Recorded Votes in the House of Commons Where the Cabinet did not Vote with the Majority

Recorded Votes Where the Cabinet did not Vote with the Majority

Recorded Votes in the House of Commons Where the Cabinet did not Vote with the Majority 1957 to Date

Note: This compilation lists recorded votes on all motions where the Prime Minister and Cabinet did not vote with the majority of members of the House of Commons. Each entry contains:

the name ot the person who sponsored the motion,
the subject matter of the motion,
the results of the vote, and,
the name of either the Prime Minister or a senior Cabinet minister to assist in determining how the Cabinet voted.

Recorded votes list the names of each Member of the House of Commons present in the Chamber, and how they voted. These votes are also known as recorded divisions or standing votes.

Search Criteria

Parliament:

39th Parliament

2nd Session

Division: 13
Sponsor: Denise Savoie (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion for concurrence at report stage as amended of Bill C-303 Early Learning and Child Care Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 138 Nays: 112
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.11.21 pp. 193-94

1st Session

Division: 209
Sponsor: Jean Crowder (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Sixth Report (No Higher Priority: Aboriginal Post-Secondary Education in Canada) of the Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development
Result: agreed Yeas: 146 Nays: 114
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.06.19 pp. 1561-62

Division: 199
Sponsor: Todd Russell (Lib.)
Motion: motion with respect to the Equalization Program and the Atlantic Accords
Result: agreed Yeas: 149 Nays: 111
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.06.07 pp. 1491-92

Division: 197
Sponsor: Olivia Chow (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Fourth Report (immediate moratorium on deportations of all undocumented workers) of the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration
Result: agreed Yeas: 147 Nays: 115
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.06.06 pp. 1483-85

Division: 194
Sponsor: Serge Cardin (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Ninth Report (water exports) of the Standing Committee on International Trade
Result: agreed Yeas: 134 Nays: 108
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.06.04 pp. 1468-70

Division: 193
Sponsor: Nicole Demers (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for third reading of Bill C-280 Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (amendment: coming into force of sections 110, 111 and 171)
Result: agreed Yeas: 151 Nays: 119
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.05.30 pp. 1443-45

Division: 190
Sponsor: Nathan Cullen (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion that the government should call Bill C-30, Canada's Clean Air and Climate Change Act, for debate and decision at Report stage and Second reading as soon as possible
Result: agreed Yeas: 155 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.05.29 pp. 1436-37

Division: 188
Sponsor: Judy Sgro (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Thirteenth Report (Protocol for the appearance of Accounting Officers as witnesses before the Standing Commitee on Public Accounts) of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts
Result: agreed Yeas: 160 Nays: 116
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.05.15 pp. 1409-10

Division: 184
Sponsor: Nicole Demers (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for concurrence at report stage of Bill C-280 Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (amendment: coming into force of sectionss 110, 111 and 171)
Result: agreed Yeas: 148 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.05.09 pp. 1382-83

Division: 183
Sponsor: Johanne Deschamps (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for concurrence at report stage of Bill C-269 Employment Insurance Act (amendment: improvement of the employment insurance system)
Result: agreed Yeas: 155 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.05.09 pp. 1380-82

Division: 182
Sponsor: Robert Bouchard (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-207 Income Tax Act (amendment: tax credit for new graduates working in designated regions)
Result: agreed Yeas: 155 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.05.09 pp. 1379-80

Division: 181
Sponsor: Pierre Paquette (B.Q.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (price of gas)
Result: agreed Yeas: 159 Nays: 122
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.05.08 pp. 1371-73

Division: 180
Sponsor: Paule Brunelle (B.Q.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (amendment: creation of a petroleum monitoring agency)
Result: agreed Yeas: 159 Nays: 122
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.05.08 pp. 1371-72

Division: 171
Sponsor: Catherine Bell (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion that a special committee of the House be created to continue the work on electoral reform
Result: agreed Yeas: 91 Nays: 175
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.05.02 pp. 1327-29

Division: 168
Sponsor: Yasmin Ratansi (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Sixteenth Report (Court Challenges Program) of the Standing Committee on the Status of Women
Result: agreed Yeas: 149 Nays: 109
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.05.01 pp. 1302-04

Division: 165
Sponsor: Bernard Bigras (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-327 Broadcasting Act (amendment: reduction of violence in television broadcasts)
Result: agreed Yeas: 176 Nays: 87
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.04.25 pp. 1265-67

Division: 164
Sponsor: Mark Eyking (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence at report stage of Bill C-278 Employment Insurance Act (amendment: benefits for illness, injury or quarantine)
Result: agreed Yeas: 152 Nays: 117
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.04.25 pp. 1263-65

Division: 163
Sponsor: Jack Layton (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-377 Climate Change Accountability Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 152 Nays: 115
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.04.25 pp. 1262-63

Division: 158
Sponsor: Paul Crête (B.Q.)
Motion: motion that the government establish, in compliance with international agreements, a policy of assistance to the textile and clothing industries
Result: agreed Yeas: 158 Nays: 113
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.04.18 pp. 1231-33

Division: 156
Sponsor: Wayne Easter (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Eleventh Report (Canadian Wheat Board) of the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food
Result: agreed Yeas: 159 Nays: 113
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.04.18 pp. 1228-29

