The federal program offering cash grants to buyers of fuel-efficient cars is a first step to cutting fuel use but it has "several defects," according to a study by the C.D. Howe Institute.
In the study, policy analyst Robin Bannerjee supports the use of grants, but notes that the majority of vehicles attract neither grant nor tax.
"This reduces the effectiveness of the policy and reduces the impetus for manufacturers to make continuous improvements," he writes.
He's critical of Ottawa for failing to adequately consult the industry and for not phasing in the policy. He also notes that the program will hurt the market share of the Big Three North American automakers, which are disproportionately affected by the selective application of the policy.
The Conservative government unveiled the program, dubbed a "feebate," in its March budget. It gives grants of up to $2,000 to buyers of new cars that burn less than 6.5 litres of gasoline per 100 kilometres. It also imposes a tax of up to $4,000 on gas guzzlers that use more than 13 litres of fuel per 100 kilometres.
Bannerjee also says the plan won't do much to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. He cites another report by the Toronto-based think-tank that said the feebate will reduce Canadian greenhouse gas emission by, at most, one megatonne of carbon dioxide equivalent by 2010.
"Clearly, the plan alone will make only a small contribution to achieving ambitious emissions reduction targets," he writes.
Bannerjee recommends that Ottawa maintain and even boost measures that encourage people to travel less — such things as increasing the basic fuel tax or bringing in a carbon tax.
"Such taxes would also provide an added incentive for drivers to switch to more fuel-efficient cars," he writes.
Related
Internal Links
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
More Money Headlines »
- Canadians flock to Boxing Day bargains
- Millions of Canadinas took part in the Boxing Day bonanza on Wednesday, although shopping malls may have been less crammed with bargain hunters this year.
- U.S. house prices drop by a record 6.7 per cent
- House prices in the United States fell in October for the 10th consecutive month, posting their largest monthly drop since early 1991, a widely watched index showed Wednesday.
- Apple Inc. shares reach $200 on core strength of IPod
- Shares of Apple Inc. hit the $200 mark for the first time Wednesday as investor confidence in the company continued rising near the end of what has been a strong year for the IPod and computer maker.
- Toyota announces plan to sell 9.85 million vehicles in 2008
- In a neck-and-neck race that could dethrone General Motors as the world's top automaker, Toyota said it plans to sell 9.85 million vehicles globally in 2008.
- Oil prices spike after Turkish air strikes in Iraq
- Oil prices jumped Wednesday on supply concerns stoked by a new round of Turkish air strikes in northern Iraq and a growing belief that U.S. oil inventories fell last week.
Blog Watch
Most Blogged about CBC.ca Articles