Story Tools: E-MAIL | PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

Charges unlikely in Ludwig shooting case, RCMP say

Last Updated: Wednesday, October 6, 1999 | 9:48 PM ET

RCMP in Alberta say it is unlikely charges will be laid in the shooting death of Karman Willis last June. Willis is the 16-year old Beaverlodge girl who was shot and killed on the Wiebo Ludwig property in Hythe.

Police say there simply isn't enough evidence right now to link anyone to the crime.

RCMP Commissioner McDermott
RCMP Commissioner McDermott

For the first time, the Willis family has spoken out, calling for justice to be done.

The tragedy happened June 24 on the Ludwig property. Ludwig's children were sleeping in a tent when joyriding teenagers in pick-up trucks drove into the yard.

According to RCMP, someone in the yard fired three rifle shots, killing 16-year old Karman Willis, and injuring another boy. Now, in a CBC National Magazine interview, RCMP say it's unlikely charges will ever be laid.

Karman Willis
Karman Willis

"There is no ballistics test available to us or anybody else that I'm aware of that will tell you who fired the rifle," RCMP Commissioner Don McDermott told The Magazine's Hana Gartner. "But the ballistics test will tell you what rifle fired the bullet. But what we have to do in an investigation like this is, you have to find the person who put their finger on the trigger and pulled it with intention of causing the shell to eject from the rifle."

McDermott said it is "very, very possible" that, under these circumstances, the RCMP will not find anyone to charge for this crime beyond a reasonable doubt.

Ludwig says no one from his farm fired the shot. But police say Ludwig's call to 911 after the shooting suggests someone on the farm did indeed pull the trigger:

911 OPERATOR: "What can I do for you Reverend?"

LUDWIG: "Uh, just had a couple of vehicles, loud mufflers run through the yard, and the lawn here. You'll probably find a couple of bullet holes in their boxes."

911 OPERATOR: "OK, you shot at someone, sir?"

LUDWIG: "Someone shot at them, yes."

Sixteen hours later, a heavily armed RCMP team moved in, with a search warrant. Police say they knew Ludwig had guns. They were taking no chances. For 10 days, they combed the property, finding three rifles. Now, months later, police doubt they can tie anyone to the crime. They know what happened, they have every reason to believe who might or might not have done it, but have no evidence to prove it.

In Beaverlodge, Karman Willis's family says they can't believe charges may never be laid.

"I just, I just want it dealt with," says mother Barbara Willis. "I just want to be able to put that part of it aside. I'm never going to be able to get over the loss of Karman because she was too big a part of our lives. But it has to be, somebody has to own up to doing it."

Related

More Canada Headlines »

Cleared man accepts pathologist's emotional apology
A man wrongfully convicted of killing his four-year-old niece forgave discredited Ontario pathologist Charles Smith on Thursday at a public inquiry into his botched child autopsies.
Sask. reserve where 2 sisters died tried to ban alcohol: chief
A Saskatchewan First Nation reeling from the deaths of two toddlers left outside in the bitter cold was trying to declare itself a dry community, the reserve's chief said Thursday.
Passport snafu involves Canadians from coast to coast
RCMP are investigating a passport mix-up that involves a teenager from Manitoba and people in Halifax and Vancouver.
OPP officers assaulted at aboriginal protest, police allege
Ontario Provincial Police say no charges will be laid after two of their officers were assaulted at the scene of an aboriginal occupation in eastern Ontario.
Dispute over heat leaves daycare in deep-freeze
Children at an Edmonton daycare are being forced to wear their snowsuits indoors for hours in sub-zero temperatures due to a dispute with the landlord.
Story Tools: E-MAIL | PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

U.S. officials won't enforce new border ID rules
U.S. rules requiring proof of citizenship to enter the country by land or sea take effect Thursday, but customs officials now say they won't be enforced for at least another 18 months.
UN head warns of catastrophe in Kenya
The head of the United Nations warned Thursday that Kenya is on the brink of catastrophe, as a second opposition MP in the east African country was shot and killed.
At least 20 dead after blast at Istanbul factory
Turkish authorities say an explosion at a factory building in Istanbul killed 20 people and injured 117 others Thursday.
more »