Division: 150
Sponsor: Yvon Godin (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-265 Employment Insurance Act (amendment: qualification for and entitlement to benefits)
Result: agreed Yeas: 166 Nays: 120
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.03.28 pp. 1177-79

Division: 149
Sponsor: John McKay (Lib.)
Motion: motion for third reading of Bill C-293 Development Assistance Accountability Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 166 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.03.28 pp. 1177

Division: 148
Sponsor: John McKay (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence at report stage with further amendments of Bill C-293 Development Assistance Accountability Act
Result: agreed to Yeas: 166 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.03.28 pp. 1173-77

Division: 141-147
Sponsor: John McKay (Lib.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend C-293 Development Assistance Accountability Act
Result: 7 divisions votes agreed to Yeas: 166 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.03.28 pp. 1173-76

Division: 136
Sponsor: Paul Martin (Lib.)
Motion: motion for third reading of Bill C-292 Kelowna Accord Implementation Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 176 Nays: 126
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.03.21 pp. 1136-37

Division: 132
Sponsor: Nicole Demers (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-280 Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (amendment: coming into force of sections 110, 111 and 171)
Result: agreed Yeas: 172 Nays: 126
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.03.21 pp. 1129-31

Division: 127
Sponsor: Francis Scarpaleggia (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Thirteenth Report (exporail) of the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage
Result: agreed Yeas: 159 Nays: 123
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.27 pp. 1079-81

Division: 126
Sponsor: Robert Nicholson (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion for extension of the anti-terrorism provisions
Result: negatived Yeas: 124 Nays: 159
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.27 pp. 1077-79

Division: 125
Sponsor: Omar Alghabra (Lib.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (citizenship and immigration)
Result: agreed Yeas: 159 Nays: 123
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.27 pp. 1076-77

Division: 124
Sponsor: Denis Coderre (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill S-211 Criminal Code (amendment: lottery schemes)
Result: agreed Yeas: 159 Nays: 109
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.21 pp. 1054-56

Division: 123
Sponsor: Paul Martin (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence at report stage of Bill C-292 Kelowna Accord Implementation Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 152 Nays: 119
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.21 pp. 1052-54

Division: 118
Sponsor: Peter Julian (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Fifth Report (imports of clothing and textiles from China) of the Standing Committee on International Trade
Result: agreed Yeas: 155 Nays: 119
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.14 pp. 1035-37

Division: 115
Sponsor: Michael Ignatieff (Lib.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (government policies)
Result: agreed Yeas: 155 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.20 pp. 1031-33

Division: 112
Sponsor: Pablo Rodriguez (Lib.)
Motion: motion for third reading of Bill C-288 Kyoto Protocol Implementation Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 161 Nays: 113
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.14 pp. 1009-11

Division: 111
Sponsor: Pablo Rodriguez (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence at report stage with further amendments of Bill C-288 Kyoto Protocol Implementation Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 161 Nays: 113
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.14 pp. 1007-09

Division: 108, 109, 110
Sponsor: Pablo Rodriguez (Lib.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend C-288 Kyoto Protocol Implementation Act
Result: 3 divisions votes agreed to Yeas: 161 Nays: 113
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.14 pp. 1007-09

Division: 107
Sponsor: Bill Siksay (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Tenth Report (issues raised by the use of security certificates under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act) of the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration
Result: agreed Yeas: 165 Nays: 119
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.13 pp. 1000-01

Division: 106
Sponsor: Irene Mathyssen (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Third Report (investments in women's groups and equality seeking organizations) of the Standing Committee on the Status of Women
Result: agreed Yeas: 165 Nays: 119
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.13 pp. 998-1000

Division: 105
Sponsor: Gilles Duceppe (B.Q.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (the government should provide the Government of Quebec with the sum of not less than $328 million to enable it to implement its plan to meet the Kyoto Protocol targets)
Result: agreed Yeas: 166 Nays: 119
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.13 pp. 996-98

Division: 104
Sponsor: Yvon Godin (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (amendment: appropriate funding for the transition to Kyoto)
Result: agreed Yeas: 166 Nays: 119
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.13 pp. 996-98

Division: 98
Sponsor: Stéphane Dion (Lib.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (Kyoto Protocol)
Result: agreed Yeas: 161 Nays: 115
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2007.02.05 pp. 960-62

Division: 96
Sponsor: Wayne Easter (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Sixth Report (Canadian Wheat Board) of the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food
Result: agreed Yeas: 165 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.12.12 pp. 902-03

Division: 95
Sponsor: Bill Siksay (N.P.D)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Sixth Report (stateless Vietnamese refugees in the Philippines) of the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration
Result: agreed Yeas: 164 Nays: 122
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.12.12 pp. 900-01

Division: 94
Sponsor: Robert Nicholson (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion to introduce legislation to restore the traditional definition of marriage without affecting civil unions and while respecting existing same-sex marriages
Result: negatived Yeas: 123 Nays: 175
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.12.07 pp. 881-82

Division: 91
Sponsor: Mark Eyking (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-278 Employment insurance Act (amendment: benefits for illness, injury or quarantine)
Result: agreed Yeas: 166 Nays: 109
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.12.05 pp. 861-62

