Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

TOM MCFEAT: ON THE MONEY

Stop! Thief!! Or maybe not.

Just another day at the shopping mall

December 19, 2007

I can't help it. I've been setting off alarm bells again. Some of my local stores are of the opinion that I might be a shoplifter.

It isn't store staff who make the accusation. It's those electronic theft-detection systems that guard the store exits.

You've no doubt heard them. The mechanized voice that often follows the alarm doesn't actually use the word "shoplifter." Instead, it suggests that the store has "apparently failed to remove the inventory control tag" from my purchase or something similar. It helpfully suggests I return to the cash to sort out this horrible mix-up.

The public pronouncement acknowledges that the person frozen at the exit is probably innocent and that the problem is probably the store's.

But the buzzers and loud warning imply the possibility that I could actually be doing something bad. The machine might as well be saying: "HEY EVERYONE. THE GUY AT THE EXIT MAY HAVE SOME OF OUR STUFF THAT HE DIDN'T PAY FOR. SHAME ON YOU. MAYBE."

You know the drill. A staffer often tries to check things out. When a cursory inspection fails to find evidence of criminality, they take everything back to their electronic thing-a-majig by the till, where they feverishly re-swipe the merchandise or take off the electronic article surveillance (EAS) tags that should have been removed in the first place. Often, the renewed effort is for naught, as the alarms still sound for some unknown reason.

You then leave the store with your goods — sometimes with an apology, sometimes not.

We shoppers, being polite Canadians, invariably put up with the embarrassment and inconvenience. I'm a veteran of these charades.

Once, when a store couldn't figure out why I was triggering their Def Con 3 alert, I'm ashamed to admit that I actually helped the probe by slowly moving selected contents of my pockets — then my wallet — and finally my shoes — back and forth through the trigger zone to see what was causing the problem. Anyone looking on must have thought I'd invented a retail version of tai chi.

Sometimes, staff helpfully suggest reasons for the alert. As in: "Did you buy a CD at another store?" or "Is there a tag stuck to the bottom of your shoe?" or "Have you just visited Chernobyl?" OK, the last one's not real, but I've been asked the first two.

A colleague tells me that his rented videos can't make it by these machines without causing a stink. Another says her security pass seems to be the culprit. She might be on to something there. Several years ago, an old security pass of mine set off alarms every time I went into two particular stores. A friend tells me that library books or his pocket utility knife sometimes set things a-clanging.

People usually find that the staff are sympathetic to their predicament and don't presume they're dealing with practitioners of the five-finger discount. After all, they hear these false positives being sounded all day long.

Often the staff simply tell you to ignore the cacophony because the machine's just decided to scream at everyone that day.

The other night, I spent almost an hour at a busy mall watching people going in and out of a big chain department store. The security buzzers were threatening to drown out the Christmas music. Not once did store staff find someone who had actually shoplifted. One harried clerk spent her time verifying that the store wasn't being robbed by a 50-person shoplifting ring.

Let's stop for a moment and look at what's happening here:

We, the supposedly valued customers, are being routinely fingered as potential shoplifters, and publicly humiliated by loud buzzers, alarms, and officious announcements. When we're finally "cleared," we're then sent on our way by staff who point out that "the machines are always doing that," as though that's an excuse we can all chuckle along with.

Enough.

Memo to retailers: Get your act together. While I have enormous sympathy for your losses from "shrinkage," as it's euphemistically called, this can't be the best way to handle the problem. I don't like being buzzed, beeped, told to go back into the store, or bothered in any way because your security system has incorrectly fingered me as a possible miscreant. After all, I've just spent money in your store. This isn't a border crossing.

It's time to either re-calibrate your security system, train your staff better, or just get machines that don't shout "J'accuse" every time someone walks in or out with a belt buckle.

The alternative is that we, the customers, will all soon ignore that advice to return to the cash register and keep walking when the alarms sound. Many customers already do that.

Just don't talk about these security devices keeping down prices by reducing shoplifting. I'm not complaining about electronic article surveillance. I'm not complaining about having all kinds of security in place. Greeters, cameras, store detectives. All fine.

I'm just fed up with shopping at stores that couldn't be bothered to figure out the difference between a library book and their own merchandise, and enrolling me in their very public self-discovery process, whether or not I want to participate.

It's no coincidence that I've done more online shopping this year than ever before. It's "virtually" alarm-free.

That's my little rant. Enjoy the holiday. And best wishes to the over-worked retail clerks who put up with a lot this time of year — often for less than $10 an hour.

They deserve better.

Go to the Top

ABOUT THIS AUTHOR

Biography

Tom McFeat

Tom McFeat is the Producer of the Business zone of CBC News Online. Tom joined CBC in 1979, and has worked as a TV reporter, writer/editor and producer at The National and at several regional CBC stations. Before joining CBC News Online, he produced The Money Show for CBC Newsworld. He is the co-author of two books dealing with online investing and money management.

