Opening Statement to the Standing Committee on Public Accounts
Correctional Service CanadaReintegration of Women Offenders
(Chapter 4 - April 2003 Report of the Auditor General of Canada)
14 May 2003
Hugh McRoberts,
Assistant Auditor General
Mr. Chairman, thank you for the opportunity to meet with the Committee to
discuss our April 2003 Report chapter on Correctional Service Canada and its
reintegration of women offenders into the community. With me today are Ron Wolchuk,
Principal, and Jocelyne Therrien, Director, who were responsible for this audit,
which we conducted as a result of a recommendation by the subcommittee of the
Justice and Human Rights.
Correctional Service Canada has accomplished a great deal in changing how women
are incarcerated and rehabilitated, particularly by closing down the Kingston
Prison for Women and replacing it with five facilities across Canada. Since
1994, the Service has developed many rehabilitation programs and modified others
to better meet the needs of women offenders. But it needs to make some improvements
in delivering programs and services to women while they are incarcerated and
while they are supervised in the community.
In the institution
The Service has not sufficiently tested the tools it uses in the initial assessment
of women offendersa critical first step in their reintegration that determines
the level of risk they present and identifies the programs they will need in
their rehabilitation.
The Service has not provided the necessary evidence of the tools' inter-rater
reliabilitythat is, evidence indicating that different parole officers
using them would assess the same offender similarly.
And one of the most important tools, the Custody Rating Scale, requires more
validity testing to ensure that it is the most appropriate tool for women.
Another of our concerns is that although employment is an essential part of
effective reintegration, women offenders have little access to meaningful work
opportunities and employment programs while they are incarcerated.
Work releases and temporary absences help prepare offenders for release by
affording them the opportunity to maintain positive contacts in the community.
But the use of these releases varied widely among women's institutions, from
some use to very little. The Service should also do more to facilitate the increased
use of special provisions available by law for the care, custody, and parole
of Aboriginal women offenders.
In the community
Despite the efforts of community parole officers and the fact that women are
generally receptive to the assistance provided to them, a high percentage of
paroles are suspended. Parole officers have identified some things Correctional
Service could provide to help keep these women in the community:
- better access to substance abuse programs and to mental health services;
- temporary facilities as an alternative to sending suspended offenders back
to the institution;
- suitable accommodation especially in communities where a half-way house
for women is not available.
Access to the right program or service in the community at the right time could
help reduce parole suspensions and increase the efficiency of parole officers.
What is more important, the potential for individual rehabilitation would improve
significantly. The Service needs to set priorities for programs and services
to paroled women offenders, dedicate the necessary funds, and measure the results.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Correctional Service Canada has greatly improved conditions
for women offenders over the last 13 years, and we are encouraged by its commitment
to continue improving.
The Committee might wish to consider asking Correctional Service these questions:
- How will it provide assurance that its assessment tools are reliable?
- How will it better test the validity of the Custody Rating Scale to assess
women offenders?
- How does it plan to better prepare women offenders for future employment?
- What specific steps will it take to give offenders better access to appropriate
programs and services in the community?
Mr. Chairman, this concludes my statement. We would be pleased to answer any
questions.
|