Division: 75
Sponsor: Ruby Dhalla (Lib.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (health care renewal)
Result: agreed Yeas: 149 Nays: 122
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.11.28 pp. 821-22

Division: 71
Sponsor: Denise Savoie (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-303 Early Learning and Child Care Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 144 Nays: 116
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.11.22 pp. 790-92

Division: 70
Sponsor: Geoff Regan (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-284 Canada Student Financial Assistance Act (amendment: Canada access grants)
Result: agreed Yeas: 156 Nays: 102
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.11.22 pp. 789-90

Division: 67
Sponsor: Brian Murphy (Lib.)
Motion: motion respecting Senate amendments to Bill C-2 Federal Accountability Act (amendment: paragraph D, as amended)
Result: agreed Yeas: 155 Nays: 119
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.11.21 pp. 769-70

Division: 63
Sponsor: Johanne Deschamps (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-269 Employment Insurance Act (amendment: improvement of the employment insurance system)
Result: agreed Yeas: 154 Nays: 105
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.11.08 pp. 665-67

Division: 60
Sponsor: Dan McTeague (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-253 Income Tax Act (amendment: deductibility of RESP contributions)
Result: agreed Yeas: 140 Nays: 125
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.11.08 pp. 661-62

Division: 59
Sponsor: Peter Stoffer (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (assistance for members and veterans of the Canadian Forces and their families)
Result: agreed Yeas: 154 Nays: 111
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.11.07 pp. 653-55

Division: 55
Sponsor: Irene Mathyssen (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Fourth Report (Pay Equity Task Force recommendations) of the Standing Committee on the Status of Women
Result: agreed Yeas: 153 Nays: 113
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.11.07 pp. 646-47

Division: 53
Sponsor: Vic Toews (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-9 Criminal Code (amendment: conditional sentence of imprisonment)
Result: negatived Yeas: 124 Nays: 152
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.11.01 pp. 617-23

Division: 52
Sponsor: Wayne Easter (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Second Report (Report on the Canadian Wheat Board) of the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food
Result: agreed Yeas: 155 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.11.01 pp. 615-17

Division: 51
Sponsor: Gerry Ritz (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-300 Canadian Wheat Board Act (amendment: direct sale of grain)
Result: negatived Yeas: 111 Nays: 149
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.10.25 pp. 581-82

Division: 50
Sponsor: Richard Nadeau (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-257 Canada Labour Code (amendment: replacement workers)
Result: agreed Yeas: 167 Nays: 101
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.10.25 pp. 579-80

Division: 49
Sponsor: Jay Hill (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion that the Seventeenth Report (Standing Orders) of the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs be not now concurred in but that it be referred back to Committee for further consideration with instruction that it amend the same so as to recommend that Standing Order 106(4) be amended by replacing the words "five days" with the words "ten days"
Result: negatived Yeas: 113 Nays: 159
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.10.25 pp. 577-79

Division: 48
Sponsor: Gary Merasty (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in First Report (Kelowna Agreement) of the Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development
Result: agreed Yeas: 160 Nays: 113
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.10.25 pp. 575-77

Division: 47
Sponsor: Maka Kotto (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Seventh Report (Study related to Canadian Museums) of the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage
Result: agreed Yeas: 146 Nays: 114
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.10.24 pp. 567-69

Division: 45
Sponsor: Paul Martin (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-292 Kelowna Accord Implementation Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 159 Nays: 123
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.10.18 pp. 545-47

Division: 42
Sponsor: Mauril Bélanger (Lib.)
Motion: mmotion for concurrence in Eighth Report (Court Challenges Program) of the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage
Result: agreed Yeas: 160 Nays: 123
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.10.18 pp. 540-41

Division: 40
Sponsor: Yves Lessard (B.Q.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (income support program for older workers)
Result: agreed Yeas: 155 Nays: 124
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.10.16 pp. 525-26

Division: 38
Sponsor: Pablo Rodriguez (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-288 Kyoto Protocol Implementation Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 152 Nays: 115
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.10.04 pp. 499-501

Division: 36
Sponsor: Maria Minna (Lib.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (Status of Women)
Result: agreed Yeas: 145 Nays: 118
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.10.03 pp. 490-91

Division: 35
Sponsor: Marcel Proulx (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Second Report (Significant property) of the Standing Committee on Government Operations and Estimates
Result: agreed Yeas: 145 Nays: 119
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.09.27 pp. 465-66

Division: 34
Sponsor: John McKay (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-293 Development Assistance Accountability Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 159 Nays: 108
Cabinet Minister: Robert Nicholson, Leader of the Government in the House of Commons, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.09.20 pp. 406-07

Division: 30
Sponsor: John Baird (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-2 Federal Accountability Act
Result: negatived Yeas: 125 Nays: 165
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.06.21 pp. 330-32

Division: 28, 31
Sponsor: Yvon Godin (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-2 Federal Accountability Act
Result: agreed Yeas: 165 Nays: 125
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.06.21 pp. 326-33

Division: 22
Sponsor: Anita Neville (Lib.)
Motion: motion that the House implement the Kelowna Accord
Result: agreed Yeas: 162 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.06.20 pp. 309-11

