Story Tools: E-MAIL | PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

Boy's death after recess fight shocks school community

Last Updated: Tuesday, November 13, 2007 | 11:59 AM ET

Grief counsellors are spending the day at a primary school in Saint-Eustache, Que., where a 12-year old boy died after a recess squabble with another student.

Yannick Charpentier died in hospital Monday afternoon after an 11-year-old girl punched him in the chest during an argument outside the Horizon-Soleil elementary school. 

Frédéric Forgues greets his sons, Olivier, left, Nathan, centre, and Simon, all students at a Quebec school where a 12-year-old boy died after a recess fight on Monday.Frédéric Forgues greets his sons, Olivier, left, Nathan, centre, and Simon, all students at a Quebec school where a 12-year-old boy died after a recess fight on Monday.
(Ryan Remiorz/Canadian Press)

The Grade 6 student had a pre-existing heart condition but doctors said it's impossible to say why he died until an autopsy is completed.

Students at the school weren't told of the boy's death until the end of the school day, and some parents were angry they weren't told sooner about the tragedy.

Karine Champagne, a journalist for French-language television network LCN, said parents never received a proper explanation of what happened in the schoolyard, despite receiving a note administrators sent home with students.

"We have that note, but it doesn't say in any way there had been a fight," said Champagne, whose three sons attend the school. "It's just written that something bad happened at the school, and kids could be shaken, and tonight we should talk to them about violence."

In the letter, school principal Christiane Rainville said the community is rallying around the boy's family. "The school is deeply distressed by this dramatic situation," she said.

"In the coming days, some children could react in ways normal in such a situation, such as having fear, denial, anger, sadness or difficulty sleeping."

The school board has assigned a team of grief counsellors and a nurse, who will stay at the school and be available to talk to students as long as needed, Rainville indicated in the letter.

Many parents said they were at a loss about how to talk to their children about the tragedy.

Charpentier's death will likely traumatize children at the school, and while it's important for parents to talk to their children about violence, it's also crucial for them to continue with their daily lives.

"Kids need routine, and the best thing you can do is get them back into a routine," said Montreal bereavement counsellor Corrie Sirota-Frankel. "Because this is not a normal situation."

Provincial police said the girl will not be charged because there is no way she could have known the fight would end with Charpentier's death.

But she's been taken into custody by youth protection officials until the investigation progresses.

The school board and police insist it was an isolated incident, at a school with no prior record of violence between students.

With files from the Canadian Press

Related

Audio

The CBC's Fiona Downey speaks to a parent and a grief counsellor about Yannick Charpentier's death (Runs: 7:49)
Play: Real Media »

Video

Amanda Pfeffer reports on Yannick Charpentier's death (Runs: 2:43)
Play: QuickTime »
Play: Real Media »

MORE MONTREAL HEADLINES »

Blizzard shuts down Quebec schools Video
Dozens of schools were closed and hundreds of airline passengers were stranded after a massive winter storm dumped near-record amounts of snow on the province.
WestJet suspends policy allowing minors to fly alone
WestJet airlines has suspended a program that allows minors to fly alone after a five-year-old girl travelling last week was able to leave her flight with a stranger.
3 inmates escape from Montreal prison
Three prisoners, considered dangerous by the police, remain at large Monday after escaping the previous night from Bordeaux Prison in Montreal.
Man who assaulted children in washrooms declared dangerous offender
A Montreal man who sexually assaulted little girls in public washrooms has been declared a dangerous offender by an Ottawa court.
Reports say Homolka has left Canada
Reports say Karla Homoka, the former wife of convicted sex-killer Paul Bernardo, along with her one-year-old son and Caribbean-born husband, have left Canada.
Story Tools: E-MAIL | PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

Afghan raid on insurgents a 'great success': commander Video
A raid on Taliban insurgents early Monday in two volatile districts in Afghanistan is being hailed as a success by the Canadian military, but a commander warns that such gains hinge on Afghan involvement.
Won't cling to power forever: Castro
Ailing Cuban leader Fidel Castro said in a letter read on state television Monday that he does not intend to cling to power forever, but invoked the example of a renowned Brazilian architect who is still working at 100.
Israel launches air strikes, targets militants in Gaza City
An Israeli aircraft hit a car filled with explosives in Gaza City after nightfall Monday, setting off a huge blast and killing a senior Islamic Jihad commander and another militant, witnesses and hospital officials said.
more »