Canada »

Cleared man accepts pathologist's emotional apology
A man wrongfully convicted of killing his four-year-old niece forgave discredited Ontario pathologist Charles Smith on Thursday at a public inquiry into his botched child autopsies.
Sask. reserve where 2 sisters died tried to ban alcohol: chief
A Saskatchewan First Nation reeling from the deaths of two toddlers left outside in the bitter cold was trying to declare itself a dry community, the reserve's chief said Thursday.
Passport snafu involves Canadians from coast to coast
RCMP are investigating a passport mix-up that involves a teenager from Manitoba and people in Halifax and Vancouver.
more »

Health »

Sports fans at risk from heart-stopping action: study
If you're a sports fan, you may be at greater risk of heart attack when the home team is playing a high-stakes game, says new research out of Germany.
Health Canada investigates drugs Botox, Myobloc
Health Canada is reviewing safety information on the wrinkle treatment Botox and a similar drug called Myobloc, just days after a call from a U.S. lobby to increase the warnings on Botox.
Doctor admits leaking research study to drug company
A Texas doctor leaked confidential research to the makers of the popular diabetes drug Avandia weeks before a study was published tying the drug to higher heart risks, the scientific journal Nature reported Wednesday.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Prairie artist Joe Fafard celebrated with National Gallery exhibit Video
A way of communicating with the public is how Saskatchewan sculptor Joe Fafard characterizes his artwork, a major retrospective of which is set to open at the National Gallery of Canada.
Amazon.com buying Audible Inc.
Internet retailer Amazon.com Inc. is buying online audiobook provider Audible Inc. to expand its reach in the digital audio content market.
Former boy soldier stands by memoir
Ishmael Beah, who wrote a best-selling memoir about his time as a boy soldier in Sierra Leone, is defending himself against reports that his account is inaccurate.
more »

Technology & Science »

Mercury could be shrinking, scientists say
The first pictures from the unseen side of Mercury reveal the wrinkles of a shrinking, aging planet with scars from volcanic eruptions and a birthmark shaped like a spider.
ICANN to close internet domain name loophole
The oversight group for the registry of addresses on the internet is hoping a change in policy will stamp out the practice of sampling or "tasting" domain names without paying for them.
NASA confirms Feb. 7 launch date for Atlantis
NASA officials formally set the launch of Atlantis for next Thursday, two months after the space shuttle was originally scheduled to lift off.
more »

Money »

Canadian economy grew 0.1 per cent in November
Economic activity in Canada inched ahead by 0.1 per cent in November, as growth remained modest through the autumn, Statistics Canada said Thursday.
Loonie loses ground
The Canadian dollar retreated more than a cent in early trading against the U.S. dollar Thursday on tepid Canadian economic growth figures, sliding oil prices and rising U.S. jobless claims.
Petro-Canada Q4 profit jumps 36%
Petro-Canada reported fourth-quarter earnings Thursday of $522 million, a leap of 36 per cent or $138 million over the same period a year ago.
more »

Consumer Life »

U.S. officials won't enforce new border ID rules
U.S. rules requiring proof of citizenship to enter the country by land or sea take effect Thursday, but customs officials now say they won't be enforced for at least another 18 months.
Website promotes red dots to stop junk mail
A Vancouver businesswoman is launching a new campaign to help people who want to cut down on junk mail delivered by Canada Post.
Loonie loses ground
The Canadian dollar retreated more than a cent in early trading against the U.S. dollar Thursday on tepid Canadian economic growth figures, sliding oil prices and rising U.S. jobless claims.
more »

Sports »

Scores: CFL MLB MLS

Milt Stegall to return next season
Veteran CFL receiver Milt Stegall is returning for another season with the Winnipeg Blue Bombers.
Alfredsson 'iffy' for the Senators
The Ottawa Senators could be without captain Daniel Alfredsson when they host the Boston Bruins Thursday night.
Gut-check time for ailing Maple Leafs
With Chad Kilger and Boyd Devereaux unavailable Thursday, Toronto Maple Leafs coach Paul Maurice will need others to step up in Carolina in hopes of halting a two-game losing skid.
more »