Division: 19
Sponsor: André Bellavance (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in First Report (Imports of milk protein concentrates) of the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food
Result: agreed Yeas: 154 Nays: 123
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.06.13 pp. 273-75

Division: 11
Sponsor: Randy Kamp (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion that the House do now proceed to the Orders of the Day
Result: negatived Yeas: 116 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.06.05 pp. 229-31

Division: 10
Sponsor: Mauril Bélanger (Lib.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (protection and promotion of the diversity of cultural expressions)
Result: agreed Yeas: 155 Nays: 121
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.05.30 pp. 210-12

Division: 8
Sponsor: Bernard Bigras (B.Q.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (Kyoto Protocol)
Result: agreed Yeas: 169 Nays: 125
Cabinet Minister: Stephen Harper, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2006.05.16 pp. 181-83

38th Parliament

1st Session

Division: 189
Sponsor: Robert Vincent (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-380 Canada Labour Code (amendment: pregnant or nursing employees)
Result: agreed Yeas: 155 Nays: 92
Cabinet Minister: Lucienne Robillard, Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs , voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.11.23 pp. 1324-25

Division: 190
Sponsor: Stephen Harper (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion that this House has lost confidence in the Government
Result: agreed Yeas: 171 Nays: 133
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister , voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.11.28 pp. 1352-53

Division: 186
Sponsor: Jay Hill (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-248 Controlled Drugs and Substances Act (amendment: trafficking in a controlled drug or substance within five hundred metres of an elementary school or a high school)
Result: agreed Yeas: 218 Nays: 31
Cabinet Minister: Lucienne Robillard, Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs , voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.11.23 pp. 1320-21

Division: 182
Sponsor: Jack Layton (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion to ask the Governor General to dissolve the 38th Parliament and to set the date for the 39th general election for Monday, February 13, 2006
Result: agreed Yeas: 167 Nays: 129
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.11.21 pp. 1301-02

Division: 181
Sponsor: Denis Coderre (Lib.)
Motion: motion that the Bloc Québécois Members' householder, on the subject of the Gomery Commission, which affects the privileges of the Member for Bourassa, be referred to the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs
Result: negatived Yeas: 134 Nays: 163
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.11.15 pp. 1273-74

Division: 180
Sponsor: Tom Lukiwski (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (Access to Information Act)
Result: agreed Yeas: 169 Nays: 130
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.11.15 pp. 1271-72

Division: 176
Sponsor: Peter Julian (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion to recognize all firefighters who have fallen in the line of duty in Canada and to support the proposed construction of a monument in the Parliamentary precinct
Result: agreed Yeas: 161 Nays: 112
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.10.26 pp. 1210-11

Division: 175
Sponsor: Edward Broadbent (N.D.P.)
Motion: amendment to motion to recognize all firefighters who have fallen in the line of duty in Canada by constructing a monument in the Parliamentary precinct
Result: agreed Yeas: 146 Nays: 129
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.10.26 pp. 1209-10

Division: 165
Sponsor: Mark Warawa (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Sixth Report (Study on the closing of RCMP detachments) of the Standing Committee on Justice, Human Rights, Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness
Result: agreed Yeas: 162 Nays: 118
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.10.05 pp. 1110-11

Division: 123
Sponsor: John Duncan (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion for third reading of Bill C-259 Excise Tax Act (amendment: elimination of excise tax on jewellery)
Result: agreed Yeas: 185 Nays: 93
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.06.15 pp. 907-8

Division: 98
Sponsor: Richard Marceau (B.Q.)
Motion: motion that the Standing Committee on Justice, Human Rights, Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness create a special subcommittee with the mandate to examine the process for appointments to the federal judiciary and make recommendations for reform, with the primary goal of eliminating political partisanship from the process, by October 31, 2005
Result: agreed Yeas: 157 Nays: 124
Cabinet Minister: Jean-C. Lapierre, Minister of Transport, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.06.07 pp. 844-5

Division: 88
Sponsor: Jay Hill (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion that the House do now adjourn
Result: agreed Yeas: 138 Nays: 57
Cabinet Minister: Andy Scott, Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.13 pp. 751-2

Division: 87
Sponsor: Rob Nicholson (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion that the Honourable Member for Prince George--Peace River (Jay Hill) be now heard on second reading of Bill C-48 An Act to authorize the Minister of Finance to make certain payments
Result: agreed Yeas: 150 Nays: 65
Cabinet Minister: Andy Scott, Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.13 pp. 747-8

Division: 86
Sponsor: Rob Nicholson (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion that the House do now adjourn
Result: agreed Yeas: 152 Nays: 144
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.12 pp. 745-6

Division: 84
Sponsor: Dominic LeBlanc (Lib.)
Motion: motion for adjournment of the debate for concurrence in 35th Report (amendment to Standing Order 81(10)) of the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs
Result: negatived Yeas: 147 Nays: 153
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.11 pp. 739-40

Division: 83
Sponsor: John Williams (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in First Report (Report of the Auditor General of Canada on the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada) of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts
Result: agreed Yeas: 153 Nays: 150
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.10 pp. 733-4