Canada »

Harper announces more rigorous product safety law Video
The federal government on Monday announced a plan that will allow for greater product recall powers, stiffer fines for manufacturers and more product safety inspectors.
Winter storm wallops N.L. after pummelling Maritimes, Ont., Que. Video
A massive winter storm blew into Newfoundland and Labrador Monday after battering Central Canada and the Maritimes.
WestJet suspends policy allowing minors to fly alone
WestJet airlines has suspended a program that allows minors to fly alone after a five-year-old girl travelling last week was able to leave her flight with a stranger.
more »

Health »

Blood pressure dropped when pill taken at night: study
Taking a blood pressure pill at bedtime instead of in the morning might be healthier for some high-risk people.
Cancer report shows disparities between developing, developed countries
There will be more than 12 million new cancer cases and 7.6 million cancer deaths worldwide in 2007, the majority in developing countries, a new report says.
Pakistan reports first cases of bird flu
Authorities in Pakistan have announced that country's first reported cases of H5N1 avian flu in a cluster of family members which may have involved human-to-human transmission.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Satellites align for Canadian film Juno
Canadian director Jason Reitman's Juno has won three Satellite Awards. The Satellites are handed out annually by the International Press Academy, which represents entertainment journalists.
Writers' union gives thumbs down to work on Oscars, Golden Globes
The union representing striking writers aimed a blow at the glamorous heart of Hollywood, refusing to allow its members to write for the Academy Awards or Golden Globe ceremonies.
Monia Mazigh to publish memoir of Arar tragedy
Monia Mazigh, who won the admiration of Canadians during her long fight to get her husband Maher Arar freed from a Syrian prison, is writing a memoir.
more »

Technology & Science »

Distant galaxy threatened by 'death star'
The powerful jet produced by a massive black hole is blasting away at a nearby galaxy, prompting researchers to dub it the "death star" for its destructive effect on planets in its path.
RIM to open U.S. base in Texas
Research In Motion Ltd. has picked the telecommunications hub of suburban Dallas as the site of its U.S. headquarters, with a plan to employ more than 1,000 people in the city of Irving within the next several years.
Edmonton researchers to test LG health data cellphone
Health researchers in Edmonton are teaming up with Korean-based LG Electronics to fine-tune a hand-held device that transmits patients' home test results to nurses using a cellphone.
more »

Money »

Former Black confidant Radler gets 29-month term Video
The 29-month jail sentence Conrad Black's one-time top lieutenant David Radler agreed to serve as part of a deal to testify against his former boss was approved on Monday.
Metals and mining stocks lead broad TSX sell-off
Stock markets in Toronto and New York endured sharp sell-offs Monday amid persistent worries about the health of the U.S. economy.
RIM to open U.S. base in Texas
Research In Motion Ltd. has picked the telecommunications hub of suburban Dallas as the site of its U.S. headquarters, with a plan to employ more than 1,000 people in the city of Irving within the next several years.
more »

Consumer Life »

Harper announces more rigorous product safety law Video
The federal government on Monday announced a plan that will allow for greater product recall powers, stiffer fines for manufacturers and more product safety inspectors.
Attractive clerks ring up sales: study
Male customers will choose to buy a dirty shirt if it's been worn by an attractive saleswoman, a University of Alberta study has found.
Canada Post fixes data-revealing web glitch
Canada Post said Monday it has fixed a security flaw that allowed log-in records from a small business shipping website to be viewable through search engines such as Yahoo and Google.
more »

Sports »

Scores: CFL MLB MLS

Red Wings clip Capitals in shootout
Pavel Datsyuk had three assists as the Detroit Red Wings beat the Washington Capitals 4-3 in a shootout on Monday.
Peterson, Vikings prevail over Bears
Adrian Peterson ran for two touchdowns as the Minnesota Vikings beat the Chicago Bears 20-13 on Monday night.
Fernando Vina used HGH to heal injuries
Former major-league infielder Fernando Vina admitted Monday that he used human growth hormone four years ago, as suggested in the Mitchell report on drug use in baseball.
more »