![20070126_jian.jpg](https://bac-lac.wayback.archive-it.org/web/20071227032135im_/http://www.cbc.ca/thehour/blog/images/20070126_jian.jpg)
Jian Ghomeshi's piece on minorities in politics struck a nerve. The piece asked the question 'Is Canada ready for a minority Prime Minister?' Here's a sampling of some of the feedback:
Thanks to Jian Ghomeshi for addressing the role race plays in politics
I'm quite disturbed by the affirmative action concept, especially when it comes to something as crucial as our government.
The reality is Canada is a racists country. I do not say this because am an minority (definitely white :) ), but because of our history.
Google Kim Campbell. Canada has had a female Prime Minister
The Leader of the Parti Québ;écois;, André Boiclair, is gay, minority?... Is Quebec part of Canada for you?
For the all the feedback, click on the permanlink below.
Somes facts you did forget:
The Leader of the Parti Québécois, André Boiclair, is gay, minority?
The Bloc Québécois deputy, Vivian Barbos emigrated from Haiti few years ago…
The Bloc Québécois deputy, Makakoto came from Cameroon 14 years ago and he is elected in a district in which there is no immigrant…first African in the House of Commons
The Bloc Québécois deputy, Maria Mourani, is from Lebanon, elected as a deputy in Montreal last year…
Is Quebec part of Canada for you?
1/26/2007 10:22:08 AM Guillaume Mercier
Hi George -
You and Jian are so young and so cute! You opened your story with Hilary Clinton declaring her candidacy on minority candidates for President. Please google Kim Campbell. Canada has had a female Prime Minister. Short-lived yes, but female nevertheless. Check it out.
1/26/2007 1:47:13 AM Lydia
You ask why there is no minorities in Parliament or as a Prime Minister. The reality is Canada is a racists country. I do not say this because am an minority (definitely white :) ), but because of our history. Did you know that there were more KKK members in Alberta then all of the United States of America (in our past)? Then look at BC my home Provence and you will see the same. In Ontario at onetime blacks could not live in certain areas, until the Supreme Court called the practises illegal. The examples are to numerous and if we want to move foreword we as collective nation must acknowledge our past.
Thank you,
Dennis Barnum
PS I can not see a black or any other minority being PM in my lifetime. As I right this my system rebelled at the idea of a minority PM, interesting.
1/25/2007 10:15:28 PM Dennis
Wow, thanks for a look into the insight of the major parties of Canada on minorities in parliament. Personally, I’m quite disturbed by the affirmative action concept, especially when it comes to something as crucial as our government. Don’t get me wrong, I’m completely indifferent as to the ethnicity or religion my prime minister is as long as they do a good job, but hindering access to perfectly competent individuals because they are white I can’t agree with. Olivia Chou mentions that parties should first really demonstrate that they have sought out a candidate of a visible minority. Isn’t this just discrimination against Caucasians- why should an Indian, an African, an Asian, etc. be chosen ahead of a Caucasian if the Caucasian is more qualified? Likewise, in a country such as Japan or Bangladesh which a Caucasian would be a minority - should someone who is white expect to be given preferential treatment? I certainly hope not! If someone is more qualified than me for the job I apply to, there’s no reason for me to chosen ahead of them because of my background. Whatever happened to let the best woman/man win? Let me take a personal example, I attend a university where roughly 80% of my program (accounting) is Asian. Using similar logic, should other ethnicities be given preferential treatment in getting in, even if their marks aren’t quite as high? Later when I took a politics course as an elective I noticed that the vast, vast majority of the class was Caucasian! Perhaps areas of interest are different due to the upbringing and atmosphere we are raised in. In the case of my politics class, considering all is equal, I personally don’t feel that it would be just to give the 5% of students whom are a minority in this situation better treatment – it’s blatant discrimination. My mommy always told two wrongs don’t make a right – I guess she was “politically incorrect” in the eyes of the NDP.
Thank you, comments anyone?
I wonder if George Stroumboulopoulos reads these…
1/25/2007 9:29:30 PM Paul
Thanks to Jian Ghomeshi for addressing the role race plays in politics and tackling the question of whether Canadians are ready to embrace diversity in our leadership.
His comment that Hillary Clinton's photo was "not the most flattering" provides an excellent segway to examining the barriers women face in politics. I look forward to his coverage of this piece as well.
1/25/2007 9:20:32 PM Tina d'Entremont, Wedgeport, NS