CBC.ca Edmonton
Alberta Royalties
  Main › Memorable quotes: who said what

Memorable quotes: who said what
 

October 1, 2007 - Auditor General's Report
“Departmental technical staff assure us that they have held the view that Alberta has not been collecting its appropriate share since 2000.”
- Page 123, Volume 1

“Beginning at least three years ago, the Department (of Energy) demonstrated that Alberta’s share had fallen below its target range. The Department estimates that it could collect an additional $1 billion or more per year without stifling industry profitability.”
- Page 91, Volume 1

September 18, 2007 - Royalty Review Panel's Final Report
"Albertans do not receive their fair share from energy development."
- Bill Hunter, Panel Chair | Opening line, Page 1

May 01, 2007 - Question period exchange
Mr. Macdonald: "How many millions of dollars have been lost due to this government’s failure to collect a fair share of royalties on behalf of Albertans? How much money have you squandered and lost?"

Mr. Knight: Mr. Speaker, absolutely none.
- Hugh Macdonald, Liberal Opposition questioning Mel Knight, Energy Minister | In the Alberta legislature

April 30, 2007 - Energy Minister in the legislature
“…There is nothing in any of those documents that would indicate to anybody that we have not collected a fair share of royalties for Albertans.”
- Mel Knight | In response to a Liberal opposition question
April 19, 2007
"When this royalty review is completed, it will become very clear that Albertans have been well served by the system, and they will continue to be well served by the system."
- Mel Knight, Energy Minister | During question period in the legislature
July 13, 2006 - Ralph Klein
"I don't know if it was completed or not, nor do I
give a tinker's damn whether it was completed or not. I've always been
satisfied that our royalty regime is proper and right. We do get our pound of flesh."
- Ralph Klein | In response when asked if his government had launched an informal review of energy royalties

July 13, 2006 - Tories question review took place
"My understanding was the review was postponed."
- David Hancock | Former advanced education minister

"I wasn't aware that it had been done either. I would love to see it."
- Lyle Oberg | Finance minister

"I don't think anything was reported -- at least not to me."
- Ed Stelmach | Premier and past intergovernmental relations minister

July 12, 2006
“…That’s what royalty regimes are designed upon: to ensure that we get our fair share of the economic rent or the excess profit. That has been accomplished in our structure.”
- Greg Melchin | Energy Minister at the time, in response to an opposition question in the Alberta Legislature.
July 11, 2006
We've looked at royalties for quite a while on a number of fronts and we've come back in the interim and decided that we do get a fair share in Alberta."
- Greg Melchin | Announcing the Alberta government, after internal reviews, will not raise royalty rates

 



^ Top Of Page
Menu

Features
Your View
Have your say
What do you think of premier Stelmach's new royalty regime?
 
Royalties reports
CBC Public Forum
CBC hosted a forum with a panel of experts. Watch the full video now:
Part 1 (1:02:59)
Part 2 (18:34)
 
Reaction to Stelmach's royalty plan

John Archer sums up the plan
CBC Radio legislative reporter distills Stelmach's new plan

CAPP is concerned

Pembina Institute disappointed

Panel review
Camam MacGillivry of ENDEV Energy Inc., and David Allwright of the Bisset School of Business at Mount Royal College.

Political commentary
Graham Thomson and Jim Gray talk about the politics

Reaction to Stelmach's TV address
Kevin Taft, Liberal leader
Brian Mason, NDP leader

 
Stelmach announcement
Premier Stelmach news conference

Listen to full, unedited audio of premier Stelmach's speech.

Full news conference available in 2 parts:
Part 1 (10:21)
Part 2 (12:19)

 
Alberta's Auditor General
Auditor General Extended Audio

Listen to full, unedited audio of the Auditor General's news conference. (runs 14:26)

 
Listen/Watch again
On Air
Listen and watch our news coverage and extended interviews on Alberta's royalty future.
More stories