More From This Author

More From
TOM MCFEAT »
Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

2nd soldier killed in Afghan rollover identified
The Canadian military has identified a second soldier killed in Afghanistan over the weekend in a vehicle rollover during a mission in the volatile Zhari district of southern Afghanistan.
January 7, 2008 | 12:50 PM EST
UN chief says 2008 is year of the 'bottom billion'
The United Nations will focus on improving quality of life for the poorest people in the world in 2008, UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said Monday.
January 7, 2008 | 4:21 PM EST
Kenyan political rivals agree to meet
Kenya's president on Monday invited his chief political rival to his official residence to discuss how to end the country's post-election violence, just hours after the opposition called off planned protest rallies amid fears they could renew violence.
January 7, 2008 | 7:42 PM EST
more »

Canada »

Crown seeks new trial for Pickton
The Crown is asking the B.C. Court of Appeal to order a new trial for convicted murderer Robert William Pickton on 26 counts of first-degree murder.
January 7, 2008 | 10:39 PM EST
Federal report calls for carbon tax, trading in Canada
Canada must put a price tag on carbon emissions and quickly develop a carbon tax or trading system to target emitters, a new federal report recommends.
January 7, 2008 | 1:02 PM EST
Sexually active gay men no longer allowed to donate organs
A number of organ donation groups said Monday that they are unaware of new Health Canada regulations that mean sexually active gay men, injection drug users and other groups considered high risk will no longer be accepted as organ donors.
January 7, 2008 | 10:08 PM EST
more »

Health »

Northerners should boost vitamin D exposure: study
People torn between getting enough sunlight ? and vitamin D ? and risking skin cancer may have their fears allayed by a recent study.
January 7, 2008 | 5:12 PM EST
Health Canada defends drug alert system
Despite evidence indicating seniors are being prescribed potentially dangerous drugs, Health Canada says it can't do anything more to make its warnings about these medications more effective.
January 7, 2008 | 12:04 PM EST
Q-Ray makers ordered to return $16 M in refunds to consumers
The makers of the Q-Ray Ionized Bracelet have been ordered to turn over $16 million US in profits, to be paid out in refunds to consumers for false advertising, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission said Monday.
January 7, 2008 | 4:32 PM EST
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Golden Globes telecast is off
The Golden Globes telecast, one of the highest-profile film award shows in the run-up to the Academy Awards, has been cancelled, a casualty of the Hollywood writers strike, the Los Angeles Times reported Monday.
January 7, 2008 | 5:44 PM EST
Cruise's United Artists signs deal with striking screenwriters
United Artists films, the moribund studio resurrected by Tom Cruise in 2006, has signed a deal with striking Hollywood screenwriters.
January 7, 2008 | 6:33 PM EST
Dr. Phil cancels show devoted to Britney
Plans for a one-hour episode of the Dr. Phil Now show devoted to pop star Britney Spears have been cancelled.
January 7, 2008 | 3:59 PM EST
more »

Technology & Science »

Zune to launch in Canada this spring
Microsoft Inc.'s Zune portable media player, first launched over a year ago as an alternative to Apple Inc.'s ubiquitous iPod, is coming to Canada.
January 7, 2008 | 4:04 PM EST
Panasonic, Comcast team on portable video player
Electronics maker Matsushita Electric Industrial's Panasonic unit and U.S. cable giant Comcast unveiled a portable digital media player that will allow consumers to record and play shows from any U.S. cable operator's system.
January 7, 2008 | 3:06 PM EST
Scientists restore sight to blind fish
Cross-breeding blind cave fish with those from separate populations of blind cave fish can partially restore their vision, overriding half a million years of evolutionary change, say U.S. scientists.
January 7, 2008 | 1:06 PM EST
more »

Money »

CIBC hires TSX Group's Nesbitt as part of management shakeup
Stung by the fallout from the U.S. subprime mortgage crunch, CIBC announced several management changes Monday, including the hiring of TSX Group CEO Richard Nesbitt.
January 7, 2008 | 4:13 PM EST
Federal report calls for carbon tax, trading in Canada
Canada must put a price tag on carbon emissions and quickly develop a carbon tax or trading system to target emitters, a new federal report recommends.
January 7, 2008 | 1:02 PM EST
TD shares hit by subprime rumours
Stock in TD Bank fell Monday as rumours ? quickly denied by TD ? swept through financial markets that the bank might face a huge writedown because of the faltering U.S. subprime mortgage market.
January 7, 2008 | 6:18 PM EST
more »

Consumer Life »

Q-Ray makers ordered to return $16 M in refunds to consumers
The makers of the Q-Ray Ionized Bracelet have been ordered to turn over $16 million US in profits, to be paid out in refunds to consumers for false advertising, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission said Monday.
January 7, 2008 | 4:32 PM EST
10% price hike expected for made-in-China toys, executive says
Consumers could be paying about 10 per cent more for China-made toys this year owing to more stringent quality control checks, according to an industry executive.
January 7, 2008 | 12:24 PM EST
McDonald's to launch 'coffee bar war' against Starbucks: report
McDonald's plans to install coffee bars to sell lattes and cappuccinos in every one of its U.S. restaurants this year, according to the Wall Street Journal.
January 7, 2008 | 1:13 PM EST
more »

Sports »

Scores: CFL MLB MLS

Clemens plays tape of McNamee
Roger Clemens played a taped telephone conversation for reporters Monday in which his former trainer, who accused him of using steroids, said, "I will go to jail, I will do whatever you want."
January 7, 2008 | 8:10 PM EST
Downie won't be suspended by NHL
NHL disciplinarian Colin Campbell spoke with rookie forward Steve Downie, but decided not to hit the Flyers forward with a ban for sucker-punching Toronto Maple Leafs forward Jason Blake.
January 7, 2008 | 3:33 PM EST
Oilers try to close Northwest gap
Sitting in the Northwest Division basement, the Edmonton Oilers will attempt to make up some ground when they host the New York Islanders on Monday night.
January 7, 2008 | 9:39 AM EST
more »