Division: 82
Sponsor: Jay Hill (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion that the First Report (Report of the Auditor General of Canada on the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada) of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts be not now concurred in but that it be referred back to Committee for further consideration with instruction that it amend the same so as to recommend that the government resign because of its failure to address the deficiencies in governance of the public service addressed in the report
Result: agreed Yeas: 153 Nays: 150
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.10 pp. 731-3

Division: 74
Sponsor: Denis Paradis (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Fourth Report (Study on the closing of RCMP detachments) of the Standing Committee on Justice, Human Rights, Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness
Result: agreed Yeas: 188 Nays: 109
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.04 p. 698

Division: 73
Sponsor: Denis Coderre (Lib.)
Motion: motion that the question be now put for concurrence in Fourth Report (Study on the closing of RCMP detachments) of the Standing Committee on Justice, Human Rights, Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness
Result: agreed Yeas: 188 Nays: 109
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.04 pp. 697-8

Division: 71
Sponsor: Raymond Simard (Lib.)
Motion: motion for adjournment of the debate for concurrence in Fourth Report (Study on the closing of RCMP detachments) of the Standing Committee on Justice, Human Rights, Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness
Result: negatived Yeas: 140 Nays: 148
Cabinet Minister: Jean-C. Lapierre, Minister of Transport, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.03 pp. 685-7

Division: 70
Sponsor: Gerry Ritz (C.P.C)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Third Report (2004 Avian Influenza Outbreak in British Columbia) of the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food
Result: agreed Yeas: 168 Nays: 122
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.02 pp. 681-2

Division: 69
Sponsor: Ken Boshcoff (Lib.)
Motion: motion that the Third Report (2004 Avian Influenza Outbreak in British Columbia) of the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food be not now concurred in but that it be referred back to Committee for further consideration
Result: negatived Yeas: 123 Nays: 167
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.05.02 pp. 680-1

Division: 67
Sponsor: Jeff Watson (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-265 Income Tax Act (amendment: exemption from taxation of 50% of United States social security payments to Canadian residents)
Result: agreed Yeas: 154 Nays: 112
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.04.20 pp. 660-1

Division: 65
Sponsor: Gilles Duceppe (B.Q.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (establish a trust account into which the Liberal Party can deposit all funds received from companies and individuals tied to the sponsorship scandal)
Result: agreed Yeas: 157 Nays: 119
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.04.19 pp. 651-2

Division: 64
Sponsor: Gérard Asselin (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-280 Employment Insurance Act (amendment: Employment Insurance Account and premium rate setting)
Result: agreed Yeas: 156 Nays: 116
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.04.13 pp. 623-4

Division: 60
Sponsor: Jim Prentice (C.P.C)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Fourth Report (Resolution of Indian residential school claims) of the Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development
Result: agreed Yeas: 149 Nays: 147
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.04.12 pp. 615-6

Division: 59
Sponsor: Don Boudria (Lib.)
Motion: motion that the Fourth Report (Resolution of Indian residential school claims) of the Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development be not now concurred in but that it be referred back to Committee for further consideration
Result: negatived Yeas: 147 Nays: 149
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.04.12 pp. 614-5

Division: 58
Sponsor: Gurmant Grewal (C.P.C)
Motion: motion for an independent judicial inquiry into the investigation of the Air India bombing of June 23, 1985
Result: agreed Yeas: 172 Nays: 124
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.04.12 pp. 612-4

Division: 55
Sponsor: Jeremy Harrison (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion to acknowledge the historic inequality of treatment and compensation for First Nations, Métis and Inuit war veterans
Result: agreed Yeas: 144 Nays: 100
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.04.06 pp. 585-6

Division: 53
Sponsor: Bob Mills (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Fourth Report (Certificate of nomination of Glen Murray) of the Standing Committee on Environment and Sustainable Development
Result: agreed Yeas: 143 Nays: 108
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.04.06 pp. 583-4

Division: 51
Sponsor: Susan Kadis (Lib.)
Motion: amendment to motion to create a secretariat responsible for overseeing the Foreign Credential Recognition Program
Result: negatived Yeas: 112 Nays: 138
Cabinet Minister: Jean-C. Lapierre, Minister of Transport, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.03.23 pp. 553-5

Division: 39
Sponsor: Monte Solberg (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (accountability of foundations)
Result: agreed Yeas: 161 Nays: 114
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.02.22 pp. 466-8

Division: 38
Sponsor: Pierre Pettigrew (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-32 Department of Foreign Affairs Act
Result: negatived Yeas: 125 Nays: 154
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.02.15 pp. 436-8

Division: 36
Sponsor: Jim Peterson (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-31 Department of International Trade Act
Result: negatived Yeas: 125 Nays: 157
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.02.15 pp. 434-5

Division: 33
Sponsor: Diane Finley (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (drop the CAIS deposit requirement and honour the commitments made to Canadian producers)
Result: agreed Yeas: 158 Nays: 114
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.02.08 pp. 403-5

Division: 32
Sponsor: Pierre Paquette (B.Q.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (assistance to clothing and textile industries)
Result: agreed Yeas: 157 Nays: 108
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2005.02.08 pp. 402-3

