Public Health Agency of Canada / Office de la santé public du Canada
Skip first menu Skip all menus Français Contact Us Help Search Canada Site
Home Centers & Labs Publications Guidelines A-Z Index
Check the help on Web Accessibility features Child Health Adult Health Seniors Health Surveillance Health Canada
Public Health Agency of Canada

Workshop on Birth Control Methods and the Prevention of  Unplanned Pregnancies - Annex #4

 1
 2
Annex 4

Theme: Table of comparison of various birth control methods (to be given to the students)

  How they work Efficiency rate Advantages Disadvantages
Hormonal methods        
The birth-control pill One pill to be taken daily, at the same time The inner lining of the uterus becomes unsuitable for the ovum to settle in approximately 98% Good efficiency rate Easy to use Does not hinder fertility Weaker, more regular menstruation; fewer menstrual cramps Possible side effects (weight gain, nausea, headaches) Directions must be followed to a tee
Depo-provera Injection given at 3-month intervals The inner lining of the uterus becomes unsuitable for the ovum to settle in approximately 99% Good efficiency rate Practical Medical check-ups at 3-month intervals Menstrual irregularities Possible weight gain
Norplant Capsule implanted in the arm The inner lining of the uterus becomes unsuitable for the ovum to settle in approximately 99%

Continued protection for 5 years

Practical

Minor surgical intervention Bleeding between menstrual cycles
"Barrier" methods The spermatozoon does not meet the ovum
The condom

Latex membrane covering the penis

Must be put on as soon as penis is erect, and removed immediately following ejaculation

Always use with a water-based lubricant

approximately 98%

Direct involvement of the partner

Easily accessible

Protection against STIs

Can tear if used improperly (expiry date past due, insufficient lubrication)

One-time use only

The female condom

Polyurethane membrane

May be put in place up to 8 hours prior to sexual relations and removed immediately following ejaculation

75 to 95%

Available without a prescription

Very resistant

Protection against STIs

Need to be at ease with one's own body

Relatively high price

One-time use only

The diaphragm (cervical cap)

Insertion of a cap covering the cervix two hours prior to sexual relations

Must remain in place 6 to 8 hours following sexual relations

80 to 90%

Few side effects

Need to be at ease with one's own body

Spermicide

Nonoxynol-9 is available as a spermicidal lubricant on some condoms, vaginal film, contraceptive gel, contraceptive sponge and vaginal foam.

70 to 80%

Available without a prescription

Questionable protection against STIs. Possible allergic reaction to N-9 causing microscopic tears in vagina. N-9 does not reduce the risk of HIV acquisition. It may actually do the opposite by causing mucosal disruptions in the genital lining. The best protection against HIV and STIs is a condom without N-9. However a condom lubricated with N-9 is better than no condom at all.

The intra-uterine device (I.U.D.)

Is placed inside the uterus

The ovum cannot settle in the uterus

approximately 98%

Always in place

Medical check-up since I.U.D. is put in place by a doctor

Long-lasting: replacement every 30 months

Possible side effects (infection of the Fallopian tubes, aches, cramps, etc.)

Possibility of increased menstrual bleeding

Fertility awareness methods

No sexual relations at all or only during infertile periods

Abstinence

No sexual relations

100%

No side effects

Nothing to buy

Protection against STIs

Necessary resistance to social and peer pressure

Needs strong commitment

Temperature method

Measuring of one's body temperature every morning

Keeping track of it on a graph

Temperature rises following ovulation

Unacceptable efficiency rate if used alone

No side effects

Sexual relations not permitted at certain times

Fatigue, stress and illnesses can affect temperature

Directions must be followed to a tee

Coitus interruptus

(withdrawal)

Partner "pulls out" prior to ejaculation

Unacceptable efficiency rate if used alone

 

Sexual relations not permitted at certain times

Emergency methods

When the other methods have failed (due to forgetfulness or an accident)

Emergency contraceptive
pill

Four pills to be taken within 72 hours of the at-risk sexual relation

The inner lining of the uterus becomes unsuitable for the ovum to settle in

Prevents the ovum from reaching maturity

approximately 98%

Prevents an unplanned pregnancy

Need to consult a doctor

Directions must be followed to a tee

Possible side effects (nausea, vomiting, drowsiness)

 

Last Updated: 2005-03-09 Top