Note: You are viewing the unstyled version of CBC.ca because you can not see our css files, or because you do not have a standards-compliant browser or you are a mobile user.

Welcome to CBC.ca


CBC News: the fifth estate - More about the fifth estatesubscribe to our e-mail newslettercontact us
Luck of the Draw
Aired October 25, 2006
Updated March 14, 2007

WATCH the fifth estate ONLINE:
Bob Edmonds
October 25, 2006
Runs 40:19
November 22, 2006
Runs 21:00
March 14, 2007
Runs 19:17
REPORTER
: Gillian Findlay
PRODUCER
: Harvey Cashore
CO-PRODUCER:
Linda Guerriero
RESEARCHER:
Albert Lee

Video available in Windows Media Player.

BOB EDMONDS: WHISTLEBLOWER
Bob Edmonds, whose story started the fifth estate's lottery investigation, died on April 2, 2007. Read a news story.

BY THE NUMBERS
the fifth estate asked statistician Jeffrey Rosenthal to look at the OLG's numbers. Here's the analysis.
UPDATE
Apology from the OLG
Since the fifth estate aired its documentary Luck of the Draw, a lot has changed for Bob Edmonds. Immediately following our program, he received a call from Duncan Brown, the CEO of the Ontario Lottery and Gaming corporation apologizing for what had happened. Mr. Brown told Bob he was ashamed of how his staff treated Bob Edmonds.

It was all Bob Edmonds ever wanted to hear. And remember the confidentiality agreement Bob had to sign? Well, the OLG released him from that. Now Bob is free to tell anyone he wants anything about his ordeal.

Bob with Gillian
Bob Edmonds visits the fifth estate after his story aired across the country.
He spoke to the fifth estate's Gillian Findlay and told her he was overwhelmed by the show of support. "I wish I could explain it," he said. "I think that the people that are watching would understand that it means so much the whole story has been brought to light by the CBC."

Viewer response
The story touched so many Canadians, the fifth estate was inundated with e-mails from across Canada. Some of them praised Bob as a hero and others were emails from people sharing their own experiences and questioning whether they had been ripped off.

OLG: NEW SECURITY MEASURES
On November 9, the OLG announced that they are implementing new security measures to protect customers. These include:

- plans to install new electronic devices at every ticket location for lottery players to check their own tickets
- changing the text on video screens that tells customers they've won, making it larger and easier to read.
- retailers and clerks cannot check a lottery ticket unless the customer has signed the back of the ticket
- investigating all insider wins of $10,000 or more

The OLG also plans to launch a campaign to educate people on how to protect themselves against lottery fraud. Read their press release.

New documents revealed in 2007
The CEO of the Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation continued to deny the claims made by the fifth estate that Bob Edmonds' case was not an isolated incident and that the corporation had paid millions of dollars to retailers in suspect claims.

In a story broadcast on March 14, the fifth estate broadcast information from documents showing that in ONE YEAR alone the OLG did just that in five separate cases; $12.5 million in one single suspect pay-out.

On Friday, March 23, 2007, the CEO of Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation, Duncan Brown, was dismissed.

ONTARIO'S OMBUDSMAN RESPONDS
On Monday, March 26, 2007, Ontario's ombudsman, Andre Marin, presented his report of the investigation into the Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation. Marin said that the organization was fixated on profits rather than customer service. Marin launched the probe into the OLG after the fifth estate broadcast Luck of the Draw in October, 2006.

EDMONDS: THE FIGHT IS OVER
On Friday March 30, the OLG finally delivered a formal apology to Bob Edmonds for their treatment of his case. On Monday April 2, Bob Edmonds lost his fight with cancer, before he had a chance to read the letter. Read a news story.
^TOP