Division: 27
Sponsor: Reg Alcock (Lib.)
Motion: motion to restore Main Estimates, under Privy Council
Result: negatived Yeas: 124 Nays: 167
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2004.12.09 pp. 328-9

Division: 26
Sponsor: Reg Alcock (Lib.)
Motion: motion to restore Main Estimates, under Governor General
Result: negatived Yeas: 120 Nays: 171
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2004.12.09 pp. 327-8

Division: 20
Sponsor: Roger Gaudet (B.Q.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (mad cow crisis)
Result: agreed Yeas: 164 Nays: 125
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2004.12.07 pp. 304-6

Division: 17
Sponsor: Stephen Harper (C.P.C.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (Mirabel Airport)
Result: agreed Yeas: 157 Nays: 118
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2004.11.30 pp. 275-6

Division: 14
Sponsor: Joe Comartin (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-7 Department of Canadian Heritage Act and the Parks Canada Agency Act and to make related amendments to other Acts
Result: agreed Yeas: 157 Nays: 112
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2004.11.23 pp. 248-9

Division: 11
Sponsor: Anne McLellan (Lib.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-6 Department of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness Act
Result: negatived Yeas: 124 Nays: 154
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2004.11.16 pp. 223-4

Division: 6
Sponsor: Yvan Loubier (B.Q.)
Motion: motion to strike a special subcommittee to propose tangible solutions for addressing the fiscal imbalance
Result: agreed Yeas: 165 Nays: 128
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2004.11.02 pp. 182-3

37th Parliament

3rd Session

Division: 46
Sponsor: Jay Hill (P.C.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-246 Income Tax Act (amendment: child adoption expenses)
Result: agreed Yeas: 168 Nays: 50
Cabinet Minister: Paul Martin, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2004.04.20 pp. 281-2

Division: 36
Sponsor: Loyola Hearn (P.C.)
Motion: motion to extend custodial management over the Nose and Tail of the Grand Banks and of the Flemish Cap.
Result: agreed Yeas: 124 Nays: 95
Cabinet Minister: David Anderson, Minister of the Environment, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2004.03.24 pp. 209-10

2nd Session

Division: 277
Sponsor: Chuck Cadman (C.A.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-338 Criminal Code (amendment: street racing)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 121 Nays: 88
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Minister of Health, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2003.11.05 pp. 1241-2

Division: 251
Sponsor: James Lunney (C.A.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-420 Food and Drugs Act (amendment)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 124 Nays: 85
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Minister of Health, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2003.10.22 pp. 1152-3

Division: 240
Sponsor: Marcel Gagnon (B.Q.)
Motion: amendment to motion to prevent medical conditions and illnesses caused by exposure to identifiable environmental contaminants
Result: agreed to Yeas: 117 Nays: 99
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Minister of Health, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2003.10.07 pp. 1107-8

Division: 218
Sponsor: Diane Ablonczy (C.A.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-421 Establishment of the Office of the Chief Actuary of Canada
Result: agreed to Yeas: 116 Nays: 98
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Minister of Health, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2003.09.17 pp. 989-90

Division: 169
Sponsor: Jim Abbott (C.A.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (support for the admission of Taiwan as an observer to the World Health Organization)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 163 Nays: 67
Cabinet Minister: Ralph Goodale, Minister of Public Works and Government Services, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2003.05.27 pp. 808-9

Division: 87, 96, 114
Sponsor: Paul Szabo (Lib.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-13 Assisted Human Reproduction Act
Result: 3 divisions votes agreed to Yeas: 113 Nays: 110 (vote # 87)
Yeas: 113 Nays: 109 (vote # 96)
Yeas: 112 Nays: 101 (vote # 114)
Cabinet Minister: Ralph Goodale, Minister of Public Works and Government Services, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2003.03.26 pp. 580-1, 589-90, 602-3

Division: 49
Sponsor: John Brydon (Lib.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-15 Lobbyists Registration Act
Result: agreed to Yeas: 121 Nays: 116
Cabinet Minister: Jean Chrétien, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2003.02.25 pp. 464-5

Division: 17
Sponsor: John Reynolds (C.A.)
Motion: motion of Business of Supply (election of Committee Chairs and Vice-Chairs by secret ballot)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 174 Nays: 87
Cabinet Minister: Jean Chrétien, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2002.11.05 pp. 163-4

1st Session

Division: 60
Sponsor: Robert Lanctôt (B.Q.)
Motion: motion that the House do now adjourn
Result: agreed Yeas: 98 Nays: 95
Cabinet Minister: Herb Gray, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2001.03.29 pp. 263-4

36th Parliament

2nd Session

Division: 1278
Sponsor: Jay Hill (P.C.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-223 Witness Protection Program Act (amendment: protection of spouses whose life is in danger)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 115 Nays: 109
Cabinet Minister: Herbert Gray, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 2000.05.02 pp. 1628-9

1st Session

Division: 544
Sponsor: Randy White (C.A.)
Motion: motion for third reading of Bill C-251 Criminal Code and the Corrections and Conditional Release Act (amendment: cumulative sentences)
Result: agreed Yeas: 122 Nays: 31
Cabinet Minister: Lyle Vanclief, Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1999.06.07 pp. 2057-8

