensing space system, including measures relating to physical and electronic protection and information assurance; and (c) the measures proposed for the communication of raw data and the provision of remote sensing products to recipients, including measures relating to physical and electronic protection and information assurance. 29. Proposed measures to comply with any conditions of the licence that restrict the communication of raw data or the provision of remote sensing products related to (a) recipients or classes of recipients of raw data or remote sensing products; (b) sensor modes; (c) types of raw data or remote sensing products; (d) the time between the acquisition of raw data by the remote sensing satellite and the communication of the raw data or the provision of a remote sensing product to a recipient; (e) the sensed territory; (f) the location of the recipients; and (g) any agreements entered into under paragraph 8(6)(b) or (7)(b) of the Act. COMMAND AND DATA PROTECTION PLAN 30. In lieu of a separate command protection plan and data protection plan, a combined command and data protection plan that contains the information and documents set out in sections 14 to 29 of this Schedule. AFFILIATED ENTITIES 31. The name, identifying information and contact information of each entity affiliated with the applicant that will be involved in the operation of the licensed system, a description of their involvement and the name, identifying information and contact information of each person who exercises control over the affiliated entity. SYSTEM PARTICIPANT INFORMATION 32. If the application includes a request to designate a person to be a system participant, (a) the proposed system participant's name, identifying information and contact information; (b) the address of each facility to be used by the proposed system participant for carrying on controlled activities, including the location and station mask of each ground station and telemetry, tracking and command station facilities; and (c) a copy of an agreement or proposed agreement between the applicant and the proposed system participant that specifies (i) the territory from which the proposed system participant will communicate raw data and provide remote sensing products or will give commands to the remote sensing satellite, (ii) the proposed system participant's data protection plan that contains the information and documents referred to in sections 22 to 29 of this Schedule as modified to relate to the participant's operations, and, if the applicant intends to permit the proposed system participant to formulate or give a command to a remote sensing satellite of the system, its command protection plan that contains the information and documents referred to in sections 14 to 21 of this Schedule as modified to relate to the participant's operations, (iii) how the proposed system participant will make raw data and remote sensing products available to the governments of countries whose territories have been sensed by the system, (iv) how the proposed system participant will make raw data available to the applicant before the data is disposed of, (v) how the proposed system participant will assist the applicant to provide service pursuant to an order under section 15 of the Act, (vi) the proposed system participant's obligation to maintain records, the address where the records will be maintained and the proposed system participant's obligation to allow the applicant access to them, (vii) the proposed system participant's obligation to make periodic or other reports to the applicant, (viii) the proposed system participant's obligation to allow the applicant or an inspector access to their facilities in order to monitor compliance with the proposed system participant's data protection plan and the proposed system participant's command protection plan, if any, and (ix) the obligation of the proposed system participant to allow the applicant or an inspector access to their facilities in order to monitor compliance on the part of the applicant with the applicant's data and command protection plans and the applicant's requirements under the Act, these regulations and the conditions of the licence.
SCHEDULE 2 PART 1 REMOTE SENSING SPACE SYSTEMS ACT
PART 2 REMOTE SENSING SPACE SYSTEMS REGULATIONS
PART 3 CONDITIONS OF LICENCES DIVISION 1 CONDITIONS IMPOSED BY THE REMOTE SENSING SPACE SYSTEMS ACT
DIVISION 2 CONDITIONS IMPOSED BY THE REMOTE SENSING SPACE SYSTEMS REGULATIONS
[51-1-o] S.C. 2005, c. 45 |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
NOTICE:
|