Division: 244
Sponsor: Dan McTeague (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-235 Competition Act (amendment: protection of those who purchase products from vertically integrated suppliers who compete with them at retail)
Result: agreed Yeas: 158 Nays: 74
Cabinet Minister: Lyle Vanclief, Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1998.10.20 pp. 1164-5

Division: 235
Sponsor: Eric Lowther (Ref.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-284 Criminal Records Act and the Canadian Human Rights Act (amendment: offences against children)
Result: agreed Yeas: 127 Nays: 103
Cabinet Minister: Anne McLellan, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1998.10.06 pp. 1126-7

Division: 177
Sponsor: Pauline Picard (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-247 Criminal Code (amendment: genetic manipulation)
Result: agreed Yeas: 134 Nays: 101
Cabinet Minister: Lyle Vanclief, Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1998.05.25 pp. 886-7

Division: 127
Sponsor: Colleen Beaumier (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-208 Access to Information Act (amendment)
Result: agreed Yeas: 143 Nays: 83
Cabinet Minister: Lyle Vanclief, Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1998.04.21 pp. 686-7

Division: 122
Sponsor: Diane St-Jacques (Lib.)
Motion: motion to review the level at which the child tax benefit is indexed
Result: agreed Yeas: 125 Nays: 102
Cabinet Minister: Jean Chrétien, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1998.03.31 pp. 652-3

35th Parliament

2nd Session

Division: 294
Sponsor: Suzanne Tremblay (B.Q.)
Motion: motion to amend the Standing Orders (Private Members' public bills, committee reports)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 99 Nays: 48
Cabinet Minister: John Manley, Minister of Industry, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1997.04.09 pp. 1367-8

Division: 159
Sponsor: Paul Szabo (Lib.)
Motion: motion to amend the Income Tax Act (amendment: care-giver tax credit)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 129 Nays: 63
Cabinet Minister: Ralph Goodale, Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1996.11.05 pp. 831-2

Division: 127
Sponsor: Roger Gallaway (Lib.)
Motion: motion for 3rd Reading of Bill C-216 Broadcasting Act (broadcasting policy)
Result: agreed Yeas: 84 Nays: 68
Cabinet Minister: Ralph Goodale, Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1996.09.23 pp. 663-4

Division: 125, 126
Sponsor: Roger Gallaway (Lib.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-216 Broadcasting Act (broadcasting policy)
Result: 2 divisions votes agreed to Yeas: 83 Nays: 66 (vote # 125)
Yeas: 83 Nays: 68 (vote # 126)
Cabinet Minister: Ralph Goodale, Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1996.09.23 pp. 662-3

Division: 124
Sponsor: Gaston Leroux (B.Q.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-216 Broadcasting Act (broadcasting policy)
Result: negatived Yeas: 67 Nays: 83
Cabinet Minister: Ralph Goodale, Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1996.09.23 pp. 661-2

Division: 115
Sponsor: John Williams (C.A.)
Motion: motion to introduce amendments to the Financial Administration Act requiring all departments and agencies to table in the House of Commons a specific response to the Auditor General's report on their activities
Result: agreed Yeas: 128 Nays: 100
Cabinet Minister: Lloyd Axworthy, Minister of Foreign Affairs, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1996.06.18 pp. 575-6

Division: 54
Sponsor: Pierrette Venne (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-217 Criminal Code (amendment: protection of witnesses)
Result: agreed Yeas: 107 Nays: 89
Cabinet Minister: Lloyd Axworthy, Minister of Foreign Affairs, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1996.05.07 pp. 308-9

1st Session

Division: 146
Sponsor: John Nunziata (Lib.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-226 Criminal Code (amendment)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 137 Nays: 103
Cabinet Minister: Sheila Copps, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1995.02.08 pp. 1101-2

Division: 137
Sponsor: Pierre de Savoye (B.Q.)
Motion: motion for second reading of Bill C-237 Bankruptcy Act (amendment: priority of claims)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 85 Nays: 79
Cabinet Minister: Lloyd Axworthy, Minister of Labour, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1994.12.08 pp. 1011-2

34th Parliament

3rd Session

No Defeated Motions

2nd Session

No Defeated Motions

1st Session

No Defeated Motions

33rd Parliament

2nd Session

Division: 500
Sponsor: John Bosley (P.C.)
Motion: amendment No. 13 on motion to prepare and introduce legislation on abortion
Result: negatived Yeas: 76 Nays: 147
Cabinet Minister: D. Mazankowski, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1988.07.28 pp. 3301-2

Division: 498
Sponsor: Gus Mitges (P.C.)
Motion: amendment No. 3 on motion to prepare and introduce legislation on abortion
Result: negatived Yeas: 105 Nays: 118
Cabinet Minister: D. Mazankowski, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1988.07.28 p. 3300

Division: 372, 373, 374
Sponsor: Lynn McDonald (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-204 An Act to regulate smoking in the federal workplace and on common carriers and to amend the Harzardous Products Act in relation to cigarette advertising
Result: 3 divisions votes agreed to Yeas: 73 Nays: 60 (vote # 372)
Yeas: 74 Nays: 57 (vote # 373)
Yeas: 77 Nays: 58 (vote # 374)
Cabinet Minister: D. Mazankowski, Deputy Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1988.05.31 pp. 2759-61

1st Session

No Defeated Motions

32nd Parliament

2nd Session

No Defeated Motions

1st Session

No Defeated Motions

31st Parliament

1st Session

Division: 8
Sponsor: Bob Rae (N.D.P.)
Motion: sub-amendment to Ways and Means Motion (Budget)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 139 Nays: 133
Cabinet Minister: J. Clark, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1979.12.13 pp. 345-6

30th Parliament

4th Session

No Defeated Motions

3rd Session

No Defeated Motions

2nd Session

No Defeated Motions

1st Session

No Defeated Motions

29th Parliament

2nd Session

Division: 8
Sponsor: David Lewis (N.D.P.)
Motion: sub-amendment to Ways and Means Motion (Budget)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 137 Nays: 123
Cabinet Minister: P.E. Trudeau, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1974.05.08 pp. 175-6

1st Session

Division: 71
Sponsor: Stuart Leggatt (N.D.P.)
Motion: amendment to motion for message to Senate that House disagrees with Senate amendment
Result: agreed to Yeas: 114 Nays: 94
Cabinet Minister: P.E. Trudeau, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1974.01.10 p. 818

Division: 63
Sponsor: William Knight, John Rodriguez, William Peters (NDP)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-203 Election Expenses Act
Result: agreed to Yeas: 90 Nays: 87
Cabinet Minister: P.E. Trudeau, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1974.01.03 p. 788

Division: 59
Sponsor: Otto Lang (Lib.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-176 Protection of Privacy Act
Result: negatived Yeas: 113 Nays: 118
Cabinet Minister: P.E. Trudeau, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1973.12.04 pp. 716-7

Division: 27
Sponsor: Edward Broadbent (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion at report stage to amend Bill C-133 Housing Act (amendment)
Result: agreed to Yeas: 133 Nays: 101
Cabinet Minister: P.E. Trudeau, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1973.06.12 pp. 404-5

Division: 18
Sponsor: Charles Drury (Lib.)
Motion: motion for concurrence in Vote 25b, Information Canada, Supplementary Estimates (B), 1972-73
Result: negatived Yeas: 107 Nays: 138
Cabinet Minister: P.E. Trudeau, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1973.03.26 pp. 212-3

Division: 15
Sponsor: Frank Howard (N.D.P.)
Motion: motion that the House do now proceed to another order
Result: agreed to Yeas: 55 Nays: 53
Cabinet Minister: P.E. Trudeau, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1973.03.16 p. 192

Division: 4
Sponsor: Allan Lawrence (P.C.)
Motion: amendment to motion to appoint a special joint committee on food prices
Result: agreed to Yeas: 128 Nays: 102
Cabinet Minister: M. Sharp, Secretary of State for External Affairs, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1973.01.18 p. 50

28th Parliament

4th Session

No Defeated Motions

3rd Session

No Defeated Motions

2nd Session

No Defeated Motions

1st Session

No Defeated Motions

27th Parliament

2nd Session

Division:
Sponsor: Mitchell Sharp (Lib.)
Motion: motion for 3rd Reading of Bill C-193 Income Tax Act (amendment)
Result: negatived Yeas: 82 Nays: 84
Cabinet Minister: R. Winters, Minister of Trade and Commerce, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1968.02.19 pp. 702-3

1st Session

No Defeated Motions

26th Parliament

3rd Session

No Defeated Motions

2nd Session

Division:
Sponsor: Speaker's Ruling on Question of Priviledge (election irregularities) appealed to House (T.C. Douglas)
Motion:
Result: ruling not sustained Yeas: 108 Nays: 114
Cabinet Minister: L. Pearson, Prime Minister , voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1965.02.24 pp. 1069-71

1st Session

Division:
Sponsor: Deputy Speaker's Ruling (L.Lamoureux) on sub-amendment to Supply Motion No. 4, appealed to House (G. Grégoire)
Motion:
Result: ruling not sustained Yeas: 83 Nays: 85
Cabinet Minister: L. Pearson, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1963.10.28 pp. 492-3

25th Parliament

1st Session

Division:
Sponsor: Lester Pearson (Lib.)
Motion: amendment, as amended, to Supply Motion No. 2
Result: agreed to Yeas: 142 Nays: 111
Cabinet Minister: J.G. Diefenbaker, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1963.02.05 pp. 474-5

Division:
Sponsor: Robert Thompson (S.C.)
Motion: sub-amendment to Supply Motion No. 2
Result: agreed to Yeas: 142 Nays: 111
Cabinet Minister: J.G. Diefenbaker, Prime Minister, voted "NAY"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1963.02.05 pp. 473-4

Division:
Sponsor: Speaker's Ruling, that there could be no appeal from Ruling of Chair under S.O. 26
Motion:
Result: appealed and not sustained Yeas: 104 Nays: 122
Cabinet Minister: J.G. Diefenbaker, Prime Minister, voted "YEA"
Source: House of Commons Journals 1963.01.31 pp. 462-3

24th Parliament

5th Session

No Defeated Motions

4th Session

No Defeated Motions

3rd Session

No Defeated Motions

2nd Session

No Defeated Motions

1st Session

No Defeated Motions

23rd Parliament

1st Session

No Defeated Motions